Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To be so upset at a strangers passive aggressive remarks (Blue Badge)

163 replies

Tryingtogetonwithit · 08/06/2023 15:05

Today in tesco carpark loading my shopping into the car with my teen daughter a lady n the row of cars behind me exclaimed loudly while helping her elderly mother out of the car "I can't believe everyone using the disabled spaces are actually disabled, look they are leaving now should we move" she continued talking but I couldn't here but didn't stop staring at me.

For clarity I have MS I usually walk with a stick but in tesco I use trolley for balance. I drive my own car and have the audacity to go out in public and do my own shopping. I have had comments before (even one man asking me to show him my blue badge!!) today just hit deep, I don't know why maybe because I was with my daughter and didn't want to make a scene.

It's taken me years to come to terms having MS and I held out for a long time not getting a blue badge. I have been medically Retired from a job I adored and didn't pass probationary period on another due to sick leave. I am currently unemployed and looks like I will be for the foreseeable as I'm so up and down healthwise. Single mum to teens/young adults and never seen myself ever being a benefits claimer, worked from i was 15, further education, married and had kids (before divorce) it gets me down daily my life isn't what I worked so hard for.

People don't realise and or maybe don't care how hurtful a passing comment can be when you are struggling.

Sorry for the post, somehow it's been carthitic letting it go in the ether of MN lol

OP posts:
NextTimeItsOver · 09/06/2023 09:52

Leftbutcameback · 08/06/2023 16:19

There’s a guy on TikTok who always get abuse because he drives a work van. People are so rude to him, there’s an assumption he can’t possible need a BB and work.

I was also pretty shocked to hear another tiktokker say she had to move her car from one BB space to another half way through her shift as the spaces had a 4 hour limit.

I follow that guy too. People are so rude to him.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 09/06/2023 09:41

Quveas · 08/06/2023 21:12

Sorry. We aren't supposed to do this because on this site we are supposed to be " kind". You are lying. Or in that alternate reality you are claiming. Blue badges are posted out AFTER evidence by qualified medical professionals or disability benefits are provided- on line or by post. The cards are not laminated - they are printed. Anyone who had ever seen one knows this to be a fact and that what you are claiming is simply impossible and not true.

If I get banned or deleted for calling you out on this lie, fine - it says nothing about me and everything about this site that continually allows people with disabilities to be attacked as liars and frauds without intervention.

My mum’s was laminated , in 1998.

It was bloody difficult to get it for her, though, and even worse renewing it, because she didn’t claim benefits ( too independent, too proud). She certainly didn’t go anywhere like ‘a spring chicken’ , I assure you.

LadyKenya · 09/06/2023 09:29

I don’t think the media helps. Look at the recent news stories about how much tax is going to support those on out of work benefits. Yes unrelated but it sets people up to view disabled people with suspicion and to see us all as cheating the system, a waste of space etc.

This. The insidious rhetoric that is being peddled by the media is dangerous, and should always be challenged. It has echoes of Nazi propaganda against people with disabilities as far as I am concerned. Totally encouraged by this disgrace of a Government.

IndigoLaFaye · 09/06/2023 08:22

The belief that the system is being abused is rife and mostly untrue. People (even other disabled people) don’t see how much of an impact these types of comments have on disabled people.

I don’t think the media helps. Look at the recent news stories about how much tax is going to support those on out of work benefits. Yes unrelated but it sets people up to view disabled people with suspicion and to see us all as cheating the system, a waste of space etc.

IamAlso4eels · 09/06/2023 08:13

Then yes, that is appalling and in that situation I'd be giving the registration number of the offending vehicle(s) to security for them to deal with.

AgnesX · 09/06/2023 07:48

IamAlso4eels · 08/06/2023 20:52

It is a myth though and the facts show it.

There are approximately 2.5 million current blue badges. The average rate of prosecution/confiscation for misuse is approximately 690 badges a year - around 0.03% of the total badges on circulation.

To even qualify for a blue badge you need to meet specific criteria and provide evidence such as PIP/DLA claim confirmation, medical reports, etc. PIP/DLA have the lowest instances of benefit fraud - only around 1.2% of all claims are paid incorrectly due to either claimant error or DWP error. A lot of medical evidence is needed to claim PIP and DLA therefore it's safe to assume that the vast, vast majority of people receiving it are genuine and that can be extrapolated to include blue badge holders.

I think you've misunderstood me. I was referring to BB space abuse by people WITHOUT a badge. Especially in places like retail parks with supermarkets where parking isn't policed.

One of my local hospitals is appalling, it's a fee for all.

Quveas · 09/06/2023 07:47

i do know someone who played the system got a blue badge when theres nothing wrong with them

just pretended they couldnt walk far and put on a limp

Again. In order to obtain a blue badge you must either be in receipt of a qualifying disability benefit, the award of which is dependant on providing detailed supporting medical evidence from your own GP / consultants and passing an assessment by a qualified medical practitioner employed for that purpose; or if you are not in receipt of such a benefit, providing medical evidence from your GP and consultant then passing an assessment by a medical professional employed by the local authority for that purpose. You cannot simply "pretend you can't walk far and put on a limp".

Yes there may be a very few people who have managed to play the disability system, but to hear it told here those number in the thousands. What actually numbers in the thousands are the numbers of people with disabilities refused the benefits they should be entitled to by a system that places no values on their lives and assumes them to be liars; and those members of the public who have the same view and therefore allow and encourage that system to thrive.

hookiewookie29 · 09/06/2023 07:45

My husband is disabled and uses 2 sticks. I am not,but I do a lot of the driving.
The amount of people who have the audacity to actually stand and share at me as I get out of the car is astounding! One man even said to me "You don't look very disabled!" ( even though I'd put a badge in the window). I replied " I'm not, thankfully. But he is" pointing at my husband as he practically fell out if the car. The man walked iffy so I shouted " I'm happy to accept your apology now!"
I know there are many people who will happily park in a disabled bay without a badge, and not give a shit about those that need the space. I like to think that Karma will get them......

loislovesstewie · 09/06/2023 05:59

Re the replies about people pretending to have a limp and getting a blue badge. I worked as a homeless officer in local government ,if an applicant said they had a health issue then we actually contact the appropriate medical professional to check on the health of the applicant. Why? Because people do lie,but clearly by doing that we caught them out. As I said up thread my adult son is now severely sight impaired and has applied for a badge. He has had to send off the letter from the consultant saying exactly that. So a medical professional has given that info. I can't believe that any local authority would just dish out a badge without checking what health issue the applicant actually has.

TommyJoesMummy · 09/06/2023 00:59

Try saying “I have MS, but I’m having a good day” either as an out loud response or just to yourself?
Just look at it differently and acknowledge that you are looking well on it and you’re doing fantastically! Don’t forget that you’re a parent, you’re running a household, you’re getting out and doing things with your kids.
It might illicit a more positive response or conversation, so you aren’t left thinking about how you were perceived later.
It might start a positive conversation with yourself on all the good things that you are?
Don’t think any more of it. She may be like that with everyone. She may have been in a bad mood. But, you were getting on well today, and I hope I don’t sound patronising. We all need a little help seeing the good side of our situations sometimes 💐

whynotwhatknot · 09/06/2023 00:52

They were dicks to you-i do know someone who played the system got a blue badge when theres nothing wrong with them

just pretended they couldnt walk far and put on a limp

SweetBirdsong · 09/06/2023 00:52

Nat6999 · 08/06/2023 23:54

I had abuse when I parked with my blue badge, a man stood & watched me put my badge on the dashboard then followed me in the supermarket shouting that if I could walk in the store I didn't need a badge. I've also had abuse for using a disabled toilet, I had wet myself while out with ds, gone to Sainsbury's to buy some leggings & pants so I could change, come out of the toilet & a man shouted that I wasn't disabled, I nearly stuffed the carrier bag with my pee soaked clothes up his nose.

Flowers
Ponoka7 · 09/06/2023 00:22

CoconutDrunk · 08/06/2023 22:13

I voted YANBU because you have a blue badge so you have every right to use the space and people should know better than to judge if someone who needs a blue badge “looks” disabled.

HOWEVER - as someone who had a family member with a blue badge and who regularly needs to use parent & child spaces, I too can get frustrated sometimes. Not only do I see people regularly misusing parent and child spaces, I also then see many parents parking in disabled bays when they can’t get one!! I know several people that admit to doing this. (Which I find appalling) it’s infuriating when you really need the extra space and someone has got the last one because they don’t want to scratch their Ferrari…

giving this lady the benefit of the doubt, perhaps she was having an awful day, every place she’d been so far had mummy wagons in the disabled bays and her frail mum was tired and desperately needed to get to the loo. so, she made a bad snap judgement when she wouldn’t normally.

I am sorry it upset you, it’s a horrid feeling but I wouldn’t take it personally

My partner has had a stroke because of a brain injury, he did have a lifetime PIP award but was kicked off. Now he's developed a lung condition and arthritis. He's waiting to hear about PIP. Our council bases a BB on PIP. Even though he's had a BB in the past, again it's delayed. So he has to park close to the Store, which means P&C. he also struggles to get out of the car. I know a few people who can't get a BB, so have to use P&C.

Nat6999 · 08/06/2023 23:54

I had abuse when I parked with my blue badge, a man stood & watched me put my badge on the dashboard then followed me in the supermarket shouting that if I could walk in the store I didn't need a badge. I've also had abuse for using a disabled toilet, I had wet myself while out with ds, gone to Sainsbury's to buy some leggings & pants so I could change, come out of the toilet & a man shouted that I wasn't disabled, I nearly stuffed the carrier bag with my pee soaked clothes up his nose.

HerMammy · 08/06/2023 23:38

Blue badges aren't easy to get, be harsh and call them out, I had to step in once when a man was going a young woman a hard time about her badge, he was put right that she was recovering from a brain tumour and was left with disabilities.

Setting · 08/06/2023 23:08

Yeh, someone thought I didn’t need a blue badge as I was young and asked if I was actually disabled. Whilst they were watching my fucking wheelchair being loaded into the car!

piedbeauty · 08/06/2023 23:05

I'm so sorry that this has happened to you. YANBU at all. 💐

Tryingtogetonwithit · 08/06/2023 22:40

@WiddlinDiddlin that is horrific but sadly doesn't surprise me 😔 I think we can conclude some people are just dicks, I don't understand why they feel so entitled, must have very unfulfilled lives 🙄

OP posts:
Tryingtogetonwithit · 08/06/2023 22:33

Good grief this has derailed a bit 😂 I've had a day to reflect and yes some people do abuse the system but I can assure anyone who needs to know, I'm not.

Blue badges are given to people who need them, anyone who qualifies can apply. Essentially the Blue Badge has absolutely changed my life I can walk (with a stick and varies depending on pain and wobbliness ) but limited walking, fatigue and very annoying incontinence issues meant I bearly went out alone the badge means I can park close to the shop I want to go to, I can go back to car if I need a rest and best of all can go into town and have a coffee with my older kids at uni. I can go out alone like any other grown adult human person.

I'm 45 and a little blue card has improved my life more than any of the drugs they have given me.

OP posts:
DyslexicPoster · 08/06/2023 22:33

This happens to us a lot. My son has asd and drops out of the car to roll about on the floor. I'm not going to lie, if your rude to me about not looking disabled I'm rude. People get taken aback then I have to point out that they are the umpteenth disablist, disabled person who have Been vitriolic to us. I don't ask what their condition is. My son is very, very, very visibly not a bog standard child.

TitoMojito · 08/06/2023 22:30

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/06/2023 18:56

Having a wheelchair in the car doesn't always stop it either.

I have had abuse hurled at me by two very vociferous pensioners (I know they were pensioners as they stated so, several times as if this should automatically qualify them) because I had taken the last blue badge space.

I apologised, initially thinking they had a badge, but we had simply got to the space first, we hadn't done anything sneaky, like nip in whilst they moved their car or anything!

They carried on, calling me a lazy fat cow, whilst my partner got my chair out, and eventually let slip they don't even HAVE a blue badge, just felt that blue badge spaces were also for anyone claiming an old age pension!

Apparently the fact my manual wheelchair is purple and has a camo print seat/back means it wasn't supplied or prescribed by the NHS!

I got bored and told them to fuck off in the end. Apparently real disabled people wouldn't do that either.

I've also had multiple incidences of people honking their horns at me to hurry up loading myself and chair into the back of our new vehicle. It takes a little while to line up and the ramps do stick out into the road-way in most carparks. Obviously what I need to help me concentrate and not drop myself and 8K of NHS funded powerchair sideways into the road off the ramp, is some mardy cunt in an Audi honking at me and revving whilst mouthing something rude!

Crikey that's awful Shock

TitoMojito · 08/06/2023 22:28

Leftbutcameback · 08/06/2023 16:19

There’s a guy on TikTok who always get abuse because he drives a work van. People are so rude to him, there’s an assumption he can’t possible need a BB and work.

I was also pretty shocked to hear another tiktokker say she had to move her car from one BB space to another half way through her shift as the spaces had a 4 hour limit.

I was going to mention this guy. His videos are so sad. And the reason he has a blue badge is because he broke his back in a terrible accident! He’s been through enough without having to listen to idiots everyday.

I'm sorry you had to deal with this, OP. Disabled spaces are for disabled people. That's all there is to it.

UpaladderwatchingTV · 08/06/2023 22:26

I had a classic yesterday. I'm severely disabled with a back problem, the only way I can travel any distance is in our motorhome, as it enables us to stop as soon as I can't sit any longer, and I can lay down immediately, until the pain is under control again. This is simply not possible in a car. We parked up in a disabled bay, and a young woman shouted out to me, 'this is a disabled bay you know'. I told her I was disabled, and pointed at my BB, the look on her face was an absolute picture. So another lesson for all those who don't think before opening their mouth about things they know nothing about, don't always assume disabled people only travel by car!!

Bobbybobbins · 08/06/2023 22:21

I have two disabled children who both have blue badges in case I have one of them with me but not the other. They are both severely learning disabled. I have been lucky so far in that I haven't had any comments but I am ready for it!

Quveas · 08/06/2023 22:21

LadyKenya · 08/06/2023 22:04

You do not have to be registered disabled to get awarded a BB. Some people can claim a BB with a Pip award, or you can apply through your LA.

There is no register of people with disabilities.

To get a blue badge you must score a certain amount of points under the mobility sections of PIP (or some other limited benefits) which are only awarded after medical evidence and assessments are completed by government departments / medically trained personnel employed by them; or, more rarely, based on a medical examination by doctors employed for this purpose by the local authority if not in receipt of qualifying benefits.

Whenever thread on blue badges starts, there's always an outcry about how many people are not really disabled (despite a host of doctors saying otherwise), but never any outcry about the number of people who die because they are denied the disability benfits they should have been entitled to...
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2020/jan/16/people-died-benefits-error
https://www.disabilitynewsservice.com/the-department-for-work-and-pensions-deaths-cover-up-and-a-toxic-30-year-legacy/
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-59067101

No doubt those people who died were denied benefits by people who were really great at laminating stuff, but had no medical qualifications. Their families will feel so much better knowing that judgemental laminating ex-"public servants" knew best.

5,000 people died before being repaid over benefits error

UK campaigners condemn ‘national scandal’ affecting ill and disabled claimants

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2020/jan/16/people-died-benefits-error

Swipe left for the next trending thread