Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Our children owe us nothing

169 replies

Shesforeverjumpingonthatsofa · 09/06/2023 18:50

Who agrees with this?

I truly believe my Dd (5) owes us nothing when she grows up. I hope hope hope she’ll want to visit regularly and spend time with us, because she wants to, and that is all.
Dh’s mum is always complaining, she’s on her own after fil passed some years ago, but she’s never worked, never learnt to drive. She complains that no one comes to do her garden, to take her food shopping, to pay her bills and help her sort them out etc. I remember when Dh was young and first starting working in his first job and they took a huge amount of board from him-a lot. His brother still lives at home with her and pays the majority of everything (agree he should contribute a fair amount living there, but if he moved out she’d be screwed)
I really feel like I brought my Dd into this world, everything I do for her is because she’s my daughter and I love her, she doesn’t owe me anything
Anyone agree?

OP posts:
DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 09/06/2023 22:32

I agree, but I also think the relationship has gone badly wrong if children feel this way about their parents after they're grown up.

I can't stand parents who think they're owed something. You're supposed to look after your kids. It's not an act of great nobility and it's not a transaction.

Ontheperiphery79 · 09/06/2023 22:31

Definitely agree that our children don't owe us anything when they've flown the nest.

I mean, mine are only 5, so a long way to go, hopefully.

I do have expectations whilst they live with me, such as contributing at an age appropriate, but I hope to God I don't ever try to cling to them/suffocate them like my Mother did to my sister and me.

Hope things pan out okay and they stay in touch when they're adults and come to see me occasionally, but I don't want them to ever obligated.

I do want them to know that they always have a place with me/I'll always try to be there for them if things ever go tits up for either, but my job is to try and raise them to the best of my ability and not stand in their way when the time comes for greater independence.

SuperSleepyBaby · 09/06/2023 22:30

I totally agree- my children own me nothing -but i would like if they turned out to be the sort of people who’d like to help me when i’m old- not for my benefit, but because it would mean they are good people - if that makes sense.

this is how my DH is with his parents. They expext nothing from him but are grateful that he wants to help out and they both enjoy each other’s company. He’s happy to help even if it puts him out..

my parents are the opposite. They expect i behave in certain ways. I feel like everything they ever did for me had strings attached- although i did not realise at the time. I think my parents had a family to create a social structure around them - and it was decided in advance that we would all be close and help each other out - but they have personality disorders etc and issues with alcohol. I did not have a very happy childhood but we are pressured to remember it was the best childhood ever. They feel they are owed for everything- then i get to feelmlike a bad person because i can’t stand them and resent doing anything for them

jannier · 09/06/2023 22:27

Grumpy101 · 09/06/2023 22:22

I see this with my grandmother - she was used to him paying all the bills, handling all the finances, all the practical stuff around the house and when my grandpa died she was completely helpless, so frustratingly useless and absolutely refused to do any of it. We tried to help, it was so frustrating, then COVID hit and she was on her own and started becoming more independent as she had no choice and she's fine now. Took a pandemic for her to figure stuff out!

Was it your grandmother's fault she was born in a time where you went from your parents control to your husband's breaking out was not so easy then ....assuming she's late 60s or older. How old were her parents ....if they were older parents they would have been born in the 1920s or before ....(I'm assuming your 20s, parents late 50s gran 80 so obviously I may be way off but just going on your description of her).

PrinnyPree · 09/06/2023 22:22

WhatNoRaisins · 09/06/2023 19:11

I think it's a good way to think when planning for your own future, you don't know how far away your children will be living for one thing. You can't assume anything in terms of this.

This is how I feel, I have one pre-school aged child and unlikely to have more. I want them to be able to spread their wings and even relocate countries if they want to without feeling the pressure to stay for us even if either of us are widowed. I will try to plan for my future and make sure I have a good support network outside of my child. If it turns out they still want to have a close supportive relationship even in adulthood that will be an added extra.

Having said that I am the main support network for my own Mother, who is in her 70s, and happy to. (Even if it is limiting my ability to move away as she moved to be closer to us after I had a baby) I do enjoy her company though and she was a loving and supportive mother when I was growing up.

I think PP who point out its probably more complicated than that when it comes to the crunch are probably correct though. Failing health, disability and the vulnerability of being widowed are probably extremely difficult and your nature to reach out for family support for comfort may be quite strong. Xx

jannier · 09/06/2023 22:22

Justalittlebitduckling · 09/06/2023 22:17

I disagree, although it’s not a popular view in Western cultures. I think we have a responsibility to cherish our elderly relatives and the way some of them are treated in the UK is a disgrace. Of course you owe them visiting, calling, etc. when they’re in a home in their 90s if they’ve been decent parents. We live in such a a selfish society and we like to pretend the elderly don’t exist.

Yes but why are the younger generations progressively getting more selfish we even see it more often in parents with young children?

Grumpy101 · 09/06/2023 22:22

I see this with my grandmother - she was used to him paying all the bills, handling all the finances, all the practical stuff around the house and when my grandpa died she was completely helpless, so frustratingly useless and absolutely refused to do any of it. We tried to help, it was so frustrating, then COVID hit and she was on her own and started becoming more independent as she had no choice and she's fine now. Took a pandemic for her to figure stuff out!

Srin · 09/06/2023 22:20

In my life time my parents and I have been through so much. Losing my sibling, their marital break up, their patching up of their relationship, me dropping out of uni and them funding me for an extra 2years so I could do another course, my relationship break ups, their ill health, their emotional and practical support with my children and an enormous amount of laughter and companionship. I love my parents and it isn’t about owing them anything but I think it would be odd if I wasn’t there for them when they needed me.

jannier · 09/06/2023 22:20

Shesforeverjumpingonthatsofa · 09/06/2023 22:11

I’m not saying I don’t help my parents are all 🤷🏻‍♀️Of course I would if they need anything, I will always be there for them.
I still stand by saying my Dd doesn’t owe me anything.

Dh does do so many things for mil, he does it, but I still find the way she expects all these things personally quite strange. She’s late 60’s, my parents are the same age and not like this at all.
She lived a life of her husband working and then driving her each week to get the weekly shop etc, him doing the garden and so on. She cooked meals and cleaned sometimes. I remember for years I only ever saw her sat in her chair smoking and watching soaps, then getting the tea ready.
Now she becomes very cross if people don’t have the time to do her garden, take her shopping, take her out, bail her out with bills…I don’t want to do this to my Dd

It sounds a bit like how many of the current generation are bringing up their children....driving them everywhere, not expecting any chores, giving everything asked for, paying for adult children ...yet so many think that's perfectly acceptable and what you do for your children.
Women of her generation were often brought up to expect to be stay at home wives not drive etc....and there are plenty of men who still think similarly if you read many threads on here....
Is it possible that years of being treated like a traditional wife left her incapable of many things or with depression? Do you know much about her history as a young mum...I know many hid everything in those days? It's taken 40 years for me to find out how things were for my mum and what was hidden from me and she's been dead more than 20.

MumApril1990 · 09/06/2023 22:19

She sounds horrible and useless tbh

Justalittlebitduckling · 09/06/2023 22:17

I disagree, although it’s not a popular view in Western cultures. I think we have a responsibility to cherish our elderly relatives and the way some of them are treated in the UK is a disgrace. Of course you owe them visiting, calling, etc. when they’re in a home in their 90s if they’ve been decent parents. We live in such a a selfish society and we like to pretend the elderly don’t exist.

Shesforeverjumpingonthatsofa · 09/06/2023 22:11

*At all

OP posts:
HelpMeGetThrough · 09/06/2023 22:11

My boys owe me nothing, just like I owe my parents nothing.

Like me, they never asked to be born, so nope, me and them are debt free.

Shesforeverjumpingonthatsofa · 09/06/2023 22:11

I’m not saying I don’t help my parents are all 🤷🏻‍♀️Of course I would if they need anything, I will always be there for them.
I still stand by saying my Dd doesn’t owe me anything.

Dh does do so many things for mil, he does it, but I still find the way she expects all these things personally quite strange. She’s late 60’s, my parents are the same age and not like this at all.
She lived a life of her husband working and then driving her each week to get the weekly shop etc, him doing the garden and so on. She cooked meals and cleaned sometimes. I remember for years I only ever saw her sat in her chair smoking and watching soaps, then getting the tea ready.
Now she becomes very cross if people don’t have the time to do her garden, take her shopping, take her out, bail her out with bills…I don’t want to do this to my Dd

OP posts:
jannier · 09/06/2023 22:11

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 09/06/2023 21:22

I don't quite get this really . Surely you do things for your family , because they are your family ? Unless there's history of abuse it's what most people do . People I know anyway .

It works up and down the generations too - my parents have recently passed away, but when they needed extra support at home I took them to appointments, helped with housework etc . Likewise I'll give my son a hand eg give him a lift if he needs it (he's 20s, lives with GF).

Yep....it's done from love and should be both ways

Lesina · 09/06/2023 22:07

I agree OP, my daughter owes me nothing. I chose to bring her into the world and thereby assumed all the responsibility of raising her. She is free of any ‘debt’ to me. I’m just stoked I have brought a great person into being. She and her own child make me smile every day :) the world is better with them in it.

Sunshineishere1988 · 09/06/2023 22:07

Agree with you…its mine and my Husband’s responsibility to prepare for the future and I would never ask my children to change their lives for us at all. If (for example) we were to become ill when we are older, I wouldn’t want to burden them with having to care for us (we would obviously still love to see them all the time - when it fits around their family life/job etc). But I dont like the thought they would ever feel they had to look after us. We try and make the most of every second of them as kids as I want them to live their own lives when they are adults and not feel burdened by us in anyway.

Shesforeverjumpingonthatsofa · 09/06/2023 22:07

@saraclara I’d be devastated! But it still doesn’t mean I believe she owes me anything

OP posts:
Honeychickpea · 09/06/2023 22:06

Lemieux3 · 09/06/2023 19:20

YANBU - I 100% agree.

Part of being a decent parent is accepting that your kids owe you nothing. They did not ask to be born!

And part of being an adult is accepting that your parents no longer owe you anything.

Okshacky · 09/06/2023 22:04

I think I’d be ashamed not to help my mum in the situation you describe. I love her and I can’t imagine not putting myself out to make her feel ok.

WhatWhereWhenHowWhy · 09/06/2023 22:03

Palomabalom · 09/06/2023 19:44

Well it’s easy to say now when you’re able and young. If you were living alone and having falls, unable to get yourself to the toilet on time, confused or scared then you might want to see a familiar face. You will be so much more vulnerable and your current child will then be an adult more capable than you, perhaps kinder and more gentle than the staff in a care home or caters paid pittance to do a quick pit stop at your house. You might realise that the power shift means your rapidly declining health/ cognitive ability and strength means a shift in the absolute conviction that you wouldn’t ask your daughter for help

^ I generally agree with this

Provided that you have had a decent upbringing or not suffered abuse etc, I think there should be some reciprocity

I think one of the downfalls of UK society today is a huge focus on rights but not on responsibility. There has to be balance.

Definitelyrandom · 09/06/2023 22:01

It’s about developing a loving relationship with your children and them developing a loving relationship with you. You support each other at appropriate points.

MumApril1990 · 09/06/2023 22:01

Living ofc

MumApril1990 · 09/06/2023 22:00

As a parent she should want to see her son loving his best life, which I wouldn’t think would involve working co- running his own house and then having to run hers also?

Is she very elderly and frail, or impaired in some other way? My 86yo Grandma does all her own shopping bills and drives, she has hired a gardener now as that’s too much for her physically. My MIL who has arthritis and Parkinson’s does her own online shopping and manages her own finances.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 09/06/2023 22:00

I have amazing parents (and in laws) and they have looked after me well and their parents in their final years. My in laws still look after my husband's grandma. My parents are still more of a support to me than I am to them and I feel I owe them so much and we often spend time with them and hep them where I can. Not out of obligation, but love, and I will willingly help all four of our parents however I can. I hope and pray my children will feel the same.