Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents unite to tell children they can’t have a smartphone until secondary school.

219 replies

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 09:56

Here’s the story:
https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/education/2023/05/26/greystones-parents-agree-to-no-smartphone-code-for-children-until-second-level/

AIBU to think we should all be doing this, with ALL primary schools having a no phones policy to enable more groups of parents to unite within their communities?

Personally, I’d like that to apply at secondary school too until 16, but I realise that ship has sailed for this current generation.

I understand a phone for contact re safety for older pupils getting home or whatever, so I can see the need for a basic phone for calls only, particularly for rural school pupils. The real issues impacting children’s mental health are driven by social media, so it’s not just about the device obviously, but banning phone usage once on school premises for all secondary pupils would be a step in the right direction and with no peer pressure to have one at a younger primary school age, it could really make a difference?

Greystones parents agree to ‘no smartphone’ code for children until second level

Move across eight schools follows rising concern about anxiety levels among pupils and early exposure to adult material online

https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/education/2023/05/26/greystones-parents-agree-to-no-smartphone-code-for-children-until-second-level/

OP posts:
BrieAndChilli · 08/06/2023 10:41

I think that kids having a smartphone in year 6 is beneficial for the following reasons:

  • lets them get used to the nuances of communicating via text - better that they learn this with people they have grown up with rather than new year 7's.
  • any issues on the class chat are easier to deal with when you know everyones parents and backgrounds - we would all check the kids phones and then communicate within the parents to talk about silly language etc.
  • the novelty of having a phone is over by the time they go to secondary school.

I think most parents have the following rules in place - or at least all 3 of my kids friends also seemd to have the same

  • locked down so apps etc need a parental code to download
  • parents knew code for phone
  • phones locked down so cant be used after a certain time
  • phones kept downstairs at night
  • parents randomly read texts and messages to ensure no bullying etc

Mine are all in secondary school now so I dont check thier phones but we do know thier codes, icloud log in is family connected etc. We also all have track my iphone active so we can see each other locations - handy when DS lost his in a field!

I dont think kids younger than year 6 need a phone though.

Gcsunnyside23 · 08/06/2023 10:41

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 10:08

Accessing social media or using apps on a smartphone during school hours is very different to school admin which can be done via a laptop or a basic phone 🤷‍♀️

Not true, my daughters secondary school seems everything to them via teams and use apps like cahoot etc in class and encourage they use their phones to access it in class

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 08/06/2023 10:39

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 10:28

I think this is awful for so many reasons, but particularly for affordability issues. Schools should provide tablets to run learning apps.

i tried pushing back and was told they can use computer suites at break or lunch.

however, in practice these are locked so you have to find a teacher to supervise it.

it’s yet another stigma for those that can’t afford it.

we also had to buy a laptop at either £15 a month or £300. Despite all the covid purchased laptops being fine just not the schools required spec (which I get) . If your pupil premium you can borrow one - read as queue up everyday to get one, and drop it back (so you don’t even get the benefit to do your homework on).

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 10:37

ParticularlySmall · 08/06/2023 10:27

Here’s a report based on 30,000 children that links earlier age of first smart phone use with worse mental health. https://sapienlabs.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Sapien-Labs-Age-of-First-Smartphone-and-Mental-Wellbeing-Outcomes.pdf

Thanks @ParticularlySmall
Exposure at a young age to apps, along with added peer pressure for a particular device (rather than a basic phone for contact) is exactly what the parents and schools in that community in Ireland are trying to prevent.

OP posts:
Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 08/06/2023 10:36

I think this is awful for so many reasons, but particularly for affordability issues. Schools should provide tablets to run learning apps who pays? The schools can't always. We live in a digital world and are creating a gap in our dc's education if we don't allow them use of a smart phone. It doesn't have to be a fancy I Phone this, or Samsung that, mine just had cheap second hand Motorolas when they first had mobiles.

kittensinthekitchen · 08/06/2023 10:35

Or how about you parent your children, and I parent mine?

Parents shouldn't be so reliant on others to make the rules and decisions for them.

The real issues impacting children’s mental health are driven by social media

That's one element. I think, for my children at least, the failing education system has a far, far bigger and lasting impact on their mental health.

pinkginfizz9 · 08/06/2023 10:35

At secondary school they use their phones in some lessons.Like cahoot quizzes

supersonicginandtonic · 08/06/2023 10:34

Not a chance. My kids use their phones for sone school work, emails, homework.

MrsAladdin · 08/06/2023 10:34

Locally, the children with phones from a young age (aged 8+) tend to come from poorer backgrounds.

No idea why or the correlation though...

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 08/06/2023 10:33

I agree about no phones needed whilst in primary school, but don't forget children from split families who can now face call the other parent, children who take themselves to and from school, tracker aps to alert you one they arrive in or leave school etc etc. Once they get to senior school they need smart phones for learning aps as such as Duo Lingo and Century. Not all schools have laps tops or I Pads to issue to the children, so their own smart phones are essential. Parents just need to be a bit more savy. We had a loose ish no phones upstairs rules until they were 14, and the philosophy that we as parents owned the phones and the dc had the use of them, so we were allowed full access if we needed it.

twistyizzy · 08/06/2023 10:29

We gave DD a very old Samsung in Yr 6 but installed Family Link so we can track usage. We had a good talk about rules + boundaries eg she has to hand over the phone wherlnever we ask so we can check it, she isn't allowed certain Apps such as TikTok/snapchat/Facebook.
Now at secondary school the school make the kids hand in their phones at morning register to the housemistress and then they are handed back at the end of every day.
It isn't about banning them, it is about teaching them how to use responsibly and that can't happen until they have one.
DD never exceeds her data/call/text limit, half the time she doesn't even charge it!

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 10:28

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 08/06/2023 10:23

I didn’t want mine to have a smartphone.
unfortunately the secondary school had other ideas, not only did they need to be smart phones they needed to be fairly new for all the apps they were expected to run.

I think this is awful for so many reasons, but particularly for affordability issues. Schools should provide tablets to run learning apps.

OP posts:
Sweetsweetlike · 08/06/2023 10:28

Personally I find my 13 year old having a smartphone very necessary for detection of his location since starting secondary. I try not to call him on his journey home from school as I don't want to encourage him having his phone in his hand whilst walking etc but it puts me at ease being able to see where he is. I also use the parental settings so he is unable to download apps without a notification being sent to my phone asking my permission, so he does not have social media. His phone is also set to lock at a certain time in the evening (and he does not have the passcode) so I don't have concerns about him being on his phone when he is supposed to be sleeping. This parental setting also allows me to distantly lock his phone, so there is no risk of him being on it whilst in class. But I do totally understand all the other issues that come up with children/teens and smartphones.

TheFormidableMrsC · 08/06/2023 10:28

My son didn't get a phone until he started year 7. I was amazed at the amount of children in primary who had phones very young. They did have to be handed to the teacher during the school day though, and were returned at home time.

Whinge · 08/06/2023 10:28

for year 6 a basic one is all that’s needed, so they go on to secondary without the desire to have a smartphone (to access apps)

This doesn't work. Plenty of children have no phone at all for primary school, it doesn't stop them wanting a smatphone when they're in secondary school.

Many posters on here grew with up without smartphones at all, and they still desire them as adults. 🤷🏻‍♀️

CornishGem1975 · 08/06/2023 10:28

Kids don't need phones before secondary school. Mine got them when they started secondary but the school has a strict 'no visible phones' policy. If it's seen, they get confiscated.

Summerishereagain · 08/06/2023 10:27

Not all children go to primary and secondary. It’s the norm for middle school children to walk to school from year 5.

Clymene · 08/06/2023 10:26

I totally agree that no phone is needed in primary.

Curtains70 · 08/06/2023 10:25

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 10:19

A separate issue, but I mean banning smartphones until 16. You’d need to buy a licence for social media apps, so a parent would have to buy that for them and be responsible for any outcomes under 16. As it stands, apps are free and have no legal age limits, so if you have a smartphone at any age you can access them.

If phones were banned (no use at lunchtime or breaks/inbetween lessons) or other pupils didn’t even have one, that would all help.

Yes I get what you're saying. Social media is just part of life now though so an outright ban until 16 isn't preparing kids for that part of life.

Educating them properly and teaching safety and taking parental responsibility for their use of it is a better approach imo.

That's not to say I don't have concerns about kids and social media use because I do. I'm just not sure banning is the answer.

With regards to phone use at school, phones are already banned in our primary school.

cocksstrideintheevening · 08/06/2023 10:25

My kids are in y7 they have had a phone since y6. They had old ipods for imessage in y4/5. Their primary school was phones in a box in the office and only y6. Secondary if the phone is seen or heard at school (unless been told to use it in class) it is confiscated until a parent comes to collect it and a detention.

The school uses Satchel One and Gateway, not having access to that would be detrimental. Banning isn't the way forward, teaching sensible use is.

Clymene · 08/06/2023 10:25

You haven't answered my question - how old are your children @NeedToThinkOfOne?

And no, a basic brick phone cannot access emails or Microsoft teams.

muddlingalong42 · 08/06/2023 10:25

SootspriteSearcher · 08/06/2023 10:19

I dont agree with banning them, my daughter got a phone age 10 so she could have some freedom to meet friends after school or walk home alone. (Year 6 but summer born)

We have clear boundaries in place, time limits, no whole class or large WhatsApp groups. She has to ask before installing any apps. We talk frequently about online safety and how once things are out there, they are there forever. I dont allow tick toc or Snapchat for that reason. My eldest is 14, has the above but doesn't post on there and has no other forms of social media.

I think what needs to be done, is parents need to be more proactive in educating our children with online safety, the same way we would any other life skill. The trouble is people get more lax with parenting the older their children get, thinking they are independent. They still need our help, guidance and boundaries in place until they reach adulthood.

This! Kids can have as many theoretical PHSE discussions as we like about this stuff but it's only when they start experiencing it for themselves that it hits home. I'm glad my DD has had the chance to navigate this with tween level issues and fallings out rather than when she's older. In an ideal world no she wouldn't have a smart phone but that's not the world we live in.

UndercoverCop · 08/06/2023 10:24

Our local grammars have very strict rules around phones not being seen, some travel long distances to get there (great schools) do understandable they might be wanted for the journey.
Smart phones are definitely not necessary for primary aged children

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 08/06/2023 10:24

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 10:19

A separate issue, but I mean banning smartphones until 16. You’d need to buy a licence for social media apps, so a parent would have to buy that for them and be responsible for any outcomes under 16. As it stands, apps are free and have no legal age limits, so if you have a smartphone at any age you can access them.

If phones were banned (no use at lunchtime or breaks/inbetween lessons) or other pupils didn’t even have one, that would all help.

i have to approve any apps mine wants to install. It pings on my iPhone.