Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To work on the assumption I won’t be able to breastfeed?

168 replies

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 06:35

When I had my first baby I wanted to breastfeed so followed all the advice and I just couldn’t latch him on. I’m due in 2 weeks: AIBU to just assume it’s probably going to be the same and just buy all the bottle feeding equipment? I’ll give it a go but I’m not really expecting it to work.

OP posts:
CheeseDreamsTonight · 09/06/2023 08:07

Are your breasts very large? All the advice was rubbish as mine are large, but when I discovered rugby ball hold it was a dream.

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 08:06

So. One more time before I leave the thread to sink into the dregs of MN and go and Iine the profits of Cow and Gate.

I could not breastfeed. I tried, but I could not latch my baby on.

It did not hurt, because I could not do it.

It was not hard to get through the first six weeks, because I could not do it.

I didn’t find it inconvenient, because I could not do it.

I went to see a lactation consultant (£200) bought a very expensive breast pump (£300) shared my post birth boobs and body with far too many FB groups, tried nipple shields, had midwives coming out.

It didn’t work. I couldn’t get the baby to latch on. I think about seven seconds was the longest we managed.

Of course, no one believes you and thinks you just didn’t try hard enough and on top of that, I get called rude 😂

It might be worth trying but I don’t know … I’m not feeling great about it all, to be honest.

OP posts:
Riverbananacarrot · 09/06/2023 08:04

Just because you couldn't the first time doesnt mean you won't be able to this time. Stacey Solomon couldn't until her Rose was born and she had 3 before that.

Have you thought about Combi feeding? Both breast and bottle? That way you can plan to do both and if breast doesnt work out you can bottle feed and have everything in the house

Also I didn't want to breast feed I bottle fed totally my own choice but I did find there seemed to be lots of support for breast feeding mums in my local area.

PizzaPizza56 · 09/06/2023 08:02

People are trying to help you, everyone here can read thank you.

What people are saying is that most people have 6 miserable first weeks where they struggle to get their baby to latch. It's a rare baby that knows what it's doing from the outset.

We know you didn't try for 6 weeks so who knows if you would have been able to if you had.

If you don't want to bf then don't, no one cares how you feed your baby. If it will help your mental health not to put yourself through establishing bf after pregnancy and birth then just don't do it!

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 08:01

Yes, it was rude. But how many times do you think someone should type the same thing politely, @SoupDragon ?

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 09/06/2023 08:01

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 07:57

It seems the ability to breastfeed and the ability to read aren’t synonymous.

Lol

SoupDragon · 09/06/2023 07:59

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 07:57

It seems the ability to breastfeed and the ability to read aren’t synonymous.

Rude.

Mischance · 09/06/2023 07:59

I could not feed my first. Scottish midwife said "Ye have nae the boozooms for it!" ... cheeky cow.

However I fed the next 2 babes till they were 12 months with no hint of a problem. So do give it a go ... I found it so much more convenient ... and pleasurable.

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 07:57

It seems the ability to breastfeed and the ability to read aren’t synonymous.

OP posts:
Zanatdy · 09/06/2023 07:57

Not really, I managed to BF one of my children (of 3). He couldn’t latch at first but I expressed but I expressed and tried him on the breast a month later and he latched and I fed him for 8 months

ElephantGrey101 · 09/06/2023 07:57

If your first baby had a tongue tie then it was nothing that you had done wrong to mean he couldn’t feed. If this baby doesn’t have a tounge tie then you will have a much easier time.

One of the mums in my birth group did not manage to feed her first baby but her second is feeding really well. Support during lockdown was rubbish but is better now.

My best friend struggled for months with her first baby and she decided to formula feed her second baby from the start. It was the right choice for her as she was much less stressed. The mum who was before me when I had my caesarean brought the little pre made bottles of formula with her to hospital as she knew she didn’t want to try again with breastfeeding. You have to do what is right for you.

MrsMikeDrop · 09/06/2023 07:55

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 07:22

I think this is what I mean, I’m reluctant to set myself up to fail by watching videos and so on. Either it works, great, or it doesn’t, so I just accept I can’t and move on.

Well that's where you're going wrong, it's an actual skill that both you and the baby need to learn. You wouldn't just get into a car and expect to know how to drive. Some might manage it out. Most will need lessons, some might even need driving gloves, a pillow on the seat or to change the steering wheel

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 07:53

That six week thing is very upsetting actually. It is clear that some people think I was breastfeeding during that time but found it painful, or tiring. I genuinely don’t know how else I can explain I couldn’t breastfeed! He just wasn’t latching on at all. Likewise, I didn’t exactly ‘give up’ with breastfeeding. I mean yeah, there comes a point where you stop trying but …

I think this has made me realise it is actually still upsetting and in many ways easier to assume formula from the get go.

OP posts:
birdglasspen · 09/06/2023 07:52

Every baby is different my first was difficult but we got there after 6 weeks, the 2nd we had no bonding time as he went to icu straight to being fed through nose….but when given the chance latched on and fed like a pro and was great no issues. Third child was horrendous and it took 3 months before things settled down and were easy. So although some experience on mothers part can be useful you will ever get the same baby to feed and it’s certainly worth trying!

Beseen22 · 09/06/2023 07:51

My first crawled to the breast after birth and fed exactly like he was supposed to. We had a few issues (mostly him never wanting to be off me) but fed completely on demand for 18m. I was entirely convinced I was a pro breastfeeder and it was down to all the prep work I'd done and the positive attitude I had to it.

I did the exact same process with DS2 and he never latched. I tried every single position, buzzedthe midwives, got support from an IBCLC etc etc etc. I knew my nipples were a functional shape and I was expressing and had gallons of milk. He was assessed for tongue tie multiple times most said he didn't have it one eventually did at 6 weeks but said it had stretched and wouldn't have prevented him for latching.

So to me sometimes it just doesn't work out with some babies. He's 3 now and incredibly strong willed so I'm convinced it was a conscious decision on his part! Just because baby no 1 never latched isn't a guarantee baby no 2 won't but I don't think its the worst idea to have a few bits set up at home.

mondaytosunday · 09/06/2023 07:48

My first son struggled and we really didn't get the hang of it for a couple weeks. My daughter was in NICU for three days so I couldn't even try at first, but once out she latched on snd did not let go!
Kids are different. Give it a go but don't put yourself down if it doesn't work out.

Purplepeaches123 · 09/06/2023 07:45

OllyBJolly · 09/06/2023 07:38

Despite being bottle fed in NICU for a few days, DC1 had no problem at all breast feeding - it just came naturally to both of us. I really enjoyed it - so easy, nothing to prepare, so easy to travel. Great excuse to sit on the sofa and watch telly!

DC2 didn't read the manual. Firstly, it was really painful. I'd managed labour with no drugs but had to take paracetamol to cope with the pain of BF. 10lb baby but didn't feed very often so I was engorged most of the time (that wasn't supposed to happen "your body will only produce what the baby needs"!) If I hadn't had such a positive experience first time, I would have given up. It is worth persevering though as it's so much less faff.

As PPs say, they're all different.

I always say the same if I’d had my 2nd baby first I would have given up with breast feeding, it was an awful start with baby number 2, but knowing how convenient it was I really didn’t want to give up!

NineOfNine · 09/06/2023 07:43

It may be easier with this baby, every baby is different.

We never managed to establish breastfeeding with DC1. He just wouldn’t latch on at all. I ended up expressing breastmilk for him to drink in bottles until we started weaning.

Completely different story with DC2 & DC3. We had some initial problems because they were jaundiced, but once the jaundice cleared up they both took to breastfeeding like ducks to water. Both of them were breastfed for over 2 years.
The difference in breastfeeding experiences wasn’t down to anything I did. Just different babies.

And that 6 weeks thing people are talking about upthread! The first 6 weeks breastfeeding either DC2 or DC3 was infinitely easier than any of the trying to breastfeed DC1 - because DC2 and DC3 were both actively latching and trying to feed, and DC1 just wouldn’t latch or do more than one or two half hearted sucks!

Oldnproud · 09/06/2023 07:41

My first wouldn't or couldn't breastfeed properly. It probably didn't help that he had been given a bottle by the midwife before bring brought to me after the birth, so had already learned the 'wrong' technique!
(This was in the early 1980s, and he was born in an outdated maternity hospital where the midwives ruled, and all the new mums stayed in hospital for at least a week.)
Anyway, after a few days of struggling to breastfeed him, the midwives said his weight was dropping too much and I should exclusively bottle feed him, so that was that.

Two years later, my second child was born in another hospital and I breastfed him as soon as he was born and he took to it like a duck to water. Latched on perfectly, and continued without a single hitch. It was a lovely experience.

In other words, OP, it is well worth trying again with your new baby. Good luck 🤞

lilsupersparks · 09/06/2023 07:41

Each baby is different - even my twins were different. My daughter was a very lazy feeder who would only feed with her brother as she couldn’t figure out how to get a ‘let down’ - she would have struggled on her own.

He had twice the feeds she did and still eats twice as much aged 8!

RonObvious · 09/06/2023 07:41

Gah - I hate to be that "did you try" guy, but did you try nipple shields? I wouldn't have been able to breast feed without them - even the lactation experts at the hospital couldn't get my daughter to latch on. Have had friends with the same experience. Not all brands worked though - I remember one was too soft and kept falling off. The Avent brand worked well for me.

Purplepeaches123 · 09/06/2023 07:40

I wouldn’t rule it out no. With my first baby, he latched immediately and BF was a breeze. I fed him with absolutely no problems at all for well over a year. I assumed it would be the same with my 2nd but after having a CS my milk didn’t come in for days and the constant, and I mean constant, suckling made me really sore. Her latch was all wrong and it took a few weeks to get right with her. It was weeks of nipple shields and tears from me until it all settled down, coupled with everyone telling me to give her a bottle etc. once sorted though it was plain sailing from there on. Baby number 3 was not interested at all in feeding. I had to constantly wake him for feeds and When he did latch on it felt weird because I’d only stopped breastfeeding my daughter about a month before he was born. He wasn’t like my other two who were permanently attached to me, I always felt like he wasn’t getting enough and it was a real learning curve despite being my 3rd baby. My point is every experience is different so get as much advice and support as you can. Best of luck to you .

FeeFiFoFumble · 09/06/2023 07:40

My first breastfed without any issues. My second couldn't really get the hang of it until he was 4 months (!) old. It was nothing to do with me and all to do with him - high palate, tongue tie, weak suction etc. It's entirely possible it was similar for your first child. So if you ask me, YAB a bit U to assume it definitely won't work but at the same time, do whatever feels right to you! If assuming it won't work puts you in a better frame of mind for dealing with it then go for it.

Either way, enjoy your new little bundle of joy once they've made an appearance ❤️

Blessedbethefruitz · 09/06/2023 07:39

My first couldn't latch either. Before my second I watched videos and read loads, but I needn't have bothered. She went for it immediately after birth and knew exactly what to do, despite having a tongue tie (chopped at 4 days). If you really want to breastfeed, do some heavy research, maybe have a lactation consultant number at hand. If you're not that bothered then stock up on bottles :)

Imnoonesfool · 09/06/2023 07:39

I had a terrible first few weeks with my first born trying to breast feed. Tbh I’d had a very traumatic labour and delivery. Baby had head injury from forceps so was in pain, I had lots of stitches so was in pain, big baby too so hungry . I just look back on those first few weeks and it was completely miserable because I couldn’t feed, he was constantly crying, I got mastitis. But I wouldn’t give up until in the end in the middle of the night whilst I was crying, baby was screaming as was clearly hungry, after attempting to pump and just blood came out, my husband drove to 24hr shop and bought some formula and made the decision that I was pressurising myself not to make.

second baby I made it very clear from the off that I was going to do first feed following delivery then she was going to be formular fed. I told all midwives. When she was born she latched straight on and fed for an hour, the midwives tried to persuade me to carry on but I had made my decision and it was like a weight had been lifted, those first few weeks were gorgeous for me. Would the breast feeding have worked ? Maybe but I don’t regret it.

so I think you have to do what is right for you and do not feel you are letting anyone down. If I could go back I wouldn’t have tried so long with my first if at all xxxx

Swipe left for the next trending thread