Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so worried re EHC Plan

85 replies

WayneCampbellsSidekick · 09/06/2023 21:57

My 3year old son is having an application made for an EHC Plan on the advice of his preschool following a visit from the local SEN advisor (high functioning ASD).
Am I right in saying they would only be doing this if his needs are deemed to be severe? So many questions and worries. Desperate for reassurance and advice/insight - is anyone who has been in this situation able to give any please?

OP posts:
PollyPeep · 10/06/2023 08:33

highlandspooce · 10/06/2023 07:14

What is the best way to describe the autistic spectrum?

The spectrum refers to how an individual is 'affected', not how they line up against others.

For example, I have a friend with an autistic child who is non verbal and incontinent, and will never live independently. I also have a brother in law and sister in law who are autistic but successfully hold down jobs and live independently. They are more mildly affected. How else can one describe such a broad range within one diagnosis?

You managed to do it right there, using words.

Not trying to be combative, trying to say the right thing. My siblings in law self identify as Asperger's but I understand that's frowned upon now.

'Identify as Asperger's' - WTF? If they have an Asperger's diagnosis they can use it all they want and it's nothing to do with anyone else. If not they can fuck right off because 'identify as' isn't a medical diagnosis.

Are you always this rude?

Mariposa123 · 10/06/2023 08:32

We’re at a similar point to you in that our DD’s preschool is supporting us in applying for a EHCP. To be honest it’s been really helpful as it means we’ve already accessed support from the LA’s SEND team, and has arranged extra transition sessions for us for reception etc. it means our daughter will get the extra support that it’s clear she’d struggle at school without. On the flip side I know of people with children who it’s clear they’d benefit from the EHCP but aren’t getting the support from their school/setting. Take all the support you can get, it can only be a good thing.

highlandspooce · 10/06/2023 08:27

@Gtsr443

I really don't know anyone involved in my son's care and in his life generally who only sees him as a labelled disabled person.
He is treated by everyone with respect and courtesy and given every possible opportunity as an individual. However we are all realistic about the extent of his needs and abilities and the amount of support he requires.
And his needs are conspicuously apparent within a minute of meeting him.

Right, so the high/low functioning label isn't needed to help him access support.

I still believe that the "autism spectrum" thing is incredibly unhelpful - particularly in wider society where people have gone from thinking all autistics are Rain Man to thinking all autistics are Chris Packham.

That's not what the spectrum means though. It's only unhelpful because people think it means 'where do you sit between rainman and Chris Packham?'

I met a woman the other day who, when I told her my son was autistic, rolled her eyes and said "Oh God not another one - it's everywhere these days."
This is what we're up against.

She is just an idiot, she doesn't need to know your sons suppers needs or whether he would be classed as high/low functioning and if that's the reason people think we need those labels they are far off the mark.

Sirzy · 10/06/2023 08:22

My son has had an ehcp since he was in year 1, I have fought a lot over the years to get the right provision written into it (he currently has full 1-1 clearly written) and because of it he is in year 8 at a mainstream secondary and thriving because we have been able to get the right provisions for him.

don’t get me wrong we still face massive challenges and things aren’t straight forward but because we had the support from an early age it has meant he has been able to access things as well as possible for him

Gtsr443 · 10/06/2023 08:21

@highlandspooce low functioning label would have absolutely hindered him because everyone involved in his care would have seen that first and him second. They would have made their decision about what he needed and his abilities without considering him as a person.

I really don't know anyone involved in my son's care and in his life generally who only sees him as a labelled disabled person.
He is treated by everyone with respect and courtesy and given every possible opportunity as an individual. However we are all realistic about the extent of his needs and abilities and the amount of support he requires.
And his needs are conspicuously apparent within a minute of meeting him.

I still believe that the "autism spectrum" thing is incredibly unhelpful - particularly in wider society where people have gone from thinking all autistics are Rain Man to thinking all autistics are Chris Packham.
I met a woman the other day who, when I told her my son was autistic, rolled her eyes and said "Oh God not another one - it's everywhere these days."
This is what we're up against.

Phineyj · 10/06/2023 07:50

Hi OP, assuming we are talking about an EHCP and not something else, think in some ways you are lucky (I know it won't feel that way!) The fact the setting is being so proactive means your son is displaying obvious behaviours in it. My daughter was already becoming a pro masker at that age (apparently no issues at school; masses at home) and as a result, we are now going through the EHCP process in year 5 (and it can take ages - we already 8 months in and it would easily take another 3; plus maybe an extra year if we have to go to tribunal again).

For your info, the key times there tend to be an issue are the transition from nursery to school and the transition from primary to secondary. Being able to put things in place ahead of those transitions is very helpful.

See if you can find other parents going through similar (look at your local authority's "local offer" web page for groups).

Tiktaktoo · 10/06/2023 07:46

An EHCP just means that your child will be able to access the adjustments they need in order to access their education. My child has one which states he needs 1:1 support for the entire school day. Without this, he wouldn’t be able to attend mainstream school. It doesn’t really mean your child is anything (e.g. severely autistic) as it’s not a diagnosis, it just provides the criteria for what your child needs to be successful in accessing their education.

JeandeServiette · 10/06/2023 07:42

It's becoming more and more usual for academically able children hampered by significant levels of autistic challenge to get EHCPs, is that's what you're asking. Bloody good thing, too. For a long time, only what was then called "Kanner" autism was properly supported.

DD & DN both went to good universities to study challenging subjects, and their EHCPs from school were used in assessing them for DSAs.

A child can be able in some domains and challenged in others. Don't think of an EHCP assessment as a bad thing or assume his future is gloomy.

nobodygoesdowninthejungle · 10/06/2023 07:41

OP, my limited experience is that a well written EHCP is very helpful as it means you avoid the arguments about what language to use. It will set out that your child has autism and then what it means for them as an individual. What can they cope with & what can't they cope with. Being able to start primary school armed with that means you should be able to avoid some of the more pointless battles with either your child or the school that you might have otherwise had.

highlandspooce · 10/06/2023 07:36

@Gtsr443

I agree to a point but overall the language about autism is useless and it is detrimental to getting effective provision.

I think the problem with effective provision runs a lot deeper than using functioning labels.

We need terminology to clearly explain need and ability because there is obviously a vast difference between a non verbal autistic person with significant comorbidities and a fully independent, employed and autonomous ND person.

Right, but anyone involved in delivering care or accommodations to those people will have detailed information. They wouldn't go off a low/high label because even within those areas people are all different and their needs are not the same

I know my ridiculously clever son will never live independently or hold down a job or marry and have kids. He can make progress in certain areas of his life as he matures but he's never going to suddenly transform into someone else.

I would have told you that about mine when he was younger. I toileted him until he was almost ten years old and had no idea he could ever live a relatively independent life but he is on the right path. A low functioning label would have absolutely hindered him because everyone involved in his care would have seen that first and him second. They would have made their decision about what he needed and his abilities without considering him as a person.

boomoohoo · 10/06/2023 07:35

Op is this about an EHCP plan - a process to assess your child's possible SEN (special educational needs)

Or - an EHP , which is an early help plan? Which is about a child and family needing a level of support at home

MissHavershamReturns · 10/06/2023 07:32

Op try to ignore the side debate about language.

To answer your most important question it does absolutely not mean that they think he’s going to really struggle in life. I can understand completely why it feels like that though as EHCPs are daunting.

What it does hopefully mean is that your setting are really on the ball and you did a great job in choosing where to send him.

My ds should have had an EHCP at 3 and we are getting one for him now in Year 6 of primary. He is very bright, has a best friends and other friends, briefly had a girlfriend and while yes he has challenges, on the whole he’s doing very well.

You can get an EHCP to ensure you continue to make good progress, if your current needs are such that extra support is required for that. Progress can be social, emotional and/or communication/language etc as well as academic.

I’m so pleased for you that they are making this application - it always goes much better if school make it!

Gtsr443 · 10/06/2023 07:29

The high/low doesn't always remain the same. People change, autistic people included.

I agree to a point but overall the language about autism is useless and it is detrimental to getting effective provision.

We need terminology to clearly explain need and ability because there is obviously a vast difference between a non verbal autistic person with significant comorbidities and a fully independent, employed and autonomous ND person.

I know my ridiculously clever son will never live independently or hold down a job or marry and have kids. He can make progress in certain areas of his life as he matures but he's never going to suddenly transform into someone else.

Sirzy · 10/06/2023 07:24

https://psychiatry-uk.com/higher-or-lower-why-using-functional-labels-to-describe-autism-is-problematic/#:~:text=Functioning%20descriptors%20can%20inhibit%20autistic,divide%20in%20the%20autistic%20community. I’m not a fan of functioning labels because personally I don’t think they help anyone but I’m not going to berate people who use them because they are widely used in society sadly but I do think discussion about the terminology is important

for me the linked article does a good summary of some of the issues around labels

Higher or Lower? Why using functional labels to describe autism is problematic – Psychiatry-UK

https://psychiatry-uk.com/higher-or-lower-why-using-functional-labels-to-describe-autism-is-problematic/#:~:text=Functioning%20descriptors%20can%20inhibit%20autistic,divide%20in%20the%20autistic%20community.

highlandspooce · 10/06/2023 07:18

LuvSmallDogs · 10/06/2023 07:15

Gotta love how parents trying to describe/ask about their child's ASD always devolves into the always helpful "language bad" telling offs.

It literally happened to us when we were given the official diagnosis sat at a table with a paediatrician, child psychologist, nurse etc. "Any questions?" "Yes, um, we've looked things up, do you think H is high-functioning or low-functioning autistic?" "We don't use those terms >:("

How and when do you place someone in the high/low category?

One of mine absolutely would have been 'low functioning' during the primary school years. He is now at university (albeit living at home) and doing amazing. The other would have been 'high functioning' and had to be taken out of school after years of mental trauma and we are slowly building up into basic social situations such as going to the shop/cafe and holiday. She is doing amazing but she is still a shell of the kid she used to be.

The high/low doesn't always remain the same. People change, autistic people included.

LuvSmallDogs · 10/06/2023 07:15

Gotta love how parents trying to describe/ask about their child's ASD always devolves into the always helpful "language bad" telling offs.

It literally happened to us when we were given the official diagnosis sat at a table with a paediatrician, child psychologist, nurse etc. "Any questions?" "Yes, um, we've looked things up, do you think H is high-functioning or low-functioning autistic?" "We don't use those terms >:("

highlandspooce · 10/06/2023 07:14

What is the best way to describe the autistic spectrum?

The spectrum refers to how an individual is 'affected', not how they line up against others.

For example, I have a friend with an autistic child who is non verbal and incontinent, and will never live independently. I also have a brother in law and sister in law who are autistic but successfully hold down jobs and live independently. They are more mildly affected. How else can one describe such a broad range within one diagnosis?

You managed to do it right there, using words.

Not trying to be combative, trying to say the right thing. My siblings in law self identify as Asperger's but I understand that's frowned upon now.

'Identify as Asperger's' - WTF? If they have an Asperger's diagnosis they can use it all they want and it's nothing to do with anyone else. If not they can fuck right off because 'identify as' isn't a medical diagnosis.

bellac11 · 10/06/2023 07:05

Ontheperiphery79 · 10/06/2023 00:47

@bellac11 in return, who are you to assume that I presume to possess that prerogative?!

As evidenced by your own writing, we don't always write correctly, or as me mean, to.

Part of my idiosyncrasies are processing difficulties, so I perhaps could have phrased it differently (just, my dear, as could you have in your retort).

Because you're telling people not to say things and saying things are outdated. Well not for those with that actual diagnosis its not and its not for you to police peoples speech.

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/06/2023 01:12

I also wish people would back off correcting terminology as its getting ridiculous. Next year it will have changed again.

A lot of autistics describe themselves as high functioning. That is their right. For those of us who dislike the catch all spectrum diagnosis then it can actually be a helpful pointer.

Op please don't panic. You are doing brilliantly getting an EHCP at that age. You can get them for all sorts of things. It's not a predictor of how good a life someone will have.

Ontheperiphery79 · 10/06/2023 00:47

@bellac11 in return, who are you to assume that I presume to possess that prerogative?!

As evidenced by your own writing, we don't always write correctly, or as me mean, to.

Part of my idiosyncrasies are processing difficulties, so I perhaps could have phrased it differently (just, my dear, as could you have in your retort).

PicaK · 10/06/2023 00:30

You have no idea how lucky you are with your preschool - to be getting him on this path to an EHCP at this stage is amazing. It will make things easier.

Bobbybobbins · 10/06/2023 00:21

It's great if you can get an EHCP done at nursery. Sets them up so much better for school. We did with both of ours though DS1 was July before he started at school in September!!

Carrusa · 10/06/2023 00:14

PollyPeep · 10/06/2023 00:04

What is the best way to describe the autistic spectrum? For example, I have a friend with an autistic child who is non verbal and incontinent, and will never live independently. I also have a brother in law and sister in law who are autistic but successfully hold down jobs and live independently. They are more mildly affected. How else can one describe such a broad range within one diagnosis? Not trying to be combative, trying to say the right thing. My siblings in law self identify as Asperger's but I understand that's frowned upon now.

We were given this when our son was diagnosed.
https://the-art-of-autism.com/understanding-the-spectrum-a-comic-strip-explanation/

It does get very combative and language changes all the time, but this cobweb kind of idea makes sense to us and seems the most widely accepted at the moment. I think it's a great build on the original idea of the spectrum.

Understanding the spectrum – a comic strip explanation

By Rebecca Burgess   For printable PDF version in English click here.  For version in Spanish click here. French version click here.

https://the-art-of-autism.com/understanding-the-spectrum-a-comic-strip-explanation

PollyPeep · 10/06/2023 00:04

Ontheperiphery79 · 09/06/2023 22:23

Please don't use functioning labels. They're outdated and insulting to Autistic people. 🤦🏼‍♀️ They often seem to be used by allists desperate to prove that their child is not 'that bad' or 'not that Autistic'.

What is the best way to describe the autistic spectrum? For example, I have a friend with an autistic child who is non verbal and incontinent, and will never live independently. I also have a brother in law and sister in law who are autistic but successfully hold down jobs and live independently. They are more mildly affected. How else can one describe such a broad range within one diagnosis? Not trying to be combative, trying to say the right thing. My siblings in law self identify as Asperger's but I understand that's frowned upon now.

MrsLamb · 09/06/2023 23:44

It's worth reading the EHCP section of the SEN Code of Practice so you understand the process you are in (you can find on gov.uk.). IPSEA and SOS SEN have good resources on their websites too.

Plans are legallly binding on all parties so helpful if you are prepped and ready to contribute, including descriptions of your child's needs and your family wishes/goals for your child. Think nationally around 4% of kids of school age have EHCPs if that helps? They are for children who need more support than is available just through the SENCO at school. Lot of children in mainstream schools have them, but they are also potentially the means to get a place at a special school if that is what is needed.