Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all films <5 years problematic in some way

269 replies

anon666 · 10/06/2023 00:24

I guess it might be a sign of rapid progress, but recently I've watched:

Pretty Woman
Dirty Dancing
Bend it like Beckham

All of which have a girl/woman falling for an authority figure. It really looks creepy to a modern eye. Or does it? Am I being too Gen Z about the whole thing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
HappiestSleeping · 12/06/2023 07:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This 👆

Besides, there are also some good strong female lead films that are not recent.

Alien (1979) and Dawn of the Dead (1978) spring to mind.

PinotGroggio · 12/06/2023 07:31

*VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia
Have you seen Twelve Years A Slave? I wouldn't call it "sanitised".

I haven’t but whilst it’s not sanitised it does fit an agenda.*

What "agenda" might that be? You do know it was based on a true story, right?

Goldencup · 12/06/2023 05:12

DemiColon · 12/06/2023 03:00

Sure they were. They were more independent, often more well read, typically had been working at least part time, sometimes had even finished school and were supporting themselves. Most 17 year olds had real responsibilities in the family.

My aunt was married and had a baby at 17, she'd been working for a year at that point and lived on her own.

My husband, at 13, went with two friends the same age on a backwoods camping trip that lasted a week, in the wilderness, without any adults.

Kids from much younger walked alone to school, or played out all day, with no contact with parents.

These kinds of experiences drive brain maturation.

I don't think this is true. I have a 19 and nearly 17 yo, they are about as mature as I was at their respective ages. At 18/19 I went out with a PHD student who was running a tutor group. Even though I approached him, I still think there was a power imbalance.

DemiColon · 12/06/2023 03:00

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 23:37

People baby 17 yos now but when I was 17, 25 years ago 17 yos were much more mature and it wouldn't have been a huge imbalance to go out with a 24 yo.

No, 17 year olds weren't more mature 25 years ago than now. What 17 yos were was put at risk at college etc in ways that we no longer find acceptable. I was 17 around that time and was manipulated by a 19 yo compulsive liar with no job and no driver's licence. At 18, I was emotionally abused by a 30 yo with a job and licence. I had no concept of red flags and how to deal with abusive men. My neurotypical peers were only a little less vulnerable.

Sure they were. They were more independent, often more well read, typically had been working at least part time, sometimes had even finished school and were supporting themselves. Most 17 year olds had real responsibilities in the family.

My aunt was married and had a baby at 17, she'd been working for a year at that point and lived on her own.

My husband, at 13, went with two friends the same age on a backwoods camping trip that lasted a week, in the wilderness, without any adults.

Kids from much younger walked alone to school, or played out all day, with no contact with parents.

These kinds of experiences drive brain maturation.

DemiColon · 12/06/2023 02:53

QueefQueen80s · 11/06/2023 14:29

@DemiColon Just because it used to happen a lot doesn't mean it's right. We're trying to be progressive and move away from things that aren't appropriate and thankfully that's being reflected more in films and tv. Then that goes into peoples heads and over generations things change.

I don't really have a problem with relationships with an age gap, I think people way overestimate its importance. People of similar ages, with similar backgrounds, and similar incomes, get into shitty exploitative relationships all the time.Teens who date other teens often have shitty relationships if they are immature but no one seems to want to ban that. Which would probably be the more sensible approach if that was the real worry.

The obsession that Gen Z seems to have with puritanism and assuming the effects of very simplistic visions of power dynamics is odd. There seems to be a very flat understanding of human relations.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 12/06/2023 01:29

i can’t remember the reasoning behind Dirty Dancing isn’t a young women pushed into having a termination j no it sure if this was shown with sensitivity or not

Penny is pregnant out of wedlock in pre-Roe America, ends up seriously ill from a backstreet abortion. She's not pushed into it by a person as much as by her circumstances IIRC

HRTQueen · 12/06/2023 00:59

Pretty Woman was always problematic

at the time many actresses were questioning why there was such a nonsense story knowing how many young women come to LA to work in the film industry. I remember going to see it in the cinema and coming out thinking well that’s all a load of ridiculous negative nonsense

i can’t remember the reasoning behind Dirty Dancing isn’t a young women pushed into having a termination j no it sure if this was shown with sensitivity or not

LifeIsPainHighness · 12/06/2023 00:56

I thought Johnny was sacked because they thought he was nicking wallets?

Ponderingwindow · 12/06/2023 00:42

Johnny is used by the older women at the club. He isn’t really free to turn down the sex and gifts they offer. To say he is the person in power is completely untrue.

he loses his job, not because he slept with Baby, but because he upset one of the mature women he was servicing. She reported him to management and that is was gets him fired. We don’t even know exactly what she reports.

johnny also isn’t free to have relationships with the daughters, and not because he is older . He is roughly the same age as Robbie. He isn’t a college boy so he isn’t good enough for those girls.

The only person who has less power than Johnny is Penny.

steff13 · 12/06/2023 00:29

But Baby wasn't 17 25 years ago because the movie was set in the '60s. And I would say a 17-year-old dating a man in his early twenties probably wasn't super uncommon during that time period. And Baby was portrayed as being much more mature than her sister who was older.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 23:37

People baby 17 yos now but when I was 17, 25 years ago 17 yos were much more mature and it wouldn't have been a huge imbalance to go out with a 24 yo.

No, 17 year olds weren't more mature 25 years ago than now. What 17 yos were was put at risk at college etc in ways that we no longer find acceptable. I was 17 around that time and was manipulated by a 19 yo compulsive liar with no job and no driver's licence. At 18, I was emotionally abused by a 30 yo with a job and licence. I had no concept of red flags and how to deal with abusive men. My neurotypical peers were only a little less vulnerable.

NotAMug · 11/06/2023 22:57

anon666 · 10/06/2023 20:52

You know what, this never occurred to me, and I think this is to an extent a red herring. He's a professional teacher at the holiday camp. She is one of the clients. The very fact that he would be fired for sleeping with one of the guests should set off some red flags. The fact that she is 17 is the other oddity.

17 is really young for an older man to seduce. If the film had been cast with a real 17 year old instead of the super confident 23 year old Jennifer Gray, the inappropriateness and vulnerability would have showed through.

As it was, I can see why no-one finds the film itself creepy, but I think age matched casting would show up the storyline for what it is - an older, mature man in a position of authority/responsibility seduces a schoolgirl.

But happy to agree to differ.

He's not really that much older though. He's meant to be early 20s. I think in RL they were 27 and 34 though so it looks odd as she looks young and he doesn't really. 17 and 24 is not a massive age gap. People baby 17 yos now but when I was 17, 25 years ago 17 yos were much more mature and it wouldn't have been a huge imbalance to go out with a 24 yo. Depending on the people involved of course. I personally think people are trying to make out DD is something it's not to suit their own agenda.

off · 11/06/2023 20:19

WakeMeUpWhenGoodOmensIsBack · 11/06/2023 19:50

Shhh!

Nobody makes insulting comments about Gen X because we keep very quiet, let the Boomers/Millennials/Gen Z fight each other, and hope they forget we're here.

A generation so dull, nobody noticed you?Wink Meanwhile, millennials over here still occasionally getting blamed for whatever "young people today" are up to, even as our children start graduating from university Grin

AliceOlive · 11/06/2023 20:18

A friend just now sent this. What timing.

Are all films <5 years problematic in some way
WakeMeUpWhenGoodOmensIsBack · 11/06/2023 19:50

off · 11/06/2023 18:49

Just imagine it. Someone making an insulting generalisation about Gen Xers. Surely that could never happen.

Shhh!

Nobody makes insulting comments about Gen X because we keep very quiet, let the Boomers/Millennials/Gen Z fight each other, and hope they forget we're here.

QueefQueen80s · 11/06/2023 19:43

powershowerforanhour · 11/06/2023 19:24

I know you're meant to separate the artist from the art etc, but I was channel hopping yesterday and came across Mel Gibson in "What Women Want" and just kept thinking "probably not to be battered and have to take out a restraining order" so had to switch over.

I used to love Leo DiCaprio and can't stand his acting now. There are babies not even born yet that he will date one day.

powershowerforanhour · 11/06/2023 19:24

I know you're meant to separate the artist from the art etc, but I was channel hopping yesterday and came across Mel Gibson in "What Women Want" and just kept thinking "probably not to be battered and have to take out a restraining order" so had to switch over.

WhatWhereWho · 11/06/2023 18:55

Are you asking if all films in the history of cinema made before a certain date are problematic? Did not pick up on the Dirty Dancing bit where a much older woman using him, the husband pays him and then goes off to another guy. Why is that not problematic? Pretty Woman I never understood that one. The romcom around prostitution -unrealistic, unpleasant and sending a dodgy message.

Some films the image they push should be questioned. And to some extent it's a good thing that things are always revaluated. Some films, if they are more serious, are just meant to show the reality of a situation. But not all films are made to teach a lesson, neither should they be.

off · 11/06/2023 18:49

lysozyme · 11/06/2023 18:28

If someone made an insulting generalisation about your generation you'd be the first to whinge about it.

Just imagine it. Someone making an insulting generalisation about Gen Xers. Surely that could never happen.

lysozyme · 11/06/2023 18:28

Gtsr443 · 10/06/2023 06:10

For what its worth I always hated Pretty Woman and I'm a Gen Xer.

I can't wait to see what artistic gems Gen Z is going to come up with.....

Sam and Sam are non binary and use they/them pronouns. They are exactly the same age. They work in ethically sourced yoghurt and vegan socks. They never have sex unless both parties have agreed to it in writing. They spend their days staring at the wall worrying about climate change and living their truth.
ChatGPT is their only friend.
The End.

If someone made an insulting generalisation about your generation you'd be the first to whinge about it.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 11/06/2023 15:39

There is an age gap of between 7 or 8 years between Johnny and Baby, although this is not really mentioned in the movie. But the age of Patrick Swayze makes it look more. If they had a 24 year old male playing Johnny it would probably not be seen as a problem because there is not the authority figure, vulnerable figure character dynamic.

Phos · 11/06/2023 15:10

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 02:49

Have you seen Twelve Years A Slave? I wouldn't call it "sanitised".

I haven’t but whilst it’s not sanitised it does fit an agenda.

QueefQueen80s · 11/06/2023 14:29

@DemiColon Just because it used to happen a lot doesn't mean it's right. We're trying to be progressive and move away from things that aren't appropriate and thankfully that's being reflected more in films and tv. Then that goes into peoples heads and over generations things change.

DemiColon · 11/06/2023 00:20

Followill · 10/06/2023 08:23

It's not the age gap as such. It's the same old troupe of creepy old man shags young blond bird. I could count on one hand how many times it is reversed so a younger man falls for an older woman.

In my experience though that's pretty accurate. It's much less common to see age gap relationships where the woman is a good deal older.

Films aren't there to show people what is (or someone imagines) is the best way to do things. They are meant to show life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread