Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour weird about my cat

140 replies

BeingGemma1979 · 07/06/2023 23:00

So a neighbour (from the next street over, houses back and across one) came to introduce herself, husband and daughter one Saturday afternoon to explain that our cat. (I live with husband and 3 kids under 10 + cat) Sometimes visited their house, and was often there during the day when we are all out. They stayed on the doorstep way too long for people randomly introducing themselves and asked so many questions about our cat and lives (her breed, whether she has a cat flap) but thought that they were maybe looking for friends for their daughter. When they left I thought it a bit odd but I was genuinely planning to invite them over/thinking of playdates. I did feel a bit weird about the cat being there but what was the harm, she works from home, we're out? Then we started to see less and less and less of our cat, she started going missing for days at a time and my daughters are getting more and more upset everyday.

OP posts:
JackRosenberg · 08/06/2023 05:41

Apologies if you've already answered this but I didn't see it in your replies - do you have a cat flap or are you locking your cat out during the day? I've been in the position more than once of living near a cat who got shut out when I was at home and who would beg at my window to come in. It can be distressing, particularly in bad weather, and I did often let them in.

I think your neighbour sounds a bit OTT but I do agree with others that the obvious solution is to keep your cat in. However, if you don't have a cat flap you should at least try that so the cat can come and go at will, that alone may resolve the issue.

SquirrelMadness · 08/06/2023 05:29

Why are you ignoring all the suggestions to keep your cat inside or cat proof your garden/build a catio? Find ways to occupy your cat indoors. Get a harness and teach it to walk with you. There are YouTube videos showing you how to train cats to walk on a lead. If you don't have time to do this then you shouldn't have a pet

I've never understand why cat owners expect everyone else to accept their pets intruding in other gardens and houses. I have pet rodents and have to be careful to keep patio doors shut, if the neighbourhood cat wandered in she would terrify and could kill my pets. Why should I have to keep my doors and windows closed, rather than other people just controlling their pets? My mum has a phobia of cats and equally should be able to enjoy her garden without fear of cats wandering in.

Cats also kill wildlife. I am a pet person, I have my own pets. But I really hate cats killing birds in my garden. I don't understand why it's acceptable. People don't let dogs run around the neighbourhood without supervision. And there are plenty of ways to keep your cat happy without letting her wander.

If people insist on letting their cats roam around unsupervised then I don't think they should be surprised when other people steal them.

AliceOlive · 08/06/2023 05:17

Sparklybutold · 08/06/2023 04:40

I would strongly consider sending her all vet bills - even a bogus one? Then getting a new cat.

Brilliant. Hire a Pet therapist and pet psychic to explain to them how she’s really feeling.

Roselilly36 · 08/06/2023 05:03

So bloody annoying when people do this, we had it with our elderly cat, family up the road stole her, she died a few months later, and they had the nerve to ask her if I wanted her body back, couldn’t believe the cheek of it.

pinksavannah · 08/06/2023 05:03

Underminer · 07/06/2023 23:53

Get a load of frozen mice from a supplier of snake food and defrost them one at a time.
Under cover of darkness, use a tennis racket to launch said defrosted mice over the fences into their garden.
They will assume the cat is bringing them in and might not be so partial to Gertrude any more. job done.

This 1000% 🤣

Stopsnowing · 08/06/2023 05:00

Put a go pro camera on it’s collar and a tracker.

Sparklybutold · 08/06/2023 04:40

I would strongly consider sending her all vet bills - even a bogus one? Then getting a new cat.

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/06/2023 04:38

Build a catio or secure your back yard - small terraced back gardens/yards are IDEAL for cat proofing, you can get suitable mesh for it (I know someone who has meshed from just above the first floor windows on the back of his house down to the fence all the way round so his parrots can fly and its a pretty big garden!).

Then just cat proof any front windows you might want to open and keep the cat in.

theGooHasGone · 08/06/2023 04:35

For goodness sake, stop letting the fucking cat out of the house. Yes, your neighbour is obviously weird and just waiting for you to say "you know what, the cat likes it better at yours anyway, you can just keep him and we'll get another" but it doesn't need all this aggro and drama. Stop letting the cat outside and this doesn't happen!

The comment about the cat not enjoying being poked and prodded by young kids may have also hit the nail on the head, though.

PupInAPram · 08/06/2023 04:24

Most cats wouldn't enjoy being 'played with' by 3 kids under 10. The cat has probably taken itself off to somewhere it can have peace and quiet and be left alone.

Montii · 08/06/2023 03:11

BeingGemma1979 · 08/06/2023 00:43

Not pet people? The cat is a member of the family. A beloved family pet. When my five year old draws a picture of our family the cat is always in it, she was three when we got her as a kitten. Sometimes the cat has more than 4 legs but she is always the right colour. Re read the message the neighbour sent me and remember my husband and I thought the cat must have died and we had to explain to the kids at this point - imagine someone sent it to you about a member of your family.

If you loved your pet so much you would be keeping it indoors so it couldn’t get over to your neighbours place.

That’s what I find so ridiculous. The answer to your problem is so easy but you seem to be ignoring it which is baffling to me.

I am a pet person for the record but I don’t think it’s appropriate for cats to be able to go annoy other people.

Your neighbours are in the wrong for trying to keep your cat but it seems like they have been trying to tell you to keep your cat away from their property for ages.

IntoDeepBlueSea · 08/06/2023 03:11

Ok, I'll swap in an electric blanket and automatic pet feeder. ..

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 08/06/2023 03:05

This whole thread feels like the twilight zone honestly 😂

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 08/06/2023 02:45

@IntoDeepBlueSea A catio is an enclosed outdoor cat run. I'd recommend against the fire pit and pizza oven in case of feline fur singeing.

forensicss · 08/06/2023 02:34

Honestly OP, you come across as really passive. Passive people end up in stupid situations like this because you refuse to take control.

The answer is that you just keep your cat at home and make adjustments to allow it to be comfortable. I don’t know why you’re rebutting this.

Like it or not, your cat probably does constantly visit them, even if they end up keeping the cat inside their house afterwards. The truth is your passive behaviour has allowed your cat to bond closely with other people, which is shit as it’s your pet. Perhaps your approach of letting the cat come and go and fend for itself has lead to your cat not being closely bonded to your own household.

IntoDeepBlueSea · 08/06/2023 02:31

You know that thing where criminals cannot help give themselves away? Her choice of language tells you exactly what she's been doing... you're spot on.

Someone tell me, is a catio a caged cat run? Presumably fully furnished with a fire pit, outside rug, and pizza oven HmmGrin

Groutyonehereagain · 08/06/2023 02:10

I blame the cat. I’ve heard that cats choose which staff to move in with.

AliceOlive · 08/06/2023 02:08

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 08/06/2023 02:01

Exactly! CF plays dumb and claims harassment but knows exactly what she is doing.

Then pretends like she cares more about the cat.

@Revoltingrhyme I’m having the rage right now. Can’t even imagine what I would do it it was my own cat.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 08/06/2023 02:01

AliceOlive · 08/06/2023 01:45

The problem with the window is that they are obviously keen to open one the cat can easily get in, but not so keen to keep the same one and allow the cat to decide when to leave.

Exactly! CF plays dumb and claims harassment but knows exactly what she is doing.

Revoltingrhyme · 08/06/2023 01:47

I cannot even put into words how much rage someone would get from me if they tried to keep one of my cats.

AliceOlive · 08/06/2023 01:45

The problem with the window is that they are obviously keen to open one the cat can easily get in, but not so keen to keep the same one and allow the cat to decide when to leave.

TeaDrinkerAnonymous · 08/06/2023 01:32

Where is your cat at the moment?

HerbsandSpices · 08/06/2023 01:30

Don't say I agree with her, obviously she's keeping the cat in her house, which she shouldn't. I don't think she's wrong about it being your problem to solve and that she doesn't have to change what window she opens (if there's a particular reason that one is the only one that serves the need she has it open for). Maybe a catio? Make sure the cat can't get out of your yard? Indoor cat?

AliceOlive · 08/06/2023 01:28

She is cruel, and I don’t think they are allowing the cat back out when it wants.

I would be livid at her comment about “the cat you paid for.” Like the cat is just an object to you.

I would absolutely stop letting the cat out for a while. Bet she will want to speak to you then.

BeingGemma1979 · 08/06/2023 01:26

TeaDrinkerAnonymous · 08/06/2023 01:22

That lady is bonkers.

I live on a cat street, there must be atleast a dozen of them, and they occasionally wander in when the door is open. However, I wouldn't dream of trying to keep any of them as know the families who own them would be devastated if they went missing. On the odd occasion when the neighbourhood cats have been shut in accidentally, they have been distressed by this. Your poor cat.

Do you have legal cover as part of any insurance cover that you could call for advice and request that they send them a letter or something warning cat their to keep her sticky hands to herself?

I think you should try and keep cat indoors for several weeks to try and re establish your importance in his life, this may mean spoiling him with treats, toys, climbing framescratching posts and play time to win him over, if you feel like he is being bribed I to spending time elsewhere. Hope you manage to get it sorted.

Thank you! Good advice. It's nonsense about cats choosing where they live, it's interesting my neighbour used the words 'lure' 'feed' 'shut in' in her messaging to me, even if to say she hadn't done it - All I ever said was to put my cat outside - fortunately when she contacted the police they reinforced my message. Less fortunately I'm not sure she's stopped.

OP posts: