Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To those of you who had children with an abusive partner...

30 replies

MAREMCKENNA · 08/06/2023 22:23

Did you ever tell them their dad was abusive? I'm specifically not aiming this at those whose children witnessed abuse, but more so towards those who have a similar situation to me. Left partner, partner no contact with both parties for years, fought for contact, had to do a domestic abuse programme, got contact back just like that, and now I'm wondering about the future and if it would ever be a good idea to tell my son the truth (when he's an older teen or adult) about his dad. Or is it just too damaging? Feeling a bit confused and worrying about the future which is a long way off, but doesn't stop me wandering what the best thing to do would be. Would you want to know? I know not many will have exactly the same scenario, but possibly similar and will be able to impart some wisdom of what they did when their kids were older...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheTellTaleHeart · 09/06/2023 19:29

@knittingaddict Yes, I can totally appreciate it’s different again, and even more difficult when there is an element of unsupervised contact. This will probably be my situation too eventually, and I’m not looking forward to it. I know it will be alot harder when the kids aren’t getting one, consistent narrative. I have been fortunate, if anyone in this position can be described as such. I went the long and official route, through fact findings and section 7 etc, which has given me a substantial paper trail from various organisations, a proportion of which is actually written for and addressed to the children, which I can fall back on if the children need a “third opinion” when they are older and ready for it.
@Babsexxx your entitled to your view, but I would say that unfortunately abuse tends to echo down the generations. If a parent is not clear about what love and a healthy relationship does and does not look like with their children, while they are young and forming their view of the world, they run the risk that their children will be next.

WheelsUp · 09/06/2023 11:00

I would tell him when he starts asking.
It's important for him to know that abuse should always mean the end of a relationship (although he's little now, he will probably date one day) and that there's no chance of reconciliation like in films.
If he finds out as a teen or adult then he will be angry at you for lying/withholding info rather than being angry at his dad. By the time he's say 10 he should have some sort of idea that you're not together because he hurt you. He might not be ready for more than that until older but children are better at accepting that kind of info than older children and growing up with the knowledge is kinder imo.

Sapphire387 · 09/06/2023 10:47

I don't believe in lying to children or shielding abusers. It does not 'protect' children to pretend that everything is fine with their other parent.

I have a somewhat different example. A few months after I first met my stepdaughter, when she was 6, she came up to me and said 'I know my mum was sick, but nobody says what was wrong, I think the doctors gave her too much food and drink and then she died'. Seriously, she sounded so sad, and so grown up. But what an awful misconception.

I said to her no, she did have too many drinks, she drank a lot of wine and it made her very sick, and then I went and got (now) DH and said she needs more of an explanation. He and his family had tried to cope by shielding her from the truth, and it was causing more pain. I was privileged that she came and spoke to me.

I am a firm believer that children need to know the truth in an age-appropriate way. Otherwise they are likely to 'fill in the gaps' themselves.

Weddingpuzzle · 09/06/2023 10:36

I really disagree with the poster above guilting people who have already been through the horror of domestic abuse for telling the truth. DC get confused about why they are split between two households if you are evasive and try to sweep things under the carpet when they ask the reason why their parents split up. DC are not stupid, they can tell when their questions aren't answered truthfully and what message are you giving them by lying to them? That you don't respect them enough to tell them the truth? If they can't trust you, their Mum, who the hell can they trust? Why should we be complicit in the continuing cycle of domestic abuse by keeping it quiet?

I told DS because I felt like exH was continuing to abuse me by manipulating the DC into thinking I left him because I was annoyed he wouldn't let me spend money. Why would I be complicit in allowing my son to be part of that? If we don't teach our sons and daughters how wrong this is by being honest about the impact it has on families how will we ever break this grip it has on us? Women are murdered every week by partners and expartners. I was nearly killed myself. Keeping quiet and pretending it isn't happening benefits nobody. Views like above, placing the emphasis on women keeping quiet, are dangerous.

Hadenough62 · 09/06/2023 09:57

@MAREMCKENNA

I left my abusive ex when my DC were 8 months old and 2.6 years old. When my eldest was around 6 she started asking about her dad, I didnt have a clue what to say or do. So I spoke to the school about it and they said the best thing to do was to tell them the truth in a child friendly manner. Not to lie and accidently put him on a pedestal

My ex was found guilty of assaulting me and given a 2 year restraining order. Alongside that they put on the order that he wasnt allowed to contact or communicate with any child of the family unless authorised by social services, family court, the local authority and or a solicitor.

So my kids know that their dad isnt allowed to see them ( I told them the police said so rather than explain about court ect ) because he isnt a nice man and he hurt me and hurts other people.

I'll forever be grateful to the judges that day for helping me keep my babies safe. I know several women who have been in the same situation as me and I'm the only one whose ex was told he wasnt allowed to see the kids, everyone else I know has to take their kids to contact centres to see their abusive fathers. I'm very very lucky in that sense. But then again, I went through a lot to get that "luck"

knittingaddict · 09/06/2023 08:13

TheTellTaleHeart · 09/06/2023 01:33

Definitely tell the truth, in an age appropriate way. I was hesitant, like you. Primarily, because I didn’t want to upset the kids and make them feel that their Dad, and by extension, they, were bad. I didn’t want them to feel bad for loving him, or feel like they shouldn’t love him. I was also concerned about being accused of parental alienation. My CAFCASS officer actually advised me to be more upfront, so this advice comes from “the horses mouth” so to speak. She even wrote a letter to the kids that was quite clear, in an appropriate way, why Daddy wasn’t allowed to see them at the minute. She told me they won’t understand why their Dad can’t have contact if I keep leaving out the part about why his behaviour was not ok. She was right. I’ve handled it much more honestly, but in a sensitive and balanced way since, and the kids accept and understand the situation much better now.

That's fine if they aren't seeing their dad. Much more problematic when they have to see him unsupervised every other weekend and half the holidays.

It's a highwire act - wanting to protect and validate them, but not wanting them to be worried about seeing him.

I would certainly talk to them in an age appropriate way as time goes by and issues crop up. I would hate for them to think that their inevitable concerns about him aren't valid.

I wrote a more personal post, but he's a stalker, so deleted it. Being paranoid is part of the package now.

MaxwellCat · 09/06/2023 07:55

no I haven’t told my children and I’m surprised so many have.

WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 09/06/2023 07:44

I did not tell my children in an age appropriate way
Aspects came out in anger, upset and frankly fear because I had never really dealt with what happened myself which was not good for the kids.
I stupidly expected my children to speak up where I couldn't, and all that happened was they did what I did, minimised, hid details and acted like things were ok after weekends at his.
It became clear there were issues, my daughter stopped seeing him.
Son continued to see him up until 14, then reconnected at 18.

Daughter got counselling and is a much more resilient person.
Son did not, he's angry with the word, has a dislike of women and sadly replicating behaviours of his Dad. Not the violence but the blame attitude, assumption he's owed something and determination to cheat the system - I do believe unless he gets a handle on that it will boil over into violence so now it's exceptionally hard trying to parent and educate an angry young adult who no longer lives at home and I've left it far too late.

Their Dad, through mental illnesses got to the stage he couldn't care for himself. He's now physically disabled (lost a leg and use of his hands) and suffered a series of strokes which means he's learning to speak again. It also means as I've spent far too long minimising anything I say now is seen by my son as an attack on someone who is severely disabled, not on the person he once was.

I really feel if I'd handled it all better, been more open in an age appropriate, neutral non emotional way they would have the skills to understand what was happening for me to help sooner.
They would better understand right from wrong
Above all, they'd know the behaviour is 100% their Dad and not because they did something wrong.
If you can talk to them. If you can't, have someone else talk to them and focus on getting yourself help so you can talk about it. Do not hide it.

Babsexxx · 09/06/2023 07:44

She could I suppose but like I said men like him don’t change they are already picking up on a few of his undesirable traits, he’s not abusive to them but they have seen him very short tempered driving road rage etc they’re 13 and 11 now.

Its strange because my 16yo has not a lot to do with him but the 13yo and 11yo don’t yet question her as to why…but I wouldn’t exactly take it upon myself to have a big sit down conversation and explain it to them as I don’t think it does anyone any good.

Goldrushed · 09/06/2023 07:26

I'm sorry about your family experience and your sister's difficulties. A child knowing what happened in their family isn't what damages them if it's done in a way that's ok for their age and stage.

But we do know that children who have lived in abusive households can have difficulties as they get older and there's lots of adults still bearing the emotional damage of early childhood experiences.
You don't shield them from that by not telling them things that can help them make sense of their story.

Please be assured that what I have said comes from professional training and experience and I'm not plucking this stuff out of thin air.
Nor are others on this thread with their own personal or professional experience including the one who talked about the CAFCASS officer writing to the child.

I'm sorry that you disagree but respectfully, you are wrong.

Velvian · 09/06/2023 07:24

I didn't share anything with my Ds1 until he was in his early 20s.

I spent so many years not saying anything negative about his dad and my family never saying anything negative about his dad. I even allowed myself to be the villain of the breakup.

It was actually when my DD (not ExH's child) started asking questions, aged about 9, that I realised I needed to tell DS. His dad's behaviour included an offence against one of my family members, which others outside of the family knew about. It was not sustainable to never say anything negative.

I don't know when I should have told him more. It is tricky. I was a teenage mum that spent years in an abusive relationship, I was very naive in lots of ways. The abuser stays in your head for years, the control extends long after the relationship ends.

Also nothing was ever reported to police, the family member didn't report either. So it really is just my word. DS says things make a lot more sense with the ExH's relationship with his SM and his reaction to DS wanting to have a conversation about his past actions.

MAREMCKENNA · 09/06/2023 07:21

Babsexxx · 09/06/2023 06:39

No don’t bother my eldest kids Dad was horrendous my 16yo remembers but the younger two don’t, I wouldn’t dream of sitting them down and saying a thing! Not only that now there all older they are getting a really good idea of his personality people like that don’t change!

But I think to sit them down to tell them is very unreasonable imagine how awkward it would be for a start? And it comes across like you really want them to know for you! Think of the kids! Outrageous.

Surely your 16 year old will tell them at some point?

OP posts:
Babsexxx · 09/06/2023 07:09

I don’t even think that’s appropriate in context to a 5yo, I wouldn’t even suggest “Daddy hurt Mummy” I’d say “Sorry but mummy and daddy aren’t really friends anymore but that’s ok we both still love you!”.

Not accurate at all to insinuate that it’s lying and it’s idamaging and tbh it’s not lying it’s not like OP has stated that when her children come to her and ask, she’s asking if she should let them know in future, so there’s that.

My mum told my Brother and Sister about there Dad and very politely so but my sister really struggles even as a late 20’s to woman even if she raises her voice at someone and questions her temperament when she’s done absolutely nothing wrong in said situations, it’s left her as a very vunerable adult who is a people pleaser to the point of it being unhealthy.

Goldrushed · 09/06/2023 07:01

@Babsexxx there's a lot of people sharing exactly why it's important that children know about things like this in a sensitive and age appropriate way.
It happened to them too.

Many of them will have witnessed or experienced the abuse too even if they don't clearly remember that.

Children and adults who don't understand their past, what happened in their families and why the situation is as it is can be really impacted by the gaps and the lack of information.

We think we're being kinder to them by concealing the harsh realities but actually we are harming them. Having an open, honest dialogue with our kids takes away the shame and the fear.

So you wouldn't tell a 5 year old that daddy strangled mummy and threw her down the stairs but you might tell them that
'daddy hurt mummy when he got angry and we want to make sure you feel safe which is why you go and see daddy at the family centre'.

Babsexxx · 09/06/2023 06:50

Think of the kids is exactly what I mean I haven’t minced my words, no matter how politely put can damage them as they see a sense of confusion and wonder if it’s there fault! Questions of weather or not that’s what they’ll become in life? so yes I think it’s outrageous to put any child/young adult through any of it.

Speaking from someone with experience from this, and how would it exactly benefit the kids them knowing? It wouldn’t.

SeulementUneFois · 09/06/2023 06:44

@Babsexxx I don't understand - what do you mean by "think of the kids"?
Also what/ why do you think that it's outrageous?

Babsexxx · 09/06/2023 06:39

No don’t bother my eldest kids Dad was horrendous my 16yo remembers but the younger two don’t, I wouldn’t dream of sitting them down and saying a thing! Not only that now there all older they are getting a really good idea of his personality people like that don’t change!

But I think to sit them down to tell them is very unreasonable imagine how awkward it would be for a start? And it comes across like you really want them to know for you! Think of the kids! Outrageous.

TheTellTaleHeart · 09/06/2023 01:33

Definitely tell the truth, in an age appropriate way. I was hesitant, like you. Primarily, because I didn’t want to upset the kids and make them feel that their Dad, and by extension, they, were bad. I didn’t want them to feel bad for loving him, or feel like they shouldn’t love him. I was also concerned about being accused of parental alienation. My CAFCASS officer actually advised me to be more upfront, so this advice comes from “the horses mouth” so to speak. She even wrote a letter to the kids that was quite clear, in an appropriate way, why Daddy wasn’t allowed to see them at the minute. She told me they won’t understand why their Dad can’t have contact if I keep leaving out the part about why his behaviour was not ok. She was right. I’ve handled it much more honestly, but in a sensitive and balanced way since, and the kids accept and understand the situation much better now.

ASimpleLampoon · 09/06/2023 00:23

I know its frowned upon to "bad mouth" an abusive ex but really who does that benefit?

I think it's better to tell the truth. In a matter of fact way , and age appropriate. I also think when they are old enough they should have all the facts however unpleasant so that any choice they make regarding continuing or pursuing A relationship is as informed as possible.

Sarahtm35 · 08/06/2023 23:22

My father was abusive but my mother has never once named him as that. And because of this I’ve always felt she downplayed his actions and growing up it took me a long time to find out the difference between right and wrong.
so for this reason I would encourage you to tell your son the truth. Even if he’s too young to remember, you don’t want him finding out second hand.

Weddingpuzzle · 08/06/2023 23:20

When he was 12, I told my DS his Dad bit and punched me and that was why we split up. He was gutted & had no idea, we split up when he was 6 and his sister was 3 and I protected them from the truth. He was asking why I left his Dad because of money and basically had got the wrong end of the stick (fed by exH) and I just blurted out the truth.

I felt so sick of not advocating for myself and I wanted him to understand the impact of male on female violence. We have spoken about it since in a much less charged way but I am not sure the damage it has done. He seems okay and still sees his Dad. I don't say anything negative about his Dad to him.

LifeIsPainHighness · 08/06/2023 22:53

MAREMCKENNA · 08/06/2023 22:46

He is already on the scene, with supervised contact.

Oh apologies!

But the resource from a PP is great, don’t cover for your ex. My parents split when I was a baby and my mum didn’t tell me her was violent on their marriage. I wish she had as I found out myself she 13 when he got loaded and beat his girlfriend black and blue in front of me. It was absolutely terrifying and had I known he was like that I’d have stopped overnight visits sooner, I was old enough and wise enough to know it made him a danger to me.

Good luck OP!

grunttheterrible · 08/06/2023 22:51

Age appropriate. DD is 11 and has maybe asked me to forgive daddy since 8 (he's has unsupervised contact for a while) You start with no, daddy wasn't nice to mummy, but I've heard he's nice to (gf's name!) and then recently she's asked specific questions like "did daddy hurt you" and I answer factually without emotion

MAREMCKENNA · 08/06/2023 22:46

LifeIsPainHighness · 08/06/2023 22:43

No experience but I’d find an age appropriate way to tell him - otherwise you run the risk of them having a rose tinted view of the absent father and if he ever came back on the scene it’s only fair to give your son a full picture. I’m sure the NSPCC has resources about how to deal with this situation

He is already on the scene, with supervised contact.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread