Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL wants to see baby every day

82 replies

PinkkHydrangea · 09/06/2023 15:22

I have a good relationship with my MIL. I wouldn't say it was great because we are quite different people personality wise, but we get along fine and have never had any sort of issues. I will add that she is the type of person who is always right, no matter what and I learned early on how to navigate this.

Me and DH are TTC (not having the best luck due to some MC) and she made a comment today that's sent my head spinning trying to think of how to fix the problem before it arises.

We were discussing someone in the family who has recently had a baby and that she's struggling with too many visitors. I was on the side of the new mum and MIL wasn't. She then said "well when you have a baby I'll be here every day and you wouldn't be able to stop me". Knowing her personality and not wanting to have an argument about a baby I haven't conceived yet, I just moved past the comment.

This was not a joke, just to be clear.

Now I'm left thinking the only option is to barricade the doors or emigrate. She lives 10 mins away.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JFDIYOLO · 28/08/2023 07:45

Lock your door!!!! A thief can be in and out in moments. People may be assaulted by intruders in their own homes.

Toddlers are escape artists and will learn to open an unlocked door and get out.

Lock it as a habit.

Get the ring doorbell.

Do not give her a key.

Start talking about what is going to happen, now, before you're even expecting. Give it time to settle in.

Have a serious talk with your OH about your requirements and find out what his thoughts are about his mother being there every day. Make sure he is 💯 certain about your views in this, understands his role is now to support his wife and child and not to appease his mother. Many men fund this difficult as we know from so many Mumsnet posts so it's best to ensure he's up to speed now. Before there's a baby.

Do the groundwork now so you don't have to be digging when you've just given birth.

SunsetsAndSandwiches · 14/06/2023 18:22

HowcanIhelp123 · 14/06/2023 15:23

And if you want to bubble yourself away from everyone you can, but equally don't expect everyone to fall over themselves to help you if you then decide you want something.

If you decide you will permit grandparents to visit once a fortnight for a couple hours at a time that suits you, that's fine. But don't be surprised when they say no to looking after that baby 8am-6pm X days a week for you for free when it suits you because you are going back to work.

If you offer no concessions or flexibility yourself don't expect it from others. If you keep people at a distance with your 'rules' that's where they will stay. That's the same treatment you will get in return. If you prevent grandparents from coming over and seeing your child, you can't be the person years down the line complaining how much more said grandparents do for the children of other siblings that have let them be much more involved and built that closer relationship. It's what you asked for.

Start as you mean to go on, if what you want is involved grandparents then let them get involved from the start. I'm not saying she should see the child daily. You'll need to address that should the need arise. But if you're looking at them looking after the child for you 2 days a week when you go back to work, well then 2 visits a week that could turn into those days isn't all that unreasonable.

This sounds like a very drastic response from grandparents, to new parents asking if they can have just a couple of weeks to get to know their baby!

HowcanIhelp123 · 14/06/2023 15:23

SunsetsAndSandwiches · 14/06/2023 15:02

"Sound advice. When did the idea of a 'little bubble' where the outside world isn't allowed start? It may surprise its proponents but parents have managed to 'bond' with their babies since time immemorial withour isolating themselves!"

I'm sorry to say that comments like this really sadden me. People can be so quick to point out that things worked 'just fine' in the past. You might not like the idea of a bubble, and that's fine - no ones telling you that you have to have one - but if others like the idea of it then allow them to choose to adopt that idea.

Each generation we get access to new knowledge and more liberation to move away from what we feel is expected of us and do what feels right for us. That is progress! No one is saying the old ways were bad necessarily, but there's no guarantee they were the best way either. Ultimately, how to live your life with a new baby is a decision for the parents and the parents alone. The grandparents views can be offered and may be helpful, but grandparents should not impose their views.

And if you want to bubble yourself away from everyone you can, but equally don't expect everyone to fall over themselves to help you if you then decide you want something.

If you decide you will permit grandparents to visit once a fortnight for a couple hours at a time that suits you, that's fine. But don't be surprised when they say no to looking after that baby 8am-6pm X days a week for you for free when it suits you because you are going back to work.

If you offer no concessions or flexibility yourself don't expect it from others. If you keep people at a distance with your 'rules' that's where they will stay. That's the same treatment you will get in return. If you prevent grandparents from coming over and seeing your child, you can't be the person years down the line complaining how much more said grandparents do for the children of other siblings that have let them be much more involved and built that closer relationship. It's what you asked for.

Start as you mean to go on, if what you want is involved grandparents then let them get involved from the start. I'm not saying she should see the child daily. You'll need to address that should the need arise. But if you're looking at them looking after the child for you 2 days a week when you go back to work, well then 2 visits a week that could turn into those days isn't all that unreasonable.

Inmydreams88 · 14/06/2023 15:18

There is no baby yet though…so this is completely irrelevant.

You say you have a good relationship with her, and only basing this off one comment she made before you were even pregnant?

SunsetsAndSandwiches · 14/06/2023 15:02

"Sound advice. When did the idea of a 'little bubble' where the outside world isn't allowed start? It may surprise its proponents but parents have managed to 'bond' with their babies since time immemorial withour isolating themselves!"

I'm sorry to say that comments like this really sadden me. People can be so quick to point out that things worked 'just fine' in the past. You might not like the idea of a bubble, and that's fine - no ones telling you that you have to have one - but if others like the idea of it then allow them to choose to adopt that idea.

Each generation we get access to new knowledge and more liberation to move away from what we feel is expected of us and do what feels right for us. That is progress! No one is saying the old ways were bad necessarily, but there's no guarantee they were the best way either. Ultimately, how to live your life with a new baby is a decision for the parents and the parents alone. The grandparents views can be offered and may be helpful, but grandparents should not impose their views.

YouveGotAFastCar · 14/06/2023 13:28

This would bother me.

Maybe she wouldn't see it through; but my MIL only stepped up her insanity when DS arrived, and man I wish we'd put a stop to it before I was even pregnant... so much of my pregnancy and his early months were marred by her batshit behaviour.

Theygolowwegohigh · 14/06/2023 13:17

Those saying don't worry, cross that bridge when it comes etc, I disagree.

She's clearly told you she will be doing what she wants regardless of your wants or your needs, whilst you're recovering from childbirth and caring for a newborn. Fuck that!

It happens. There are threads upon threads about grandparents behaving like this. It's far from unusual sadly.

I'd start putting boundaries in place now. Doors locked. Doorbell. Do that BEFORE there's a baby on the scene.

I'd also feel her out more around this topic. Get a feel of what you'll be up against. Make sure DH is on the same page with you in terms of parenting styles, how often you'd like grandparents involved, plans on visitors after baby is born (both read up on the fourth trimester). If your DH isn't able to be on the same page and have healthy boundaries then THAT is the problem, over and above mil.

AliceInTheMoon · 14/06/2023 13:13

My parents were waiting outside my home when I brought my baby home from hospital. That was the start of a nightmare, on a daily basis. I was very young, I didn't set boundaries but I would definitely advise anyone who has these concerns to just be as bolshy back.
Eg MIL "I'm coming round every day and you can't stop me ".
OP "oh yes I fucking can, just watch me" 😘

Hoppinggreen · 14/06/2023 13:04

The key is your DH.
If he agrees with her or is unable to stand up to her then you have an issue

toomuchlaundry · 14/06/2023 13:01

I wouldn’t have wanted my MIL or my DM visiting every day after having DS

JudgeJ · 14/06/2023 12:40

Loopylalalou · 13/06/2023 13:34

I think you’re being a little harsh. Would it be her first grandchild - or one close by? She’s excited too. Start now - say an hour every day between two and three, leaving her to think you’ll be using the time to have a nap. It’ll soon pale.
Wherever possible ,it’s best that every child is raised in a ‘community’. Appreciate those that’ll become part of that child’s future.

Sound advice. When did the idea of a 'little bubble' where the outside world isn't allowed start? It may surprise its proponents but parents have managed to 'bond' with their babies since time immemorial withour isolating themselves!

caringcarer · 14/06/2023 11:19

JudgeJ · 14/06/2023 11:01

Hopefully these rules will also apply to the OP's own mother, the other grandmother, but I doubt it!

I treated my own Mum and MiL the same. Same rules applied to both.

JudgeJ · 14/06/2023 11:01

caringcarer · 09/06/2023 15:33

Sometimes when she just turns up you might be out or you might have friends over. She will need to give you a day/ time to expect her. You might be glad to hand your baby over to her for an hour or so to get some sleep. If she builds a good relationship with a baby she might offer to babysit from time to time. I wouldn't be upsetting her.

Hopefully these rules will also apply to the OP's own mother, the other grandmother, but I doubt it!

GCPH · 14/06/2023 10:58

I fully understand your concern - sounds like a very good idea for your partner to set boundaries about visiting when you’re pregnant (until then just don’t worry about it as you have enough on your plate) and when baby comes firmly channel her visits into things that genuinely do help - maybe taking baby for a walk in the pram for an hour at nap time, helping with practical tasks like laundry, food prep etc. If she genuinely wants to help she should be happy to do this. If she just wants baby cuddles there’s a time and place for that and it has to suit you.

Mix56 · 13/06/2023 17:51

Here are a few starter replies:
Haha "Not on your Nelly"

Then, "I know you're not "that" kind of MIL....tinkling laugh...,"

Or.. "over my dead body" smile

"Do you really want us to move?" Raised eyebrow

"Not happening"

If she continues, You say sternly, No-one forces entry in my home.
I will not be receiving guests daily, & without notice. This my home, my body, our baby. I intend to choose who & when I am "at "home".

Boymum1005 · 13/06/2023 16:45

thecapitalsunited · 13/06/2023 13:35

All these people saying that they wished they had this kind of support or someone who cares don’t realise that this sort of boundary stomper usually only cares about themselves. They won’t be turning up to help out they’ll be turning up to hog the baby while you bust your balls cleaning and wait on her hand and foot because it will be about what MIL wants not the new mother. If you are lucky once the novelty wears off you won’t see her again. Or worse, she’ll start to manipulate the kids to obey her every whim too.

I agree with this too. My DM would come and make me a cuppa, take baby for a walk so I could shower/sleep (and she lives almost 2 hours away).

MIL would come in, say ‘make us a coffee’, sit on the sofa leaving me to sit, very painfully, on the floor, pick baby up out of his bouncer/say ‘give him here’ if I was holding him. She would also stay for 4-5 hours whereas most visitors only stayed for an hour at most in the early days.

We stopped answering the door and sometimes even the phone until we fell into a habit of weekly visits/visits when invited. That said, I suffered with PP OCD so couldn’t handle anyone touching my baby or anything the baby might touch.

Now DS is 2 and I have another DS who is 8 months old, I’m super grateful for the help so close to home. It’s important to me, now I am more rational, that my children grow up knowing how many people love and care for them

Countingdowntodecember · 13/06/2023 14:04

Just.be clear that this won’t be happening whenever she mentions it: “Don’t be silly MIL, of course I could stop you from coming round every day. If you ignored me telling you not to, I just wouldn’t open the door”.

thecapitalsunited · 13/06/2023 13:35

All these people saying that they wished they had this kind of support or someone who cares don’t realise that this sort of boundary stomper usually only cares about themselves. They won’t be turning up to help out they’ll be turning up to hog the baby while you bust your balls cleaning and wait on her hand and foot because it will be about what MIL wants not the new mother. If you are lucky once the novelty wears off you won’t see her again. Or worse, she’ll start to manipulate the kids to obey her every whim too.

Loopylalalou · 13/06/2023 13:34

I think you’re being a little harsh. Would it be her first grandchild - or one close by? She’s excited too. Start now - say an hour every day between two and three, leaving her to think you’ll be using the time to have a nap. It’ll soon pale.
Wherever possible ,it’s best that every child is raised in a ‘community’. Appreciate those that’ll become part of that child’s future.

Louoby · 13/06/2023 13:24

Set expectations from the off. We did this with my MIL - she was the same. I commented a few times and said that two days a week was acceptable 😂
Lock your front door and get a ring doorbell. If she tries to just turn up without an invite and you don't answer then she may get the hint that she needs to call first. At that point you say, not today - maybe Friday. She will soon understand she's not welcome everyday.

Boymum1005 · 13/06/2023 13:10

Seas164 · 09/06/2023 15:29

I'd concentrate less on the relationship with your MIL and more on the one with your DH because it's going to need to be rock solid and very aligned on this issue if she's not going to be allowed to cause major dramas and stress for you going forward.

There is actually lots you can do about it, but you're going to need the full backing and understanding of your DH.

This!

I moved to DH hometown and we live on the next street to MIL. My DM is 100 miles away. She made similar comments during my pregnancy and DH asked family and friends for a 2 week newborn bubble to be respected, and to wait for an invite/asked for nobody to turn up unannounced.

We actually felt ready for visitors after about day 5 and she did get a bit huffy but the baby isn’t going anywhere! He’s now 2 and the novelty of visiting / babysitting has well and truly worn off! We only see her every other week now.

But totally agree that your relationship with DH needs to be super strong as it’ll be him communicating the boundaries. And agree with PP about getting a ring doorbell and keeping the door locked. I dodged many an unwanted visitor from my sofa with that!

Something that has occurred to me after having 2 DS’s (although I feel the same as you about my MIL) is that I will always be the MIL in this scenario in the future. And I would be genuinely heartbroken if my boys didnt want me to spend time with their new baby!

SunsetsAndSandwiches · 13/06/2023 13:04

Hi OP,

I can see there's a lot of differing advice on this thread.

I just wanted to add some solidarity with how tough the thought of these issues can be when you're struggling with TTC. I am in the same boat but with my DM, and somehow the fact that we are struggling to have a baby makes it feel even worse - I think it's the thought that, when we do hopefully finally get our baby, we will have overcome so many hurdles to get there so I can't bear the thought of things "spoiling" those early days.

I have spoken to my DH about it and I did find it helpful that we've agreed to approach everyone in the family when the time comes and say that we would like a few weeks to ourselves to get to know our baby, and after that we'll be in touch to arrange times for people to visit if they wish. We both have large extended families so it seems to make sense to make specific arrangements. I wouldn't expect to keep the grandparents waiting a few weeks to visit but I still think that we will try to set boundaries.

I know a lot of people talk about the importance of keeping the grandparents on side to help out with childcare etc. I can understand that, but I would say that no DM or MIL should be using that against you if you try to set some boundaries.

Good luck with TTC and I hope when your baby arrives that you and your DH can work together to keep MIL in line!

Codlingmoths · 13/06/2023 12:16

If you don’t move, ring doorbell, lock and chain, and remember I knew many mums whose babies woke early and they’d just go out for a walk at 7 since they’d been up for a couple of hours and breakfast in cafe. Even if you’re actually at home in bed it’s a perfectly good fib!

Willmafrockfit · 13/06/2023 12:14

this is rather hypothetical

what is she like currently about visiting?

Wonderingmyhead · 13/06/2023 12:10

Try not to worry about this now OP. This a very much a 'cross that bridge when you get there' situation. I thought I wouldn't want people round helping much before the baby arrived, but now very much wish I had a bigger support circle. Looking after a baby is incredibly hard and you will also likely want your baby to have a bond with grandparents. The only way to get a bond is to spend time together. Good luck with your TTC journey 💐❤️