Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think it could be easier

57 replies

Namechangeforthispostpurpose · 09/06/2023 17:34

If I left.
15 years , a generally good bloke, although often manchild. I no longer have a concept of what constitutes a normal relationship.
what is your current partner like to you…. 15+ years relationship PLEASE respond.
I just want the odd bit of romance and depth
tried all the usual to move things forwards.
I want to know if a fat middle aged average looking and average intelligent woman could be loved …
not just used as shag fest
my theory is most women hold on to a decent guy… so what’s the offerings like second time around?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AcrossthePond55 · 11/06/2023 00:37

Namechangeforthispostpurpose · 10/06/2023 10:43

Yes he knows how unhappy I am
I don’t desperately want someone else but I don’t want to live alone for ( potentially) 40 years.
not sure if the scraps I get are better than no scraps ever again ever !

So basically, you're saying you'd rather live with 'atmosphere', and survive on scraps thrown by this man who does not treat you nicely than live on your own in a peaceful home living, not on scraps, but on what you choose to create for yourself.

When I was very young and in an abusive marriage, a very wise older woman told me "It's better to be alone than to be wishing you were". And she was so right! There's nothing wrong with living alone when the alternative is unhappiness. What about living alone are you afraid of?

Listen, I'm old and I've seen and done a lot. And I tell you this: we only get one go round on this beautiful Earth, so don't waste it in unhappiness.

If you do choose to leave, maybe you'll meet someone, maybe you won't. Life offers no guarantees. But no matter what the future holds for you, you are 'sufficient unto yourself', whether you believe it right now or not.

Sarahzb · 11/06/2023 00:21

Oh dear, a relationship is caring about someone else.

ChristmasFluff · 10/06/2023 12:53

Why are you even contemplating another relationship when you aren't even out of this one yet?

I ended my marriage to a man who sounds much better than your husband - because I wasn't happy and did not love him the way a wife should love a husband. For example, I couldn't bear the thought of having sex with him, much as I loved him as a friend.

He tried to do his bit around the house, but actually often made things worse...

And yes, I left and was happier (well, once I got out of the abusive relationship I fell into after separating...). I still am - single and loving it 16 years on.

Of course I have had relationships - some good some bad. But I love my life as it is, and a man would have to be bloody awesome for me to compromise that - which most men cannot accept.

Men are not your saviours. YOU are your own saviour. The next 40 years alone? BRING IT ON!

BumpyaDaisyevna · 10/06/2023 12:20

Namechangeforthispostpurpose · 10/06/2023 10:43

Yes he knows how unhappy I am
I don’t desperately want someone else but I don’t want to live alone for ( potentially) 40 years.
not sure if the scraps I get are better than no scraps ever again ever !

I think the key question is are you both invested in trying to sort this out, or not.

I don't think you can force him to feel concern about the state of his own marriage. He has to feel that and want to see if something can be done. Even if at present he can't see the solutions - in order to make it work you need at least to have someone who wants to find some different ways of thinking about things so that you can have more of a partnership - a creative marriage that you can both help each other to thrive in. At the moment it's sounding like you're trying to sow seed in a drought ridden soil.

So that's the question really for you both. Do you both acknowledge that it's not working and something needs to change? If so, couples therapy could help.

If he is happy to bury head in the sand then you have the choice to stay or go.

Beware of thinking that the only problem in this marriage is him, though. It always takes two to tango and you'd need to think about whether you can really hear whatever it is that HE might tell you he is unhappy with and think about that.

Sundaystorm · 10/06/2023 12:16

@BreviloquentBastard I feel warm and fuzzy after reading your post. My husband is amazing too. There really are good men out there.

InBedBy10 · 10/06/2023 12:07

I can't believe some of the responses on this post.

Staying in a relationship you are miserable in is NOT better than being single!

I get the thought of being on your own for the next 40yrs is scary but is spending the next 40yrs with someone who clearly doesn't care, love or respect you any better?

You sound miserable OP. Take a leap of faith and end this relationship. Maybe you'll have to be on your own for a while but at least you'll have the chance of finding real happiness. You've no chance if you stay.

Whenwillitallmakesense · 10/06/2023 11:47

goldenlocks · 10/06/2023 08:04

@Whenwillitallmakesense has clearly not done OLD.

You sound sad OP. Can you give examples? Can you be single?

And you know that because...you're psychic? Or you just like making assumptions about people you don't know based on the fact that they think some single men are decent?
Wind your neck in and just stick to giving comments on the OP's problem, not trying to be clever with other posters

Namechangeforthispostpurpose · 10/06/2023 10:43

Yes he knows how unhappy I am
I don’t desperately want someone else but I don’t want to live alone for ( potentially) 40 years.
not sure if the scraps I get are better than no scraps ever again ever !

OP posts:
Namechangeforthispostpurpose · 10/06/2023 10:42

Sorry that was in response to the lucnhbox example!

OP posts:
Namechangeforthispostpurpose · 10/06/2023 10:39

I would get ‘ why are you having a go at me, all the other mums manage…. ‘
then I would get pissed off then get told
‘ why are you always so arsey with me’

OP posts:
SophieStew · 10/06/2023 10:23

You seem to view the only option to leaving this marriage to be a relationship with another man who might/might not be just as shit.

Have you never considered being single and happy? Your marriage sounds pretty miserable to me but does he know how unhappy you are?

Do you communicate well?

Hbh17 · 10/06/2023 10:19

I think in a long marriage, a lack of "romance" is fine and not unusual - in fact, I'd probably find it quite annoying 🤣 It's also true that the grass isn't always greener.

But if it bothers you, OP then it bothers you. The only thing that concerns me is that you worry about finding another partner. What's wrong with ending this relationship and just being single - the happiest women I know are single.

ladyvimes · 10/06/2023 10:16

Been together 17 married 13. I love him very much. He is kind and funny and a wonderful father. We are a team. We’ve been through a lot and it’s not always been easy. He is totally unromantic and struggles to show emotion, affection but will cuddle me in private. Sex life is ok, prob once a week on average, which I’m happy with - he’d like more!! We do argue and get annoyed with each other but we always have! He generally pulls his weight around the house although my standards are higher than his. Don’t think he’s even cleaned a bathroom but I’ve accepted this and it’s not an issue. I love him for who he is and we are very happy.

TidyHomeTidyMind · 10/06/2023 10:06

It sounds like the lack of romance is the least of your worries to be honest.
He's one of the many millions of man children that unfortunate women like us get saddled with (been with mine almost 20 years!)
They make all of the right noises in the beginning, lovely dates, plenty of time with friends, the house is run jointly by both of you......then boom, kids come along and they sit back with their foot off the pedal and coast through life quite contentedly.
Meanwhile, in the background is a woman holding it all together.
Only you know if your living situation is worth putting up with it for. If you would get a decent settlement if you divorce and could live comfortably without him then it might be worth splitting, there is no guarantee that you would find anyone amazing though.

BreviloquentBastard · 10/06/2023 10:02

Together 16 years. I love him a little more every day.

He's a good man. Kind, gentle, communicative, funny, warm and loving. Very open with his affection, always has been. A rampant snuggler. Very handsome which is a bonus. He pulls his weight around the house, all chores are split 50/50, all cooking split 50/50. I haven't washed a dish for years because I hate it so he does them for me (in exchange for me doing the laundry). He absolutely adores our daughter and has always been a great, active father. He never shouts, which means a lot because my mum and dad were bellowers and I hate it.

Big romantic gestures have never been much of a thing for us, but for me it's more the small gestures that shows he knows me, or has been thinking about me. Tiny things. Bringing me my favourite chocolate, or buying me a new journal he knew I'd like, or parking up on the sofa next to me while I'm chilling and giving me a foot rub.

We've had some hard times too, but the important thing for me is that even when we've been furious with eachother, or struggling, or exhausted, or miserable, we've done everything in our power to tackle the problem together as a team, instead of turning it into me VS him. On the days I hated him most I still felt loved by him and felt like he was on my side.

I would say... Don't give up hope that you might meet one of the good ones "later" in life if you do choose to leave, they are out there. My MIL met her person in her 50's, and he's a wonderful man. Never married, no kids, just never met the right person, but a really lovely, genuine guy and treats MIL like she's a goddess incarnate. They do exist, BUT they are rare. Lazy entitled manchildren unfortunately do seem to be the norm.

Sundaystorm · 10/06/2023 09:50

Married 27 years. He’s the best man I know, kind, funny, loving, empathetic. We laugh a lot and spend a lot of time together. He is a fully functioning adult and does housework, shopping etc. He’s a fantastic dad to our now adult children. We are blessed and lucky to have him. I appreciate him all the more for having a really toxic and abusive childhood and a run of bad relationships before him. It makes me really appreciate what I have.

Tidsleytiddy · 10/06/2023 09:46

Just had our 25 wedding anniversary. Marriage got off to a shaky start. Lots of drinking and staying out. (Him, not me). Now been sober for 21 years. He is kind, wise and highly intelligent. I’ve never met anyone like him. Not romantic and sometimes I do wait for a bit of excitement but he never criticises me, gives sound advice and we are happy together. We both enjoy our own company and that of each other. Wouldn’t swap him for the world x

BumpyaDaisyevna · 10/06/2023 09:44

Namechangeforthispostpurpose · 10/06/2023 09:14

Can you please explain ( and I’m sorry if this sounds weird) what does working through something together actually look like ? What happens?

You say "I feel totally disconnected from you at the moment like you are not interested in me it the kids you're in your own world doing your own thing"

He might say "you don't tell me what you want, you want to do everything yourself the way you want if, you're interested in the children and not in me, if I do something I feel I will be criticised " ...

And so on ...

And in the days that follow he makes an effort to read the school emails and to say did you notice DC1 has speech day how will we work that? And books a restaurant for your anniversary v

And you make an effort to care for him as well as the kids - if you get new lunchboxes for the kids you buy him a nice one too and you make him a nice lunch one day. And if he is getting ready to take the kids Mountain biking you leave him to it and you don't try to take charge.

Recent example from my marriage🤣

Namechangeforthispostpurpose · 10/06/2023 09:14

Can you please explain ( and I’m sorry if this sounds weird) what does working through something together actually look like ? What happens?

OP posts:
Namechangeforthispostpurpose · 10/06/2023 09:13

I have worked so so so hard at my marriage I can not bend any more or communicate any more or forgive any more. It all falls on deaf ears
it all gets belittled
I can’t Imagine working through something together …. I usually have to explain why I want what i want for around three hours and getting an apology ….. is impossible

OP posts:
Namechangeforthispostpurpose · 10/06/2023 09:09

I’m so sorry you’ve been unwell , that’s so lovely that your DH has been supportive
mine isn’t when I’m I’ll. asks me when I’m going to bE better ( and I’m rarely Ill)
makes me feel like an inconvenience and then I pay the price for being ill with a lot to catch up on when I’m back to it.

OP posts:
KevinDeBrioche · 10/06/2023 08:48

Marriage is hard. I don’t know anyone that doesn’t have to work at it after the first 10+ years. If you are the same people as when you first met then you haven’t grown at all, it depends whether you can figure out a a way to grow together.

without a a good relationship modelled in your childhood it makes it even more difficult to know how things should be or what you should accept.

M0rT · 10/06/2023 08:32

I'm married about half the length of time you are, but I'm chiming in because my DH has had to deal with me becoming very ill and coped like a champ without ever making me feel a burden.
There are of course things that irritate each other, compromises made etc
I could and have talked for hours about the "house blindness" and our different ideas of what tidiness means!
But when the shit hit the fan he was fantastic and uncomplaining and because it's cancer I've got to know people who were nowhere near as fortunate as me in their partners when they needed support.
The big problem there is they also block support from others as everyone assumes your partner/family will be helping so don't want to intrude.
As a stranger on the internet I'd say have a think about how he copes with adversity and would he step up for you, equally is there enough love and respect from your side to support him through a debilitating illness?
Hopefully this never becomes your reality but it's a good thought exercise in if it's worth counselling/ trying to reignite a spark or if it's time to start thinking of your future as an individual.

whatkatydid2013 · 10/06/2023 08:14

We’ve been married 15 years. OH isn’t perfect but there is a lot more I like in our relationship than I don’t and any things that we do that upset the other one we work on improving.

What do you like about your husband/what is good in your relationship and is it enough to offset whatever isn’t? If so can you work to improve some things? I feel like expecting to be blissfully happy at all times in a long term relationship is unrealistic but expecting to be considered and to have your partner act in ways that make it clear you matter to them is very reasonable.

goldenlocks · 10/06/2023 08:04

@Whenwillitallmakesense has clearly not done OLD.

You sound sad OP. Can you give examples? Can you be single?