Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say no to helping increased contact

30 replies

ABugWife · 09/06/2023 11:53

A family member is only allowed supervised contact with their children and it has fallen on me to accommodate this.

So it is once a week after work for 3 hours and then every other weekend for 4 hours.

They went back to court this week and I was lead to believe that the supervision aspect would be dropped. However this is not the case. My family member has actually requested to increase contact time, so one day every other weekend would now be for 8 hours, 10 - 6 .

The thing is, no one bothered to ask me am I available for these increased hours. I have a full time job and three children of my own, plus hobbies and a relationship to try and fit in.

It feels like a big commitment.

I have said sorry, I can only do 10 - 4 at the weekends as I have my own stuff to fit in. Family member is apparently unhappy with this (coming from their partner, they haven't said so themselves) Family member hasn't even bothered to tell me contact had changed!

So AIBU to say no to the change and offer a compromise. I know it's the only chance they have to see their kids so I feel terrible but I have my own life to fit in too.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
nothingcomestonothing · 12/06/2023 17:25

It is really hard to comprehend I think, that someone can let their child down in this way. It's not the same at all I know as this is your sis, but I have a lot of compassion for my DCs birth mum. She isn't a bad person, at all, and she loved her kids. But she wasn't able to put them first, or really understand how her behaviour was damaging to them. And she paid a very heavy price for that.

Your sis and her DC are very lucky to have you.

ABugWife · 12/06/2023 16:11

That is heartbreaking! I am so glad your DD has you now.

I am by no means the perfect mum but I just can't imagine not putting my kids first to this extent.

OP posts:
nothingcomestonothing · 12/06/2023 15:57

ABugWife · 12/06/2023 14:50

I haven't heard anything at all from anyone official. It was Dsis that said the contact centre wouldn't do it.

its so hard when there are two amazing kids stuck in the middle of all this and we just want to shake her!

Ultimately I feel somewhat responsible, I encouraged her to leave the relationship, it was abusive and controlling. What I didn't see coming was her deteriorating to the point she couldn't look after the children on her own. He was keeping her on the straight and narrow to some extent.

None of this is your fault. You couldn't have known this is how things would end up, or prevented it, and you've gone out of your way to facilitate contact.

Ultimately you can't paper over the cracks for your sis. She (it seems) has lied to you about the contact centre, and she's asked for more contact then let her children down by not turning up for it.

I have adopted DC, my DD remembers her birth mum not turning up for contact, and how she (my DD) would make excuses for her that the bus must be late or the day was wrong etc. My DD was pre school aged at the time Sad It's horrible to see the children caught up in this, but I don't think it's in your hands to fix it.

ABugWife · 12/06/2023 14:50

I haven't heard anything at all from anyone official. It was Dsis that said the contact centre wouldn't do it.

its so hard when there are two amazing kids stuck in the middle of all this and we just want to shake her!

Ultimately I feel somewhat responsible, I encouraged her to leave the relationship, it was abusive and controlling. What I didn't see coming was her deteriorating to the point she couldn't look after the children on her own. He was keeping her on the straight and narrow to some extent.

OP posts:
nothingcomestonothing · 12/06/2023 14:27

The contact centre wouldn't touch the case, they said it was too complex as there was an ongoing criminal court case at the time. (my family member was the victim, Ex was the defendant)

Have you actually been told that by someone official, OP? That's what contact centres are set up for, they can stagger different parties arriving and leaving etc so there no crossover. Contact.centres absolutely do facilitate contact when there's a criminal court case going on, I've known of families this has applied to.

Is there a chance that your relative has told you that the contract centre isn't an option, knowing you'll cover up for their lateness etc where a contact centre won't? I really feel for you but this isn't a situation you can sort - the children will notice mum is late etc, even at a very young age, and ultimately is it in their best interests to be having increased contact when their parent isn't reliable enough to attend it?

Discretionassured · 12/06/2023 14:05

I absolutely get your instinct to protect the DC from the truth about their inadequate parent OP but I don't think you can, or at least not completely. The only way this can possibly work is if you have cast iron boundaries and the strength to enforce them, not easy when there's (naturally) so much emotion involved.

I'm thinking you set the hours you're happy to provide supervision (sister can take it or leave it, that's what's on offer) and you have a 'x strikes and you're out' approach to her turning up on time, if she's late more than x times you will withdraw yourself from supervising contact.

It will be hard, sister will likely kick back and there will be short term drama but you hold all the power here. Taking the DC out of the equation for a second you are doing your sister a massive favour and it's entirely reasonable that you decide how much time you are willing to commit, even though dsis will likely not see it that way!

The DC are lucky to have you but you can't (and probably shouldn't) protect them from every failure by their parent. They will be able to see when they look back as adults how hard you tried to fill that gap and they will understand that you had to do it around your own life and responsibilities. You are doing your best for all of them but you can't be all things to all people Flowers

Lizzt2007 · 12/06/2023 13:27

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 12/06/2023 11:31

@ABugWife

The not taking responsibility /continual excuses and you absolutely shouldn't blame him for his actions 😕/lack of reliability..... THIS WILL ALL BE PART OF THE PICTURE!

As you know, kids need consistent, reliable loving adults... Not ones who cant be arsed to turn up on time for their precious protected time every week/who need continual prompts to do the most basic things.

You say he jas a manipulative ex... This is no doubt the narrative he's created.... I've met plenty of men who bounce back & forth to family courts asking for more and more contact (which they rarely, consistently, turn up for...).

They appear to do this to manipulate /dominate their ex partners....
(it's very difficult to have a normal life with your kids... When you're taking them back & forth for contact....). I remember several men delighted that their exes cancelled their plans /'couldn't see new boyfriend' as they had to facilitate contact... That the bloke, high-handedly wouldn't turn up for/very late... Pure dominance/coercive control.

If the women didn't facilitate the men KNEW that this may well go ib their favour when they return to the family court....

Lots of supposition in this. Did you miss that it's MUM that is ops family member and doesn't have custody? Your rant against men is completely biased and irrelevant to ops situation .

ABugWife · 12/06/2023 11:41

I was trying not to out myself but it is hard to keep up all the they/them stuff.

OP posts:
IamtheDevilsAvocado · 12/06/2023 11:38

ABugWife · 12/06/2023 11:34

@IamtheDevilsAvocado My family member is female. I know she isn't trying to manipulate or control the ex, throughout their relationship it was very much the other way round.

So much so that the police were trying to prosecute. We initially believed he took the children just to punish her.

However reading through some of the reports and things I do genuinely believe the children are better off where they are.

Sorry, i missed that the non-resident parent was female!

ABugWife · 12/06/2023 11:34

@IamtheDevilsAvocado My family member is female. I know she isn't trying to manipulate or control the ex, throughout their relationship it was very much the other way round.

So much so that the police were trying to prosecute. We initially believed he took the children just to punish her.

However reading through some of the reports and things I do genuinely believe the children are better off where they are.

OP posts:
Igmum · 12/06/2023 11:32

So sorry you're going through this OP and no, it's absolutely not unreasonable for you to want time for your family and yourself. This could be shared out among several relatives. I suspect, however, your relative won't bother to do this and will simply blame you.

ABugWife · 12/06/2023 11:31

The thing with a contact centre, if mum is late or doesn't turn up, the children are in a very uncomfortable situation and it's very obvious to them.

If they are just at mine and mum is late I can distract them, keep them entertained, feed they biscuits etc and it hopefully doesn't feel quite so shit for them.

OP posts:
IamtheDevilsAvocado · 12/06/2023 11:31

@ABugWife

The not taking responsibility /continual excuses and you absolutely shouldn't blame him for his actions 😕/lack of reliability..... THIS WILL ALL BE PART OF THE PICTURE!

As you know, kids need consistent, reliable loving adults... Not ones who cant be arsed to turn up on time for their precious protected time every week/who need continual prompts to do the most basic things.

You say he jas a manipulative ex... This is no doubt the narrative he's created.... I've met plenty of men who bounce back & forth to family courts asking for more and more contact (which they rarely, consistently, turn up for...).

They appear to do this to manipulate /dominate their ex partners....
(it's very difficult to have a normal life with your kids... When you're taking them back & forth for contact....). I remember several men delighted that their exes cancelled their plans /'couldn't see new boyfriend' as they had to facilitate contact... That the bloke, high-handedly wouldn't turn up for/very late... Pure dominance/coercive control.

If the women didn't facilitate the men KNEW that this may well go ib their favour when they return to the family court....

SantaFeSister · 12/06/2023 11:21

OP this doesn't sound sustainable at all. I would be pushing your sibling to get this into a contact centre, it would be more reliable for all.

ABugWife · 12/06/2023 11:14

I don't know how you did it @IamtheDevilsAvocado , I am beyond frustrated at my family member and that is just one person.

I was out of the house at 1am picking up my won DC from a party (my children are older) and I still managed to get up on time.

If you only see your children 6 times a month then you sure as hell be on time. Nothing should be in the way of that!

Unfortunately I think my family member knows I will pick up the slack, not for them, but for the kids who are desperate to spend time with their mum.

Totally outing here but it's not the first time we have been through this either. She has an older child who also lives with their dad that she rarely sees at all. That child is a teen and going off the rails unsurprisingly. I am trying to do all I can to see a better outcome for these children but it just won't be enough I fear.

OP posts:
IamtheDevilsAvocado · 12/06/2023 11:12

PS men returning to court often believe (wrongly) that they are able to get their supervision aspect voided... When there has been zero change in their behavior!!

Another point... You arr getting a sanitised/wrong version why they can't see their kods unsupervised.... Social services will have a better overview than family does!

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 12/06/2023 11:09

ABugWife · 12/06/2023 10:22

Contact was yesterday - Family member wasn't there at 10, I had text a reminder on Saturday, I text at 10.10, no reply.

10.30 I get a text saying they had over slept and would be there in 5 mins. finally turned up at 11.am. I asked whats the point of increasing contact if they can't be bothered to show up.

Honestly so frustrating and as usual, it wasn't their fault, they had just forgotten to set an alarm. They weren't late on purpose therefore I shouldn't be angry.

Those kids are so lucky to have a doting person who loves spending time with them!

Ok... I used to work in contact centres supervising these sessions...

  1. As others have said, to have supervised contact only are from serious concerns - this is not a kid being late for school /or a parent swearing in front of them!
  1. The late arrival /general not mentioning expecting you to facilitate... Aren't indicative of devoted parent moving heaven and earth to see their kids.. Late arrivals at contact centre was not uncommon- oversleeping was a common reason given .... Sometimes was obvious they were hungover /coming down.

( Put on multiple alarms /get a passing friend to hammer on your door at key time. - if you're serious about seeing your kids...! ).

The repeat offenders (continually late/not turning up /) we used to eventually withdraw support... (after we had several problem-solving chats with them... Obvs different if medical issues or a one off..)! Contact centres are an expensive resource.... (why so many family are asked now!).

I think you need to be really clear HOW many hours you are happy to give... Before these kids are on doorstep expecting to be looked after!

ABugWife · 12/06/2023 10:52

I guess I was thinking more that they aren't a danger to the children as in able to look after them, I didn't think of it terms of reliability. If I wasn't there for drop off then what would have happened.

It's so frustrating that they refuse to take responsibility. They were late the week before last to week day contact because they didn't realise what day it was.

OP posts:
GoalShooter · 12/06/2023 10:41

So disappointing OP.

TragicMuse · 12/06/2023 10:30

This is a person who didn't see their children for 5 months and now has court approved contact and yet they didn't set an alarm and were late to the extended time they want?

And you don't think supervised contact is required?

It clearly is. Your relative is unable to prioritise the children's needs and meet their expectations. Until they take responsibility for their own actions and put the children first every single time then supervision is needed.

I really think you should stop making excuses for them and stop letting them use you as a meat-shield who picks up their slack.

ABugWife · 12/06/2023 10:22

Contact was yesterday - Family member wasn't there at 10, I had text a reminder on Saturday, I text at 10.10, no reply.

10.30 I get a text saying they had over slept and would be there in 5 mins. finally turned up at 11.am. I asked whats the point of increasing contact if they can't be bothered to show up.

Honestly so frustrating and as usual, it wasn't their fault, they had just forgotten to set an alarm. They weren't late on purpose therefore I shouldn't be angry.

OP posts:
LakeTiticaca · 09/06/2023 12:35

Yanbu. You are doing more than enough to help already and shouldn't be expected to compromise your own family time for someone else. As above pp's say, they will have to use a contact centre

LadyJ2023 · 09/06/2023 12:28

I wouldn't be doing this and if something goes wrong you could get accused of alsorts that's why we have contact centres

Padstow58 · 09/06/2023 12:19

I have other siblings who could potentially have helped but they have their own things going on so they haven't been asked.

But you have your own things going on as well,OP. You have a full time job and your own children.

Tell your family member what you can comfortably do and let your siblings take up some of the slack.

ABugWife · 09/06/2023 12:03

The contact centre wouldn't touch the case, they said it was too complex as there was an ongoing criminal court case at the time. (my family member was the victim, Ex was the defendant)

This has since been dropped by the CPS so i suppose it could possibly an option now.

I don't mind on the whole helping out, the children are my family too and I love seeing them. I just feel bad for reducing the amount of time I am able to offer.

OP posts: