Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to believe frequent SM posters are massively unhappy?

87 replies

Ncbo · 09/06/2023 07:20

I don't use social media much, more of just a watcher than poster.

It's become painfully obvious to me that the "perfect happy couples" are in actual fact miserable and playing out their life on an app that actually nobody gives a crap about.

Same with the parents who overshare their kids and show every detail of their day.

Just got me thinking as the neighbours argue every other day, on their kiss and make up days it prompts a post on SM declaring their undying love for each other 🙃

OP posts:
ThanksAntsThants23 · 09/06/2023 13:40

Yanbu to think this. My cousin post pics and little stories about her kids constantly, like “aww child did/said this cute thing, I’m such a lucky mum, love th so much”. Her kids live with their grandparents and she rarely sees them because she’s a very low functioning alcoholic. Firm her SM you’d never guess this though!

deathbyhayfever · 09/06/2023 13:35

No, but I think SM brings an awful amount of bitterness and jealousy.

A beautiful mum posting with her lovely home as background? Of course she must be miserable and neglect her children. You can't be a lovely happy mum unless you live in squalor apparently.

Inspiring shots of amazing holiday destination? They must be miserable and drowning in debt, they will be living under a bridge very soon, just wait and see.

Enthusiastic shots and accounts of sporting events? Only from someone struggling with low self esteem, obviously has no private life and some sort of eating disorder.

Happy and beautiful photos of a wedding? One is obviously cheating and they'll be divorced within the year.

So yes, I believe people who posts about how unhappy anyone else must be are very unhappy and bitter themselves, are not genuine friends and need to get a hobby 😂

CountTo10 · 09/06/2023 13:34

I don't know what research has been done into this phenomena but I wonder if these people portray what they would like it to be rather than what it is and then they can pretend the FB life is their real life. Or a bit of a fake it until you make it scenario that if they keep posting all the lovely bits that's how it will be.

There was a very sad case where a woman was murdered by her boyfriend. Her FB was specifically mentioned in court as it portrayed a loving, lovely relationship. One specific incident was pointed out when they'd gone to Rome and her FB was all photos of the lovely flowers he'd bought her and the lovely meals and wasn't she lucky to have a BF like him. What it didn't say was that on that holiday he beat her up really badly and she flew home early. She stayed with him and she continued posting all these 'look what my lovely BF has bought me aren't I lucky posts?' Maybe she was trying to convince everyone who was telling her to leave him that they were wrong?

SweetBirdsong · 09/06/2023 13:33

I don't think ALL social media posters (who post very frequently,) are really unhappy @Ncbo BUT I do think SOME of them are - and SOME of them are clearly trying to prove something. (And that is that they're really happy, and having an amazing life, and everything is wonderful and perfect.) It's never true, as NO-ONE has a perfect amazing life, (with no problems,) and couples DO fall out, and extended family members fall out with each other too. Also, even the 'best behaved' kids are little shits sometimes!!!

One woman I know (40-ish) is a SAHM with 2 kids aged 10 and 8, and she is CONSTANTLY posting photos of her kids, and her and her DH, and blathering about how amazing her kids are, how loved up she is with her 'hubster' (yep that's what she calls him!) and there's not a day goes by when she doesn't post something.

Some days there are 5 or 6 posts a day, always with photos. And her kids are the cleverest, prettiest, most amazingly academically gifted children in the world. Much cleverer than others their age. She believes they should be in a school for super brainy children, as normal schools are not good enough. 🙄

I have had to unfollow (not unfriend) her, because I am sick of her inane and tedious posts coming up on the top of my timeline every time I go on facebook!

But yeah for sure, the more I see someone blathering on and on and ON about their amazing relationship, and their perfect life, the more I think 'nah... not buying it mate!' 😆

tattygrl · 09/06/2023 13:33

Depends what they're posting, I think, generally.

However, during a time when I was housebound for a few months, I ended up adminning a mental health support group on facebook, and let me tell you, that was an exhaustive education in the fact that what people post on their social media page is MASSIVELY misleading. People would post on their main, public feed pictures of them with their family, beaming around a dinner table, looking radiant in each other's company, with a cheesy/heartfelt post about family time and appreciating how lucky they are etc., then come into the MH support group with the most horrendous tales of family discontent, toxicity, drama, issues, the whole gamut. Same for posts about relationships, then would come into the group posting all about what their partner had said and done and how much they were struggling.

I already knew theoretically that people post the highlights of their life publicly on social media, and to take it all with a pinch of salt, but it really was illuminating and quite shocking the disparity between what people were publicly posting vs what they were revealing in the MH group. I obviously never said anything to them or anything else about this observation, and I didn't judge them for it, but it was just ordinary people; not social media "influencers" posting perfect lives, but normal people just making normal, "wholesome" posts about their lives, only to reveal the true horrors of it all in the MH group. It was a definitive lesson for me in never, ever taking ANYTHING seriously on social media.

Verv · 09/06/2023 13:24

QuizzlyBears · 09/06/2023 13:17

I don’t agree with that at all. I think some people can find it hard when they see happy couples being portrayed online over social media etc, and that it is easier for them to believe it is fake/unhealthy rather than consider that there are couples out there who are genuinely just happy and perhaps getting the validation they wish they could have. Not the case for everyone, I know that.

I find it hard when happy couples are portrayed on social media but one half is on the phone to me mulling a split.

Thepeopleversuswork · 09/06/2023 13:21

I don’t agree with that at all. I think some people can find it hard when they see happy couples being portrayed online over social media etc, and that it is easier for them to believe it is fake/unhealthy rather than consider that there are couples out there who are genuinely just happy and perhaps getting the validation they wish they could have. Not the case for everyone, I know that.

I agree: I think the assumption anyone who posts pictures of their spouse must automatically be in an unhappy relationship doesn't stand up to logical scrutiny at all and says more about the self esteem of the person who holds this theory than it does about the people posting pictures.

Of course there are individual cases where that happens. But to draw some sweeping conclusion to the whole of humanity is daft.

Oblomov23 · 09/06/2023 13:19

Nope. I don't believe this. This assumption that it's all a facade, maybe for a few, not most. I only post a bit but what I post is real. And I just don't think this insistence that all fake, can be substantiated.

BethDuttonsTwin · 09/06/2023 13:18

Not necessarily “massively unhappy” but when I was posting regular Look At Me updates they were kind of a FU for the benefit of people in my life who I felt were judging and criticising my situation at the time. As I have got older and stopped caring what others think I have stopped posting so much and hardly ever do now. So there was certainly negativity and conflict around being on social media so much but I wouldn’t say I was massively unhappy.

Butchyrestingface · 09/06/2023 13:18

AceofPentacles · 09/06/2023 07:25

Yes I know one couple where the DP confided in me twenty years ago that he didn't love his wife but she posts daily about how great her life is with him.

The two things aren't mutually exclusive though, are they? He's not happy with her but possibly does a good job of hiding it and/or treats her well, hence = happy days for her.

QuizzlyBears · 09/06/2023 13:17

Verv · 09/06/2023 13:14

I use social media, usually Facebook and insta.
Not unhappy at all but also rarely reference my relationship.
I remember saying once that the sign of a healthy relationship was no sign of it on SM.

I don’t agree with that at all. I think some people can find it hard when they see happy couples being portrayed online over social media etc, and that it is easier for them to believe it is fake/unhealthy rather than consider that there are couples out there who are genuinely just happy and perhaps getting the validation they wish they could have. Not the case for everyone, I know that.

Sidking · 09/06/2023 13:15

Not necessarily, I post more when I'm in a good place. When I'm in a state of overwhelm and I'm struggling I go very quiet

Verv · 09/06/2023 13:14

I use social media, usually Facebook and insta.
Not unhappy at all but also rarely reference my relationship.
I remember saying once that the sign of a healthy relationship was no sign of it on SM.

Izzabird · 09/06/2023 13:13

Thepeopleversuswork · 09/06/2023 12:58

I think this is a massive generalisation and you can't begin to understand why individual people use SM. I agree with a PP that a lot of people experience a kind of reverse schadenfreude and tell themselves that everyone on SM must be unhappy because they want to feel better about themselves.

People use SM for a vast array of different reasons. Yes some of them will be trying to paint over the cracks in their marriage and some are narcissists... but a lot of younger people in particular use it to communicate with each other. It's a completely natural part of life, like breathing. Some people use it like a digital photo album, some people use it to blow of steam about their political views, to share jokes and silly memes or cat videos, some people use it to keep in touch when they have lost phone numbers etc. It's far too simplistic to say all SM users are desperately unhappy and dying inside.

I also think increasingly women in particular are subjected to a nasty moralistic tone about their use of social media. People routinely post that their (female) friends are "attention seeking" on Facebook or Insta or that someone should "act their age" etc. I'm curious to know if men judge each other's use of Insta in the same way. I'm going to guess not.

Yes, exactly.

I don't think there is any correlation between happiness, health of relationship, excitingness of life etc and SM use.

DH and I both use Instagram, but have entirely different practices and philosophies for what we post, and how often. Mine is essentially a diary of 'stuff I've seen that was interesting, striking, beautiful, strange etc', his is a much more full-on documentation of events and people. I might post once or twice a week, and then post nothing at all for a fortnight or more, DH might post 30 job-photos over a weekend. I hate being photographed so I'm seldom in them, but DS is. Most of my posts don't contain people.

My ten most recent posts are the view from a mountain summit (I climbed it with a friend, but he's not in the photo), a strange illustration in child's book thrown on the street, DS's hand wearing jelly rings, a few strange pieces of graffitti, a ewe and lamb, a painting I bought, DS on another summit. DH's are much more numerous, and all of professional occasions, friends and travels.

HashBrownandBeans · 09/06/2023 13:09

We are the soppy in public and on social media types and yes, we are that happy. Not had an argument yet and it’s been 9 years

StormShadow · 09/06/2023 13:03

I think some people are just oversharers and/or addicted regardless of whether they're happy or sad at that point in their lives. I know people who document everything that's going on, and with those people, I wouldn't necessarily assume they were bullshitting if they were saying how wonderful their spouse is or whatever. It'd just be how they felt that particular hour of the day, and there'd be something else on there soon enough.

But there are definitely also people who doth protest too much on social media, yes.

Tourmalines · 09/06/2023 13:00

That’s a drop in the ocean from the 2 billion or so Facebook users GloriousD .

Thepeopleversuswork · 09/06/2023 12:58

I think this is a massive generalisation and you can't begin to understand why individual people use SM. I agree with a PP that a lot of people experience a kind of reverse schadenfreude and tell themselves that everyone on SM must be unhappy because they want to feel better about themselves.

People use SM for a vast array of different reasons. Yes some of them will be trying to paint over the cracks in their marriage and some are narcissists... but a lot of younger people in particular use it to communicate with each other. It's a completely natural part of life, like breathing. Some people use it like a digital photo album, some people use it to blow of steam about their political views, to share jokes and silly memes or cat videos, some people use it to keep in touch when they have lost phone numbers etc. It's far too simplistic to say all SM users are desperately unhappy and dying inside.

I also think increasingly women in particular are subjected to a nasty moralistic tone about their use of social media. People routinely post that their (female) friends are "attention seeking" on Facebook or Insta or that someone should "act their age" etc. I'm curious to know if men judge each other's use of Insta in the same way. I'm going to guess not.

OhBling · 09/06/2023 12:51

I am very much in the "everyone should use SM however works for them because the great thing about it is that the rest of us can just scroll on past whatever doesn't work for us" camp. And overall, I am quite happy to look or ignore, depending on my mood, holiday photos, stealth boasts, endless baby pics etc.

Having said that, rather cynically, if I see a couple where one or both are posting extraordinarily, borderline inappropriate posts about how great the other one is, the best mummy/daddy ever etc etc, especially if it happens more than once... my antennae do prick up because sadly, many of these I've seen have either subsequently broken up or I know enough about in real life to know it's a complete load of bollocks.

ontheplayground · 09/06/2023 12:41

The 3 people I know who post most on social media really do have enviable lives and great marriages/families (and I know them well enough to be pretty sure).

They also all enjoy photography, and have numerous friends and family who live a long way away or in a different country - so it's a way of keeping them in the loop as well.

I'm sure there are people who fake a lot on SM, but you also get plenty of genuine ones. Just like in real life...

FragrantBumFluff · 09/06/2023 12:41

Chipsahoy · 09/06/2023 09:41

Lonely I think. Maybe insecure too.

If I’m out doing something fun with my family or friends and we get a good pic, I’ll upload it to Instagram as long as it’s a good pic of me.

My page is mostly holiday photos, kids/dogs being cute and days/evenings out - of course these are the highlights, I’m not about to post a photo of me with my mum bun and tatty leggings taking the bins out. Doesn’t mean my page isn’t real life and I’m perfectly happy and secure!!

So yabu 😁

Freeballing · 09/06/2023 12:28

I think that people who think things like 'oh they must be so unhappy and insecure because they post on facebook/instagram' are probably a bit unhappy and insecure themselves. They make themselves feel better by telling themselves that it is all for show, Anne's life/relationships whatever are crap really.

The people I know that post the most on social media are just generally social, outgoing, happy people and they don't have any social media angst/don't over analyse everything.

Growingouttogether · 09/06/2023 12:22

Of course SM is mostly a highlights reel, and of course behind the screen life is not like that 100% of the time but no I definitely don’t agree that those I know who post frequently are miserable, or attention seeking. I post pretty frequently and I have a wonderful life, I only have friends on my SM who I enjoy seeing their updates, the nice things they’re doing and watching their kids grow. If I didn’t enjoy seeing their posts then I would know we aren’t really friends so I wouldn’t have them on SM. You can be happy that other people have good things happening without it degrading your own. I also get a lot of good ideas of things to do and visit from friends posts.

Pooterlie · 09/06/2023 10:23

I agree OP. Not so much couples but I have a few friends who post multiple times a day and honestly it gives the impression that they are in a mental health crisis more than anything. I think it's reflects tremendous neediness and a thirst for validation that I think is very unhealthy.

One of them stopped posting for a few months and said that not a single SM follower reached out to see if she was OK.

stingypeasant · 09/06/2023 10:12

lieselotte · 09/06/2023 08:43

I think people use it as a diary - I sometimes post quite banal things on Instagram like going into the office on a nice day and taking a pretty picture of London. But when you scroll through in later years you might remember something you had forgotten doing, so it's quite a nice record.

What I don't understand is the "Stories". What is the point of going to all that effort of posting something for it to disappear after 24 hours? It makes much more sense to actually post.

I like stories for the exact reason that many of them really are not very interesting long term. A coffee in the sunshine is a lovely moment to share but it doesn't need to be kept for all eternity. Stories are like a passing comment. I post things like Christmas family picture or a new addition to the family or something with significance

Swipe left for the next trending thread