Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think new man should have told me he has performance issues

406 replies

QueenAnnesLeftSock · 09/06/2023 09:41

i’d just like to start by saying that this isn’t about the performance issues, I will use the sex board for that. It’s about whether IaBU to be annoyed or disappointed that he didn’t tell me about it. I wanted to ask here first so I don’t dive in with both feet and make him feel worse than he prob already does.

background: I’m 38. A while ago I met a guy online, not through a dating site, more a friend of a friend type situ. He’s 38 and never been married nor as far as I can tell has he really had a very serious relationship. We started off chatting as part of a larger group and then it went to private emails and then phone calls. He is brilliant, a lovely man, and even though I was worried that the remote stuff wouldn’t be real it was all actually better when we met in person. So far so good right!

but the thing is we’d got very flirty before meeting, lots of chat about what we wanted to do, that sort of thing. Only when I stayed over for the first time, it just wasn’t happening. It’s been about 2 months now, we’ve spent the night together several times and he just can’t, there’s nothing happening down there at all. I haven’t said anything, I’ve just tried various things and then it’s just moved back to kissing and talking and we haven’t discussed it but it’s becoming a real elephant in the room.

So I don’t want to be but I can’t deny now I’m feeling a bit fed up, we’ve spent so many hours talking about everything under the sun and describing stuff in detail, and now I feel that he was maybe sitting there knowing all along that he wouldn’t be able to do it. I think I need to come to terms with how I feel about this before I tackle the topic with him so i don’t make it alllll about me, if that makes sense.

To summarize aIBU to be pissed off that for months i thought we were sharing our deepest secrets and sexy chat when he was keeping something hidden and must have known it was going to be difficult or impossible to do what was being described?

Any thoughts welcome 🙏

OP posts:
AAAAABBBBBCCCCC · 09/06/2023 18:30

He's an 'ATANA'.

All Talk And No Action.

Yep, it's deceit. Yep, he thought you would fall for him and sex wouldn't matter.

I've been through it before. Horrible and embarrassing. I couldn't stay with someone like that. Next, he'll be calling you a nymph all because you want your needs met.

Those women who say sex doesn't matter are having shit sex, or have a low sex drive, or aren't sexually attracted to their partner.

It bloody well SHOULD matter to any normal couple!

Spottycarousel · 09/06/2023 18:12

From experience, it becomes a big issue over time. Sexual satisfaction is a big need for most people in a relationship no matter how much you want to pretend it doesn't.

Firstly though, you need to communicate about it. If that is impossible your relationship has no future anyhow.

MrsLighthouse · 09/06/2023 18:10

I would prepare for him to react badly - even finish with you due to embarrassment - but if he’s worth having in every other area then surely it’s worth trying to talk to him before giving up ?
Just say something alone the lines of “ you must know by now l really like you so can we talk about something that might feel awkward ?” Or “it’s funny that this is going so well except in one area ..are you ok to talk about that because l really feel ready to ? “

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/06/2023 18:00

Now I feel like I should have known it was all a bit too good to be true

Not at all, OP; this is something which happens to most men occasionally (and sometimes, sadly, all the time) but there aren't that many in his age group where it seems to be a major ongoing problem

As a PP said it might have been better if he'd got medical advice before starting a relationship, but then again we can't know that he hasn't.
Anyway while you're quite right that it's a shame, the underlying point is that nobody's owed a relationship and you can end one for any reason or none.
I'm sure you'll be decent about it and avoid hurting his feelings as much as you can, but if this is (understandably) a dealbreaker for you I'm not sure you have any other realistic choice

UpshotCrow · 09/06/2023 17:56

My DP has issues following a very serious incident. There are good sources of treatment and therapy via a regional rehabilitation centre.

A lot of the men there are veterans and say they don't post about it online because it attracts kinksters and nutters but they do meet up. They know that not talking about it is not an option. It's no-one's 'fault'. It is what it is, and it's surpassable.

Entering into a new relationship without discussing it though ... no.

Evaka · 09/06/2023 17:52

I'd give him a chance to get some help. My partner had some psychological stuff that got in the way for us for a while but he sought and got help, and our sex life is excellent now. It can be devastating for a guy to experience and also hard for them to get help because they tonnes of pressure on being good in bed. Not saying it's for you to sort out OP, just that if he's willing to get help it may be worth sticking around a little longer.

babyproblems · 09/06/2023 17:50

Maybe he’s very nervous?? You deffo need to have a bit of a chat. Is he very shy? What’s he like after a drink, is he a bit more relaxed? If so I would go out for a lovely meal and a drink and then on the walk home or a cosy, just-the-two-of-you-setting I’d bring it up and say how much you like him and you wanted to ask if he was feeling ok and see if anything comes to light. Xx

DoingSomethingUnholy · 09/06/2023 17:45

puffyisgood · 09/06/2023 17:29

At the risk of stating the obvious, you cannot pin any real hopes on a relationship with someone who you've not yet met in person. You just don't know how well you'll get on in practice.

Anyway, what OP has described is really odd. If this is someone who'd portrayed themselves as, say, 'looking for friendship, maybe more' then something of that sort, that'd be one thing, and maybe that's a relationship that could work on a largely platonic, perhaps non-exclusive level, but spending a lot of time sexting or whatever despite being, by the sound of things, more or less dead from the waist down, just screams 'time waster'.

They've been in one another's company several times and nothing is happening downstairs for him, this isn't a case of they haven't met yet. They get on great by the sounds of it but he can't get an erection, sounds like op is looking for more than a friend so this isn't going to work.

Peppadog · 09/06/2023 17:44

It's not too good to be true. You really like him, just bring it up and hopefully he can get it sorted. I feel so sorry for a guy that just gets binned due to something like this, I assume he hasn't brought it up as is ashamed and hoping it won't keep happening.

Toohotto · 09/06/2023 17:43

Depends on how much you like him & whether or not he's willing to discuss it & try to do something about it. It's only been 2 months, he could be very embarrassed about it. It sounds a bit callous & harsh to just say ditch him if everything else is good. If you want an intimate relationship with each other then you should be able to discuss this.

PinkPlantCase · 09/06/2023 17:30

Please update the thread when you find out OP 😂

puffyisgood · 09/06/2023 17:29

At the risk of stating the obvious, you cannot pin any real hopes on a relationship with someone who you've not yet met in person. You just don't know how well you'll get on in practice.

Anyway, what OP has described is really odd. If this is someone who'd portrayed themselves as, say, 'looking for friendship, maybe more' then something of that sort, that'd be one thing, and maybe that's a relationship that could work on a largely platonic, perhaps non-exclusive level, but spending a lot of time sexting or whatever despite being, by the sound of things, more or less dead from the waist down, just screams 'time waster'.

SchoolShenanigans · 09/06/2023 17:28

He obviously can't get it up. That isn't going to change without medical help.

Which surely he should have sought before starting anything romantically.

This is absolutely a deal breaker, unless you're just looking for a friend. He should have told you and he should be seeking help.

Personally, I would just friendzone him and move on. He'd being disingenuous.

Any decent person would explain, however embarrassing it is, that sex isn't an option now. Instead he's led you up the garden path.

Allblackeverythingalways · 09/06/2023 17:28

pendleflyer · 09/06/2023 17:03

so you are bringing past issues of your own to bear/achieving personal payback when advising the OP? Doesn't sound too healthy to me. Or helpful. How many others are similarly motivated on relationship threads I cannot help but ask.

I don't need to any more, I met an actually nice guy that ticks all of my boxes and is always upfront with me.
Honesty. People should try it.
She's in a new relationship, she should be having the time of her life. It WON'T get better.

DeliciouslyDecadent · 09/06/2023 17:28

I agree with @WombatChocolate

You're asking if it's unreasonable that he hasn't owned up to his problem, but really it's your problem too (and you're avoiding mentioning it.)

It's actually hard to understand how you can have oral sex with someone (as the receiver) yet not find the other person is turned on by it, but not question it.

Have you considered he might be thinking 'Why the heck has @QueenAnnesLeftSock not said anything to me?'

If there have been many intimate occasions, yet he's never aroused, why on earth is this not being discussed?

He's possibly unreasonable not to mention it (maybe he's ever-hopeful he will rise to the occasion?) but you are equally unreasonable for getting into bed with him time after time, expecting something different.

You know- definition of madness- 'doing the same thing over and over, and expecting a different outcome'.

Talk to him!

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 09/06/2023 17:28

Divorcedalongtime · 09/06/2023 10:50

He probably thought it would be different with you because he fancies yoj more…

I had a fling like this where it was quickly obvious that he couldn’t penetrate…

he was the best at giving oral though, my first time cumming without making any effort myself. So silver linings.

Why can't I find one like that?

acpk55 · 09/06/2023 17:26

QueenAnnesLeftSock · 09/06/2023 13:00

@SleepingStandingUp we’ve done other things, yes. I didn’t want to get too graphic on here but lots of hands and oral stuff; he is very keen to please and he visibly enjoys being touched, it just doesn’t actually do anything and therefore he doesn’t get the same obvious pleasure that I do.

And to me giving my partner pleasure is a key part of me enjoying sex, although I would be open to the idea that he can have pleasure in more ways than the obvious, I’d be lying if I said it wouldn’t be disappointing. Maybe he’s scared of rejection if he brings it up, like I said, I do get that, but at the same time, it’s clearly not fixing itself!

you have probably hit the nail on the head, with the rejection comment, just look at the number of posters who said bin him without a second’s thought

I would imagine that the discussion needs to be around what is he going to do about it, (Dr , pills, urologist, pumps) etc and which any if any of these you are okay with

WombatChocolate · 09/06/2023 17:21

Depends if you think he’s someone you can see something longer term with, or if really it’s just for short term sex.

If it’s just about sex and it’s not happening, then it’s probably worth ending it.

If you think that if the sex thing can be sorted, he’s someone you’d like to spend more time with and can see something longer term, it’s definitely worth talking about with him.

This has gone beyond a one meet-up thing. Personally, I think that if you’re prepared to be intimate and talk about the details of sex you’d like to have, having the conversation about it not actually happening should be happening and should have happened already. Yes, he should have been talking about it, but so should you OP. Lots of good opportunities are wasted because people don’t or won’t communicate…it’s a real shame if there’s potential there.

Yes, it’s an awkward conversation. It s worth it if you think there could be something between you. If you just want to have sex and it doesn’t really matter with who, then this barrier seems quite significant, especially if you are finding it difficult to raise the issue.

I expect it won’t be a popular view, but I personally think that if you’re prepared to ‘talk sex’ and have sex, you also need to be prepared to talk about what is and isn’t happening and communicate about it, if you’re looking at anything beyond one-night hook ups.

This thing of blame isn’t worth it. You both have to talk about it, even though it’s tricky. The question is whether you’re prepared to push yourself to do that in the hope there’s something good to come out of it, or don’t want to bother and just move on.

DeliciouslyDecadent · 09/06/2023 17:18

he is very keen to please and he visibly enjoys being touched, it just doesn’t actually do anything and therefore he doesn’t get the same obvious pleasure that I do.

Curious- so although he 'visibly enjoys' being touched, his willy isn't joining in. Is that what you mean?

Sorry but my money is on him being gay and in the closet, or with some health issue which means he can't.

You need to ask him.

DeliciouslyDecadent · 09/06/2023 17:14

Not read all the posts but could he be gay and in denial?

With men like him, it's either a physical/ purely mechanical issue that needs medical help (Viagra or similar)

or , it's emotional and needs therapy if he has some hang ups.

I mean, does he get turned on with you? Is the kissing passionate or half-baked?

Does he get an erection at all?

CheshireCat1 · 09/06/2023 17:11

You need to bring the subject up, he’ll probably thank you for doing so. If you really like him and want to invest in this relationship just explain that you’ll support him all the way but he must get help, in the first instance by seeing his GP to rule out any underlying issues or even psychological ones. It could be an easy issue to solve.

ThatFraggle · 09/06/2023 17:11

pendleflyer · 09/06/2023 17:03

so you are bringing past issues of your own to bear/achieving personal payback when advising the OP? Doesn't sound too healthy to me. Or helpful. How many others are similarly motivated on relationship threads I cannot help but ask.

You are BU

Everybody brings their past issues when giving advice. That's the point.

And I completely agree. Women being socialised to 'be nice' leads to them suffering in the end. Better to nip things in the bud and be called a bitch.

WisherWood · 09/06/2023 17:11

I’d be inclined to ditch him but I wouldn’t do it without talking to him first to see what the issue is.

This really. And not because I somehow want to help out the poor little man but because I wouldn't want to end something otherwise good unless I had talked about it first. It can be difficult to know when to talk about something like this, but if he's fine to have phone sex, then he can talk about his ED. So at a point when you're not being intimate, just say you want to talk about it and go from there. I think if you go into the conversation prepared to end the relationship, you'll be able to be more open because you won't be thinking 'oh, mustn't offend him in case he thinks I'm dumping him' or similar.

pendleflyer · 09/06/2023 17:03

Allblackeverythingalways · 09/06/2023 16:19

I learnt to be unkind because of "nice" men that have tried to make me believe I'm lacking if they have an issue of any sort.
Fuck. That.

so you are bringing past issues of your own to bear/achieving personal payback when advising the OP? Doesn't sound too healthy to me. Or helpful. How many others are similarly motivated on relationship threads I cannot help but ask.

littleburn · 09/06/2023 16:53

I think you're being primed to accept this as the norm for your relationship OP. You say that in all other ways he's a lovely guy, but bear in mind you're only two months in so he will be on his best behaviour right now. The misleading you with the sex talk and now blithely carrying on as if all is ok is not 'nice guy' to my mind.

Yes it's sex and it's a sensitive issue, but in any other aspect of a new relationship words and actions not matching up this early on would be a red flag. Clearly there's a problem, he knows there's a problem and, in my opinion, is gaslighting you by acting as if there's isn't.

I'd give him a chance and raise it and see what he says. If he in anyway tries to turns it back on you or doesn't want to address the issue then that'd be it for me.