Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse pregnant employee request to delay recruitment?

56 replies

Namechangecover · 08/06/2023 18:01

I manage a small team of 6 people. One of the team members is pregnant (she is deputy team manager), her role requires a specific set of skills and a qualification that no one in the team can cover so we need to recruit for a mat leave cover - it will also take a good few months to train the cover on internal systems (ideally the pregnant team member will do the training and handover). She wanted to wait until 13 week scan until we recruit a cover as wanted to check all okay with the pregnancy. That has been and gone and she is now 16 weeks. All seems fine with pregnancy but she is very anxious (has paid for at least 4 reassurance scans since testing positive). She now wants to wait until 20 week scan to make sure all okay before we start interviewing for cover. AIBU to gently say we have to recruit now regardless of her view.

OP posts:
volcanoroll · 08/06/2023 19:52

MrsMoastyToasty · 08/06/2023 19:50

Train up one of the team to her role and backfill their position with a temp.

Why?

volcanoroll · 08/06/2023 19:52

Namechangecover · 08/06/2023 18:49

Thanks! Yes she has told everyone in the team

All good to go then. I mean presumably this person is going to be needed whatever happens with her pregnancy.

MrsMoastyToasty · 08/06/2023 19:50

Train up one of the team to her role and backfill their position with a temp.

TheCreamTeaWasFromMe · 08/06/2023 19:47

BTW I have been very generous and optimistic in the timelines for advertising, screening and interviewing. In my experience a fast timeline from the advert going live, to having a preferred candidate who accepts an offer, is four weeks - and that assumes that everyone has diary availability at the right times to do interviews....

TheCreamTeaWasFromMe · 08/06/2023 19:45

If she plans to go off at 37 weeks, and she's 16 weeks now, that gives you 21 weeks in which to advertise, interview, offer, onboard and train her replacement.

Let's say you get the role live on LinkedIn this coming Monday (week one). You'll want to give it at least a week to see who responds. Interviewing starts in weeks two and three (depending on the availability of your longlist). Second interview for the shortlist in week four. Obtain approval to hire and make the offer at the end of week four, and hope acceptance is quick. That's a month gone already.

If the role cover needs a specific qualification, how likely is it that there's someone out there who can start immediately? Let's call this scenario A, be optimistic and assume your new hire is a contractor who is at a loose end and can start straight away. HR checks, paperwork and IT kit ordering and laptop imaging etc are normally at least two weeks to complete. That's the end of week six.

Your new hire starts in week seven, and you now have 14 weeks left in which to train them. That's feasible, but only if you start recruitment now and get someone who's available immediately.

I would think it's more likely that they'll either have a bit of a contract to finish, or a notice period to work - let's call this scenario B and say its four weeks, in which case your training period has just been trimmed back to 10 weeks to accommodate notice. Might be tight given that you've said that the training will take time. But probably still do-able.

However if you can't start recruiting for another 5 weeks (waiting until staff member is 20 weeks and has had her scan plus results, which realistically takes you to 21 weeks), then your training time in scenario A is cut to 9 weeks. Tight but you can probably still make it work. In scenario B the training time is cut to 5 weeks - is this really feasible?

My advice would be to sit down early next week,and work out a training plan with your staff member, and then add timing points to it. That should give you a view of how long you actually need for training. If it's more than 5 weeks then you cannot delay recruitment any longer.

1offnamechange · 08/06/2023 19:45

What's her concern? I honestly don't understand why, given that everybody already knows about the pregnancy, it makes any difference to her either way?

Given how long recruitment can take, even if you start now will you even be at interview stage by 20 weeks? So you can just reassure her that you're starting the process, if anything happens then you'll just end it before making someone an offer so nobody loses out (apart from the time spend sifting applications).

But even if (god forbid) she lost the baby after you'd arranged cover it's not like she then gets forced out of her job, you'd presumably either have to end the new person's contract early or keep them both on, neither of which is her problem, nor would it be affected by waiting until 20 weeks.

Namechangecover · 08/06/2023 19:27

KateyCuckoo · 08/06/2023 18:57

Does she also have issues with her husband telling his family that they are expecting a baby?

Not that I’m aware of. Her and her DP (not DH) have told everyone now as far as I know.

OP posts:
AhNowTed · 08/06/2023 19:02

Mushroo · 08/06/2023 19:01

Coming at it from another view, I’m not even planning on telling work until after the 20 week scan, they don’t need to know.

What would you have done if she hadn’t told you?

My point exactly

Mushroo · 08/06/2023 19:01

Coming at it from another view, I’m not even planning on telling work until after the 20 week scan, they don’t need to know.

What would you have done if she hadn’t told you?

AhNowTed · 08/06/2023 19:00

What's the big deal between 16 and 20 weeks?

Many women I know wouldn't even tell their employer at the 16 week stage.

What's the rush?

There are MONTHS to go.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 08/06/2023 18:59

It's poor business continuity planning to only have 1 person (other than you) able to do the work.

KateyCuckoo · 08/06/2023 18:57

Does she also have issues with her husband telling his family that they are expecting a baby?

Koalaslippers · 08/06/2023 18:55

Given that she doesn't need to have told you yet and that the matb1 form isn't issued until after the scan has taken place it seems a bit odd to me that you are trying to recruit now. I'd wait a few weeks.

Namechangecover · 08/06/2023 18:49

volcanoroll · 08/06/2023 18:33

If she hasn't told the rest of the team she is pregnant you will have to make sure you are careful how you refer to it in front of others. Eg. A fixed term contract to help out. Apart from that you can do whatever you like.

Thanks! Yes she has told everyone in the team

OP posts:
volcanoroll · 08/06/2023 18:33

If she hasn't told the rest of the team she is pregnant you will have to make sure you are careful how you refer to it in front of others. Eg. A fixed term contract to help out. Apart from that you can do whatever you like.

OfficerPastiche · 08/06/2023 18:32

YANBU.
But as this is pregnancy related anxiety I don't think you can say anything logical that will ease the situation. Maybe tell her that recruitment will take a while so it won't be 'real' until much later, if that helps?

Eleganz · 08/06/2023 18:32

Namechangecover · 08/06/2023 18:20

My impression was she is worried about somehow jinxing the pregnancy, not that she is worried about being replaced.

yes, this is her worry

Then you know it is irrational and so need to deal with it politely but firmly. There is no place for superstition in your decisions as a manager.

Eleganz · 08/06/2023 18:30

It is not really anything to do with her. You are the manager and you have to recruit for the cover according to your organisations rules. If she has an issue with this I think you need to have a kind but honest conversation with her about how this is your decision and you need to think of what is in the best interests of the team and the business.

My view, as a manager, is if you can get the cover in place do it now. This will allow as much time for knowledge transfer as possible.

steff13 · 08/06/2023 18:26

You're not being unreasonable.

Have you contacted Liam Neeson? I heard he has a very specific set of skills. 😁

Namechangecover · 08/06/2023 18:26

iwasthewalrus · 08/06/2023 18:09

Has she formally applied for maternity leave? At my work (public sector) we can’t recruit until we have that.

But if your work do things differently then perhaps highlight to her that even if you advertise now it’s likely to be another few weeks before you can actually offer the role. And ultimately if something changes and she doesn’t go on maternity leave after you've found someone to cover that’ll be your problem to resolve not here.

she has told more senior management but not submitted a MATB1 or but anything in writing. She’s also informed verbally of her intended last day in the workplace (and booked holiday from then for 2 weeks, which is 3 weeks prior to her due date) - I’m not sure if that counts as formal notice yet though.

OP posts:
Namechangecover · 08/06/2023 18:20

My impression was she is worried about somehow jinxing the pregnancy, not that she is worried about being replaced.

yes, this is her worry

OP posts:
Namechangecover · 08/06/2023 18:19

Shopper727 · 08/06/2023 18:07

Is there no one in house you could train instead? Or as well as? Seems a bit daft to only have one person being able to do certain things. What if she becomes unwell - my pelvis was unstable and I was off from 26 weeks with last pregnancy so things can happen, must be worrying for you both but the recruitment will take a while if you even got someone first time by which time she could be almost off on mat leave depending how much annual leave she has.

I can also do her role and cover when she is off but have full time responsibilities of my own so can’t do it for a year. A significant part of her role (approx 50%) requires a specific qualification that no one else except me and her have. The others can do the rest of her role but have full time responsibilities of their own - so not really the capacity to pick up at the moment. We do need to recruit externally.

OP posts:
Maloneyb · 08/06/2023 18:18

StrawBeretMoose · 08/06/2023 18:16

My impression was she is worried about somehow jinxing the pregnancy, not that she is worried about being replaced.

A PP suggestion to train other people is good anyway, regardless of pregnancy what happens if she is on leave or I'll or resigns.

She doesn't even need to have told work about her pregnancy yet.

Your last point is valid.
i didn’t tell anyone at work (other than my manager) until I was 5.5/6 months.

StrawBeretMoose · 08/06/2023 18:16

Maloneyb · 08/06/2023 18:03

I was like your employee. Anxious, many scans etc. however I had to force my employer to get my role out to advert as the idea of it not being recruited to was more stressful as I’d have to come back to a role that hadn’t been looked after.

make it clear to her that you are doing this for her and for yourself/business to ensure she doesn’t have to stress.
she probably needs reassurance that you’re not replacing her permanently - we defo get this fear lol.

My impression was she is worried about somehow jinxing the pregnancy, not that she is worried about being replaced.

A PP suggestion to train other people is good anyway, regardless of pregnancy what happens if she is on leave or I'll or resigns.

She doesn't even need to have told work about her pregnancy yet.

iwasthewalrus · 08/06/2023 18:09

Has she formally applied for maternity leave? At my work (public sector) we can’t recruit until we have that.

But if your work do things differently then perhaps highlight to her that even if you advertise now it’s likely to be another few weeks before you can actually offer the role. And ultimately if something changes and she doesn’t go on maternity leave after you've found someone to cover that’ll be your problem to resolve not here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread