Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ignoring "No Dogs" sign

83 replies

ChocChipHandbag · 08/06/2023 15:32

Our small local park has a top area with a playground that displays "No Dogs" signs. There is a grassy area for ball games, picnics etc where dogs are not allowed, although they can be walked through the path next to it on a lead to the large dog-friendly bit of the park.

I constantly see people letting their dogs run round there.

Every now and again I politely point out the sign and about 50% of the time they will push back with "oh, I didn't think it mattered" "No kids here at the moment are there?" "He/she is no trouble" "it's not for people like me who pick up after their dogs" or something much ruder. Sometimes I will be interrogated about why I care, as if the Council sign is irrelevant.

AIBU to wonder what goes on in these people's minds? These are middle class people with labradors etc, not louts with devil dogs on strings.

(And for what it's worth, I care because grass is not wiped clean of poo when it's picked up, dog pee burns the grass and my son is scared of dogs).

OP posts:
Talkingfrog · 09/06/2023 13:14

We have a park near us that has a fenced off courts. The signs clearly say no dogs to be allowed in the courts, but people go in and shut the gates so the dogs can run around in a confined space -they don't always clear up after themselves either. The playground area is also fenced off with signs that no dogs are allowed - that is ignored too, but not as much.

BelindaBears · 09/06/2023 13:06

Nothingisblackandwhite · 09/06/2023 12:18

You have to much time on your hands . Or are you one of those weirdos that hates dogs

I dislike dogs, so I’m one of your weirdos. But you don’t have to have “too much time on your hands” to feel pissed off at not being able to enjoy local open spaces due to dogs being where they shouldn’t. The shit is right there in front of me on my commute. The dogs “being friendly” are right there in the fenced off playgrounds when I’m there with my child.

Nothingisblackandwhite · 09/06/2023 12:18

You have to much time on your hands . Or are you one of those weirdos that hates dogs

Plutonium7000 · 09/06/2023 12:09

Everytime you see this take a photo of the dog in the play area and post it on local Facebook page with a comment about it. Usually other people will add comments below, sometimes gets the message across that it's not acceptable.

DrCoconut · 09/06/2023 12:06

Sorry, pressed post too soon. Our local park is ruined by out of control dogs. And unfortunately they are not all cuddly Labrador types. They are the type that look like they will maul you and the owners are not the type you want a confrontation with either. It's a pity but we rarely go now.

DrCoconut · 09/06/2023 12:03

Our

BCCoach · 09/06/2023 10:48

What goes on in their minds is that they literally don't care. They know that rules and laws are not enforced and that there will be absolutely no repucussions for breaking them. See also: pavement parkers, fly tippers, litterbugs, speeders, disposable BBQ arsonists, illegal escooter riders etc.

People often say about such people "they don't think the rules apply to them." This is incorrect. They know full well that the rules apply to them, they just choose to ignore them in the full knowledge that they can do so.

Strawberrypicnic · 09/06/2023 10:31

It's not dog owners but entitled people in general. Admittedly there is a quite a big crossover. In our local park there is a pond with ducks, geese and other types of water birds, and signs saying please keep dogs on leads around the water fowl. The other day I saw a family let their dog repeatedly run at groups of birds chilling on the ground and force them to scatter into the air. The owners were just stood there gawping. I honestly don't really understand how these people manage all the tasks that are essential for existing from day to day.

ChocChipHandbag · 09/06/2023 10:00

Daisybuttercup12345 · 09/06/2023 09:47

I wouldn't take my dog in there, but you also need to be addressing you son's terror of dogs for his own benefit.

That's in hand, as I explained in my post at 18:27 yesterday.

OP posts:
Daisybuttercup12345 · 09/06/2023 09:47

I wouldn't take my dog in there, but you also need to be addressing you son's terror of dogs for his own benefit.

Flossflower · 08/06/2023 21:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ButterCrackers · 08/06/2023 20:42

ChocChipHandbag · 08/06/2023 18:37

The signs aren't to keep the dogs on a lead, they are "no dogs". The dog free part of the park actually has a sign at the entrance which states "dog-free gate" and there is a 5 foot fence separating the dog-friendly and dog-free sections, with a gate in the middle to pass from one part to the other. The lawn in question has a big "no dogs" sign on the fence that is legible from all parts of it.

It's not really allowed to walk your dog in a lead along the path through the middle of the dog-free bit, but it does feel more unreasonable to object to that as it's quite a long way round by road to the dog gate.

Absolutely - no dogs means no dogs. My dog doesn’t go into non dog areas. To add that I see mainly selfish dog owners out there.

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/06/2023 19:22

Nope, doesn't land any better from dog owners.

I often remind people a certain park I walk through is on lead only - but it apparently doesn't include their 'he's friendlyyyyyyyyyyyyy' dog jumping around mine or shitting over there under a tree.

They're usually defensive and ready to be pretty rude and often the reason is their dog is not well trained, and absolutely fucking awful on the lead pulling them all over, so its easier to leave the dog off and let it do 'whatever'.

Theres another 'no dogs' park I go through with mine as he's an assistance dog and again, the number of dogs in there is huge - we only go through it as it cuts out a really inaccessible route (cars parked on pavements, not enough dropped kerbs etc) for the wheelchair otherwise I'd not bother at all.

It pisses me off because when enough people complain, we will end up with more and more dog control orders and fewer places to take them - they're fucking it up for all the responsible owners.

madeleine85 · 08/06/2023 19:13

As a dog owner I agree with following signs where there are any, and generally keeping dogs on leash around children. You never know when a loud car will go by, something in the distance makes noise etc and the dog gets scared (or the child does). I will say that some non dog owners can be overzealous at times without checking the signs in the location they are in. I've been at a children's park which was not fenced in, and had signs saying "dogs on leash". My lab mix was on the leash (for context I do not frequently take my dog to childrens parks, my toddler demanded to go to the park while we were out on a dog walk, the poor dog had not been out for 8 hours, and I had no one to help and couldn't leave children alone as they are far too young), I was there with my two very young children, pushing my littlest one on the swing for a few minutes. My dog was happily lapping up attention from children who wanted to pet him while on leash and he was attached to me the entire time. A middle aged man who was a complete stranger, with no children at the park, came up and started shouting at me to take my dog out as he could spread worms to the children and aggressively telling me that I was going against the park signs and rules. I was truly shocked, pointed to the signs, asked what I was doing against the rules, After some very incorrect and rude statements from him, he stormed off to get help from park workers. Not wanting a confrontation I picked up a screaming toddler and made her leave the park and went home.. I later checked the rules and the only one I found for that park that applied was one saying that there was to be no intimidation, harassment or bullying behaviours in the park. I am still too nevervous to go back there with my children and dog, and actually get worried taking my children alone in case he comes back. FYI there were other dogs on leash at that park, just not attached to an owner at the swing set. It sounds ridiculous, but this experience really had a lasting impact on me. So yes, where there are signs, I believe that they absolutely should be followed, and I do not appreciate dog owners going against them, but also, some people do take things much too far as vigilantes when not doing research properly (a very small portion of people though).

TheHandmaiden · 08/06/2023 19:01

They are just entitled- that's it.

ChimChimeny · 08/06/2023 19:00

At the beach the other day there were loads of people walking their dogs despite the signs saying no dogs allowed

We were on the beach at Wells in Norfolk Easter weekend, there was a bloke who's only job was to patrol the beach telling people when they'd taken their dogs over to The non-dog side, he must have racked up a lot of.steps that day!!

ChocChipHandbag · 08/06/2023 19:00

I get that if you are someone who has a dog in your living space all day every day, maybe even on your bed or sofa, it must be really really weird to think that a dog could remotely bother someone who has to share a park with it.

I'm trying to think of an equivalent, I dunno, maybe a park that doesn't allow picnics? We all have food in our homes, everyone loves food, right? We all need to eat. I clear up after myself, what's the issue?

Would I have a picnic anyway under a No Picnic sign? If I could not work out what on earth might be the reason for banning picnics there? And the picnic area next door was very busy?

I like to think I wouldn't. But maybe that's unrealistic.

OP posts:
ChocChipHandbag · 08/06/2023 18:44

Seasonofthewitch83 · 08/06/2023 16:41

Do people take their dogs into the enclosed areas because then they can let them off lead? I have a colleague whose dog has shit recall so she gets up at 6am to take him to the fenced kids playground to let him piss all over it instead.

That's awful. No, the dog area is enclosed too.

OP posts:
ChocChipHandbag · 08/06/2023 18:37

ButterCrackers · 08/06/2023 17:41

I have a dog and he’s always on a lead when out for walk or in a park, wood etc. The dog owners you mention need to be fined heavily for disrespecting the signs to keep their dog on a lead.

The signs aren't to keep the dogs on a lead, they are "no dogs". The dog free part of the park actually has a sign at the entrance which states "dog-free gate" and there is a 5 foot fence separating the dog-friendly and dog-free sections, with a gate in the middle to pass from one part to the other. The lawn in question has a big "no dogs" sign on the fence that is legible from all parts of it.

It's not really allowed to walk your dog in a lead along the path through the middle of the dog-free bit, but it does feel more unreasonable to object to that as it's quite a long way round by road to the dog gate.

OP posts:
ChocChipHandbag · 08/06/2023 18:32

midsomermurderess · 08/06/2023 16:45

The middle classes not following the rules? Fetch the smelling salts. It’s a truism, but you can’t change other peoples’ behaviour, only your reaction to it. Are there alternatives?

Alternatives to the park? Stopping going there would not be changing my response, it would be depriving myself of a nice facility be side of their behaviour.

Also, I can live with the dogs being there, it just annoys me that they ignore a rule that is supposed to benefit others.

I suppose I could decide not to let it make me angry. But that's how society falls apart, if good people ignore bad things...

OP posts:
ChocChipHandbag · 08/06/2023 18:27

ItsCalledAConversation · 08/06/2023 16:38

Is it a fenced off area? We have a local park where there’s a huge open grassy area with a wooden play structure in the corner. There is a no dogs sign up near the play structure but dogs are allowed off lead in the park, so you are supposed to guess how close to the play structure your dog is allowed. It’s often deserted, in which case my kids with play on the structure and dog and I will play sticks nearby. If there were kids on the play equipment I’d take my dog further away, but it’s not made crystal clear what the rules are.

OP if you’re very anti-dogs maybe your boy is picking up on it and it’s feeding his fear? My DD was very scared of dogs when little (rightfully so, I kind of think it’s sensible of little kids to be wary)…but she loves them now she is bigger. Wanders off point of thread, sorry!

I'm not anti dogs at all. I'm anti people who think rules don't apply to them.

I am allergic to dogs so can't pet them or have them in my home- make me sneeze and get itchy eyes and if their saliva gets on me I come up in hives. (No allergy risk whatsoever crossing paths with them in the park).

I'm definitely not afraid of them and I think some dogs are beautiful- I love whippets in particular. I encourage my son to play with our neighbour's and relative's dogs and I have tried not to stoke his fear, which has come out of nowhere.

OP posts:
SmurfHaribos · 08/06/2023 17:58

Well done OP. Definitely not being unreasonable.
Myself and my children are frightened of dogs due to numerous incidents with dogs jumping up, running up and barking, bowling us over, running over our picnic (when we were sat there) and eating our food (out of our hands), covering us with mud, scratching us, shoving their heads in our groins. These aren’t one off incidents but multiple. Owner usually then says something along the lines of “Oh, they’re just being friendly/Oh, don’t you like dogs then/Oh, are you frightened of dogs then/Oh, they just want to get to know you”.
Opinions are formed by personal experiences and my opinion of dogs is resolutely negative as my experiences have been overwhelmingly negative.
Plus (with the exception of assistance and working dogs) they are terrible for climate change as they have a high carbon footprint. No one should be getting dogs as pets, the environment cost is too high. They might be nice to have but the planet is experiencing a climate emergency and we all need to take urgent action.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 08/06/2023 17:49

KStockHERO · 08/06/2023 16:26

Dog owner here. Actually, more than that - massive dog lover, dog obsessive madwoman.

It really annoys me when people do this for all the reasons you've talked about. And it gives all dog owners a bad name.
I always say something.
If I have my phone on me, I take pictures of the dogs too and if/when the owners take issue, I say that I'm sending the pictures to the Council.

It depends on what the bylaws are in your area in terms of policing. In my local park, the Council can fine up to £500 for a dog off-lead outside of the allotted times. So the excuse that they don't have resource to police it is bullshit.
On one of the rare occasions the Council has wardens in the park, I watched them stop ten people in about half hour. If every one of them got fined, that'd be £5,000. Even if half appealed and didn't pay, that's £2,500. Surely that's more than the Council paid out for the 30-mins of two wardens' time?!

This seems to have just been outsourced to a private company by my council. Suddenly people are being fined left, right and centre. It’ll be a huge income stream for a while until the message gets through.

Trickedbyadoughnut · 08/06/2023 17:44

I am a dog owner and can confirm that it does NOT go down better from a fellow dog owner. The only time it helps is if I see people not picking up, I whip out a poo bag (I have some in every pocket whether I'm with the dog or not) and say, oh it's nightmare when you get caught without a bag, isn't it? I haven't so far been insulted in that situation!

Makes the rest of us look bad. Hate this kind of behaviour.

HanSB · 08/06/2023 17:42

Some dog owners are very entitled and selfish thinking that rules do not apply to them. My children's school has a no dog policy but in the last couple weeks before the half term I noticed one woman carrying her dog in the playground in her arms several occasions and then today I saw someone else doing the same - obviously think they are better and above it all with small dogs they can carry!

Swipe left for the next trending thread