Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think concert cancelling has become far too prevalent

281 replies

MXVIT · 08/06/2023 13:41

and I think its a terrible precedent to have been set

I am probably just an unfeeling wench but I think it is dreadful how easy this has become to do, Lewis Capaldi taking three weeks off to be "Lewis from Glasgow" again bascially saying "I know you've forked out on hotels and travel, and thanks, but sorry"

For me it just shows a huge disrespect to fans. When you're a rich and famous star (all from the hard earned money from your fans) and all of the luxury that that life affords - you don't get to turn it on and off, and I'm sorry, but you don't get to put yourself first 100% of the time. Thats the trade off.

I would never buy tickets to concerts again after the spate of this happening. Adele, Sam Smith, Lewis etc.

AIBU ?

OP posts:
VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 08/06/2023 18:59

ShyMaryEllen · 08/06/2023 18:46

If you read my next post (before yours) you will see that I am not refusing to recognise anything of the sort. I could equally ask why you refuse to recognise the impact of colleagues taking months off with stress on those who are left to cover their work.

I am currently working for a department with a sickness absence rate running at a ten year high, thanks to a recent reorg. I do not resent my colleagues for taking time off sick with stress. I have taken time off sick myself. I have attempted suicide at work in a previous job and will not put myself through that level of work-induced mental illness again.

If you are covering for someone who is off sick by doing more work, stop. The missed work is management's problem, not yours. You can do someone else's work instead of your own, but you can't do more than one person's work.

I am absolutely sick of people treating work-induced mental illness as "not really an illness" or something you just have to suck up. I am sick of people treating working extra hours to keep up with the workload as some kind of badge of honour. Stop shilling for the bosses, get a backbone, and look out for your own health.

alloalloallo · 08/06/2023 18:59

CoffeeWithCheese · 08/06/2023 17:18

This. I think people don't fully appreciate just how bloody hard it can be to live with Tourettes and some of the people I've worked with who have the condition struggle to even get a brief single word out in the middle of a tic attack - let alone put on a concert to a packed venue. I didn't appreciate how blooming painful their tics could get either - it's not just little twitches and possibly a bit of swearing like the stereotype can think.

I'm assuming the Glasto focus because it's only a short festival set and the emphasis is not on him as a headliner so it's a manageable goal while he recovers somewhat.

Yes, I agree.

My daughter has Tourette’s and sometimes people just don’t understand just how tough it is. It’s not just a bit of random twitching and swearing

She finds it painful, debilitating, exhausting and frustrating and it’s taken a huge toll on her mental health.

It’s not always a case of being better prepared. Tics wax and wane. Yes, she’s learned her triggers - stress and anxiety are her biggest trigger, she’s currently in the middle of exams and she’s having daily tic attacks where she can barely talk or walk. She’s given herself a black eye, knocked herself out head butting a metal pole, scraped her hands and knees with constant falls.

I watched his documentary and I know that he struggles the same way

We’ve got tickets to go and see him too. If he cancels, he cancels

ClemFandango1 · 08/06/2023 18:52

Earlier this year I attended a concert the thought of which had literally kept me going when I was suicidal. So I'd have been pretty upset if it had been cancelled.

However, accidents/illness happens, and it's hard to be cross with Lewis Capaldi.

I know a semi-famous artist and know what massive lengths she went to to keep her tour dates when she had a nasty throat infection. Most touring artists do take it seriously.

ShyMaryEllen · 08/06/2023 18:46

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 08/06/2023 18:30

Because getting another job is so easy Hmm

Why do you refuse to recognise the responsibility of the employer not to overload the workforce?

If you read my next post (before yours) you will see that I am not refusing to recognise anything of the sort. I could equally ask why you refuse to recognise the impact of colleagues taking months off with stress on those who are left to cover their work.

Frogmila · 08/06/2023 18:34

If LC's mental health is bad enough that he can't perform then fine to take time off. I can imagine it's very hard having Tourette's and having to get up onstage when you're unwell knowing you'll be tic-ing more than usual and you don't have control of that. However I do not think the reason given is fine. You can't just say 'I prefer to prioritise other fans at a more prestigious event'. It's disrespectful. He should just have said something like 'I'm going to have to postpone/ cancel due to ill health and am very sorry but hope to be able to pick up again later in the year.

Similarly Adele's reason in Las Vagas was disrespectful. She should either have given proper details about why the show was not in a fit state or got on with it and made it work. People pay to hear her sing, not see her doing a huge Pink- style stage performance.

No idea about Sam Smith.

Hopefully in future they will be a lot more mindful of taking on too much at once as it must be enormously pressure beong where the buck stops for a huge tour but it's better for everyone involved, especially themselves, to say 'no' early in planning rather than pull out last minute. I think this heavy album touring model is so tough on artists, there must be another way if they want to perform. Residency or a little and often approach with a simpler stage show maybe?

RomanRoysSearchHistory · 08/06/2023 18:31

Mariposista · 08/06/2023 14:23

It's interesting that it's the younger artists doing this, and it seems to be applying to every aspect of life. People of our grandparents' generation saw commitments as commitments, rather than being flaky, self centred individuals who always put no 1 first and that's acceptable. I don't recall Rod Steward, Tom Jones, Simply Red etc cancelling concerts willy nilly. Young people and their me me me poor me mindsets, and it will only get worse.

Inclined to agree here.
Dave Grohl broke a leg on stage but finished the gig on a chair to not let the fans down.
Imagine Sam Smith or Adele etc doing the same..

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 08/06/2023 18:30

ShyMaryEllen · 08/06/2023 15:58

I see this in the same way as people taking time off work because of stress. Yes, stress is horrible, but going sick adds to the stress of everyone else doing the same (already stressful) job. Someone cancelling a gig is putting their welfare ahead of those who have bought tickets, booked hotels, arranged travel, taken time off work etc.

It's not a binary choice between cancelling and being drugged up so you can perform until an early death, just as it's not a choice between taking a salary while off sick and running yourself into the ground. In both cases there is a third option - in the first case book fewer dates on the tour, and in the second get a less stressful job even if it doesn't pay as well.

Because getting another job is so easy Hmm

Why do you refuse to recognise the responsibility of the employer not to overload the workforce?

OfficerPastiche · 08/06/2023 18:24

ShandaLear · 08/06/2023 18:00

Adele and Sam Smith are well into their 30s so hardly ‘the snowflake generation’. Lewis Capaldi has well documented health issues which are exacerbated by stress. What has changed is willingness to talk about it. When pop stars cancelled gigs in the past they didn’t give a reason and everyone assumed it was a drug overdose or syphilis or they’d lost their voices and we accepted it. It was entirely possible they’d had serious mental health issues. Nowadays singers and bands make relatively little money from albums and singles, and so touring is the big money spinner for them and their management/hangers on. This is why there are so many gigs to go to these days and why so many bands tour relentlessly. I’m only surprised this doesn’t happen more - singers/song writers are a commodity and there are newer younger prettier more talented faces coming up behind them constantly - ready to take their place. It’s no wonder they are overcommitted, and the only surprise is that this doesn’t happen more frequently. The people who look after them need to curb their greed and take better care that they don’t kill the goose that lays the golden eggs.

See, what baffles me is that if we're comparing touring musicians to 'other' occupations needing mental health days and blah2... There are plenty of occupations with similar constraints, it's grind and get out once you've made your money. Investment banking, working for a large tech company, etc.

Why don't performers do the same - is it the lure of the 'celeb' lifestyle (which, if they're controlled to such an extent isn't all that it's made out to be?) Is an ordinary life beneath them?

Is it the buzz of performing for large crowds?

LindorDoubleChoc · 08/06/2023 18:20

GreenWheat · 08/06/2023 17:17

It's incredibly unprofessional. Plan more breaks before selling tickets. They are jumping on our ability to accept cancellation through covid and turning it into the norm.

This is exactly what I think.

LindorDoubleChoc · 08/06/2023 18:17

Yanbu. LC should know himself well enough by now to know if his schedule is going to be too much.

OMG12 · 08/06/2023 18:15

anotherside · 08/06/2023 17:52

The problem is the music industry overworking musicians. The musician gets blamed and loses the respect and trust of the fans when he/she breaks under pressure imposed by record labels and tour promoters.

I might be wrong but is part of the problem also that since the rise of Spotify, YouTube etc, live performances are the only way for most musicians to get any decent money. I suspect the amount of money actually changing hands for access to songs/albums (be they physical or digital) is just a small fraction of what it used to be pre 2000.

Absolutely- around 2000 there was the whole Napster situation. It was clearly pointed out by a number of musicians that precisely this situation would happen, record companies wouldn’t put money into developing new acts, they’d want acts that would sell out stadiums immediately, gig tickets would rise massively in price merchandise would go through the roof. Those musicians sounding the alarm bell were crucified.

people used to tour to support their albums, the tour itself was often a bit of a loss leader or hopefully break even to shift albums. Now it’s the other way round.

Artists built themselves up first supporting bigger acts than headlining small venues, then slightly bigger venues, a slot third on the bill at a festival. Maybe a couple of arenas then headlining a fesitival then some stadiums after then had learned their craft. Record companies just won’t invest in this strategy which is probably far better for the artist anymore.

Dentistlakes · 08/06/2023 18:10

It’s the fault of his management. He’s obviously very vulnerable and they are over scheduling him. They use them until they break and then appear surprised when they have nervous breakdowns or fall foul of drug/alcohol addiction.

However, they way he has worded his statement is very badly thought out. I would just have said he needs to take some time out for his mental health and left it at that. All the stuff about being ready for Glastonbury will only get people’s backs up.

AcrossthePond55 · 08/06/2023 18:09

Shows get cancelled for many reasons, it's not always the artist being 'a snowflake'.

The logistics around a 'major' show is unbelievable. It's not just 'show up and sing'. Tour planning can take a year or more just getting the multitude of things that it takes to make a good show organized and planned out. Unfortunately they're like dominoes, if one piece falls the others follow. This is what happened to Adele's Vegas residency. She wasn't being a diva, things fell apart 'backstage' and she took the 'blame' rather than point fingers.

A really good artist doesn't want to give a half-assed performance. If their voice or playing isn't in 'tip top' shape they know if they go out and sing or play their fans will be extremely disappointed and there will be 'fallout'. Plus everyone, high and low, needs to put their own health first. Celine Dion's recent cancellation is an example of this. I daresay that this would also apply in cases of true mental health issues or exhaustion.

I know there are divas/divos who cancel because of tantrums. My son works in the music industry and has told me some epic stories, none of which I'm at liberty to share because he'd kill me. Plus that would be the end of any juicy gossip.

But give an artist a break. Yes, it'd disappointing. But as long as they 'make it right' by issuing refunds or rescheduling then they're doing right by their fans.

Firefly86 · 08/06/2023 18:03

The absolutely insane cost of tickets and sometimes sold out a year in advance! And they think an apology will make up for it? Ah, i don't feel like it and because he's a big star everyone is ah poor soul, mind yourself...
World gone mad.

ShandaLear · 08/06/2023 18:00

Dartmoorcheffy · 08/06/2023 13:50

Completely agree. And it is always the snowflake generation too. Considering the astronomical cost of tickets these days too it's extremely selfish behaviour that shows no respect to the fans who have enabled them to get where they are.

Adele and Sam Smith are well into their 30s so hardly ‘the snowflake generation’. Lewis Capaldi has well documented health issues which are exacerbated by stress. What has changed is willingness to talk about it. When pop stars cancelled gigs in the past they didn’t give a reason and everyone assumed it was a drug overdose or syphilis or they’d lost their voices and we accepted it. It was entirely possible they’d had serious mental health issues. Nowadays singers and bands make relatively little money from albums and singles, and so touring is the big money spinner for them and their management/hangers on. This is why there are so many gigs to go to these days and why so many bands tour relentlessly. I’m only surprised this doesn’t happen more - singers/song writers are a commodity and there are newer younger prettier more talented faces coming up behind them constantly - ready to take their place. It’s no wonder they are overcommitted, and the only surprise is that this doesn’t happen more frequently. The people who look after them need to curb their greed and take better care that they don’t kill the goose that lays the golden eggs.

Fererr · 08/06/2023 17:55

squashyhat · 08/06/2023 17:44

They should just take more drugs and carry on. Worked in the 60s and 70s!

Elvis got deeper into drug addiction to cope with his heavy tour schedule. His story was tragic.

anotherside · 08/06/2023 17:52

The problem is the music industry overworking musicians. The musician gets blamed and loses the respect and trust of the fans when he/she breaks under pressure imposed by record labels and tour promoters.

I might be wrong but is part of the problem also that since the rise of Spotify, YouTube etc, live performances are the only way for most musicians to get any decent money. I suspect the amount of money actually changing hands for access to songs/albums (be they physical or digital) is just a small fraction of what it used to be pre 2000.

Lacucuracha · 08/06/2023 17:48

I'm inclined to say YABU. If people can't afford wasted travel and host costs, then they should bear that in mind when buying tickets.

For myself I can't even be bothered to make the trip to big London venues even when I am given the tickets for free for work. I certainly wouldn't make the 1 hour trip for LC, let alone stay overnight.

squashyhat · 08/06/2023 17:44

They should just take more drugs and carry on. Worked in the 60s and 70s!

Takemyselfdancing · 08/06/2023 17:31

I agree op.

I have been concerned about Tom Jones touring around Europe this summer with 30 concerts in 8 weeks at the age of 83! How can he do the travelling and performing and all it entails, sometimes on consecutive nights?

OMG12 · 08/06/2023 17:30

I grew up with metal bands in the 80s, apart from Axl Pose what most people thought was a cunt they carried on,

Metallica had to divert plane to get their drummer to hospital en route to Donnington festival landed in England carried on with guest drummers step on pyro carry on a few nights later with second and third degree burns

broken arms, legs, singers with broken ribs. Tours with 5 gigs a week sleeping a drafty buses. Even death only stopped them for a few weeks

Who can forget Dave grohl with his broken leg.

The singer from iron maiden fell off the stage a couple of meters broke his ribs carried on.
Drummer from Def Leppard had his arm ripped off, adapt and keep playing after a few months their guitarist has had cancer for years, keeps going.

It’s an industry where there is going to be constant rejection constant moving, constant pressure, constant criticism. People probably need to consider whether their mental health is up to these sorts of things before going into it. Being a touring musician is fucking hard, people have misconceptions of fame.

i think you should be able to sue for lost travel/hotel costs if they cancel.

TooJoy · 08/06/2023 17:26

I really like lewis capaldi and he seems like a genuine, down to Earth guy.
I bet he wrote that status himself, whereas others would get their manager to write it or word it.

He also has Tourette’s which can be physically and mentally draining and I think looking out for your health (either mental or physical) is more important than anything else, especially things like work/performances which aren’t life or death situations.

But it does frustrate me that more breaks aren’t put into these tours.

I don’t know how they work but I can never understand why these performers burn themselves out by doing world tours in such a short amount of time, instead of spreading it out for longer.

People are saying it’s the younger stars but some of the older stars (especially child stars) were treated horrendously and many did burn out or turn to drugs to cope.

There are not many stars from 10+ years ago who don’t have a story to tell about being overworked.

But back then they had no choice but to carry on or lose their fane whereas now the stars can stay connected to their fans through social media and they don’t need to do as much to be able to get publicity.

Qilin · 08/06/2023 17:22

fyn · 08/06/2023 16:52

If you watch his documentary and see how painful his tics are, he says when they get out of control he can barely move and can’t breathe, in addition to him struggling with his mental health. Hindsight is wonderful but he’s young and will have been told what to do by his management. I have tickets to see him in August, if it’s cancelled so be it. I go sick off work when I’m not well and he should be able to too.

One of my daughter's friends has Tourette's and suffers from related tics and seizures linked to it. Started getting much worse when she was about 16/17 following a viral infection and continues today, aged 21.

She doesn't know when they will start to ramp up and become worse, so she can't plan to have time off work/university when it suits. She can be fine one week and then have debilitating issues the next.

It can be really difficult to manage. It's great he is managing to still do what he loves whilst suffering from this, along with the mental health issues that can come with it.

I've been going to concerts for several years now and cancellations have always happened. Sometimes for far less of a reason too!

Concert tickets, when bought through official channels, are pretty much always refunded if there is a cancellation, or if you can't make the rearranged date.

I always ensure any accommodation is refundable when booking for things that could change and would be out of my control.

I went to a concert recently abroad. We chose a place we'd still be happy to visit even if the concert didn't happen.

PaperSheet · 08/06/2023 17:22

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 08/06/2023 17:19

Okay but then in the same argument, entertainers have chosen a profession where they can cancel gigs and shows and prioritise themselves if they want. They have to deal with however those decisions impact their career.

Well in theory anyone can choose to prioritise themselves. But no one can then complain if their then career tanks.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 08/06/2023 17:19

PaperSheet · 08/06/2023 17:17

I'm self employed so technically don't have a "boss". (Can still get "fired" though) Also it means if I don't work I don't get paid. So while it might be nice to take weeks or months off, I have chosen a profession (which given my time again I would not do) which means I cannot do those things. Its just life.

Okay but then in the same argument, entertainers have chosen a profession where they can cancel gigs and shows and prioritise themselves if they want. They have to deal with however those decisions impact their career.