Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To work on the assumption I won’t be able to breastfeed?

168 replies

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 06:35

When I had my first baby I wanted to breastfeed so followed all the advice and I just couldn’t latch him on. I’m due in 2 weeks: AIBU to just assume it’s probably going to be the same and just buy all the bottle feeding equipment? I’ll give it a go but I’m not really expecting it to work.

OP posts:
SerafinasGoose · 09/06/2023 11:46

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 09/06/2023 11:43

OP, I honestly think that midwives and other mums should stop harassing new mums to breast feed. I honestly couldnt care less about being told to breast feed, why the extra stress if you dont want to. I was an older mum so couldnt give a f**k what midwives told me I should do about feeding.

The problem is they tell you one thing all the way though pregnancy, and the advice radically changes as soon as the baby arrives.

Constantly beating the drum about what others should be doing isn't going to cut it. It just gets people's backs up; no one likes to be told what to do. Alternatively, some consistency and proper education as to potential barriers and pitfalls would be strongly advisable, because the West - the UK in particular - has obvious issues with low BF rates.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 09/06/2023 11:43

OP, I honestly think that midwives and other mums should stop harassing new mums to breast feed. I honestly couldnt care less about being told to breast feed, why the extra stress if you dont want to. I was an older mum so couldnt give a f**k what midwives told me I should do about feeding.

bowzen · 09/06/2023 10:45

dizzydizzydizzy · 09/06/2023 08:29

It's a learned skill. Just like learning to drive. Maybe have a chat with the NCT - they are experts in baby feeding and have lots of local support plus a National helpline. Look at this page:

www.nct.org.uk/local-activities-meet-ups/feeding-support

Not really.... First baby breast fed fine, 2nd one doesn't! Despite previously breastfeeding. It really depends on the baby's temperament, not just a learnt skill... I've been to several breast feeding clinics and classes for professional advice

AuntieJune · 09/06/2023 10:33

First baby: distressing months of struggling to feed, combo feeding, pumping and doing top up formula, tongue tie cut, etc etc

Second baby: came out, latched on, zero stress

Just have an open mind and see what happens. They have different mouths!

You could always plan to combo feed and see how it goes

CecilyP · 09/06/2023 10:22

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 08:06

So. One more time before I leave the thread to sink into the dregs of MN and go and Iine the profits of Cow and Gate.

I could not breastfeed. I tried, but I could not latch my baby on.

It did not hurt, because I could not do it.

It was not hard to get through the first six weeks, because I could not do it.

I didn’t find it inconvenient, because I could not do it.

I went to see a lactation consultant (£200) bought a very expensive breast pump (£300) shared my post birth boobs and body with far too many FB groups, tried nipple shields, had midwives coming out.

It didn’t work. I couldn’t get the baby to latch on. I think about seven seconds was the longest we managed.

Of course, no one believes you and thinks you just didn’t try hard enough and on top of that, I get called rude 😂

It might be worth trying but I don’t know … I’m not feeling great about it all, to be honest.

I know what you mean OP. I spent 5 days on a large busy post-natal ward and noticed that while some babies took to breastfeeding straight away, others were particularly clueless. It had nothing to do with the determination of the mother - the babies had definitely not watched the videos! Your first was definitely one of those; your second might be completely different and know exactly what to do.

I would definitely go into it with an open mind. If you want to try breastfeeding, give it a go. You might be pleasantly surprised. Also, no harm in buying bottle feeding equipment to be prepared for both eventualities. If you don't use it you can just sell/donate to someone who will.

SerafinasGoose · 09/06/2023 10:22

SaveMyUsername2 · 09/06/2023 10:14

The OP literally said her baby didn’t latch ever. No cluster feeding, no sticking with it . Did not latch.

Yes, I'm aware.

The specific question asked in the OP was whether she could assume the same thing would happen with baby #2. The inability to latch might well not be an issue again, but these are experiences as to what else most commonly sabotages BF.

SaveMyUsername2 · 09/06/2023 10:14

SerafinasGoose · 09/06/2023 09:46

The help is there but you have to be assertive, to ask for it, and to keep asking.

I was fortunate: I had a local support group run entirely by volunteers (not NCT) who kept me sane when lack of sleep was making me completely crazy.

My own experience (I BF for 18 months) was: no one can possibly warn you how hard this is over the first 12 weeks. To me it was a case of gritting my teeth and getting through the gruelling, exhausting phase. After this it was a breeze, especially when out and on the go: much easier than carting bottles everywhere and heating them.

To my mind this is the number 1 reason why breastfeeding so often fails is simply that new mums are not sufficiently warned about cluster feeding! Those phases where the baby seems latched onto you almost constantly makes us assume the baby is always hungry and this must mean we're not producing enough milk. So we top up with formula and then supply ends up sabotaged and we really don't produce enough milk.

New mums need to be warned this is a normal and necessary phase, that it's designed precisely to stimulate milk production, that it will quickly pass and has nothing to do with under-production.

I got alarmed whenever this sort of thing happened, or in the early stages where I wasn't sure DS was feeding enough. It wasn't helped by being practically on my knees with exhaustion from day and night feeding.

As long as they're gaining weight, all is fine. If DS had been losing weight that would have been a different thing entirely, and I'd have made a different feeding decision. Be guided by your baby, your body, and your HV. You can only make these decisions on the basis of the circumstances surrounding you. Yes, UK BF rates are low and we do need to explore the reasons for that. But IMO there's altogether too much angst - not to mention defensive attitudes - surrounding it.

The OP literally said her baby didn’t latch ever. No cluster feeding, no sticking with it . Did not latch.

Twiglets1 · 09/06/2023 10:11

dizzydizzydizzy · 09/06/2023 08:29

It's a learned skill. Just like learning to drive. Maybe have a chat with the NCT - they are experts in baby feeding and have lots of local support plus a National helpline. Look at this page:

www.nct.org.uk/local-activities-meet-ups/feeding-support

Rubbish.
People like you give NCT a bad name. Not listening just pushing a breastfeeding agenda.
I did breastfeed mine and it was nothing like learning to drive! It was very easy for me but I was lucky and can still show some empathy for people who want to but can’t breastfeed.

YouveGotAFastCar · 09/06/2023 10:01

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 07:22

I think this is what I mean, I’m reluctant to set myself up to fail by watching videos and so on. Either it works, great, or it doesn’t, so I just accept I can’t and move on.

That’s fine if it’s how you want to do it; but remember baby hasn’t done it before and there is a learning curve.

Ironically loads of people ask me for breastfeeding advice now, and tell people I found it really easy. I struggled for the first 10 weeks, it was hard. I’m glad I pushed through and we’re still feeding at 18 months, although not nearly as much, but it didn’t come naturally to me or DS.

I think you might be setting yourself up to fail by expecting baby to just know what to do; if I’m honest. It’s absolutely okay not to try this time, if you don’t want to or your head isn’t in the right place.

CurlewKate · 09/06/2023 09:55

@SerafinasGoose "Help and support, and to learn from other women's experiences."

She has specifically said that she doesn't want this. That's why I asked what she did want. To see if there is anything helpful I could offer.

Lottle · 09/06/2023 09:52

@Woodentoyshurt I'm confused what you wanted folk to say? Are you right to assume you won't be able to breastfeed this time round? YABU

SerafinasGoose · 09/06/2023 09:49

CurlewKate · 09/06/2023 09:29

@Woodentoyshurt "It’s not fine to say ‘well you clearly did not put in the effort so why are you even asking’"

Of course it's not fine to say that. I'm sorry if that's how my post sounded to you. But it seems that you want something from this thread and I don't know what it is. What is it?

Help and support, and to learn from other women's experiences.

BF is not so impossible as many people make it sound. Were this the case the human race would have struggled to survive in the strength and numbers it has.

For sure, it isn't always the right decision for every mother and every baby, but UK rates are unusually low by global comparison. There will be a reason for that.
Thinking 'I can't' before you even start won't be helping, though. Hence the (very sensible) reason for this thread.

CurlewKate · 09/06/2023 09:48

@Woodentoyshurt Fair enough. A lot of people struggle the first time and not the second. Is that all you want? Good. Glad you got what you need.

SerafinasGoose · 09/06/2023 09:46

The help is there but you have to be assertive, to ask for it, and to keep asking.

I was fortunate: I had a local support group run entirely by volunteers (not NCT) who kept me sane when lack of sleep was making me completely crazy.

My own experience (I BF for 18 months) was: no one can possibly warn you how hard this is over the first 12 weeks. To me it was a case of gritting my teeth and getting through the gruelling, exhausting phase. After this it was a breeze, especially when out and on the go: much easier than carting bottles everywhere and heating them.

To my mind this is the number 1 reason why breastfeeding so often fails is simply that new mums are not sufficiently warned about cluster feeding! Those phases where the baby seems latched onto you almost constantly makes us assume the baby is always hungry and this must mean we're not producing enough milk. So we top up with formula and then supply ends up sabotaged and we really don't produce enough milk.

New mums need to be warned this is a normal and necessary phase, that it's designed precisely to stimulate milk production, that it will quickly pass and has nothing to do with under-production.

I got alarmed whenever this sort of thing happened, or in the early stages where I wasn't sure DS was feeding enough. It wasn't helped by being practically on my knees with exhaustion from day and night feeding.

As long as they're gaining weight, all is fine. If DS had been losing weight that would have been a different thing entirely, and I'd have made a different feeding decision. Be guided by your baby, your body, and your HV. You can only make these decisions on the basis of the circumstances surrounding you. Yes, UK BF rates are low and we do need to explore the reasons for that. But IMO there's altogether too much angst - not to mention defensive attitudes - surrounding it.

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 09:32

Jeez, I’m sorry for sounding irritable but I’ve literally just told you 😂

Quite a lot of people have confirmed that while they struggled with their first they didn’t with their second. That’s really good to hear and really encouraging. Is that OK? Sure?

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 09/06/2023 09:31

I think the ideal thing would be to give it a go, and keep and open mind, but be prepared (both mentally and in terms of having formula and kit) in case you can’t.

But you never know. It might have been specific to your DC1.

Equally, if it feels like to big a hurdle mentally, don’t worry about just going to formula

CurlewKate · 09/06/2023 09:29

@Woodentoyshurt "It’s not fine to say ‘well you clearly did not put in the effort so why are you even asking’"

Of course it's not fine to say that. I'm sorry if that's how my post sounded to you. But it seems that you want something from this thread and I don't know what it is. What is it?

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 09:25

@CurlewKate seriously? It’s fine to say ‘it didn’t work for me first time but was so easy second.’ It’s not fine to say ‘well you clearly did not put in the effort so why are you even asking’

OP posts:
DappledThings · 09/06/2023 09:18

I don't understand why people are giving you a hard time for deciding not to breast feed after what sounds like hell on earth last time. Add in a toddler and I can well understand why you'd not want to do it again.
I don't think anyone is. OP asked if she was unreasonable to assume her second baby will have the same issues as her first. That's why the vote is as it is. Hardly anyone thinks it's unreasonable not to try and bf if she doesn't want to but it is unreasonable to assume it will be just as difficult.

stargirl1701 · 09/06/2023 09:15

I to EBF managed 10 very painful days with DD1 ending in sepsis and resus for me.

DD2 just seemed to 'know' what to do. She was EBF for 6 months and weaned at natural term aged 5 and half years.

Wildly different!

CurlewKate · 09/06/2023 09:05

@Woodentoyshurt What do you want from this thread? Like many posters, I'm here to say it's absolutely fine and perfectly reasonable to decide to ff from birth. But it's not reasonable to assume that bf won't work this time because it didn't last time. There is no judgement at all in those statements. Just fact. But you seem to want more/different. What do you want?

CoachBeardsJane · 09/06/2023 09:04

Woodentoyshurt · 09/06/2023 08:10

The comments on here are very upsetting @Twizbe . I don’t want to go to a breastfeeding group, thanks, it would be more upsetting in person. The message I’m getting is that I just didn’t try hard enough, and I’m genuinely not sure what else I could have done. I’m not willing to put in that level of effort this time, apart from anything else I can’t just ignore my first child’s needs while I try to breastfeed the second.

I don't understand why people are giving you a hard time for deciding not to breast feed after what sounds like hell on earth last time. Add in a toddler and I can well understand why you'd not want to do it again.

Just prepare for it to not work, get all the stuff you think you'll need, give it a go after birth and if they don't latch then just syringe the colostrum into baby's mouth and then crack on with formula feeding.

A happy mum = a happy baby. Just try it though, it might work, but fed is best and no midwife is going to judge you, and if they do they're clearly in the wrong job.

Signed a midwife.

Ag52q · 09/06/2023 09:00

I voted YABU because I think you shouldn't assume it'll be the same. This baby is a different baby. First baby wasn't latching, it wasn't anything you've done or not done, it wasn't because you haven't tried hard enough. Don't blame yourself, let go of the guilt if you still have it (I know it can linger and make you feel rubbish).

I had an awful experience the first time around, baby lost lots of weight etc and definitely not for lack of trying on my part. He was too sleepy, didn't want to latch, didn't want to feed. I've listened to all the advice and I cried so much those first weeks. I still feel quite upset when I think about it, the feeling of failing to do something that should come naturally is awful.

Second baby though, I set myself to try with no pressure, I tried and he did latch and fed consistently. He was back to birth weight on day 5! I was so shocked and pleased. I won't lie, I still worried about things changing and going wrong again, but it was a completely different experience. I didn't do anything different. My body is the same, second baby was just a different baby.
I know you don't want to hear any more advice and I understand it, it gets tedious hearing "have you tried this and that" after you've tried everything but nothing worked.

Just try it with an open mind and don't blame yourself whatever the results. I feel like you'll have time to buy bottle feeding equipment after baby arrives, but also you could get some and keep it sealed and return it if you don't use it! Best of luck.

TooJoy · 09/06/2023 08:54

You’re saying that you could not BF because your baby couldn’t latch which sounds like there wasn’t an issue with you and your nipples, but that you just had a tricky baby.

There’s nothing to say that your second baby won’t be much easier and be able to latch.

There is no pressure though.
If you want to try and BF then try.
If you don’t want to BF then don’t.

SaveMyUsername2 · 09/06/2023 08:52

NineOfNine · 09/06/2023 08:39

I get that.

When breastfeeding, there’s a massive difference between dealing with a newborn baby who just won’t, for whatever reason, and dealing with a newborn baby who’s demanding to be breastfed every few hours, or who’s not latching quite right when they’re actively feeding, or who’ll only breastfeed when held in a certain position.

The second sort of baby can make the first 6 weeks tough, but it’s still possible to get through that.

The first sort of baby - well, what are you meant to do when a baby just won’t breastfeed, no matter what you try? In the end, we came down to a choice between bottle feeding DC1 and watching him starve (We went for bottle feeding, obviously).
And it is upsetting when you’ve had a breastfeeding experience like that, and then other people just assume that you weren’t trying hard enough.

Yep. Trust me no amount of porridge was going to up my supply and there’s only so much head tilting I could bear x