Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Legal and ethical dilemma

173 replies

sunshine080 · 09/06/2023 21:40

My job requires a professional registration in order to perform. My current registration expires shortly and I have been contacted to renew it. In order to renew I have to confirm that I am still fit to practice, and declare that there have been no changes to my health that would impact this. So I have two choices; lie and keep my job (because without a registration, I have no job), or declare my health issues, be unable to renew and lose my job - which subsequently means losing my house, being unable to support my family and child, etc. I am already in a high state of anxiety about this predicament and the closer it gets to the expiration date, the worse it's getting.

WWYD?

OP posts:
ErmentrudeTheCow · 10/06/2023 05:25

What was the amitryptiline prescribed for? It's usually used for nerve pain

Oreoo · 10/06/2023 05:02

You need to ask your medical team their opinion I have chronic health conditions and I'm FTP. I take medical advice , medication and reasonable adjustments if needed. It depends what the condition is could you change job role to something less physically demanding?

Nanaof1 · 10/06/2023 04:55

Nanaof1 · 10/06/2023 04:24

What kind of health issues do you have? I think a lot depends on just what your job is and how the health issues affect that.
It never seems to end well when people lie. It might work at first, but it's difficult to live a lie and remember it each and every single day.

Okay, finished reading the thread. Perimenopause is not a life-changing medical issue. It's one that needs some medical help to get sorted but it will improve with either HRT, decent anti-depressants and getting rid of your anxiety. Honestly, it sounds like your symptoms are making you anxious and panicky. That's normal. Get to the menopause clinic (sounds wonderful and very worth it to me). They will help you, as will your work if you are just honest with them. I hope you soon find relief.

Nanaof1 · 10/06/2023 04:24

sunshine080 · 09/06/2023 21:40

My job requires a professional registration in order to perform. My current registration expires shortly and I have been contacted to renew it. In order to renew I have to confirm that I am still fit to practice, and declare that there have been no changes to my health that would impact this. So I have two choices; lie and keep my job (because without a registration, I have no job), or declare my health issues, be unable to renew and lose my job - which subsequently means losing my house, being unable to support my family and child, etc. I am already in a high state of anxiety about this predicament and the closer it gets to the expiration date, the worse it's getting.

WWYD?

What kind of health issues do you have? I think a lot depends on just what your job is and how the health issues affect that.
It never seems to end well when people lie. It might work at first, but it's difficult to live a lie and remember it each and every single day.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 04:18

alpenguin · 10/06/2023 03:53

Perimenopause as awful as it can be, isn’t a declarable Illness it’s a life stage all women go through and it is something that can be managed effectively with HRT and if necessary antidepressants. It also sounds like counselling might also be beneficial to you.

Unless you have an actual serious illness that affects fitness to practice then re-register and take the time to try to fix the peri-m symptoms. Speak to your occupationsm health department for support and advice and consider taking some sick leave to properly care for yourself.

Menstruation is a life stage women go through, yet I was with Dsis when she collapsed fainting with pain on a railway station platform.

The symptoms are the problem, illness or not.

alpenguin · 10/06/2023 03:53

Perimenopause as awful as it can be, isn’t a declarable Illness it’s a life stage all women go through and it is something that can be managed effectively with HRT and if necessary antidepressants. It also sounds like counselling might also be beneficial to you.

Unless you have an actual serious illness that affects fitness to practice then re-register and take the time to try to fix the peri-m symptoms. Speak to your occupationsm health department for support and advice and consider taking some sick leave to properly care for yourself.

bottleofbeer · 10/06/2023 03:43

Generous sick leave policy? For real?

Hahaha

user1492757084 · 10/06/2023 03:28

You need to find a way to become healthy enough to practise.
I would lie and then make sure I were healthy and fit to meet regulations.
Seek professional help in getting well as quickly as you can.

Titusgroan · 10/06/2023 02:51

As long as the menopause drugs do the trick just write on the form you have the menopause and presumably the medication you are on thats required
However if drugs are not sorting your symptoms out it is unethical to carry on working in a clinical environment dealing with people.
What if something dreadful happened and it was found you had lied. The registration will include insurance so if a claim is made it will be investigated.

No offence OP but I wouldn’t want someone with brain fog, forgetting things etc dealing with me or my family.

You say you could, in your job, kill someone. If you lied and someone one died or was hurt you’d end up in jail.

HerbsandSpices · 10/06/2023 01:06

I do think if you're not fit to practice and may harm someone, you have to declare it. However, since this seems to be a case of severe menopause related symptoms, I think you should consult a menopause specialist, as has been suggested. I know it makes things harder and can be awful to live through, but there is help available. If you haven't consulted a menopause specialist, you haven't tried all avenues yet.

SpringViolet · 10/06/2023 00:56

I found it helpful to print of a copy of the NICE guidelines for perimenopause/menopause diagnosis and take it with me to the GP demanding to know why they weren’t following them when I was suffering but kept getting fobbed off.

https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng23/chapter/Recommendations#diagnosis-of-perimenopause-and-menopause

i was initially prescribed synthetic HRT but after reading on here, asked for bio identical HRT and was again fobbed of so again asked why they weren’t following NICE guidelines for prescribing it and got it without a murmur.

Please go back to your GP and do the above, then take a a few weeks off work to let HRT kick in (night sweats and brain fog cleared pretty quickly for me). Tell GP it is affecting your work so you get signed off.

Recommendations | Menopause: diagnosis and management | Guidance | NICE

https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng23/chapter/Recommendations#diagnosis-of-perimenopause-and-menopause

Whoiscomingtosaveyou · 10/06/2023 00:37

I would invest the money going to a private menopause clinic asap. Speak with your employer about menopause support also.
My symptoms resolved within 3 weeks of starting treatment and your professional body will have some leeway for payment timing. Your employer should support you whilst you start treatment, even it it means reduced caseload for that time.

Ponderingwindow · 10/06/2023 00:37

This really has nothing to do with the registration. If your health changes are significant enough to cause the registration to be denied, they are significant enough for you to need to declare preemptively.

can you look into a moderate-term sick leave to allow you to focus on running down this issue

another option might be switching to a reduced schedule.

Even working 80% might give you the extra rest you need. Yes, it would mean a reduced income, but possibly not as reduced as changing careers.

DramaAlpaca · 10/06/2023 00:31

LaurieFairyCake · 09/06/2023 22:25

WHAT !!!

It's menopause ! You take the drugs ! You spend £300 at the Newson clinic if you have to and get HRT Flowers

In a few weeks with a few patches YOU WILL BE FINE

YOU ARE FIT TO PRACTICE - you just feel shit, I know and I've been there FlowersFlowersFlowers

Get someone to check your work, you have well being policies - the NMC are not going to accept that as a health condition

Absolutely this!!!

pizzaHeart · 10/06/2023 00:30

I agree with PPs that if you feel so unwell you shouldn’t practice atm you should ask for a sick leave.

I know it sounds too simple but have you read Davina’s book about menopause? It helps to get your thoughts together for an appointment and give your language to describe the whole picture. Your anxiety about the situation is high and it looks like your GP is literally blinded by it and doesn’t go into other symptoms. Davina’s book gives your examples how to describe different symptoms without sounding too anxious.

Catpuss66 · 10/06/2023 00:28

Don’t just assume it is the menopause, I worked in the nhs for 36 yrs & felt ILL for a couple of years raised bp, ocular migraines everything was changing tasks took longer, hearing loss, eyes deteriorating put it down to advancing years & menopause. Started HRT did help with ‘ anxiety’ that I could not control, psychological release of adrenaline up to 50 times a day. Lucky I was able to retire at 55. The nhs were unsupportive, bullying. I since have found out I have multiple autoimmune conditions & kidney disease, I think it was triggered by the menopause. See your union or ACAS get some support. There are menopause clinics or well women clinics. I am shocked how easily we women are labelled as emotional, there is very little professional curiosity. With work you have to be honest your professional body will withdraw your pin if they find you have not being honest you know this. I did this you start to worrying about the future, losing your house all this effort thinking about this ( which may not happen) not enough maintaining your PIN & asking HR & OH for help. If the person who you say is your friend told you this not sure she is. What did she think it Was going to make you feel better remember management look after their own. Be proactive. Best of luck

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 10/06/2023 00:26

@porridgeisbae
I don't feel HRT will directly help (except maybe via placebo effect) - your doctor would probably have prescribed it nowadays if you were going through menopause and wanted it, as they are less worried about cancer risk etc than they once were.

They have to accept you're peri-menopausal first. One of the GPs at my surgery absolutely refuses to accept that I am despite the long list of symptoms and issues. She doesn't seem to believe peri-menopause is a thing and as I'm still having periods it's nothing to do with the menopause.

Talking to a different GP got me the Mirena which at least has sorted out the flooding.

Amybelle88 · 10/06/2023 00:26

Re-register and take some time off - I think this is actually what you need and your situation could be rectified, but you need to be away from work in order for it to happen. Get tested for menopause and go from there, but ask for second opinions along the way if you're not happy.

If nothing changes and you don't feel you can be responsible, then consider the other route.

Sending lots of healing x

silentpool · 10/06/2023 00:25

Please go see a menopause specialist. GPs are often gatekeepers on this issue. Since I went on HRT (estrogen, progesterone and now just recently testosterone), it's been night and day in terms of my well being.

Bananarepublic · 10/06/2023 00:25

Endofroadwhatnext · 09/06/2023 23:38

OP I think you are seeing this as too black and white.
i am a HCP and there have been times I’ve been unfit to work due to ill health, on one occasion for 5 months.
the answer was not to deregister but take sick leave whilst working on the problem, being referred to OH and being supported to practice within the scope if my abilities when I returned.
when I read your post I thought I was going to read that you had a serious neurological or mental health issue or drug dependency and not peri menopause symptoms. Whilst I do not doubt you are unwell that does not strike me as warranting relinquishment of your registration.
I would suggest taking a proactive approach here- go to your Gp and say that things are so bad you may have to deregister. If that doesn’t prompt them to investigate or operation then get a private consult- yes it’s expensive but not as expensive as losing your job.
Get signed off for a bit- therefore nothing legally or morally to compromise you.
speak to your Manager and ask for a referral to OH- there will be adjustments they can make to help you function adequately.

You're absolutely right. Although I wonder if the anxiety the OP is feeling about this issue might in itself be part of the peri menopause symptoms. I certainly found even simple setbacks as insurmountable for a while. That's definitely improved by some degree but is still not quite what it was.

LadyVF · 10/06/2023 00:18

I don’t work for them BTW!

LadyVF · 10/06/2023 00:18

£300 for an appointment with a meno GP at the BUPA menopause plan here
I saw an excellent Dr (after not being abje to get an appt with my own one and suffering increasingly intolerable symptoms). Called them, and got an online appt within days. HRT prescription sorted.

Menopause Plan | Menopause treatment | Bupa UK

Our Menopause Plan includes two consultations with a doctor trained in menopause, a care plan, a 24/7 Anytime HealthLine, and more.

https://www.bupa.co.uk/health/payg/menopause-plan

Gremlinsateit · 10/06/2023 00:15

This is not an either/or situation, OP, and I expect that it’s your symptoms (and possibly your medication) that are making you feel like you have only two choices.

You need to make an appointment to see a new doctor, first of all.

Then inform your professional body that you will have a condition to declare when you register but you’re seeing a dr about it and will let them know more when you do.

Then depending on timing of the registration, either declare diagnosed depression (or whatever the first dr said) or symptoms of peri menopause (if the second dr says so).

PPs have helpful advice too. Don’t despair! This is a completely manageable situation and you have the skills to manage it.

DarkDarkNight · 10/06/2023 00:14

I’m sorry you are experiencing this. Can you see another GP? You need to keep pushing. Anecdotally I have a few friends who have had brilliant results with HRT and also medication for vitamin D after one was found to be very deficient. They had the same symptoms - brain fog, anger, feeling very down, lack of energy and now feel much more themselves.

Has your company got a Menopause policy (are you NHS?). Approach Occupational Health and if you don’t get any help go off in sick and get signed off while you get sorted. Insist on another GP, don’t be fobbed off with antidepressants which aren’t getting to the root of the problem.

bumblenbean · 10/06/2023 00:12

@TheodoreMortlock impairment by reason of health is still a FTP issue, but is obviously treated differently to misconduct issues. It does still go before a FTP committee if it gets to that stage (and many cases don’t!) as it is a ground of impairment just like misconduct, lack of competence, conviction etc.

OP, I’m a regulatory lawyer. I deal with FTP cases in healthcare every day. Having a health condition, particularly something like menopausal symptoms, is by no means an automatic bar to renewal. But if it’s impacting your day to day life/ practice and you have serious concerns about safety, you do need to be honest about it. When you renew for most healthcare regulators, you have to sign a declaration confirming whether you have health conditions. If you falsely state no, that in itself can become a misconduct FTP matter (should it come to light that you do- although arguably if you don’t have a diagnosed condition it might not).

I would definitely make use of your regulator’s guidance online and advice line (most have them), and talk to your union and employer. If your health was investigated by your regulator the usual process is that you undergo a medical assessment and they give an expert view. They can comment on whether they think it affects your FTP and any adjustments / treatment etc they think is needed. Only in the most serious cases (often severe mental health / addiction issues) do they say the person is completely unfit to practise in any circumstances.

but please don’t write yourself off like this- there is no way you should just accept menopausal symptoms (if that’s what they are) mean the end of your career. I would 100% open an honest and constructive dialogue with your employer and speak to your regulator - they aren’t out to remove people Willy nilly and will want to do what they can to support you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread