Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Prison sentences for violent crimes piss me off.

67 replies

Princessfuckingpeach · 09/06/2023 15:21

Ever notice how sentencing for acid attacks or domestic violence, rape, SA, child SA are absolutely piss poor.
Look at Charles Bronson or Robert Maudsley's sentencing, neither ever hurt a woman or child.
Colin Pitchfork/Paul Gadd (Gary Glitter) etc get let out to reoffend.
Even acid attacks and their horrific nature aren't given massive sentences from what I've seen?
My theory is because it doesn't really affect men.
I just find the prison sentencing in the UK to be a bad joke and I'm prepared here with my hard hat on to be told I'm unreasonable.
But with the rise of incels, violent porn, the Andrew Tate brigade etc, that times are just getting worse for women and children?

OP posts:
scorpiogirly · 12/06/2023 10:56

Completely agree with you. I'd like to see capital punishment brought back for the worst crimes.

JustGeorgie · 12/06/2023 10:55

I'd also like to evidence of sentences being harsher for women!

TheHandmaiden · 12/06/2023 10:51

The prisons are full. I would decriminalise some drugs and then use the capacity for violent offenders and sex offenders. Drugs are a medical issue: ir used to be regarded as such in the UK.

PrivateEyeAnnie · 12/06/2023 10:44

Naunet · 12/06/2023 10:29

It’s been shown many times that women on average get harsher sentences than men for the same crimes.

Please show me your evidence because in my DIRECT experience I have seen the exact opposite.

Naunet · 12/06/2023 10:29

PrivateEyeAnnie · 12/06/2023 10:04

Depends on the case in particular. I know of several women who received a v light sentence, And I still don’t understand how. I suspect because they were women.

But in general allowance is given if you plead guilty. In my experience few perpetrators of street crime admit to anything, in fact the don’t usual say anything at all.

It’s been shown many times that women on average get harsher sentences than men for the same crimes.

Princessfuckingpeach · 12/06/2023 10:27

onefinemess · 12/06/2023 09:00

Well OP, you're part of the problem. And so is everyone else, it's OUR fault.

As a society, we don't the first clue about what we actually want from our Government. It's easy to be critical, but we have to step back and look at what we created. We got exactly what we "asked" for in terms of public services.

We want the police to deal with ASB, fine, but they better not ever speak to our own child, if they do we will make complaints, accusations and call them bullies.

We want the police to arrest dangerous armed criminals, but those officers better think twice before they use any kind of force, because hey, they're ALL just bullies in uniform and how hard can it be to arrest a skinny 14 year old gang member who just stabbed some kid in the park as part of some gang initiation. I mean come on, using a Taser to arrest an armed criminal, those officers need to be put in prison you all cry.

We want convicted criminals to be locked up, but not actually punished, because that would make them feel stressed, or even, God Forbid, offended! And we don't like the idea that people should have ANY authority over anybody anyway.

We are just as important as our Boss (sorry, supervisor, sorry that word is too aggressive, I meant to say, co-worker) because don't forget, we're all equal.

I could go on, the point is you are unhappy with the sentences, but you're not happy to give the police more powers or the money to buy better equipment. You don't want to pay a single penny more in taxes to build more prisons, and you don't know what you want those prisons to do anyway.

Prison is a 2000 year old solution to a modern problem. People commit crime so we convict them and give them a criminal record. Great, now they can't get a job so have no choice but to commit more crime to get money. We set them up to fail.

Prisons are full, there's no space for the prisoners already in there, let alone new ones. We need to work out what we want the police to do before we even talk about prison sentences.

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

OP posts:
PrivateEyeAnnie · 12/06/2023 10:04

Naunet · 12/06/2023 09:32

Yet murder on the street normally results in more prison time than someone murdered in their own home…

Depends on the case in particular. I know of several women who received a v light sentence, And I still don’t understand how. I suspect because they were women.

But in general allowance is given if you plead guilty. In my experience few perpetrators of street crime admit to anything, in fact the don’t usual say anything at all.

Naunet · 12/06/2023 09:32

PrivateEyeAnnie · 12/06/2023 09:22

Doesn’t affect men ???. Men are much more likely to the victims of violent attack and twice as likely to be murdered. And it’s not just women who avoid dark alley ways or underpasses. Also, many young lads in inner city areas simply won’t go out on their own, even in broad daylight.

But you are right about sentencing in this country and I find the Colin Pitchfork thing wholly unacceptable. He murdered two young girls. How is that not a full life term ?.

In my opinion we don’t have a Justice System in this country, just a legal frame work. I should know.

Yet murder on the street normally results in more prison time than someone murdered in their own home…

Naunet · 12/06/2023 09:30

Ilovetea42 · 12/06/2023 08:24

@DdraigGoch of course they can be, I didn't say they should get off scot free but it needs to be taken into account in terms of sentencing. The age of criminal culpability in the UK is one of the youngest in the world and I don't think it reflects well on us when we know for a fact that their brain development isn't finished yet and the areas around decision making, impulsively and understanding consequences and long term impact are some of the last to fully develop. You can't ask someone to make decisions they don't have the physical ability to make and then hold them fully responsible. Plus I do think there's a lot can be done with young people to intervene and when you look at the statistics, it's usually children and young people in the care system and from significantly disadvantaged backgrounds who are over represented in the justice system. These are vulnerable children and that needs to be taken into account.

Like the man in Scotland who raped the 13 year old girl and walk away with no prison time because he was under 25? I’m sure it will bring great comfort to the victim, to know that the man was under 25 so wasn’t really at fault. But then she doesn’t really matter does she, it’s all about what’s fair for the rapist. I’m sure it’s a great message to send men under 25 too, you all get one free rape of a woman or child, go at it lads 👍

PrivateEyeAnnie · 12/06/2023 09:22

Doesn’t affect men ???. Men are much more likely to the victims of violent attack and twice as likely to be murdered. And it’s not just women who avoid dark alley ways or underpasses. Also, many young lads in inner city areas simply won’t go out on their own, even in broad daylight.

But you are right about sentencing in this country and I find the Colin Pitchfork thing wholly unacceptable. He murdered two young girls. How is that not a full life term ?.

In my opinion we don’t have a Justice System in this country, just a legal frame work. I should know.

onefinemess · 12/06/2023 09:00

Well OP, you're part of the problem. And so is everyone else, it's OUR fault.

As a society, we don't the first clue about what we actually want from our Government. It's easy to be critical, but we have to step back and look at what we created. We got exactly what we "asked" for in terms of public services.

We want the police to deal with ASB, fine, but they better not ever speak to our own child, if they do we will make complaints, accusations and call them bullies.

We want the police to arrest dangerous armed criminals, but those officers better think twice before they use any kind of force, because hey, they're ALL just bullies in uniform and how hard can it be to arrest a skinny 14 year old gang member who just stabbed some kid in the park as part of some gang initiation. I mean come on, using a Taser to arrest an armed criminal, those officers need to be put in prison you all cry.

We want convicted criminals to be locked up, but not actually punished, because that would make them feel stressed, or even, God Forbid, offended! And we don't like the idea that people should have ANY authority over anybody anyway.

We are just as important as our Boss (sorry, supervisor, sorry that word is too aggressive, I meant to say, co-worker) because don't forget, we're all equal.

I could go on, the point is you are unhappy with the sentences, but you're not happy to give the police more powers or the money to buy better equipment. You don't want to pay a single penny more in taxes to build more prisons, and you don't know what you want those prisons to do anyway.

Prison is a 2000 year old solution to a modern problem. People commit crime so we convict them and give them a criminal record. Great, now they can't get a job so have no choice but to commit more crime to get money. We set them up to fail.

Prisons are full, there's no space for the prisoners already in there, let alone new ones. We need to work out what we want the police to do before we even talk about prison sentences.

Ilovetea42 · 12/06/2023 08:27

Ilovetea42 · 12/06/2023 08:24

@DdraigGoch of course they can be, I didn't say they should get off scot free but it needs to be taken into account in terms of sentencing. The age of criminal culpability in the UK is one of the youngest in the world and I don't think it reflects well on us when we know for a fact that their brain development isn't finished yet and the areas around decision making, impulsively and understanding consequences and long term impact are some of the last to fully develop. You can't ask someone to make decisions they don't have the physical ability to make and then hold them fully responsible. Plus I do think there's a lot can be done with young people to intervene and when you look at the statistics, it's usually children and young people in the care system and from significantly disadvantaged backgrounds who are over represented in the justice system. These are vulnerable children and that needs to be taken into account.

Also in relation to voting, I think young people need more education and information around their options politically before I'd suggest they vote otherwise they'll likely go with what way their family vote anyway. But I think that including young people and encouraging them to have a say and a place in their communities and actively thinking about what future they want to create actively works against antisocial behaviour which is why most youth services promote good citizenship as part of their work.

Ilovetea42 · 12/06/2023 08:24

DdraigGoch · 12/06/2023 00:15

I also think age should be taken into account as we know young people's ability to make decisions and have solid foresight isn't cemented until at least 21.

So young people aren't expected to be able to know right from wrong, yet many politicians are keen on lowering the voting age to 16.

@DdraigGoch of course they can be, I didn't say they should get off scot free but it needs to be taken into account in terms of sentencing. The age of criminal culpability in the UK is one of the youngest in the world and I don't think it reflects well on us when we know for a fact that their brain development isn't finished yet and the areas around decision making, impulsively and understanding consequences and long term impact are some of the last to fully develop. You can't ask someone to make decisions they don't have the physical ability to make and then hold them fully responsible. Plus I do think there's a lot can be done with young people to intervene and when you look at the statistics, it's usually children and young people in the care system and from significantly disadvantaged backgrounds who are over represented in the justice system. These are vulnerable children and that needs to be taken into account.

DdraigGoch · 12/06/2023 01:22

Greenshake · 12/06/2023 01:15

@DdraigGoch I am not saying I agree with it, but it’s where we are at unfortunately. The Government aren’t prepared to invest money in criminal justice, and have made a right pig’s ear of recent legislation. We all pay the price for that.

Don't worry, I didn't take your post as an endorsement of government policy, just quoting it.

Greenshake · 12/06/2023 01:15

CherryBlossomAutumn · 12/06/2023 01:11

I think we should be way less tolerant of violence anywhere and with anyone, and really tackle it as a society. This would be multi-faceted, with a lot of early prevention in families and with any kids showing aggression or violence, redirecting into more positive ways of coping and tackling the causes. Then very good interventions as soon as police are involved, even if not charged. And yes I also think that repeat violent offenders should get the prison time over those who do not harm others.

Glasgow successfully lowered their rates of knife crime through a zero tolerance approach working at all levels, schools, community etc.

I also cannot believe that people get off with nothing watching child abuse. They create that market, that has to have some kind of heavy punishment.

They don’t get off with nothing. Where did that come from?

Greenshake · 12/06/2023 01:15

@DdraigGoch I am not saying I agree with it, but it’s where we are at unfortunately. The Government aren’t prepared to invest money in criminal justice, and have made a right pig’s ear of recent legislation. We all pay the price for that.

CherryBlossomAutumn · 12/06/2023 01:11

I think we should be way less tolerant of violence anywhere and with anyone, and really tackle it as a society. This would be multi-faceted, with a lot of early prevention in families and with any kids showing aggression or violence, redirecting into more positive ways of coping and tackling the causes. Then very good interventions as soon as police are involved, even if not charged. And yes I also think that repeat violent offenders should get the prison time over those who do not harm others.

Glasgow successfully lowered their rates of knife crime through a zero tolerance approach working at all levels, schools, community etc.

I also cannot believe that people get off with nothing watching child abuse. They create that market, that has to have some kind of heavy punishment.

DdraigGoch · 12/06/2023 01:02

Greenshake · 12/06/2023 00:23

The argument here is that the likely sentence length would not be adequate for the individual to access treatment programmes etc.

Ah yes, "short sentences don't work, therefore we shall replace them with something even softer" rather than imposing longer sentences.

Greenshake · 12/06/2023 00:40

Yes, one of the programmes was pulled but due to an increase in re-conviction rates rather than making people “worse”. The approach taken is quite different now and is strengths based.

TheHandmaiden · 12/06/2023 00:34

I've never been convinced that you can do much to rehabilitate sex offenders albeit that the government tries. I think there was some evidence it made them worse.

Violence you can do something I think. The element of public protection for prison is still important, with rehabilitation if possible.

Greenshake · 12/06/2023 00:23

TheHandmaiden · 12/06/2023 00:20

I would not have suspended sentences available for sex offending or violence. These are physical harms that have long effect on the victims. It is wrong to suspend them. Violence or sex offending should pass the custody threshold.

The argument here is that the likely sentence length would not be adequate for the individual to access treatment programmes etc.

TheHandmaiden · 12/06/2023 00:20

I would not have suspended sentences available for sex offending or violence. These are physical harms that have long effect on the victims. It is wrong to suspend them. Violence or sex offending should pass the custody threshold.

DdraigGoch · 12/06/2023 00:15

I also think age should be taken into account as we know young people's ability to make decisions and have solid foresight isn't cemented until at least 21.

So young people aren't expected to be able to know right from wrong, yet many politicians are keen on lowering the voting age to 16.

Ilovetea42 · 10/06/2023 12:04

I feel that the context of the perpetrators life does need to be taken into account to an extent, for example a young person who's grown up in an extremely violent home and been brought up in care around violence hasn't been given a fair chance to learn how to resolve conflict etc properly. I also think age should be taken into account as we know young people's ability to make decisions and have solid foresight isn't cemented until at least 21. Equally disability, diagnosed poor mental health and additional needs should be taken into account for sentencing. But once you take all that out of the equation then yes for your average adult offender who hasn't been a victim themselves and had full capacity at the time of the violent crime, we should have much harsher sentencing than what we do but I think we also need better and more effective early intervention work and much more effective and more thorough rehabilitation work as well. We also need better mechanisms for reporting and evidencing crimes like dv, rape and sa.

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 10/06/2023 11:48

The statement "Men are significantly more likely to be the victim of violent crime" is only true if you don't treat sexual violence as a form of violence.

According to Rape Crisis, 1 in 4 women experience rape/sexual assault as an adult. In comparison, it's 1 in 18 men.

We know that many rapes and assaults go unreported, and of those that are, the police don't always act (never mind prosecute).