Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents unite to tell children they can’t have a smartphone until secondary school.

219 replies

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 09:56

Here’s the story:
https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/education/2023/05/26/greystones-parents-agree-to-no-smartphone-code-for-children-until-second-level/

AIBU to think we should all be doing this, with ALL primary schools having a no phones policy to enable more groups of parents to unite within their communities?

Personally, I’d like that to apply at secondary school too until 16, but I realise that ship has sailed for this current generation.

I understand a phone for contact re safety for older pupils getting home or whatever, so I can see the need for a basic phone for calls only, particularly for rural school pupils. The real issues impacting children’s mental health are driven by social media, so it’s not just about the device obviously, but banning phone usage once on school premises for all secondary pupils would be a step in the right direction and with no peer pressure to have one at a younger primary school age, it could really make a difference?

Greystones parents agree to ‘no smartphone’ code for children until second level

Move across eight schools follows rising concern about anxiety levels among pupils and early exposure to adult material online

https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/education/2023/05/26/greystones-parents-agree-to-no-smartphone-code-for-children-until-second-level/

OP posts:
Fairislefandango · 08/06/2023 14:49

I think what needs to be done, is parents need to be more proactive in educating our children with online safety.

Kids probably know more about online safety than their parents do. It's not a lack of education about the risks (kids are told about that constantly at school even if not by their parents). It's that the education can't compete with the temptation and the peer pressure. Kids know what they're not supposed to do and why. They do it anyway.

BodyKeepingScore · 08/06/2023 14:42

DS14 had one in Y7. We live incredibly rurally, not only was the walk to the bus, and subsequent bus journey quite long, but he would have been completely isolated from his peers without one. It's all well and good saying use a laptop, but young people primarily use messaging apps to communicate, these wouldn't be available on a pc or laptop, excluding him from group chats or messages from friends making plans outside school. His phone is linked to our family account. I know his pin and he accepts there are regular spot checks. We have restrictions on our Wi-Fi at home but more importantly he has been taught appropriate behaviour and online safety from an early age. It's a parents role to do this, not a blanket ban on smartphones.
I'm reliably informed that young people simply do not message via conventional text messages anymore.

TheKeatingFive · 08/06/2023 14:21

I haven't rtft, so apologies if already covered, but if kids need to be contactable at all times, why can't they use a Nokia style dumb phone instead?

We (parents) are having a class meeting about this tonight as it happens

TeeBee · 08/06/2023 14:02

I don't think this is necessary. I am responsible for my children and didn't give my children a phone until I deemed it necessary. Mine didn't have one until secondary school and their school has strict policies about no phones to be seen during the school day. I don't need other people to parent for me.

EarringsandLipstick · 08/06/2023 14:00

The world functioned fine before 2007, smartphones have been around for only a short time and they have ruined children's mental health.

Oh come on!

'The world functioned fine ...' argument has been used by generation after generation about each new invention - TV, air travel, cars...!

The human condition is to innovate & evolve, so developments will keep happening, and will have positives & negatives.

Phones have not ruined kids' MH, poor management of their access to web-based content has. It poses a challenge for parents but one that has to be met.

daffodilandtulip · 08/06/2023 13:59

I don't know if it's just my teenagers and their mates but there seems to be a shift away from the massive use of social media. They use their smartphone to socialise, listen to podcasts, listen to music, watch YouTube etc - which I don't think are actually that unhealthy if you compare it to adults watching tv and reading a magazine.

Plus mine need it for their bus ticket and their homework apps. I can also track them to check they've arrived at school/caught the bus/are near home. They've have been known to be told to take a photo of things in class or snap a QR code as well, although it's a strict "no visible phones" policy generally.

onefinemess · 08/06/2023 13:57

The negatives of allowing children access to the technology far outweigh the positives.

The world functioned fine before 2007, smartphones have been around for only a short time and they have ruined children's mental health.

justteanbiscuits · 08/06/2023 13:45

Mine got theirs for secondary school - old hand me down phones with no sim for some stuff before that at home but they didn't take them to school. They don't have to have them for their secondary - everything they can view / use their phone for can be done on a laptop, and if they are seen with a phone out on school grounds it's automatic detention. Two of my 14 year olds friends don't have smart phones, no one seems that bothered that they don't, but both do have their own, good, laptops at home. Mine share a laptop at home or use mine, which wouldn't be practical when checking their classes for the day or what ever in a mad morning panic. I also use the tracking on it in some circumstances - but always ask them first.

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 13:40

A licence is unfeasible. Do you actually want your tax money spent on policing that?

Not a government controlled licence- more like ownership from the social media companies and app providers. They need clarity on the age use. If they want to run a social platform and allow under 16s in it, then they must hold responsibility. As a parent you would subscribe, like for Netflix or whatever to pay for the platforms if you wanted your under 16 to access it. As it stands, all access is free, children as young as 9 are viewing and engaging in content for adults, with ads served at your under 16s to allow them to have the app/social content for ‘free’.

As a PP said, it’s time for a reset. Shouldn’t that include age-restrictions, or better guidance for parents?

OP posts:
MoorRain · 08/06/2023 13:36

onefinemess · 08/06/2023 13:02

Nope.

Actually this is true- the only little child I know who has a phone has it for this reason. Doesn’t use it for anything else but the system has been a God send for them.

MoorRain · 08/06/2023 13:34

We as a friendship group (very close, like family. Children all in the same class/school etc) have decided no phones until year 7. The children grumble but they are all in the same boat. We also have the same rules on sleepovers/alcohol/vaping/horror movies etc!

Wildlyboring · 08/06/2023 13:20

x2boys · 08/06/2023 13:07

Oh well🙄

Smart phones and Dexcom are life-changing for children and parents in these situations. It's allowed my daughter's best friend to have some autonomy back and her mother to have to reassurance to let her have more freedom.

HazyDragon · 08/06/2023 13:19

Cosycover · 08/06/2023 13:14

Ffs

The correlation is vulnerability.

Cosycover · 08/06/2023 13:14

MrsAladdin · 08/06/2023 10:34

Locally, the children with phones from a young age (aged 8+) tend to come from poorer backgrounds.

No idea why or the correlation though...

Ffs

Cosycover · 08/06/2023 13:13

My son is 9 and I like that he can take his phone with him when on playdates and when outside playing.

So we don't all agree.

ReachForTheMars · 08/06/2023 13:11

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 12:59

I'm not in agreement with no phones until 16 which the OP has suggested is a good idea.

To be clear, I haven’t suggested that at all. I don’t personally believe that apps and social media should be available to under 16 without licence- You can only get apps and a browser for accessing social on smart devices- so the same way cigarettes, alcohol are under control by age and licence, which wasn’t always the way and of course, people still get these things underage.

See the OP article, the schools are not suggesting banning phones (no am I) or keeping young people off technology that supports learning.

A licence is unfeasible. Do you actually want your tax money spent on policing that?

Parents can just not buckle to peer pressure or buy a telephone without the internet.

x2boys · 08/06/2023 13:07

onefinemess · 08/06/2023 13:02

Nope.

Oh well🙄

onefinemess · 08/06/2023 13:02

x2boys · 08/06/2023 12:07

You might change your mind if you had a diabetic teen who needs one so he knows when his blood sugars are too high or low
He's currently doing his GCSE,s and has been pulled out of several exams as his phone triggered by his Dexcom,has alerted him his blood sugars were to low and he needed to have some orange juice/ jelly babies
It's also very reassuring for me knowing it will alert what night ,if they go to high or low.

Nope.

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 12:59

I'm not in agreement with no phones until 16 which the OP has suggested is a good idea.

To be clear, I haven’t suggested that at all. I don’t personally believe that apps and social media should be available to under 16 without licence- You can only get apps and a browser for accessing social on smart devices- so the same way cigarettes, alcohol are under control by age and licence, which wasn’t always the way and of course, people still get these things underage.

See the OP article, the schools are not suggesting banning phones (no am I) or keeping young people off technology that supports learning.

OP posts:
HazyDragon · 08/06/2023 12:55

As a primary school teacher, there's no way my yr5 child is having a phone. Just yesterday I had the pleasure of reading messages, clearly sent from a pedophile, to a child the same age. Every week without fail we have to deal with fallouts, that have happened over WhatsApp, and spilled over into school. This starts with children as young as 7 & 8 years old!

There is nothing to be gained to exposing your young children to smartphones. But it's easier to say 'yes' and expect schools to deal with it.

I have a 10yo desperate for a phone, the answer will continue to be 'no' until at least year 7.

I think the pact (or even a ban!) is a wonderful idea and would keep to many children safe. It's not just about your child, but children as a whole.

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 12:49

Things such as Satchel one, Teams and other platforms can be accessed through browsers on a range of devices and don't require a smart phone.

Great post @LolaSmiles and the other points you make are exactly what I’ve said in my previous posts. When things do unravel, no doubt it’ll be the teachers that are blamed for misuse in the classroom. I’m not a teacher, but would fully support anyone in education who is struggling to manage the impact of social media on learning and the welfare of young people.

OP posts:
littleripper · 08/06/2023 12:44

the issue where we live is that there are NO payphones anywhere. So not having a phone inhibits independence. A nokia brick was the solution for us.

Justalittlebitduckling · 08/06/2023 12:37

Maybe at year 5 introduce simple phones with no cameras as they get more independent and start getting ready for secondary school.

PurpleBugz · 08/06/2023 12:36

My child's phone is linked to mine. I have to ok all her app downloads and I won't ok any social media or harmful games that are all about shallow female body image

Swipe left for the next trending thread