Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for 50% of pizza cost from friend?

242 replies

rainonmetonightnel · 09/06/2023 21:16

I had a friend over who's actually my SIL also.

She suggested getting a Papa John's when I said I could do us a just salad for lunch

I said that sounded nice, so ordered it from my app on the just eat app.

It came and I went to have a slice. She had plated herself up with half the pizza, despite me mentioning previously that I'd give DS a slice or two when he came home, as a treat (he really likes cold pizza!)

She hasn't mentioned paying me back, at all

When she was finished eating, all of it was gone

We ordered a large pizza

AIBU to ask for 50%? She also drank most of the 7UP

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 09/06/2023 23:28

A: she should have sucked it up and ate what you offered
B: you need to suck up the cost after you agreed to it and chalk it up to the price of hosting.

C: wow this all sounds so petty on all sides

Lacucuracha · 09/06/2023 23:28

Absolutely ask for half.

Did you invite her for lunch though? Or did she outstay her welcome?

Next time tell her you’ve got no food in and no money to order a takeaway.

I’m guessing she never hosts and wouldn’t spend a penny on you? People like this never do.

Nicecow · 09/06/2023 23:25

Your SIL and your friend, can you really not shout her half a pizza 🙄 next time don't order it if you don't want to.

PumpkinQueen1 · 09/06/2023 23:15

I think she's a cheeky fucker.

You offered her a salad, she suggested getting a Papa Johns. You then offered to cook her a pizza from your freezer, but she persuaded you to buy a Papa Johns. And then expected you to pay for it all.

I feel its a bit too late to ask her for money now, but next time she suggests lunch I would say to her that it's her turn to pay. And in future tell her you can't afford a takeaway, so it's salad, freezer pizza, or nothing!

ArgosKettle · 09/06/2023 23:12

My parents always taught me if you cant do something with taste, best not to bother.

It sounds like the biggest issue to you is the money... Inviting someone for lunch which would have consisted of salad leaves and a few extra's isn't lunch. And complaining hours later over a few pounds is such poor taste. You sound really hard up and its okay, but if that is the case; don't host 'Lunch' and get stroppy that guests want to eat an actual meal.

AliceMcK · 09/06/2023 23:03

rainonmetonightnel · 09/06/2023 21:24

It was large? And was actually really big!

My DDs could polish off a large pappa johns pizza between them when they were 5 & 7 yo

Next time you arrange a lunch date say great let’s do xy or Z and your treat this time.

Livingincanadaafter19yearsinlondon · 09/06/2023 23:03

HappyCatty · 09/06/2023 22:55

A large papa johns pizza is big.

In your opinion. Clearly not in your SIL's.

Anyway, salad and a few other bits were also on the table too

Ah, a nice drip feed. So really it's not about the money, you just think your SIL is a greedy pig who should have willingly given up some of her pizza for your son and not guzzled most of the pop.

I feel bad now for previous post. I had thought SIL ate all of the pizza bar one slice. Misunderstood that one! So OP is annoyed SIL ate half a pizza, the same amount she would have eaten had she not decided to keep some back for her son. Is that it?

Watchinghurling · 09/06/2023 23:02

It would be tight to ask for money now. Just ask for her to pay the next time.

FreefallFlight174 · 09/06/2023 23:01

The Papa John's website says a large is 13.5 inches? That would only serve 2 moderately hungry adults in our house, so YABU OP

Hollyppp · 09/06/2023 22:58

It’s too late to ask for the money now.

Just order the same at her house next time and get her to pay and don’t pay your half. Say ‘oh it’s your turn to get this one’

ArgosKettle · 09/06/2023 22:58

rainonmetonightnel · 09/06/2023 22:50

Also, just pizza? Why on earth wouldn't you chuck some salad out too? Maybe then your SIL wouldn't have eaten all "her" half and also incorrectly thought that since you had planned to provide lunch then you would get the pizza instead... Just message her and say, lovely to see you, the pizza was X amount, just send it over when you get a chance.

A large papa johns pizza is big. Anyway, salad and a few other bits were also on the table too

To be fair, if someone invited me over to their house for lunch; I wouldn't expect to pay for said lunch.
Salad and bits doesn't seem like lunch to me, its usually to accompany a meal. Also, I have to say a large pizza doesn't get shared in my house. I have a large and finish it by myself.

How long have you been friends?

HappyCatty · 09/06/2023 22:55

A large papa johns pizza is big.

In your opinion. Clearly not in your SIL's.

Anyway, salad and a few other bits were also on the table too

Ah, a nice drip feed. So really it's not about the money, you just think your SIL is a greedy pig who should have willingly given up some of her pizza for your son and not guzzled most of the pop.

rainonmetonightnel · 09/06/2023 22:50

Also, just pizza? Why on earth wouldn't you chuck some salad out too? Maybe then your SIL wouldn't have eaten all "her" half and also incorrectly thought that since you had planned to provide lunch then you would get the pizza instead... Just message her and say, lovely to see you, the pizza was X amount, just send it over when you get a chance.

A large papa johns pizza is big. Anyway, salad and a few other bits were also on the table too

OP posts:
HappyCatty · 09/06/2023 22:49

rainonmetonightnel · 09/06/2023 22:38

Well there was because I left some for him

But, but, but... that was YOUR choice. If someone expected me to give up some of my lunch so someone could have it cold later they'd get short shrift. If they were going to be there eating with us, then I'd have said we should order an XXL or whatever would be enough for three people. So when you looked and all the pizza was gone, that was because she (quite rightly) had taken her half, you had had yours and made the decision to leave some of yours for your son. You made it sound like she had taken her half, you had taken one slice and then when you looked again, all the pizza had gone. Which clearly wasn't the case. You are complaining she ate her half, but then complaining that you couldn't have the same amount as her AND have some left for your son. Goodness!

Also, just pizza? Why on earth wouldn't you chuck some salad out too? Maybe then your SIL wouldn't have eaten all "her" half and also incorrectly thought that since you had planned to provide lunch then you would get the pizza instead... Just message her and say, lovely to see you, the pizza was X amount, just send it over when you get a chance.

Dacadactyl · 09/06/2023 22:47

nebulae · 09/06/2023 22:13

So a pizza doesn't do 4 people in your house then, since you're having garlic bread (which is like extra pizza really) and salad with it. A pizza partly does 4 people in your house.

The point being that there were only 2 of them, therefore one pizza wouldn't be a stingy portion.

Florissante · 09/06/2023 22:42

Boomshock · 09/06/2023 22:36

It would be plenty for dinner too.

Most large pizzas would be 2000kcal minimum for a thin crust!

MN bingo: "no wonder we have an obesity crisis in this country" and "we've lost sight of what a normal portion looks like".

SouthLondonMum22 · 09/06/2023 22:40

rainonmetonightnel · 09/06/2023 22:37

I suppose I'm just annoyed because it's fine to take half if you're actually paying! Not just almost insisting on papa johns then not handing anything over

So if she didn't eat half, you wouldn't be asking her to contribute towards it?

Falafelfiend · 09/06/2023 22:39

See, I think the opposite. I don't like the nickel and diming over a 7 Up. Sometimes I pay, sometimes my sister does.

We are also close. That's why I don't want to send her a bill because she was hungry!

Holly60 · 09/06/2023 22:39

I think there are two separate issues. I think you were unreasonable to assume she was happy to share her lunch with your DS.

I think she was unreasonable to not pay for what she ate

rainonmetonightnel · 09/06/2023 22:38

ApiratesaysYarrr · 09/06/2023 22:31

But presumably you also ate half the pizza if there was none left for your DS?

Well there was because I left some for him

OP posts:
Holly60 · 09/06/2023 22:37

Falafelfiend · 09/06/2023 22:34

People must have different relationships than I do because if I ever messaged my sister or my SIL for money after a lunch, that would be the end of that relationship. And vice versa. Or any family member.

They sound like very fragile relationships then.

I'd message 'Oi you owe me for lunch' and they'd message back 'how much?' Or '😂😂😂' depending on their mood. But we are quite close and get each other.

aSofaNearYou · 09/06/2023 22:37

It's fine to want to split the cost, that or one of you paying are both fine imo. But I also don't think she was wrong to take half the pizza. The idea was for you two to share, that was probably how much she wanted to eat, so if you just declared you'd save son for your son, rather than asking if she minded splitting three ways, it wasn't unreasonable to assume you meant from your half.

rainonmetonightnel · 09/06/2023 22:37

Mirabai · 09/06/2023 21:36

If you wanted your son to have a piece could you not have given him a slice of your half?

That aside - CF assuming you’ll pay.

I suppose I'm just annoyed because it's fine to take half if you're actually paying! Not just almost insisting on papa johns then not handing anything over

OP posts:
Boomshock · 09/06/2023 22:36

thanksroyalmaill · 09/06/2023 22:28

I disagree with other posters. I really think sharing a large pizza for lunch with a friend amounts to a normal portion size each. It’s not too small. It’s lunch, not dinner.

I’d only be able to get through a whole large pizza by myself if I hadn’t eaten anything else all day and it was like 10pm. Even then I’d likely be full enough to leave some, or the pizza would get too cold to be enjoyable enough to hoover up. This friend was only popping by too, so it’s not like she would be accessing the pizza at OP’s all night like a family would with a takeaway and constantly graze. I think the friend took the P a bit here.

It would be plenty for dinner too.

Most large pizzas would be 2000kcal minimum for a thin crust!

Falafelfiend · 09/06/2023 22:34

People must have different relationships than I do because if I ever messaged my sister or my SIL for money after a lunch, that would be the end of that relationship. And vice versa. Or any family member.