Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Personal Beauty Standards/Choice is not "Social Conditioning"

65 replies

MammyZ · 09/06/2023 15:01

Just on the back on the toenail painting thread - my response to that one would be - Of course you don't have to paint them, your feet and toenails really just need to look clean and tidy. However, if your personal standard is that you like your nails painted especially with open-toed shoes, then for a wedding you will probably feel better if you can find the time to do them!

Of course there were many different responses on thread ranging from "you defo need to paint them!' to "why would you bother painting them?". And then there were comments that painting your nails is a result of the patriarchy or social conditioning that women are subject to.

Personally I wouldn't be the very highest maintenance woman but I have highlighted my dark-blond hair since I was 16 (I don't run back to the salon after 6-8 weeks), I love getting shellac on my fingers and toes (I get the toes done about 5 times a year and just clip them in the meantime as they grow!). I also always wear foundation in public but that's because I have rosacea and feel more confident with the redness covered. I am very particular about looking after my sensitive skin to manage this also.

But for a wedding I think that there's an effort that I like to make - whether this be shaven legs (I'm fairly fair so I'm not obsessive about shaving all time but for a wedding it's a minimum in my book), a bit of tan and painted nails if I'm wearing sandals, or tights if closed-toe.

Do some people really think that I and others only do these things because I have been socially conditioned by the patriarchy? Where is the line between grooming - which takes effort and time also - and crossing into doing things because we think it's expected of us?

I personally think it's my own personal standard and choice to do these things because I love the way I feel when they're all done. And I enjoy the time that I put in to and the effort I put into getting ready for an event.

OP posts:
Verv · 09/06/2023 15:48

Ah but you forget that some people are socially conditioned to turn up on every thread to let women know that they are puppets of the patriarchy.

5128gap · 09/06/2023 15:43

My view is that everything we do to our bodies beyond the minimum necessary for comfort, health and hygiene is rooted in our socialisation in one of 3 ways.

  1. To comply with societal expectations (patriarchy)
  2. To deliberately flout societal expectations (as set by the patriarchy)
  3. Because we enjoy looking at our own appearance in a certain way (our tastes will have been influenced by the patriarchy in either way 1 or 2 above)
So, unless you do no grooming other than be clean and weather appropriate you are acting under the influence one way or another. People who are defyers tend to be a bit sniffy about complyers, but it's two sides of the same coin.
MammyZ · 09/06/2023 15:40

Preps · 09/06/2023 15:31

Making an effort for a wedding is in itself social conditioning, surely?

Of course! And we can see from art in history that humans have made an effort for special occasions and celebrations for thousands of years.

And look, this isn't even necessarily about me, and I'm not so naive that I don't think and know that all the things we do are socially influenced.

BUT my point is that I DO recognise that not shaving your legs is an option, and the world won't end if I went out with a bit of visible fluff on my legs. And nowadays there's the freedom to not shave your underarms if you don't want to. If I saw/met someone who didn't do it I have no judgement, I recognise they are making the free choice not to do it. And I'm making the choice to do it (every now and then when I remember!)

OP posts:
Turfwars · 09/06/2023 15:40

Day to day I don't shave, I get my hair done about 3 times a year, usually when it gets too heavy to tie up. I don't wear make up to work, or do my nails.

But for special occasions I'd do some or most of those things. I fully acknowledge that the extra grooming above being clean is social conditioning. I want others to see me look my best by our current cultural standards. And the days when I don't do those things, it's also influenced by social conditioning.

fivetonap · 09/06/2023 15:33

Hadalifeonce · 09/06/2023 15:07

Any grooming I do, I do for myself. I am long past caring what others think of me.

Weird. We live in a society. We survived only by being part of a group

LangsNot · 09/06/2023 15:32

Personal beauty standards don't happen in a vacuum. Example is during lockdown, most people relaxed their so-called personal beauty standards (because no one was judging and there was no one to impress because there was nowhere to go), and for many, it completely disappeared.

It's social conditioning that causes what we may think of as personal choice. I'd sooner call something less socially influenced or a personal standard if it goes against social norms. Otherwise, it's not so easy to tell.

Preps · 09/06/2023 15:31

Making an effort for a wedding is in itself social conditioning, surely?

MrsTerryPratchett · 09/06/2023 15:31

Preps · 09/06/2023 15:28

Yes, it is social conditioning. Why do you think painted nails look "nice"? It's because that's what you've been taught. Not necessarily by the patriarchy though, it's other women who have largely created these standards for you.

It's also really obvious that different groups have different norms for grooming standards. e.g the people I went to school with have very groomed/enhanced brows and lashes, the people I work with (teachers) don't, but in either group, whilst exceptions are not unheard of, they do stand out.

Other women can be flying monkeys for the patriarchy. The whips are in our own heads now.

JamSandle · 09/06/2023 15:31

Definitely for the patriarchy. I only bother shaving if I'm in a relationship (or looking) for example.

WheelsUp · 09/06/2023 15:29

You are kidding yourself that it's not social conditioning.

feel more confident with the redness covered. I am very particular about looking after my sensitive skin to manage this also. This is because social conditioning means pressure for you to go out with flawless looking skin.

But for a wedding I think that there's an effort that I like to make - whether this be shaven legs (I'm fairly fair so I'm not obsessive about shaving all time but for a wedding it's a minimum in my book), a bit of tan and painted nails if I'm wearing sandals, or tights if closed-toe. also social conditioning. I'm not suggesting that you attend looking dishevelled and scruffy but you do this because you want to advertise that you made the effort to conform to societal norms like hair removal.

Preps · 09/06/2023 15:28

Yes, it is social conditioning. Why do you think painted nails look "nice"? It's because that's what you've been taught. Not necessarily by the patriarchy though, it's other women who have largely created these standards for you.

It's also really obvious that different groups have different norms for grooming standards. e.g the people I went to school with have very groomed/enhanced brows and lashes, the people I work with (teachers) don't, but in either group, whilst exceptions are not unheard of, they do stand out.

Sigmama · 09/06/2023 15:26

Why do women wax/shave legs etc before a date, if not for the patriarchy

CharlotteRumpling · 09/06/2023 15:24

You should watch the scene in The Devil Wears Prada where Miranda Priestley tells Andy why she chose a blue cardie.

ItsNotRocketSalad · 09/06/2023 15:23

Are my choices only because I think it's expected of me?

Your choices aren't made in a vacuum but are influenced by the society you live in and want to be a part of.

Do you think if you'd been born in 1850 you'd still darken your legs and lighten your hair?

Do you think it you'd been born in an Amazonian tribe with no outside contact you'd want to paint your toenails?

If you'd been born male would you think shaving your legs for a wedding is a bare minimum?

Clymene · 09/06/2023 15:23

The point is that your 'choice' is not being made in a vacuum.

I can promise you that if you lived alone on a desert island you wouldn't do any of it. It's all for other people. Not necessarily men but because you want to project an image. You feel better about yourself if you feel like you look nice, like you've made an effort.

There's nothing wrong with that at all - we all do it. Even those of us who reject beauty standards are still making a choice about social conditioning.

MrsTerryPratchett · 09/06/2023 15:23

Valour · 09/06/2023 15:15

Being free of body hair, makeup on, wearing a dress, hair done up makes me feel good too OP. As far as that's concerned, I do it for myself- but the only reason that I feel good about those things is that society has dictated that those are the things that should make me feel good. It's sad really- the patriarchy kind of owns that clean, smooth, pretty feeling I get when I'm done up.

This.

Technically, it's free will and choice. But the choices we make are dictated by society, specifically the patriarchy.

Why on earth do women insist they only feel 'clean' when hairless and men who are fastidious and hygiene-focused don't? Why do no men own hair straighteners?

The range of choices you are 'allowed' is the same. Your illusion of choice is deciding within that range.

waterlego · 09/06/2023 15:22

Agree that it is social conditioning but that people shouldn’t feel bad or ashamed of whatever grooming they do or don’t do. And heartily agree that it isn’t ’weak-willed’ to adhere to grooming and beauty standards. It’s what the majority of us do, after all.

In an ideal world, I wouldn’t shave my legs or armpits, even to go to a wedding. I’m inherently lazy and would always choose to have an extra 20 minutes in bed than spend time grooming. I also really don’t like the feel of freshly shaved skin. But I do shave (if I’m going to a wedding at any rate!) Because it’s ‘normal’ and expected and I’m not strong enough to withstand people staring or commenting or thinking that I’m trying to ‘make a point’. 🤷🏼‍♀️

TimesRwo · 09/06/2023 15:22

Sigmama · 09/06/2023 15:09

Removing any body hair is done for the patriarchy really, not saying I don't do it but that's its origins surely

Even ancient civilisations had hair removal. It’s a concept that has been passed on for centuries, enforcing the concept of traditional male and female features. No matter how you look at it, there is definitely a patriarchal element to it and always has been.

Gtsr443 · 09/06/2023 15:20

A lot more people had poodle perms when they were fashionable.

This. It's all just fashion. Fashion is driven by the society that creates it. You might feel you have free choice OP but you are told repeatedly through the media what is expected of women today. And what is desirable today won't be the same in a couple of years.

EthicalNonMahogany · 09/06/2023 15:20

but there are no options outside social conditioning:)

stargirl1701 · 09/06/2023 15:20

Of course it is social conditioning. Look at grooming standards in any civilisation throughout time - Romans, Egyptians, Vikings, etc.

Humans are social mammals.

Papernotplastic · 09/06/2023 15:19

You think your ‘blue’ legs are unattractive because you live in a society where tan is seen as attractive. Sun beds have been replaced by safer fake tans but the beauty ideal has stayed the same. It’s actually a relatively recent beauty trend. Tanned skin on women was seen as a sign that they had to work outdoors, so avoiding the sun and having porcelain skin was considered the ideal. That’s why all the sun parasols and gloves in period dramas.

MammyZ · 09/06/2023 15:19

EthicalNonMahogany · 09/06/2023 15:14

Do some people really think that I and others only do these things because I have been socially conditioned by the patriarchy?

Yes. Hth

But you're huffing about it as though we are saying there's something weak-willed on your part or that we are insulting you as if you could choose and you've made a bad choice.

We are all socially conditioned in a huge number of ways. We don't behave like our grandmothers. No shame to them or us, we're just acting like the big chimps we are and trying our best to be accepted into a society which rewards those who have genetic predisposition to fitting in.

Why does it bug you so much?

I'm not huffing about anything and I'm not bugged about it either. I am curious when I hear the flip side view "you're only doing these things because you've socially conditioned".

Of course I know that trends change etc, but I do think there's enough options out there that people can choose the one for themselves without it being boiled down to all social conditioning

OP posts:
Snowtrails · 09/06/2023 15:18

I do it because I think the lightest tan (from the daily Dove one) is better on me than my blue legs!

Yes, but if blue legs were fashionable other people would be buying blue leg cream and you'd be considered a natural beauty!

EthicalNonMahogany · 09/06/2023 15:17

And to your last point OP, nobody is saying that your choice to put shellac on your nails means you are judging those who don't, or that they are judging you. Just that we can see that you are making a choice that helps you fit into a social world. When I DON'T paint my toenails I am maybe making a choice that helps me fit into a group that I want to be part of.

Saying you don't have to do it is true. It is also true that when you do do it, is is a choice you make due to social conditioning. The social conditioning is what puts shellac on the table as one of a number of legitimate choices for you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread