Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To limit the number of dogs

37 replies

TooJoy · 08/06/2023 18:05

I’ve just watched the dog attack video in London where a woman is being attacked by 3 dogs.

The man is able to restrain 2 but every time he tries to grab the 3rd, another one gets loose and it keeps happening and the dogs basically take in turns to attack her (she doesn’t have life threatening injuries fortunately).

I don’t know if these were all his or if she was with him or not but I do see many people with multiple dogs and we know that pack mentality is a real thing and this is usually when people get killed or injured.

Of course they should be on a lead but I can recall a few times when they’ve got out of the lead somehow during an attack.

I am not anti-dog at all and I have a massive bull breed myself who most MNers would hate but I just have the one and I have her on a lead at all times. I will hire an enclosed dog field where she can be let off with her other dog friends.

I used to let her off the lead in a public dog park because she was so well behaved but she was attacked by other dogs on 3 different occasions.
None of them were bull breeds or strong breeds but each time the owner had multiple dogs and could not restrain them and it was very scary.

So AIBU to think that we need to limit the number of dogs that one person walks at a time?
Not just by professional dog walkers but by owners too.

I think you should walk a maximum of 2 dogs, else you are not properly in control.

If you own more that 2 then you need to hire private spaces or be prepared to walk them 2 at a time.

And if you own a powerful breed like myself then you should only walk/own one at a time.

I’d be interested to see others opinions on this.

YABU - people should be able to walk multiple dogs (3+)

YANBU - people should be limited to walking 1 or 2

I do think there should be much tighter restrictions on dog ownership in other areas too but I think walking 1 or 2 as a maximum could be a good start.

OP posts:
ToBeOrNotToBee · 08/06/2023 19:02

Nope completely agree.

Even small breeds are unmanageable in large numbers.

Case in point was walking my young staffy, women with I kid you not, 10 dachshunds, comes into view, all off lead.

Every single dog runs up to us, my dog is on a lead, the dachshunds surround us and start going for us. My hands are wrapped around my dog stopping him from retaliating whilst the useless owner is desperately trying to call them off which none of them listen to.

This goes on for ages, and at times I feel like letting my dog go and letting the inevitable happen, but I'm not a twat and know exactly whose dog would be called dangerous.

Eventually a passerby intervenes and dachshund owner swans off, all dogs still off lead.

Thelnebriati · 08/06/2023 19:00

I voted YANBU even though I've often owned or walked multiple dogs. I hope they introduce mandatory liability insurance for all dog owners now.

AliceMcK · 08/06/2023 18:57

Absolutely agree. I don’t walk our dog because I can’t control her, she’s a lot better as she’s matured but she’s a happy bouncy Lab that gets excited. I’ve got chronic health problems and don’t have the strength sometimes to deal with her. I’d certainly never stand a chance if there was an attack or something happened with other dogs.

I will take her to a local park after the school run on my own, she jumps out of the car and plays for a while. It’s usually empty. There are a few dogs we’ve got to know but most of the time I call her back into the car if we see dogs approaching, I will let her back out when they have past or if we know them. She’s got good recall and there is never any bother getting her straight in the car. We also take her to a doggy day care place where she gets lots of running around and walks with other dogs with experienced dog people.

I see lots of people walking multiple dogs, some are tiny (look like rats) so it would be ok to walk several of them, but I absolutely agree on larger breeds 2 max, even 1 dog if it’s a strong dog. And anyone who physically can not control their dogs should not be allowed to walk them in public.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 08/06/2023 18:55

I think it is a pretty sensible idea. It would be relatively easy for the police to act on a law that said no more than two dogs per adult in public. No arguments about breeds or how well trained they are.

I think all dogs muzzled and on leads in public (other than designated areas) would be sensible too.

I love dogs but they are too often out of control and the consequences of that are horrible.

MaterDei · 08/06/2023 18:47

WetBandits · 08/06/2023 18:10

I’ve voted YANBU but I suppose it depends on the dogs. Multiple tiny dogs who are easily rounded up might not be such a problem, or even bigger dogs who are impeccably trained. If the dogs are lead pullers or lead reactive then 2 is plenty. Reminds me of two women I saw at the beach once who met up and hugged and didn’t notice that the four dogs they had between them (two each) had wrapped the leads around their legs and they just…fell and rolled away down the beach with four dogs in tow 😂 it was hilarious to watch and the women also found it funny once they’d managed to stand up but it could have been awful if the dogs were that way inclined.

6 Jack Russell's or similar would be a very big problem actually....

AlwaysGinPlease · 08/06/2023 18:46

Could you not have posted on one of the other 100 threads about this 🙄

Elieza · 08/06/2023 18:40

Perhaps mandatory muzzle legislation for all dogs will come in. Then if dogs get loose nobody gets seriously injured in an attack.

TooJoy · 08/06/2023 18:39

Oftentimes · 08/06/2023 18:27

It depends on the dogs. We have 4 dogs and sometimes walk them together. They’re all small, easy to control and well trained. Saying that I never let them off lead in public places. I’d be annoyed to be told I couldn’t walk them together because some twat decides they want multiple xl bullies.

It would be a shame for a lot of people but lots of people who own/walk multiple dogs say that theirs are also well trained and they’re in control etc (not saying you’re not).

It would be much more difficult to police if people were allowed to walk more than 2 only if they were well behaved because you’d have lots of owners saying yes of course they’re well behaved but actually not being able to control them if they were to attack or be attacked.

OP posts:
TooJoy · 08/06/2023 18:36

CouldIHaveThatInEnglishPlease · 08/06/2023 18:16

I said YABU because, there are actually already guidelines on this.
dog walkers insurance would only insure a maximum of 6 dogs for example, and some local licenses only allow 4.
Obviously, walking 6 shih tzu’s are very different to walking 6 XL bully’s though.

I do believe it should be illegal to walk a dog off the lead on public ground. If you want them off the lead then find a private field, but on public ground they should always be kept on a leash.

It’s sad but I do agree that it’s come to a time where dogs shouldn’t be off the lead in public places.

OP posts:
Oftentimes · 08/06/2023 18:27

It depends on the dogs. We have 4 dogs and sometimes walk them together. They’re all small, easy to control and well trained. Saying that I never let them off lead in public places. I’d be annoyed to be told I couldn’t walk them together because some twat decides they want multiple xl bullies.

CouldIHaveThatInEnglishPlease · 08/06/2023 18:16

I said YABU because, there are actually already guidelines on this.
dog walkers insurance would only insure a maximum of 6 dogs for example, and some local licenses only allow 4.
Obviously, walking 6 shih tzu’s are very different to walking 6 XL bully’s though.

I do believe it should be illegal to walk a dog off the lead on public ground. If you want them off the lead then find a private field, but on public ground they should always be kept on a leash.

WetBandits · 08/06/2023 18:10

I’ve voted YANBU but I suppose it depends on the dogs. Multiple tiny dogs who are easily rounded up might not be such a problem, or even bigger dogs who are impeccably trained. If the dogs are lead pullers or lead reactive then 2 is plenty. Reminds me of two women I saw at the beach once who met up and hugged and didn’t notice that the four dogs they had between them (two each) had wrapped the leads around their legs and they just…fell and rolled away down the beach with four dogs in tow 😂 it was hilarious to watch and the women also found it funny once they’d managed to stand up but it could have been awful if the dogs were that way inclined.