Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think concert cancelling has become far too prevalent

281 replies

MXVIT · 08/06/2023 13:41

and I think its a terrible precedent to have been set

I am probably just an unfeeling wench but I think it is dreadful how easy this has become to do, Lewis Capaldi taking three weeks off to be "Lewis from Glasgow" again bascially saying "I know you've forked out on hotels and travel, and thanks, but sorry"

For me it just shows a huge disrespect to fans. When you're a rich and famous star (all from the hard earned money from your fans) and all of the luxury that that life affords - you don't get to turn it on and off, and I'm sorry, but you don't get to put yourself first 100% of the time. Thats the trade off.

I would never buy tickets to concerts again after the spate of this happening. Adele, Sam Smith, Lewis etc.

AIBU ?

OP posts:
Florenz · 10/06/2023 10:41

How is he going to sell tickets in the future? No-one will have any faith that the concerts will actually take place. Certainly no-one will want to book trains/hotels/annual leave etc in advance, so he'll be relying far more on locals.

melj1213 · 10/06/2023 09:38

Merrymermaid7 · 10/06/2023 00:04

That may have been his words but it was time off for his mental health, have you seen his documentary? He was unable not unwilling to perform and needed to take time out. It is very unfortunate that people miss out and may lose money but health trumps everything. I have had concerts I've booked cancelled due to covid and lost lots of money on travel, can't be helped. If you are a fan try to be compassionate and empathize

Nobody is saying he shouldn't take time out if he needs it, what people are saying is that a) his mental health should be taken into account when scheduling his shows and appearances because, unlike a freak leg break accident, someone with diagnosed mental health and medical issues knows about them beforehand and therefore should be taking them into consideration during the planning stages of the tour, not just cancelling mid-tour and b) if he does need to take time out there is a way to announce it without alienating people who have paid for tickets by essentially saying "Sorry I can't make the gigs that my fans have paid to see me at, I want to focus on Glastonbury where I'm not even headlining"

Both of those things should be handled properly by his management.

The tour schedule should have been made taking his medical info into account - just looking at the tour schedule as a lay person it is a lot, of both performing and travelling. As someone with anxiety there is no way I could manage all the stress and pressure of that schedule, so why was nobody in his management team highlighting this and trying to work in places where he can have a break or ease the pressure?

It is far easier to set a schedule where you do fewer gigs but leave room for either rest breaks or adding in extra dates (even if they are small "secret gigs" done in more intimate venues) than schedule that you are more than likely going to cancel half of. Or even just streamlining the tour schedule to minimise the stress of the travelling etc.

I remember in my student days there would often be big bands doing "secret gigs" during their tours - ie smaller venues where tickets went on sale a few days/hours before the gig - when they were on tour, so my friends and I would always look for where there were a few days break in a tour schedule, especially if they were coming to one of the cities nearby, and keep an eye out for secret gig tickets on one of those dates. We got to see so many great bands that way for much less than a full gig ticket would have cost. It didn't cost a lot to put those shows on as it was often just a pared down show - the band, instruments, a stage and a hall, no fancy lighting or pyrotechnics etc - and the venues got more in the way of publicity than payment (especially if they started getting a rep for always getting secret gigs when big stars were in town)

As for the actual announcement, there are much better ways to word a cancellation announcement that don't make it sound like he just wants to prioritise one event over another because of its prestige - everyone wants to perform at Glastonbury but that doesn't mean you have to tell everyone that you're going to sacrifice them to make that happen.

Again, management should be stepping in to advise him on what not to say - he doesn't have to talk about his mental health or go into any great detail but it was specifically highlighting Glastonbury that was the issue for many, so all he needed to do was say "I need to take a break, so I'm cancelling everything until at least the end of the month to give me some time to recover. The tour and the schedule is just too much for me and I feel like I'm not at my best. I don't want to do that to my fans so I'd rather disappoint people by cancelling and rescheduling for when I'm feeling better than disappoint people because of the sub par performance they would get otherwise".

Then he could have either added something like "I'm hoping to make it to Glastonbury at the end of the month but I'll update you with a decision once I've had some time away to focus on recovering," or just left Glastonbury off the post altogether and made a separate one a few days/weeks later to announce that he was feeling better after taking time out and was aiming to have Glastonbury as his return performance.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 10/06/2023 09:34

Record companies have nothing to do with touring.

Management and agents and promoters do.

aSofaNearYou · 10/06/2023 09:09

@Kazzyhoward well, yes, you've listed yourself some of the reasons people end up in bad contracts. Artists are usually individual young people without business experience, who have very little leverage as they need a record deal to achieve their dreams and there are hundreds of other talented artists who could take their place. They're negotiating with huge companies. I don't think it's lack of engagement that leads to a bad deal, I don't think it's surprising that's the position they end up in.

Kazzyhoward · 10/06/2023 09:01

aSofaNearYou · 10/06/2023 08:41

Artists basically sign away their souls in a lot of ways to get a record deal, it often results in them being in a shitty position.

Yes, but no one holds a gun to their heads, do they?

They have the option to negotiate a different deal, different record company, etc.

Perhaps they need better advisors, managers, lawyers, etc., so that they don't sign deals they don't understand? From what I've read over the years, far too many use parents, brothers, husbands/wives, boyfriends as their "manager" - people who have little or no experience in management - it's no surprise they get stung into poor contracts, unrealistic working obligations, etc. But on the flip side, some "professional" managers are nothing but leeches and don't have their clients' best interests at heart either! Either way, perhaps the artists themselves need to show more interest in contract negotiations rather than leaving it up to amateurs who don't know what they're doing or professionals who are as keen to milk the artist as the record company!

wildfirewonder · 10/06/2023 08:46

Dartmoorcheffy · 08/06/2023 13:50

Completely agree. And it is always the snowflake generation too. Considering the astronomical cost of tickets these days too it's extremely selfish behaviour that shows no respect to the fans who have enabled them to get where they are.

Yawn at 'snowflake generation'.

Was it better when performers ploughed on through substance abuse, or performance-exacerbated anorexia like Karen Carpenter, or shot themselves in the head?

Shock horror that a performer should say 'It would be detrimental to my health to carry on with this'.

aSofaNearYou · 10/06/2023 08:41

Florenz · 09/06/2023 19:55

How do record companies force them to tour? I'm pretty sure the artist would need to sign a contract in return for quite a lot of money.

Artists basically sign away their souls in a lot of ways to get a record deal, it often results in them being in a shitty position.

OfficerPastiche · 10/06/2023 00:10

LifeIsPainHighness · 08/06/2023 23:42

YANBU

Some of these artists behave appallingly and it’s all very well getting a refund at some point on your ticket but the hotels, travel, childcare etc is not reimbursed and they don’t give a shit.

I don’t bother with concerts these days, especially newer artists. From what I’ve seen online it looks like a very self centred affair. As for Lewis Capaldi - he has cracking ditties but I can’t believe that people pay a fortune to go and see an unhygienic looking sweaty man who doesn’t brush his hair sing in a grey tracksuit. No effort at all.

It feels like the days of amazing concerts with artists who know how to work their audience and power through whatever happens are long gone.

Go to Halsey... You won't be disappointed. Amazing performer, really in tune with the audience.
I'd pay to see her again and again.also London Grammar.

Merrymermaid7 · 10/06/2023 00:04

That may have been his words but it was time off for his mental health, have you seen his documentary? He was unable not unwilling to perform and needed to take time out. It is very unfortunate that people miss out and may lose money but health trumps everything. I have had concerts I've booked cancelled due to covid and lost lots of money on travel, can't be helped. If you are a fan try to be compassionate and empathize

WestOfWestminster · 09/06/2023 23:39

Unfortunately, its a risk you take when you book shows. These are humans, with real lives, and as I have said before, they dont just cancel shows because they feel like it. Its a huge catastrophic financial loss when it happens

I don't think its always a huge financial risk for the artist/record company when they cancel, as they will often have significant insurance against this happening.

jitterbugs · 09/06/2023 23:30

A lot of the concerts Lewis cancelled were small venues to support local record shops and small venues. Tickets were less than £20 (i paid £12 a few weeks ago to see him in Kingston/London). He was amazing, so genuine, so talented but the stress/tics were so evident. He would have been loosing money on these small venues but I don't doubt for a minute that he really wanted to perform in small venues, I think he just over committed. I wish him well and respect anyone putting their mental health first.

OMG12 · 09/06/2023 21:41

Florenz · 09/06/2023 19:55

How do record companies force them to tour? I'm pretty sure the artist would need to sign a contract in return for quite a lot of money.

I think the difference now between many of the new artists and old artists is the fact those who are still going often live for performing live, they’ll stream through almost anything most don’t need the money. Look at probably the two biggest metal acts iron maiden and metallica. Metallica are astronomically rich, they are touring at the moment, two back to back shows each city, different songs each night.,I think one of their tours lasted 2 years 4-5 shows a week. They own their own back catalogue, no record company but they love playing live.

iron maiden, their singer literally went from a speaking tour to touring on his own with an orchestra through Europe and South America, had just over a month off to include rehearsing for the iron maiden show currently going through Europe playing near a two hour set every other night. Their bassist is also touring with his solo band at the same time so plays shows on some of his days off! They’ve toured every year(apart from covid for nearly 50 years - the drummer has just turned 71! It’s unlikely they need they money.

im not sure many new pop artists have the same thirst for playing live. They’ve generally not earned their stripes, slowly getting used to fame, they burn out very quickly.,Many aren't that talented auto tuned to fuck. I can imagine performing is stressful trying to make things work rather than having excitement about the performance and creativity.

LaDamaDeElche · 09/06/2023 21:27

Dartmoorcheffy · 08/06/2023 13:50

Completely agree. And it is always the snowflake generation too. Considering the astronomical cost of tickets these days too it's extremely selfish behaviour that shows no respect to the fans who have enabled them to get where they are.

Have you watched his documentary? If someone had a physical problem that they thought they’d got on top of, but it flared up again it would be a different story. People suffering with mental health problems can feel well when they organise something, but x months later that may not be the case.

Florenz · 09/06/2023 19:55

How do record companies force them to tour? I'm pretty sure the artist would need to sign a contract in return for quite a lot of money.

aSofaNearYou · 09/06/2023 19:41

People have already said my thoughts on this - more and more artists have spoken out in recent years about how record companies essentially force them to tour and they're often not up to it. Lewis in particular clearly struggles with it.

I can see why people think his announcement wasn't very respectful but on the other hand, that leaves him in a position where the only way to get out of being overworked is to be really public about his mental health issues. I don't think that's an expectation we'd have of other people in the workplace.

Tbh, more generally I'm not of the school of thought that celebrities are lucky to have a lot of money so need to crack on and cope - I think it sounds like one of the worst working cultures imaginable, between the intensity of public and press scrutiny, to being treated like a commodity by managers behind closed doors, it's a breeding ground for mental breakdowns and substance abuse issues.

Qualityh20 · 09/06/2023 19:25

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 09/06/2023 19:18

Grohl cancelled subsequent gigs though, including a Glastonbury set.

Florence was absolutely brilliant at Glastonbury so great replacement and cancelling the tour after Taylor Hawkins death totally understandable

Florenz · 09/06/2023 19:19

The best thing to do may have been for him to pay for a similar act to appear in his stead, and also to offer to refund anyones tickets who did not want to see his replacement.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 09/06/2023 19:18

Qualityh20 · 09/06/2023 19:03

Not sure how advance the tours are booked, his tourettes is recent but I would be fed up if I had tickets. Let's face it Dave grohl broke his leg 2 songs into the foo fighters set, he finished the rest of the night in a chair. Old fashioned rock n roll.

Grohl cancelled subsequent gigs though, including a Glastonbury set.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 09/06/2023 19:17

Seasonofthewitch83 · 09/06/2023 16:13

Yep, its a bummer. It's why you would be a fool to book non-refundable travel and accommodation.

Unfortunately, its a risk you take when you book shows. These are humans, with real lives, and as I have said before, they dont just cancel shows because they feel like it. Its a huge catastrophic financial loss when it happens.

You don't get the annual leave refunded, even if you insured all the monetary costs.

Qualityh20 · 09/06/2023 19:03

Not sure how advance the tours are booked, his tourettes is recent but I would be fed up if I had tickets. Let's face it Dave grohl broke his leg 2 songs into the foo fighters set, he finished the rest of the night in a chair. Old fashioned rock n roll.

Quinoawoman · 09/06/2023 18:23

It's shit, but at the end of the day you don't want your favourite singer being seriously unwell due to being overworked. Since when did people start believing they own these performers or have a right to demand their presence?

Just for info - I had tickets for a Foo Fighters gig which was cancelled b/c Dave Ghrol broke his leg. It was shit, but there you go, that's life. I don't want him performing in pain.

LlynTegid · 09/06/2023 17:57

Perhaps given all the money that they add on for 'fees', Ticketmaster and the other leeches could compensate proven hotel and travel costs.

Kazzyhoward · 09/06/2023 17:19

Seasonofthewitch83 · 09/06/2023 16:13

Yep, its a bummer. It's why you would be a fool to book non-refundable travel and accommodation.

Unfortunately, its a risk you take when you book shows. These are humans, with real lives, and as I have said before, they dont just cancel shows because they feel like it. Its a huge catastrophic financial loss when it happens.

Nice bit of victim blaming there. Not all travel/accommodation is refundable, and even if it is, there's usually time limits for cancellation/refund. There'll be virtually nothing you can get a refund for if a concert is cancelled on the day itself or the day before. Refundable accommodation is also usually more expensive.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 09/06/2023 16:13

melj1213 · 09/06/2023 14:38

But it's not just the show tickets people lose out on.

It's cost of travel, hotel accommodation, meals etc that all add up, especially as you then have to budget for those costs a second time if you want to attend the rescheduled show, and for some people they just can't afford that. Like Adele's Vegas show, people were flying in from around the world when she made the announcement - she had to have known beforehand that she wasn't going to be ready but instead of cutting her losses and cancelling early she waited until people were literally enroute to the opening night to cancel. These people were then stuck in Vegas with all the associated costs and all they got was "sorry, you can come again when we've rescheduled" despite the fact many people were fine with the rescheduled tickets but weren't fine with the added cost of a second round of flights/accomodation adding hundreds, if not thousands, to their cost total.

Not to mention for some people it's holidays from work that they then lose out on - most of my holiday allowance at work for the last few years has gone to covering childcare in the holidays (not quite so necessary now as DD is a teen so I don't need actual childcare) as ExDH and I share custody 50/50 so I had to cover half the summer/Christmas/Easter hols as well as half terms and, with using paid childcare, I just about managed while still having a few days left over for emergencies and/or to treat myself to a day off to myself.

If i book a concert and take a holiday from work only for the concert to be cancelled I have then lost a day's holiday that I could have saved to use for a trip with DD or to do something else fun

Yep, its a bummer. It's why you would be a fool to book non-refundable travel and accommodation.

Unfortunately, its a risk you take when you book shows. These are humans, with real lives, and as I have said before, they dont just cancel shows because they feel like it. Its a huge catastrophic financial loss when it happens.

melj1213 · 09/06/2023 14:38

Seasonofthewitch83 · 09/06/2023 12:51

You get refunded though so you have not lost out on anything.

He would have lost a lot of money from cancelling the shows.

But it's not just the show tickets people lose out on.

It's cost of travel, hotel accommodation, meals etc that all add up, especially as you then have to budget for those costs a second time if you want to attend the rescheduled show, and for some people they just can't afford that. Like Adele's Vegas show, people were flying in from around the world when she made the announcement - she had to have known beforehand that she wasn't going to be ready but instead of cutting her losses and cancelling early she waited until people were literally enroute to the opening night to cancel. These people were then stuck in Vegas with all the associated costs and all they got was "sorry, you can come again when we've rescheduled" despite the fact many people were fine with the rescheduled tickets but weren't fine with the added cost of a second round of flights/accomodation adding hundreds, if not thousands, to their cost total.

Not to mention for some people it's holidays from work that they then lose out on - most of my holiday allowance at work for the last few years has gone to covering childcare in the holidays (not quite so necessary now as DD is a teen so I don't need actual childcare) as ExDH and I share custody 50/50 so I had to cover half the summer/Christmas/Easter hols as well as half terms and, with using paid childcare, I just about managed while still having a few days left over for emergencies and/or to treat myself to a day off to myself.

If i book a concert and take a holiday from work only for the concert to be cancelled I have then lost a day's holiday that I could have saved to use for a trip with DD or to do something else fun

Swipe left for the next trending thread