Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to think these job interview expectations are unfair?

66 replies

throwawayinterview · 09/06/2023 16:18

Applied for a job with a government agency - the ad said that they were recruiting 'Nationwide' (I live in NE England). The agency in question has offices all over the country and I confirmed before applying that I would be expected to work from the one in the nearest town to me for a minimum 2 days a week in the office with the rest done from home. All fine by me, quite keen to get back into an office environment as I'm currently 100% WFH.

I received an invitation to interview for the job - great! Except the interview has to be done in person in their offices in London on a specific day next week, and (crucially) travel expenses will not be reimbursed. I have explored with the agency whether there is an option to do the interview remotely via Teams but no dice. I'd be happy to attend the local office to interview in person but from their response I know that's not going to be an option either.

Getting to London at comparatively short notice during peak times will cost me £££ and will be a pain to arrange between putting in a last minute full day annual leave application at work (without it being too obvious what I'm up to) and sorting childcare for the start and end of the day due to the travel times.

I'm not desperate to leave my current job and the money is pretty much the same so I'm probably just going to turn down the invitation, but AIBU to think that, with advances in technology these days, it's a bit ridiculous to expect someone to attend an interview for a job hundreds of miles away from where they'll actually be working and to expect them to fund it themselves?

OP posts:
Eleganz · 09/06/2023 22:02

MarnieCres · 09/06/2023 20:46

I regularly interview people for teacher and headteacher posts. Candidates are expected to travel ( except during the pandemic) and do, travelling expenses are not paid.

So? OP is not a teacher and the shitty recruitment practices of the education sector should not be a model for anyone.

DewinDwl · 09/06/2023 21:45

MarnieCres · 09/06/2023 20:46

I regularly interview people for teacher and headteacher posts. Candidates are expected to travel ( except during the pandemic) and do, travelling expenses are not paid.

Do you insist on interviewing in a place hundreds of miles away from the future place of work?

God read the opening post

Daffodilwoman · 09/06/2023 21:38

I also think that is ridiculous. Withdraw your application and tell them why.

TrueScrumptious · 09/06/2023 21:35

I would expect the interview to be online or at a local office. But I’ve never heard of being reimbursed travel expenses for an interview in decades. I’m in the private sector.

forensicss · 09/06/2023 21:30

OfficerPastiche · 09/06/2023 21:26

Actually for mass hiring they won't have the 'same' interviewers, it's impossible. As long as they're all trained to the same standard.

It's also a bad sign to be unable to meet the team you'll actually be working with and get a feel for them. Your immediate colleagues and like manager have th biggest impact on your work life and I personally wouldn't like to be hired without at leaet talking to them .

OP did not state it was mass recruitment anywhere so where have you got that from? With mass campaigns CS tend to use pre-recorded video interviews and assessment centres. OP states the role is hiring nationwide - therefore you can assume the team hired will be based nationally. Therefore OP might merely work in the same office as the staff in the local office and have no direct involvement with them as her immediate colleagues and manager may be based nationwide.

OfficerPastiche · 09/06/2023 21:26

forensicss · 09/06/2023 21:12

I think you’re being unreasonable to ask them to interview you at your local office, as presumably the staff conducting the interviews work in London and the staff at your local office aren’t conducting interviews. In any job there will be multiple applicants being assessed at interview so it’s important to have the same interviewers and questions posed to every candidate for a fair process. Not all staff will be trained on conducting interviews and preventing bias or scoring candidates accurately etc. I can see why this is an outright no, but would ask again whether the interview could be over teams. I’d also double check the job advert to see if travel to London may be required as part of the role.

Actually for mass hiring they won't have the 'same' interviewers, it's impossible. As long as they're all trained to the same standard.

It's also a bad sign to be unable to meet the team you'll actually be working with and get a feel for them. Your immediate colleagues and like manager have th biggest impact on your work life and I personally wouldn't like to be hired without at leaet talking to them .

FusRoDah · 09/06/2023 21:20

I'm public sector and we haven't reimbursed interview expenses for ages (which I think it outrageous considering the salaries offered are all shit), but would generally offer a Teams option for interviews for candidates far away. If you're not desperate to move jobs, I'd walk away if they won't interview remotely.

forensicss · 09/06/2023 21:12

I think you’re being unreasonable to ask them to interview you at your local office, as presumably the staff conducting the interviews work in London and the staff at your local office aren’t conducting interviews. In any job there will be multiple applicants being assessed at interview so it’s important to have the same interviewers and questions posed to every candidate for a fair process. Not all staff will be trained on conducting interviews and preventing bias or scoring candidates accurately etc. I can see why this is an outright no, but would ask again whether the interview could be over teams. I’d also double check the job advert to see if travel to London may be required as part of the role.

HappiestSleeping · 09/06/2023 21:06

IfYouDontAsk · 09/06/2023 16:33

@HappiestSleeping but the interview location is not even where she’d be contracted to. She’d be contracted to the NE office so fair enough if they insisted she interview in person at the local office but it’s seriously unfair to expect her to bear the cost and inconvenience of travelling hundreds of miles to somewhere she wouldn’t even be working.

Yes and no. I get what you mean, however it isn't unusual to need to go where the gaining manager is located. As I said, I've only been in the private world, but this would be the norm. One either wants the job, or not. Local office interview would have been a good thing to offer from an employer point if view (I would have done this), however not a given.

I do agree that there was a lack of notice and expectation setting.

MarnieCres · 09/06/2023 20:56

thatcornishfeeling · 09/06/2023 20:48

But that's not really comparable. A HT or a teacher is an in person role. So an interview "in person" makes sense. And if they're travelling long distance it's usually a personal decision to relocate.

Totally missing the point 😂

No, I haven't missed the point.

We managed to interview virtually during the pandemic. Now not an option.

Academy schools are located over a large area, some national trusts, but there is never an option for prospective candidates to be interviewed in their nearest school, they would still have to travel to where the interviewing panel are.

Never any travelling expenses.

thatcornishfeeling · 09/06/2023 20:48

MarnieCres · 09/06/2023 20:46

I regularly interview people for teacher and headteacher posts. Candidates are expected to travel ( except during the pandemic) and do, travelling expenses are not paid.

But that's not really comparable. A HT or a teacher is an in person role. So an interview "in person" makes sense. And if they're travelling long distance it's usually a personal decision to relocate.

Totally missing the point 😂

MarnieCres · 09/06/2023 20:46

I regularly interview people for teacher and headteacher posts. Candidates are expected to travel ( except during the pandemic) and do, travelling expenses are not paid.

Kitcaterpillar · 09/06/2023 20:44

Ridiculous circumstances but it's really discouraged have a mix of in-person and virtual interviews, as the virtuals are disadvantaged so I assume they're trying to avoid that. Good plan, shit execution.

NineOfNine · 09/06/2023 20:40

This is totally ridiculous.

I can understand why they don’t want to reimburse people for travelling.

But if there’s really no option for interviews at the job location, and the interviewers have to be hundreds of miles away from the actual job location - then they really should offer candidates the option of virtual interviews via Teams or Zoom or suchlike.

thatcornishfeeling · 09/06/2023 20:35

I had this too. The role was advertised via my local government.

3 miles away they have an office but told me my interview had to be in London which is 6 hours away. The train ticket was hundreds!!

And gave me 2 days notice. 🤣 I declined and explained why.

I also applied for a similar role at the Local Authority. 3 miles away. Interview via Teams.....

RedRosie · 09/06/2023 20:30

I interview a lot and very much prefer to interview people in-person, and we always do this now that it is possible again. This is because you learn so much more about candidates. But it's most unfair not to reimburse for travel (or offer a local interview). I'm really surprised OP, especially if this is the public sector/civil service.

tackling · 09/06/2023 20:15

Not very inclusive of them and they're supposed to be good at that. This is a way that cuts out anyone who can't afford it.

InSpainTheRain · 09/06/2023 18:51

That's ridiculous, especially for a first interview. I'd expect a Teams/Zoom for the first one then if in person travel should be reimbursed. YANBU to turn down.

whittingtonmum · 09/06/2023 17:43

I would expect to be interviewed in the office where I would work - not many, many miles away without travel expenses offered. I'd explain that when you withdraw your application.

Eleganz · 09/06/2023 17:43

OP, I would make it plain that the cost of attending an in person interview at relatively short notice in London from your base in the North East is not something you can afford at this time and move on.

I really wouldn't waste my time with the civil service at the moment, from all the contacts I know in there (I am public sector but not civil service) - it is a shit place to work. Morale is through the floor.

Eleganz · 09/06/2023 17:39

Rightiothen13 · 09/06/2023 16:29

I would hope that expenses aren’t paid by the tax payer. A load of money going to people who knew the distance and the cost, took the risk of an interview, wasn’t good enough to get the job, but we pay their costs anyway.

relieved that common sense prevails

What a load of nonsense. If you are recruiting nationally and you hold all interviews in London, of course you should reimburse. If you can't do that then virtual interviews are what you should be offering.

The public sector is struggling to recruit decent people due to the penny pinching attitude of "tax payers" like you and the governments you vote for.

The best thing is to get the best candidate for the job, not the one who can afford to show up to the interview.

DoneByWeds · 09/06/2023 17:21

I don't think there would be much scope to influence them on the lack of payment of expenses as that is a widespread policy across public sector as other posters have said.

However, I do wonder if there is a challenge here around how inclusive their recruitment process actually is. It seems to me that it doesn't offer equally fair access to the process, it favours those nearer to London in terms of cost (so harder for people from a less well off background) and time (posing child care considerations for some but not all). This argument only holds because they are doing the recruitment a considerable distance away from where the job will be located.

CantGetDecentNickname · 09/06/2023 17:01

First round of interviews are normally virtual now. Makes much more sense. Subsequent interviews are face to face, but by then you stand a better chance of being offered the job. It does seem very unfair.

MooMooSharoo · 09/06/2023 16:59

throwawayinterview · 09/06/2023 16:29

Agreed, that's the bit that's really annoyed me - frankly I don't have room in my budget to shell out £150+ of my own money for a job I'm by no means guaranteed to get. Likewise, I can understand that the public sector might not want to fund that - which is fine, just let me interview remotely and they won't have to!

And to be honest, if it's a government department job, they'll probably give it to someone internal but have been forced to list it online and "consider external applications".

I'd be withdrawing my application and providing feedback as to why.

whynotwhatknot · 09/06/2023 16:54

Yeah does seem unfair unless its a standard thing now to get everyone to london

is the money worth it