Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents unite to tell children they can’t have a smartphone until secondary school.

219 replies

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 09:56

Here’s the story:
https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/education/2023/05/26/greystones-parents-agree-to-no-smartphone-code-for-children-until-second-level/

AIBU to think we should all be doing this, with ALL primary schools having a no phones policy to enable more groups of parents to unite within their communities?

Personally, I’d like that to apply at secondary school too until 16, but I realise that ship has sailed for this current generation.

I understand a phone for contact re safety for older pupils getting home or whatever, so I can see the need for a basic phone for calls only, particularly for rural school pupils. The real issues impacting children’s mental health are driven by social media, so it’s not just about the device obviously, but banning phone usage once on school premises for all secondary pupils would be a step in the right direction and with no peer pressure to have one at a younger primary school age, it could really make a difference?

Greystones parents agree to ‘no smartphone’ code for children until second level

Move across eight schools follows rising concern about anxiety levels among pupils and early exposure to adult material online

https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/education/2023/05/26/greystones-parents-agree-to-no-smartphone-code-for-children-until-second-level/

OP posts:
Idkmanbutgonnatattoo · 08/06/2023 18:00

One of the biggest things is that children from maybe 12+ would struggle to organize going places outside of school to meet friends without their parents with no phone with group chat

Fandabedodgy · 08/06/2023 17:44

justteanbiscuits · 08/06/2023 17:26

A boy in my year at school ended up in hospital (luckily survived) after doing this. In 1989, well before social media. Kids doing stupid dares spread around isn't new unfortunately

I remember doing that at school in the 80s

noblegiraffe · 08/06/2023 17:44

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 17:24

Timing- I’ve just read that the 14 year old boy who died at school in Scotland yesterday was apparently replicating ‘a social media challenge called 'Tap Out'.
The game is believed to cause people to pass out due to a lack of oxygen.’

That boy’s family must be utterly devastated. It’s that kind of thing I am so sick of reading about. He was 14😞

The boy's family says it wasn't a TikTok challenge and that the boy was being bullied.

NumberTheory · 08/06/2023 17:39

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 17:24

Timing- I’ve just read that the 14 year old boy who died at school in Scotland yesterday was apparently replicating ‘a social media challenge called 'Tap Out'.
The game is believed to cause people to pass out due to a lack of oxygen.’

That boy’s family must be utterly devastated. It’s that kind of thing I am so sick of reading about. He was 14😞

Some kids are going to do stupid things whether it’s egged on by social media or by friends/frenimies IRL. When I was in school one kid was killed crossing train tracks which he did as a dare. No social media or smart phone involved.

Just as I try to ensure my kids are safe when they go off by themselves in the physical world without stopping them from having any independence at all, I try to make sure my kids are safe online (with a smart phone) without stopping them from using social media entirely or any of the other smart phone functionality. We have limits that I police. We talk. We discuss what to do in different situations.

They may well do the odd thing I don’t know about, just as I did the odd thing my mum didn’t know about when I was a kid, and they may have the odd thing go wrong, just as I had the odd thing go wrong, but they’ll also develop skills, understanding and resilience while doing so.

I have no problem with schools banning phone use during the school day if that’s their ethos, but I won’t be supporting a parent ban on phones. If you want to say no to your kid, that’s fine. I won’t be saying no to mine.

justteanbiscuits · 08/06/2023 17:38

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 17:34

Oh gawd, you miss the point entirely. Social media wasn’t around then for them to win peer approval for trying the dares, filming it, probably bullying other children into taking part and then enabling children of all ages to see it. This is a traumatic situation for the school staff to deal with too😞

They did it for the laughs and approval of their peers around them, and the "stories". My point being, these things aren't unique to social media sadly.

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 17:34

justteanbiscuits · 08/06/2023 17:26

A boy in my year at school ended up in hospital (luckily survived) after doing this. In 1989, well before social media. Kids doing stupid dares spread around isn't new unfortunately

Oh gawd, you miss the point entirely. Social media wasn’t around then for them to win peer approval for trying the dares, filming it, probably bullying other children into taking part and then enabling children of all ages to see it. This is a traumatic situation for the school staff to deal with too😞

OP posts:
CoffeeWithCheese · 08/06/2023 17:33

Mine have had them for a while now at the upper end of primary. Their best friends moved to the other end of the country and it lets them keep in contact, plus as we're starting to allow more freedom in preparation for moving to secondary - it supports that. I can say that mine have had less bother over phones than the kids who've just been handed them over the last month or so prior to going to secondary, because the sheer novelty's not there and because we've been able to support them in learning how to use them and not be a total muppet with it.

Yes we have rules about their use and we won't let devices be in the bedrooms past a certain time of evening, and app installs need to be approved and the kids know that I do reserve the right to go through their phones if I feel the need - so no, they're not horrendously sleep deprived screen zombies - and at the moment they both have their heads screwed pretty well on. Both kids have come to me when anything's been said that was remotely controversial via phones (and it was ludicrous stuff like someone calling someone else a poo poo head over who got to take a model home made in school). I'd rather have tackled how to deal with situations like that then in that low-key way than have to tackle it with more complex stuff later - so the kids know about not deleting messages and bringing them to me instead, about who to add as friends and we've worked through lots about real friends and online friends, and really obvious things like how to take a screenshot of anything that you're at all worried about. From the kids' school there's not one particular secondary that the kids move onto so the cohort is going to be scattered and they want to keep in touch as well.

I'd be bloody pissed off if I was expected to join forces with some mini parental mafia though to avoid other parents having to deal with pestering.

edwinbear · 08/06/2023 17:26

@noblegiraffe agree with you completely on phones downstairs at night. My two have an Alexa in their rooms which they can use as alarms and listen to music on. Phones are off at 9pm and stay downstairs overnight to charge. That’s always been a condition of owning one.

justteanbiscuits · 08/06/2023 17:26

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 17:24

Timing- I’ve just read that the 14 year old boy who died at school in Scotland yesterday was apparently replicating ‘a social media challenge called 'Tap Out'.
The game is believed to cause people to pass out due to a lack of oxygen.’

That boy’s family must be utterly devastated. It’s that kind of thing I am so sick of reading about. He was 14😞

A boy in my year at school ended up in hospital (luckily survived) after doing this. In 1989, well before social media. Kids doing stupid dares spread around isn't new unfortunately

Dowhatshard · 08/06/2023 17:26

@noblegiraffe agreed. Need it for my alarm and need it to listen to music to fall asleep/relax are very common reasons put forward by kids.

I got this from my DD but I insisted on alarm clock and cd player with really relaxing stories such as Paddington, The Worst Witch (yeah babyish stuff but it’s calming) this worked great until age 15. It buys you time, if you get some good habits in you will find the lure of Snapchat has really worn off. Every year you can keep them off social media is a win, as they get older they are more able to make their own decisions.

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 17:24

Timing- I’ve just read that the 14 year old boy who died at school in Scotland yesterday was apparently replicating ‘a social media challenge called 'Tap Out'.
The game is believed to cause people to pass out due to a lack of oxygen.’

That boy’s family must be utterly devastated. It’s that kind of thing I am so sick of reading about. He was 14😞

OP posts:
Kitkatfiend31 · 08/06/2023 17:23

I have year 3 children who have smartphones and the ability to send inappropriate messages to others is a real issue. Unfortunately many parents don't check phone usage or take any responsibility for their child's actions.

VickyEadieofThigh · 08/06/2023 17:22

I'm chair of governors at a primary school. Today I had yet another call from the headteacher about yet another issue of online bullying amongst children.

This week, I watched a programme on TV about how a man had systematically groomed a number of 12 and 13 year old girls, having first pretended to be 15, and then raped them.

This week I read another article about how children as young as primary age are accessing pornography via smart phones and tablets.

Parents: giving your child a smart phone is NOT keeping them "safe". In fact, it's doing the exact opposite.

LolaSmiles · 08/06/2023 17:20

We've since had contact with a variety of IT issues - they don't have the expertise - and often haven't thought though any of the problems or developed a consistent approach - and we've found questioning anything isn't welcome.
That's a poor experience for you, but confirms what I've long suspected: the staff who are quick to jump on an app haven't really thought it through and are letting 'engagement' come before appropriate decision-making.

It's poor leadership if they aren't willing to listen to parents on these sorts of topics.

The school leaders I respect on this topic have had different views and made different decisions for their schools, but it was very clear that they'd considered inclusion, accessibility, and technical issues in their decisions.

awimbawaaay · 08/06/2023 17:17

I don't think MH issues are wholly the fault of smart phones. I think it's because kids aren't let out anymore. I see it constantly on here "I'd never let my 8yo out to the park" etc, when even in the 2000s that was a completely normal part of life.

I think if there is issues like bullying then smartphones can make this worse, but I really don't think they're the root of all evil. I think modern life on the whole is what's fucking up ALL our mental health. And I say that as someone who really hates my own smartphone and resents how much I have to use it just to function (app for this, login for that etc). Both my girls (8 and 13) have pretty much free access to them whenever they want, but they regularly choose to do other stuff. I knew from the start I wasn't going to make it some kind of forbidden fruit and it's working well so far.

noblegiraffe · 08/06/2023 17:16

My DCs' primary school begs parents every year not to give kids phones because of the sheer amount of time teachers at school have to spend dealing with the fallout. Cyber bullying, bitching, inappropriate messages etc.

I've only skimmed the thread but what I bloody wish parents of secondary kids would band together and do is NO PHONES IN BEDROOMS AT NIGHT.

The amount of shit that goes down at 3am. Kids that come into school and fall asleep in lessons because they are up all night. The constant pinging of messages that mean they can't sleep properly.

When I tell kids they shouldn't have phones in bedrooms they instantly argue that it's their alarm clock, they listen to music/podcasts as they fall asleep.

Buy an alarm clock. Buy them a radio. Take the phone away at night.

gogohmm · 08/06/2023 17:16

Neither of my DD's had a smartphone before 14 because they were still not as common (they had Nokias from age 10 when they transferred schools, remember not everyone transfers at 11!) one dd is fine, one has lots of mental health issues. Smartphones are becoming a bogeyman, when in reality it's far more complicated

pimplesquisher · 08/06/2023 17:09

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 10:19

A separate issue, but I mean banning smartphones until 16. You’d need to buy a licence for social media apps, so a parent would have to buy that for them and be responsible for any outcomes under 16. As it stands, apps are free and have no legal age limits, so if you have a smartphone at any age you can access them.

If phones were banned (no use at lunchtime or breaks/inbetween lessons) or other pupils didn’t even have one, that would all help.

Phones are banned in all the secondary schools near me. I dont agree with stpping secondary age children from using smart phones outside of school though.

Dacadactyl · 08/06/2023 17:02

I agree this would be a good thing. Both my kids only got phones on their 11th bdays and then I policed it like a hawk and set limits on them (not allowed to have the phone every day, only allowed on for an hour or to catch up with texts, not allowed certain apps, no phones overnight etc)

DD is 16 now and self regulates well. Her phone screen time averages one hour a day or less. She's popular, outgoing, at parties etc so it's not affected her social life.

Her school don't allow phones out on school grounds at all. If you're caught, the phone is confiscated and they make a PARENT come to collect it, they won't give it back to the child. I think it's a great policy.

DS is 11 and we are in the early stages of laying down the law with him. Think he'll be harder to police cos he's a different character but I do think it's important not to allow electronics to become their lives.

GiraffeDoor · 08/06/2023 16:57

I almost agree. Mine definitely didn't need a phone until secondary, when he suddenly definitely did need it (so much of the homework is set to be done online, he has a significant journey home, so he does most of it on the school bus). And a phone's expensive, so it made sense that he got it for his birthday in Year 6, in preparation for starting for Year 7.

However, I'm a teacher myself, and we don't HAVE to set so much work online. It definitely can be very beneficial to the kids' learning, but not enough so to risk their mental health for. I know a lot of parents feel pressured into getting their kid a phone before they really wanted to because they needed a digital device for school.

Havehope21 · 08/06/2023 16:47

I understand why people want this, but I was bullied at school and my phone was the only way of communicating with my mum who helped me... it was a lifeline.

Reugny · 08/06/2023 16:44

NeedToThinkOfOne · 08/06/2023 16:07

🙄 if only I was presenting a hypothetical parenting situation…sadly, it’s all too real.

Age restrictions in the very small print and very much a don’t blame us approach from all the providers. So maybe I’m looking for regulations, rather than restrictions? As I said earlier, I’m not in any way telling people how to parent, who would attempt that on here? I’m not that brave. 🤣

I agree it should be law that certain apps are not to be used by under 16s and making the app owners e.g. Meta liable if they are used by children.

ZenNudist · 08/06/2023 16:42

You police your dc and I'll police mine. My dc both had smartphones in primary. I keep them locked down. They get access under supervision from me only for e.g. pokemon go, WhatsApp family members. It was mainly a games device. They didn't take them into school. When ds1 needed one for walking to school he got an old non-smart phone.

Reugny · 08/06/2023 16:42

Fandabedodgy · 08/06/2023 15:29

Our schools recently provided chromebooks to every pupil

Within about 2 days they'd all broken the security settings and fully enabled themselves full access to everything

Not letting them have smartphones wont stop them accessing the internet.

The key thing is to teach them to do it safely and to know how to get help when it goes wrong

It's much harder to lie in bed under the covers with a chromebook than a smartphone.

It is much harder to sit at the dinner or restaurant table with a chromebook than a smartphone.

And yes they need to be taught internet safety.

BogRollBOGOF · 08/06/2023 16:37

It's the Christmas of y6 for us so the DCs have a couple of terms within primary school. That's on the late end of the school's culture

DS1 is in y7 and has my old phone. He needs the smart function to be able to use the bus. It also means that he can use the payment and Satchel One away from home. He's very introverted so isn't bothered about communicating with other people. Being able to zone out with youtube has saved us from some overwhelm meltdowns that were brewing by refocussing on something soothing and shutting out overwhelming sensory input.

DS2 is y5 and walks a short distance home. He can ring me from the landline at home and has been known to do so. If he took a phone to school, he should hand it in to reception anyway. He knows that it will be around Christmas and he's ok with that. He's already one of the last in the class and some have had phones for years. It is already becoming an impediment to his social contact outside school. The other technical problem is gaming platforms and connectivity.

Would I love to avoid all the potential problems that come with smart phones and would bans be an easy way to do it? Yes. But in the real world they also come with benefits and there are guarenteed problems by isolating children from cultural norms too. So it's a best-fit approach between my ideals, and the practicalities of the real world. To me, during the year before transition to secondary school is a practical stage to introduce them, with boundaries and support ready for them to be used. Y6 is also a sweet spot at starting to develop independence, but still being quite open with parental relationships and supervision. Leave it too late and teenagers can often go much more private.

Swipe left for the next trending thread