Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents unite to tell children they can’t have a smartphone until secondary school.

219 replies

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 09:56

Here’s the story:
https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/education/2023/05/26/greystones-parents-agree-to-no-smartphone-code-for-children-until-second-level/

AIBU to think we should all be doing this, with ALL primary schools having a no phones policy to enable more groups of parents to unite within their communities?

Personally, I’d like that to apply at secondary school too until 16, but I realise that ship has sailed for this current generation.

I understand a phone for contact re safety for older pupils getting home or whatever, so I can see the need for a basic phone for calls only, particularly for rural school pupils. The real issues impacting children’s mental health are driven by social media, so it’s not just about the device obviously, but banning phone usage once on school premises for all secondary pupils would be a step in the right direction and with no peer pressure to have one at a younger primary school age, it could really make a difference?

Greystones parents agree to ‘no smartphone’ code for children until second level

Move across eight schools follows rising concern about anxiety levels among pupils and early exposure to adult material online

https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/education/2023/05/26/greystones-parents-agree-to-no-smartphone-code-for-children-until-second-level/

OP posts:
OlympicProcrastinator · 08/06/2023 12:00

Remaker · Today 11:52
I am not fond of bans. It’s just lazy parenting to expect everyone to fall into line with what you’ve decided is the big issue

Although I have a ban in place myself, I do agree it’s lazy parenting to expect others to fall into agreement. I’m an outlier when it comes to my teen without a smart phone but I don’t ask for other parents to follow suit nor have I discussed it with anyone else. I do what is right for my family as does everyone else. If you are giving in just because you are afraid of your child badgering you for one then it’s the boundaries in your house that is the problem not other parents decisions.

Phoenix9 · 08/06/2023 11:57

Whilst I can see your point on not having smart phones for social media and particular apps.. there is enough decent parental controlled software to limit the use of these things on any child's smartphone.

Banning smartphones isn't the answer. They have plenty of benefits as well as negatives, been able to track their location, emergencies, my daughter has her diabetic apps to monitor her blood glucose. Other medical conditions are also using apps to assist with monitoring.. my kids also use their phones to communicate with both parents when at the other parents house. Keeps a track of their homework, and plenty of other educational uses.

It's not necessarily smartphones that's the issue. It's social media and message boards, Snapchat things like that are the issue and have negative links to mental health.

Lochjeda · 08/06/2023 11:57

My son won't be getting one until secondary and I regret getting my daughters one prior to that. He does have a smartwatch with sim we can call and he can call us on when out playing.

Summerdressjellyshoes · 08/06/2023 11:56

But no one is denying that smartphones can be problematic. Ads are one of those potential problems. I could list hundreds of others. You can't simply ban everything that's potentially problematic.

The reason that people are asking how old your children are is because until you gave actually lived through the teenage years, in todays world you will have a different perspective.

onefinemess · 08/06/2023 11:56

Smartphones should have age limits.

Like 18 certificate movies. Or driving.

There is no need for children to have unrestricted access to the internet.

thefamous5 · 08/06/2023 11:56

They also use google to check things like bus and train timetables if they go into town, tide times so they can go to the beach safely and things like that, as well as using them for school work.

napody · 08/06/2023 11:54

I agree for Primary kids- in my local circle of friends we've done this unofficially- all our kids know you get a phone when you go to high school so they don't bother pestering sooner. Obviously some in their classes have them younger but it's really helped having that culture of 'not til y7-. And OP I agree- I think the later the better, all practical issues can be met with a basic phone for getting in touch with home, or a device at home for school stuff. Unfortunately I agree it's not realistic for secondary schoolers- that ship has sailed. And yes, I think the inability to switch off and get away from the intense world of secondary school social politics is a big problem for many teens :(

thefamous5 · 08/06/2023 11:53

My children are in primary school (years 5 and 6) and have phones. Sometimes they ride to school alone and stop off at their friends on the way home. They also go to youth groups straight from school.

They have smartphones because they have WhatsApp to talk to their family and friends

Remaker · 08/06/2023 11:52

I am not fond of bans. It’s just lazy parenting to expect everyone to fall into line with what you’ve decided is the big issue.

I didn’t need a ban to decide that my children would not have a phone until secondary school. Actually I gave it to them in the final week of year 6 as both of them were going to a different school to their friends so it allowed them a chance to connect with the people they wanted to stay in touch with. But it’s not up to me to decide on behalf of everyone what is best.

Banning them until 16 is ridiculous and completely out of touch with the real world.

Doagooddeed · 08/06/2023 11:49

My DD didn't have a phone until about 10, a smart phone at 13, this was just a few years back.
However, what i subsequently learned was that she could access whatever she wanted via her friends phones/tablets.

U can only do so much but there is zero reason for children to be using phones in school

Clymene · 08/06/2023 11:48

It helps to have had lived experience of parenting teenagers though @NeedToThinkOfOne so I'm guessing by that response, you don't have teenage children so this is all theoretical to you.

I'm afraid I don't have much time for people judging other people's parenting when they've not faced similar challenges.

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 11:47

Summerdressjellyshoes · 08/06/2023 11:40

I don't need to look. You'd have to have been walking around with your eyes closed for the past few years not to realise (a) how targeted ads are online (b) that there is an epidemic of vaping in young people and it's a huge problem

So when I talk about social media use on smartphones I include the ads as having an impact on children’s mental health too? Parents are not consuming the ads, but might be thinking they’re across all the apps their children see. Again, you’re only ad served on smart devices, not brick phones.

OP posts:
Drfosters · 08/06/2023 11:45

The things is the world has changed and we can’t turn back. I agree about primary school unless there is a reason that they need it. Mine got theirs I think in the last term as they started to walk to school by themselves. Secondary school they need them now- they discuss homework, arrange their social lives, use apps for schoolwork. My children always load up any language tests on them and do on the way to school. Mine haven’t suffered anything with regards to social media. I wish my son would be on it less but then again he has just got high marks in his end of year exams and has a lot of extra curricular things that aren’t affected so can’t complain it is affecting him. It is now a case of working with the tech rather than against it.

mondaytosunday · 08/06/2023 11:45

My kids are late teens now but they didn't have phones at all til secondary. There was no need to communicate with friends outside school as they saw them every day. In fact very very few kids had phones in primary then. It seemed a right of passage to get a phone for start of secondary, just as it was got my daughter to have her ears pierced the day after Y6 ended!
My kids started at a school that didn't even have computers in primary!

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 11:43

kittensinthekitchen · 08/06/2023 11:08

@NeedToThinkOfOne

So, how old are your children then?

How ironic, you’re asking me to share personal information…we don’t have to have children of a particular age to be concerned about an issue that potentially impacts all children?
Or that they’d have to be my own children for me to have concerns for friends, family and young people in general?

OP posts:
NortieTortie · 08/06/2023 11:42

My 7yo has a smartphone. It was cheaper (giving him my old phone) than getting him a replacement tablet after his broke. He uses Whatsapp to communicate with his Nanny whom he only sees a few times a year and to talk to his cousins. Obv no other social media and there's a password so he can't download apps without permission. He uses the web browser to look up e.g. learning websites or walkthroughs for games but that's with supervision and is otherwise off-limits. Doubles as a nightlight (app) and a white noise machine (another app) too. Not sure how it'll go as he gets older and has an interest in joining SM.

I understand the restriction though. Sometimes I scroll through YouTube shorts or Facebook reels and I'm shocked at the content parents are either letting their child record or have no knowledge of their child doing. Plus ofc the bullying aspect.

Summerdressjellyshoes · 08/06/2023 11:40

I don't need to look. You'd have to have been walking around with your eyes closed for the past few years not to realise (a) how targeted ads are online (b) that there is an epidemic of vaping in young people and it's a huge problem

MaxwellCat · 08/06/2023 11:30

No I don’t agree my kids have a phone to talk to their father on plenty of separated parents get kids phones so they can communicate with their children directly when with the other parent.

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 11:27

Summerdressjellyshoes · 08/06/2023 11:20

Smartphones and vaping are completely different.

There is absolutely no good reason whatsoever for any child or adult to vape. The only possible benefit I can think of is to quit actual cigarettes.

Smartphones are beneficial to our lives.

You might be interested to see how the ads work on social media re vaping. Ads aimed directly at young people, non smokers, colourful and cool ads. Have a look. You could even yourself time by searching anything vape related on social and you’ll be ad served (read: targeted) in no time.

OP posts:
Barnella · 08/06/2023 11:26

I don't know anyone who gave their kid a smartphone before senior school. Phone use is banned at our school until sixth form (unless it's an emergency and you ask permission).

I don't entirely agree with people saying "phones are here to stay, no going back". While they are here to stay, I think how we use them and how we let children use them will change hugely over the next few decades. We are starting to understand more about the effects of phones on young brains (well, all our brains)- I suspect by the time our children have children of their own, the free way we let kids use their phones, social media etc will seem as unconscionable as the way we now look back on things like smoking around children, travelling without car seats etc.

pinboardwizard · 08/06/2023 11:26

Off topic, but the story photo made me think of 'Motherland' with the token dad and the yummy mummy pushing herself to front and centre.

Lemontango · 08/06/2023 11:25

I don’t think banning phones is a good idea. It only makes them more appealing to children and someone is bound to get one from somewhere and they’ll all be gathered round it! My DS has had a smart phone for a few years he’s 10 now (it was an old handset with a free sim). He’s not bothered about it, hardly looks at it. All his friends have started getting them now (yr5) and they’re a bit obsessed. Sometimes there’s 400 odd messages on his phone when I check it. These are children who have been asking for phones for ages.

My DD had a phone from about yr4 too and she’s not really bothered either. She uses WhatsApp to keep in touch with friends but she doesn’t have TikTok or any other sm. She’s 12 and has never asked for those apps.

We talk to them both about online safety and stupid TikTok trends etc.

I think making children wait longer for something they will get eventually isn’t a good idea. Parents need to be responsible for what their children are viewing and be really pro-active in keeping them safe.

DS doesn’t take his phone to school and has never wanted to. DD does and is allowed to use it sometimes in lessons to look things up. She mainly has it to contact us after school if there’s a problem with the bus.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 08/06/2023 11:25

I agree.

My son is 11 and due to be moving up to secondary in September. The rule with him and his brothers was that they would get a phone on their 11th birthday, which would have strict parental controls on it and DH would monitor.

Youngest doesn't even take his phone to school, but a lot of his friends do. There's been a lot of talk in his friendship group about how intense the WhatsApp groups can be - in one, one of the girls was calling and calling and calling one boy and leaving messages like 'when you said you were doing something I didn't think you'd ignore me'. His mum had to get involved in the end. Genuinely don't understand why they don't take the phones off them.

ichundich · 08/06/2023 11:23

I agree but it's a lost cause when by year 4 the majority of kids now have smartphones "to keep them safe". The irony!

JandalsAlways · 08/06/2023 11:21

Interesting, I watched something on television last night where the kids actually wish that phones were banned as it creates so much pressure and anxiety for them. If they are banned it takes the decision and need for peer pressure out of their hands.