Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think new man should have told me he has performance issues

406 replies

QueenAnnesLeftSock · 09/06/2023 09:41

i’d just like to start by saying that this isn’t about the performance issues, I will use the sex board for that. It’s about whether IaBU to be annoyed or disappointed that he didn’t tell me about it. I wanted to ask here first so I don’t dive in with both feet and make him feel worse than he prob already does.

background: I’m 38. A while ago I met a guy online, not through a dating site, more a friend of a friend type situ. He’s 38 and never been married nor as far as I can tell has he really had a very serious relationship. We started off chatting as part of a larger group and then it went to private emails and then phone calls. He is brilliant, a lovely man, and even though I was worried that the remote stuff wouldn’t be real it was all actually better when we met in person. So far so good right!

but the thing is we’d got very flirty before meeting, lots of chat about what we wanted to do, that sort of thing. Only when I stayed over for the first time, it just wasn’t happening. It’s been about 2 months now, we’ve spent the night together several times and he just can’t, there’s nothing happening down there at all. I haven’t said anything, I’ve just tried various things and then it’s just moved back to kissing and talking and we haven’t discussed it but it’s becoming a real elephant in the room.

So I don’t want to be but I can’t deny now I’m feeling a bit fed up, we’ve spent so many hours talking about everything under the sun and describing stuff in detail, and now I feel that he was maybe sitting there knowing all along that he wouldn’t be able to do it. I think I need to come to terms with how I feel about this before I tackle the topic with him so i don’t make it alllll about me, if that makes sense.

To summarize aIBU to be pissed off that for months i thought we were sharing our deepest secrets and sexy chat when he was keeping something hidden and must have known it was going to be difficult or impossible to do what was being described?

Any thoughts welcome 🙏

OP posts:
QueenAnnesLeftSock · 15/06/2023 16:36
  • a secret groomer that should have said
OP posts:
QueenAnnesLeftSock · 15/06/2023 16:35

Wow, I forget how this place is batshit sometimes 😂.

The range of suggestions from making him book a hotel right now to him not fancying me to him being gay to him being a secret to me printing out this thread to show him is precisely why I said in the OP that I wasn’t asking for speculation on the cause. It’s disrespectful to a human being whom I like very much.

Nor am I prepared to disclose details of my private/social life to explain how/when we’ve met up, nor the graphic details of what we did and what was said, it’s all deeply personal. I’m satisfied with all that.

@OhForFucksFuckingSake has nailed (again, thank you!! 😘) how I had started to feel about it, and that is what we will be discussing the next time I see him.

OP posts:
2bazookas · 15/06/2023 16:01

When I read you have DC, I chilled.

IF he was a man uninterested in sex with adult women
IF he patiently groomed a single parent to gain access to her children

That would make perfect sense of the flirty phone sex , kissing and foldling that never leads to  physical arousal/PIV/orgasm. AND the fact he has never offered any discussion to explain a very weird  set of behaviours.
DeliciouslyDecadent · 15/06/2023 15:44

@ThatFraggle Is that quote of my post and your reply aimed at me or the OP (you're a bit obtuse or maybe the sarcasm isn't really working.)

If it's aimed at me, what I'd say to you is that if the OP is that concerned, she ought to have opened her mouth and discussed this the 2nd time it happened.

She wants to blame him for something that may have only happened with her (maybe he likes her as she likes him but there is something about the sexual chemistry that isn't working for him and he's giving HER the benefit of the doubt for a while.) Maybe in RL she doesn't do it for him compared to the phone but he wants to give it time.

So odd to blame another person for not 'admitting' something when they may have not been any history to admit- and to avoid talking about it yourself.

Pots and kettles, eh?

pendleflyer · 15/06/2023 15:35

can't help but wondering after all this, and OP having made up mind, possibly even before starting the thread, that the plan is to present the bloke with a printout of the thread and a mumsnet petition. or even a torchlit procession.

OP - talk, tacttfully, to him - only way forward.

ThatFraggle · 15/06/2023 15:21

DeliciouslyDecadent · 15/06/2023 15:14

Well, to answer your question.....

YES you are being unreasonable.

Why?

Because you don't know if this is a long-standing issue or if it's new with you.

It may have only happened with you, the first time you tried to have sex.
And once it has, it's set up a pattern of anxiety and ED.

You are also being unreasonable to keep on seeing him with this pattern being repeated and not asking him why.

You are also being very unreasonable and not realistic to expect a man to admit to ED so soon when dating, especially if it's something that hasn't happened before, or not often.

You don't give the impression here that you have tried to communicate with him, offer him reassurance that 'it's okay, don't worry about it' the first time it occurred.

What may have been stage fright with you, have become a bigger issue the more you have dated.

I think you should stop asking who is 'unreasonable' as if this is some judge and jury situation, and start engaging with the emotions.

OP, don't you know, the most important thing in the world is the feelings of this man who's leading you in a merry dance.

DeliciouslyDecadent · 15/06/2023 15:14

Well, to answer your question.....

YES you are being unreasonable.

Why?

Because you don't know if this is a long-standing issue or if it's new with you.

It may have only happened with you, the first time you tried to have sex.
And once it has, it's set up a pattern of anxiety and ED.

You are also being unreasonable to keep on seeing him with this pattern being repeated and not asking him why.

You are also being very unreasonable and not realistic to expect a man to admit to ED so soon when dating, especially if it's something that hasn't happened before, or not often.

You don't give the impression here that you have tried to communicate with him, offer him reassurance that 'it's okay, don't worry about it' the first time it occurred.

What may have been stage fright with you, have become a bigger issue the more you have dated.

I think you should stop asking who is 'unreasonable' as if this is some judge and jury situation, and start engaging with the emotions.

Thesharkradar · 15/06/2023 12:33

myladydarbanville · 15/06/2023 11:28

The fact the OP has also just acted like it didn't happen is equally weird, in my view.

"I haven’t said anything, I’ve just tried various things and then it’s just moved back to kissing and talking and we haven’t discussed it but it’s becoming a real elephant in the room."

I don't think it's all that weird, presumably this man has talked himself up and promised her lots of 'big hard penis action' (please excuse the phrase) this man according to her is very nice, kind, personable and so it would be inconceivable that he had deliberately lied about this.
She would have presumably felt some mixture of sorry for him, uncomfortable, embarrassed, confused. But given him the benefit of the doubt because he's such a nice guy and assumed it was a one-off ....and then when it turned out not to be a one-off it's harder to say anything because you didn't say anything the first time.
With hindsight she probably would have handled it differently but no one has the benefit of hindsight.

JimnJoyce · 15/06/2023 12:00

@JerkintheMerkin brilliant username and howling at the mental picture of the string.
I'm imagining a Fingerbobs mouse for some reason.
And I quite like a bit of BDSM but not when thats all its ever going to be

JerkintheMerkin · 15/06/2023 11:51

@JimnJoyce that's exactly what my ex did! Into BDSM (pleasure dom) to gloss over the fact that he had ED. Most perturbed to see bits of wool tied round his penis to keep it hard.

myladydarbanville · 15/06/2023 11:28

The fact the OP has also just acted like it didn't happen is equally weird, in my view.

"I haven’t said anything, I’ve just tried various things and then it’s just moved back to kissing and talking and we haven’t discussed it but it’s becoming a real elephant in the room."

ThatFraggle · 15/06/2023 11:23

myladydarbanville · 15/06/2023 10:35

He's lied by omission

That is an assumption. You don't know that.

Let's say it never happened before.

First time: everyone's nervous. Fine.

After the Second time:

  • He needs to say he's been to the GP And
  • This has never happened before. Can we try xyz.
  • I'm on a medication. This is one of the side effects they said might happen. I'm taking it for 6weeks/forever.

The fact that he's just tried to act as if nothing is weird suggests lying by omission.

myladydarbanville · 15/06/2023 10:35

He's lied by omission

That is an assumption. You don't know that.

Clymene · 15/06/2023 10:06

OhForFucksFuckingSake · 15/06/2023 09:26

I think what you're essentially asking OP is:

'I'm uncomfortable that this man explicitly represented himself to be fully functioning sexually in order to get me to be sexual with him. I now realise this was a deliberate misrepresentation and I feel a bit violated. Are my feelings valid and am I allowed to call him out on it?'

My answer is yes.

I'm sorry you've had so very many replies shaming you for not centering his feelings and not taking responsibility for trying to fix whatever's wrong with him that he won't even acknowledge.

Honesty is critical to trust, which is critical to a healthy sexual relationship.

He's lied by omission about something that probably would have had an impact on whether you would have enthusiastically consented to phone sex. I don't blame you for feeling very conflicted about that and I think he owes you a conversation.

Beautifully put

OhForFucksFuckingSake · 15/06/2023 09:26

I think what you're essentially asking OP is:

'I'm uncomfortable that this man explicitly represented himself to be fully functioning sexually in order to get me to be sexual with him. I now realise this was a deliberate misrepresentation and I feel a bit violated. Are my feelings valid and am I allowed to call him out on it?'

My answer is yes.

I'm sorry you've had so very many replies shaming you for not centering his feelings and not taking responsibility for trying to fix whatever's wrong with him that he won't even acknowledge.

Honesty is critical to trust, which is critical to a healthy sexual relationship.

He's lied by omission about something that probably would have had an impact on whether you would have enthusiastically consented to phone sex. I don't blame you for feeling very conflicted about that and I think he owes you a conversation.

myladydarbanville · 15/06/2023 08:38

The title of your AIBU was: AIBU To think new man should have told me has performance issures?

Perhaps he doesn't have performance issues, normally.

Perhaps he has not had intercourse in a while - perhaps since whatever illness/operation/recovery period - and did not know he would have performance issues.

Perhaps he fancies you more in the abstract but less so in person.

So he could hardly have warned you in any of these instances.

How can anyone else tell you how you should feel in these circumstances? You can feel whatever way you feel.

But also, surely how you feel about it all would be influenced by finding out what the actual situation is with his performance issues?

Any thoughts welcome

Clearly not! My thoughts are, as stated, you need to talk to him to find out what is going on. I would have thought the second time it happened might have been a good moment, but that is just my view.

narrichi · 15/06/2023 08:38

Assuming he isn't celibate out of choice, or waiting for marriage -- the impotence is one thing. The lack of communication and lying through omission is another. The fact that he seems unable to even talk about it after two months would probably put me off the idea of a relationship.

porridgeisbae · 15/06/2023 08:03

Yet another MN thread with a question about something that would be best revealed not by asking the pyschics of MN, but by speaking with the person it actually involves.

@myladydarbanville What OP asked in the OP is whether she's reasonable to be annoyed. Effectively, whether we might be annoyed in her shoes. Of course that's a question to ask third parties, not the bloke.

'Hi lover, am I being unreasonable to be annoyed that you led me on?' Wouldn't make sense.

QueenAnnesLeftSock · 15/06/2023 06:57

@myladydarbanville can I ask what question you think I asked?

because it absolutely wasn’t:

  • what is wrong with him if anything
  • does he like me enough
  • should I change my childcare arrangements and work shifts and social life and other commitments to see a man more quickly
  • is the relationship going anywhere

i asked one question about my own feelings on a topic before initiating a conversation with someone about something deeply personal…!

OP posts:
myladydarbanville · 15/06/2023 00:05

Yet another MN thread with a question about something that would be best revealed not by asking the pyschics of MN, but by speaking with the person it actually involves.

MsDee1995 · 14/06/2023 22:59

If he is good in all other ways, the best, and least embarrassing way to say it might be....
"Hey, I'm really enjoying spending time with you, but when I plan to spend the night (or evening, afternoon, or whatever...) with you, I was hoping for it to be a little more fulfilling, and expected that that would mean more than just cuddling. Do you not enjoy actual intercourse, because I notice that we never seem to get to that point, and that is very frustrating for me, especially with a person that I care for a lot, and hope to have a long term relationship with. If you don't feel the same, please let me know."

Adults cannot be afraid to have serious conversations with each other. Good luck to you both!

DeliciouslyDecadent · 14/06/2023 21:08

QueenAnnesLeftSock · 14/06/2023 18:40

Well - I didn’t expect him to mention it so much as I would expect someone who couldn’t do something not to be very graphic about doing it.

There’s a big difference. I don’t go on phone calls talking about my ability to do the splits for a reason!

Do the words 'fantasise' and 'masturbation' mean anything to you @QueenAnnesLeftSock ?

Honestly, you are concluding a lot from your few meetings with him.

He's either got an anxiety issue or a medical one.

If it's the former, you simply don't know if it's with you (no criticism of you) or if it's occurred before.

As many of us have said, in this thread, it takes two to have a conversation. You've had time to start it on each occasion.

QueenAnnesLeftSock · 14/06/2023 18:40

Well - I didn’t expect him to mention it so much as I would expect someone who couldn’t do something not to be very graphic about doing it.

There’s a big difference. I don’t go on phone calls talking about my ability to do the splits for a reason!

OP posts:
ThatFraggle · 14/06/2023 15:04

DeliciouslyDecadent · 14/06/2023 14:49

They fell in love over the phone. They had all sorts of intimate discussions. It was a long distance relationship.

So yes. He could have said, 'I've got a problem surrounding performance issues. Can we talk face to face?'

There is nowhere the OP says they are in love.

I don't think you understand men at all.

In love' being used loosely.

They got to like each other well enough to talk for hours and go to bed together. Is that better.

Maybe I don't understand men at all.

But having an open/vulnerable conversation on the phone is something millions of people are happy to do.

DeliciouslyDecadent · 14/06/2023 14:49

They fell in love over the phone. They had all sorts of intimate discussions. It was a long distance relationship.

So yes. He could have said, 'I've got a problem surrounding performance issues. Can we talk face to face?'

There is nowhere the OP says they are in love.

I don't think you understand men at all.