Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so worried re EHC Plan

85 replies

WayneCampbellsSidekick · 09/06/2023 21:57

My 3year old son is having an application made for an EHC Plan on the advice of his preschool following a visit from the local SEN advisor (high functioning ASD).
Am I right in saying they would only be doing this if his needs are deemed to be severe? So many questions and worries. Desperate for reassurance and advice/insight - is anyone who has been in this situation able to give any please?

OP posts:
WayneCampbellsSidekick · 10/06/2023 16:16

Thankyou everyone for your replies and reassurances. So many different scenarios running through my mind. So now the preschool are requesting the EHCP, what are my next steps? Is there anyone’s door I should be hanging on? Thankyou again for all your responses, I’m very grateful for any advice and insight xx

OP posts:
JeandeServiette · 10/06/2023 16:13

Don't be scared off @WayneCampbellsSidekick

As you see, there are some contested issues around autism, but the key thing for your DS is on track to get the help she needs and get it early. Which is huge.

itsgettingweird · 10/06/2023 12:57

It's great they are already setting it up for your ds to receive the support he needs.

My ds has asd (camhs even described him as what people call HFA rather than Asperger's 🤷‍♀️) and a neuromuscular condition.

It's nothing to do with functioning or IQ (my ds iq is really high) but rather where the support is greater than usually provided under sen support in schools.

Everyone is different but despite having an EHCP through until he finished college my ds has 10 GCSEs 9-4, equivalent to 3.5 a levels at grade B and a level 4 qualification, works in computers at a high level and competes for Britain in his sport.

Despite being highly intelligent he has severe problems in some areas of learning and academically needed support to communicate his knowledge and learn some skills required for adult life.

An EHCP is no indication of prognosis. It's to enable young people to meet their own personal full potential.

PollyPeep · 10/06/2023 12:53

Sensibletrousers · 10/06/2023 11:22

This graphic is helpful.

My 14yo son can pass as “high functioning” or even neurotypical- but inly because we have curated and managed his life, environment, school, advocated for him, taught him to self advocate, manage his sensory and social needs daily, plan for every eventuality, etc etc so that his needs are met most of the time. He still needs a lot of down time as all of the “high functioning” and masking takes its toll, and that’s what people don’t see. All of the accommodations and thought and effort that makes it possible.

But if anyone saw him in meltdown, or suicidal Autistic burnout (at age 11), not at school for a year, depressed, a shell of a boy, they would absolutely not describe him as “high functioning”.

Some Autistic people’s challenges are external and visible, others are internal. No two Autistic people are alike. And their “functioning” can change day to day - just as neurotypical people’s can.

Just to add, Asperger’s has not been a diagnosis in the DSM-5 for a decade. Dr Asperger was/is controversial as that diagnosis was originally used for Autistic people who could still be “useful to society / the economy” instead of locked up in institutions or asylums. He was also a N*zi. Just giving some background on why a large part of the Autistic community balk at the label, which is their right. I personally don’t believe in telling anyone how to describe themselves, but some context to the wider conversations will help with understanding.

Thank you, that graphic is helpful.

PollyPeep · 10/06/2023 12:49

highlandspooce · 10/06/2023 08:56

@PollyPeep

Are you always this rude?

When people 'identify as' a disability?, yeah, probably.

I actually didn't mean to be rude there but you can't identify as Asperger's. You either have the diagnosis, and n which case you can use it, or you don't, In which case you don't.

Ah I think perhaps my post wasn't clear. They do have autism which is "high functioning", diagnosed when children. This was originally called Asperger's which I know is a term that was fallen out of favour, but they use this term themselves to describe themselves. Another poster said that certain labels are insulting to austistic people but I think people have the right to use what they feel best fits their condition.

TheSnowyOwl · 10/06/2023 11:35

The EHCP can be fantastic to make sure that school is able to meet your child’s needs and get any additional funding and resources required for this.

TheSnowyOwl · 10/06/2023 11:33

PollyPeep · 10/06/2023 00:04

What is the best way to describe the autistic spectrum? For example, I have a friend with an autistic child who is non verbal and incontinent, and will never live independently. I also have a brother in law and sister in law who are autistic but successfully hold down jobs and live independently. They are more mildly affected. How else can one describe such a broad range within one diagnosis? Not trying to be combative, trying to say the right thing. My siblings in law self identify as Asperger's but I understand that's frowned upon now.

My daughters were termed as level 1/2 but I know of other children who are level 3.

Dancingcandlesticks · 10/06/2023 11:29

The problem with low and high function is that it’s often used as a term to denote how academically able a child is, which does not necessarily correlate with their life skills or other challenges. it’s wildly simplistic and doesn’t really aid with understanding what support that person needs or their gifts and strengths.

You can be a person who finds learning hard but is less impacted by sensory issues or is socially more able to interact with non autistic people (this may come at a mental health cost… which is another thing!).

You can also be MENSA level acdemically but struggling to manage day to day due to the environment or expectations of others. Autistic people (including children) need to be understood for all their strengths and support needs.

The terms are inaccurate for that reason but frequently used by schools and professionals so we absolutely shouldn’t be having a go at parents who use terms they’ve been told.

Sensibletrousers · 10/06/2023 11:22

This graphic is helpful.

My 14yo son can pass as “high functioning” or even neurotypical- but inly because we have curated and managed his life, environment, school, advocated for him, taught him to self advocate, manage his sensory and social needs daily, plan for every eventuality, etc etc so that his needs are met most of the time. He still needs a lot of down time as all of the “high functioning” and masking takes its toll, and that’s what people don’t see. All of the accommodations and thought and effort that makes it possible.

But if anyone saw him in meltdown, or suicidal Autistic burnout (at age 11), not at school for a year, depressed, a shell of a boy, they would absolutely not describe him as “high functioning”.

Some Autistic people’s challenges are external and visible, others are internal. No two Autistic people are alike. And their “functioning” can change day to day - just as neurotypical people’s can.

Just to add, Asperger’s has not been a diagnosis in the DSM-5 for a decade. Dr Asperger was/is controversial as that diagnosis was originally used for Autistic people who could still be “useful to society / the economy” instead of locked up in institutions or asylums. He was also a N*zi. Just giving some background on why a large part of the Autistic community balk at the label, which is their right. I personally don’t believe in telling anyone how to describe themselves, but some context to the wider conversations will help with understanding.

To be so worried re EHC Plan
Mydcchangedmyusername · 10/06/2023 10:29

I find it interesting that the debate is usually about high functioning and low functioning as if there isn't a middle ground.

highlandspooce · 10/06/2023 09:40

the 'can't wipe his bum now he's at uni' thing hit a raw nerve.

I really didn't say this. I said i toileted him until he was almost 10 and his needs changed dramatically over the next few years. I still have to give a lot of support but I can see a future for him I didn't envisage back then.

Sorry to raise it but I relent don't want to be misquoted.

Sirzy · 10/06/2023 09:27

One word of warning is be prepared for it to be a fight. A lot of areas seem to refuse to applications for needs assessments as standard even when the criteria are clearly met. Be prepared to appeal. Read up and make yourself knowledgable about the law because some local authorities have odd definitions.

sadly a lot of children end up left behind because parents aren’t able to do the fighting needed. That isn’t anything against the parents but it’s a system which sets young people up to fail

take any help you can now to get things in place.

PN54DJS · 10/06/2023 09:23

Ontheperiphery79 · 09/06/2023 22:23

Please don't use functioning labels. They're outdated and insulting to Autistic people. 🤦🏼‍♀️ They often seem to be used by allists desperate to prove that their child is not 'that bad' or 'not that Autistic'.

But some people simply are high functioning...

It isn't offensive at all.

Gtsr443 · 10/06/2023 09:14

@highlandspooce No probs. Forget about it. We're all in it together. I've just had a week of dealing with doctors and psychiatrists and PIP and EHCP and I'm so fucking worn out with having to defend and explain myself. I shouldn't have posted really. Apologies too for ablist thing - the 'can't wipe his bum now he's at uni' thing hit a raw nerve. Have a good day.

Inthedarkagain · 10/06/2023 09:14

That's a fair point Sirzy. They should really be basing his level of functioning on his ability to be independent though IMO, not where he is academically. I this is a symptom of the lack of support and underfunded services more than anything.

Dancingcandlesticks · 10/06/2023 09:13

I am in the process of applying for an EHCP for my older autistic child who isn’t able to cope. This is sadly common.

It is really good news if you school/nursery are ensuring your child has support from the start. From my anecdotal evidence few autistic children manage the transition to secondary school without needing additional help (sometimes moving schools or even leaving school altogether). The children who have had an EHCP in primary seem to fair better.

I know plenty of teens with EHCPs who are doing well academically. It’s a bit of a common misconception that it’s all about intelligence or academic potential. It’s about getting the right support around children and YP so they can access education.

TravellingSpoon · 10/06/2023 09:11

Could we get back to the point of the OP'S thread? The OP is clearly a Mum who is anxious and worried about the future and all this disagreement isnt going to help. Can you take your 'debate' somewhere else because all you are doing is derailing the thread and it isnt helpful, infact it seems cruel.

OP - My son has had an EHCP since he was 6 (although it was a statement for the first couple of years, which is what children had under the old system). The process can be frustrating, and at times it can be drawn out, but a good EHCP can ensure your child gets the support they need. In our case, it also means he has a place at a special school, which he wouldnt get without one. Mainsteam beyond reception was a disaster for him.

As a PP said, SOS SEN or IPSEA are a great support. There are also some great FB groups if you are on FB.

Please try not to worry, it is a good thing the professionals involved in your sons care are doing this. A large number of people have to fight to get professionals to listen.

Inthedarkagain · 10/06/2023 09:10

I do think this could be a supportive thread if there is less bickering over semantics. It is clear some people find the 'high/low functioning' label helpful, whereas others don't like it. It's down to them and nobody else what they choose to use. I personally would rather use a simple label than gave to give a lengthy description of my son's needs. I have found it helpful, otherwise people tend to minimise his needs, which doesn't help accessing support. Each to their own I say. Both sides of the argument are right.

Sirzy · 10/06/2023 09:08

Inthedarkagain · 10/06/2023 08:33

I agree with this. My son is probably autistic and probably at the lower functioning end. Getting assessed soon hopefully. I'd rather be able to say he is lower functioning so people understand his needs as a lot of people still assume autism is just a bit of social anxiety and intense interests!

Watch thread with interest as I'm waiting for EHCNA currently.

But this is where it gets complicated. My son would probably be classed as high functioning because he is fairly academically able. But that doesn’t show the exceptional level of support he needs. He is 13 and has full 1-1 in school. He can’t be left alone at all, the idea of being able to nip to the shop and leave him home is years off if ever. He doesn’t sleep properly. He doesn’t eat. He only became fully independent with toileting last year (and still not 100% reliably)

but because he can attend mainstream school people see him as high functioning so the expectations of what he can do are unrealistic if people just see a function label. I am at the point of starting to really worry about adulthood and what that will look like for him.

really functional labels in my view are about how things look to outsiders rather than the actual day to day life lived.

DyslexiaMum1 · 10/06/2023 09:05

And for the OP, I echo PP.

Absolutely brilliant that the pre school are doing this. Engage fully and advocate for your boy. Get him ALL the support he needs.

We are having our Ed Psych visit next week for our child who is going through the EHCNA (NA-needs assessment) and he is in y4. A bright child but unable to read or write above reception level and whilst "high-functioning", when his anxiety hits....the levels of fear and violence are debilitating for them and the whole family. He has a range of SpLD (diagnosed).

Good luck x

DyslexiaMum1 · 10/06/2023 09:01

Her sister hasn't "identified" as Aspergers. The PP clearly said her sister was diagnosed with Autism, the diagnosis given was "Aspergers" and although "Aspergers" is not a term used as widely anymore, her sister feels "aspergers" best fits the way her autism presents. Essentially a type of "higher functioning autism".

So much aggression when I think at the end of the day, we are all on the same page....advocating for support for the autistic community? But I may be wrong.

highlandspooce · 10/06/2023 08:58

Gtsr443 · 10/06/2023 08:37

@highlandspooce I've been up all night with my son. I'm very tired and stressed having had a bitch of a week dealing with my son's medical issues and I need you like a fucking hole in the head dissecting every opinion this morning. I don't agree with you. I think you are talking ablist shite actually. But anyway have a nice day.

Apologies; I thought we were just having a balanced discussion there. I didn't mean to antagonise you but I am absolutely not being ableist at all. It's a horrible word to throw at someone who has indicated they have at least 3 autistic children. I'm autistic myself so perhaps my communication isn't the best but I absolutely didn't intend to appear ableist. I want the best for everyone here.

I'm sorry again

highlandspooce · 10/06/2023 08:56

@PollyPeep

Are you always this rude?

When people 'identify as' a disability?, yeah, probably.

I actually didn't mean to be rude there but you can't identify as Asperger's. You either have the diagnosis, and n which case you can use it, or you don't, In which case you don't.

Gtsr443 · 10/06/2023 08:37

@highlandspooce I've been up all night with my son. I'm very tired and stressed having had a bitch of a week dealing with my son's medical issues and I need you like a fucking hole in the head dissecting every opinion this morning. I don't agree with you. I think you are talking ablist shite actually. But anyway have a nice day.

Inthedarkagain · 10/06/2023 08:33

bellac11 · 09/06/2023 23:33

Who are you to think you speak for everyone. My sister describes herself as high functioning because she is, sees herself as that and this is what she was diagnosed with when she was diagnosed with Aspergers.

As someone says, names, language, terminlogy changes every 5 mins, often for the worse to become less descriptive and helpful.

I agree with this. My son is probably autistic and probably at the lower functioning end. Getting assessed soon hopefully. I'd rather be able to say he is lower functioning so people understand his needs as a lot of people still assume autism is just a bit of social anxiety and intense interests!

Watch thread with interest as I'm waiting for EHCNA currently.

Swipe left for the next trending thread