Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Health visitor has made me feel shit

342 replies

elm26 · 07/06/2023 20:18

Health visitor came and all she did is criticise.

2.5 week old baby is having too much formula (4oz every 3.5-4 hours) she's hungry and I'm not going to deny her it. I should be waking her every 2 and giving her 2oz apparently. She scared the life out of me saying if I let her sleep for 3-4 hours, she could go into a deep sleep and never come out of it (cot death).

She doesn't like the play mat that we have for her (just one of those soft ones with toys above) as we have a spaniel and apparently she should never be on the floor as we have a dog including for dog hair reasons. Spaniel is 8 years old, not boisterous, we NEVER leave them in the same room together, if she's on her mat one of us sits right next to her so dog can have a sniff of her head then he wanders off to lay down. They are ALWAYS supervised. I would never want any harm to come to her and it's also my responsibility as a dog owner to make sure he's calm and not stressed too. We've kept his routine the same, I put baby in sling and walk for an hour every morning and then DH takes him out for a further 30 minutes in evening. He seems happy and settled, no jealousy or warning signs.

The dog hair, what can I do? I literally Hoover every single day (1 bed flat so only takes 5 mins max), my flat is clean (I actually have OCD), I hate clutter, my DH has been great and we've been keeping on top of everything so it's not like she walked into a state, I'm proud of my home.

She doesn't like that we use the perfect prep machine for the bottles. I explained I can't breastfeed as at first she wouldn't latch despite numerous attempts and help from midwives and secondly my milk dried up so quickly. She was a tiny 5lb 15oz when she was born because my placenta stopped working and she stopped growing. I already feel guilty enough about this and honestly, enough was enough and I chucked in the towel and moved her to Aptamil to get some food into her. She is now 1lb over her birth weight and midwives say she is thriving. HV thinks we should be using the boiling water method.

Apparently I shouldn't have a Moses basket mattress protector under the Moses basket sheet. It's not padded or thick or anything like that, it's super thin and from Mamas and Papas for Moses baskets, surely they wouldn't sell if not safe?

She doesn't like how I held her, on my chest with her head tucked to one side. I do this as skin to skin for a couple of hours a night to make her feel secure and close. She said it's dangerous in case I fall asleep. I do this around 7pm with DH in the room with me.

I just feel like utter shit now. I had 13 miscarriages, this little girl is my whole world and my DH and I have felt on top of the world since having her and really thought we were doing a great job as a team. Obviously I'm never going to know it all and I'm also a first time Mum.

I've suffered horrifically with depression and anxiety in the past including inpatient treatment in a psychiatric hospital after my 13th miscarriage for severe depression and grief.

I was so proud of myself and DH for having this content baby who's put on weight, seems super healthy and we love her so much. I've booked in to start a baby massage/yoga/first aid and music class with her starting in a couple of weeks and now I'm dreading it in case others judge me.

I'm dreading her coming back 😢

OP posts:
Dav1988 · 07/06/2023 21:16

Toddler101 · 07/06/2023 20:27

Re: mattress protector, it's just a waterproof layer which is fab for the inevitable spit ups or poonamis in the cot!

PLEASE anyone correct me if I’m wrong about any part of this (about to be a new mum!) but isn’t their bed being waterproof (obviously with an appropriately thin protector) an important criterion for a safe sleeping space according to the Lullaby Trust? This needs clarifying with the HV team OP if you have been told otherwise by this woman.

Florencey · 07/06/2023 21:15

Beautiful photo you sound like you're doing a wonderful job, I'm sorry she made you feel that way. There's no need for abruptness when delivering sensitive advice.

my health visitor made me cry trying to pressurise me into bottle feeding and then left didn't even check I was ok, so much for being bothered about our mental health!

Anothermother3 · 07/06/2023 21:15

You and your baby girl and pup seem to be doing wonderfully. Dogs are actually a protective factor against certain allergies. Bring on the dog hair! Also google benefits if children having dogs. There are plenty. Maybe the HV doesn’t like animals - they’re just individuals so you get some that are brilliant and some that aren’t. It’s not you it’s her. Enjoy your precious baby. She’ll be on the move before you can blink. Also don’t feel like you can’t ask for another HV.

Cheeserollanyone · 07/06/2023 21:15

Congratulations OP on your baby girl. You look gorgeous and such a lovely picture.
Your HV sounds awful.
When I had my DD (16 years ago) my HV was great and when I mentioned she slept from 8pm until 6am, she said I was lucky to have a baby that would sleep. My DD was putting on weight, and all was fine. She had no concerns. My DD has always been a good sleeper. My DS's never slept so all babies are different.
Enjoy your little girl OP.

BellatrixLestrangesHeatedCurlers · 07/06/2023 21:15

Haven’t rtft but remember you from your induction thread (think it’s you anyway!!) - congratulations on your beautiful baby ❤️

nothing useful to add as no experience but hv sounds a delight 🙄 tons of mums on here have good advice x

SimonsCow · 07/06/2023 21:14

DD2 was a covid baby so no health visitors. I trusted my own instincts and it was great.

Nagado · 07/06/2023 21:14

I’m not a mum but I have raised a few babies (long story!). As everyone else has said, the woman is a prat and is clearly pushing her own ideas onto the mums she visits. You look like you’re coping amazingly, your baby is beautiful, your dog is adorable.

Also, I did baby massage last year, he absolutely loved it. It was like the baby version of catnip. Highly recommended.

SunnySaturdayMorning · 07/06/2023 21:14

surely they wouldn't sell if not safe?

Please don’t buy into this thinking, OP. They sell lots of things for babies that are not safe (cot bumpers, sleep nests etc.)

LittleMG · 07/06/2023 21:13

Op you don’t have to see the health visitor tell her not to come back. That is an absolute load of shite. Perfect prep are great, mattress protectors are fine, loads of people have dogs (wtf) and she’s worried you’ll fall asleep holding her. Should Have said you’re more likely to fall asleep listening to her crap. My little boy has a birth injury and was very ill when he was born and the health visitor kept ringing me to ask what was happening when I had so much to deal with it was a living hell. Last thing I needed was them! Don’t have her back.

SimonsCow · 07/06/2023 21:13

i had some amazing health visitors and some utterly crap ones. What got me was their inconsistency- I used to go to a walk in clinic once a week as DD had some health issues. Not once did I receive the same advice. Growth was an issue so some of them would advise going to the docs/keeping a close eye, and some would shrug and say ‘you’re small too and she looks healthy’.

housedramas · 07/06/2023 21:12

I disengaged with our health visitor on my third child. She was talking utter crap and I wasn't prepared to listen to the text book talk that was running me down. I genuinely suggest you do the same. You sound like you have everything sorted and your baby is happy and healthy.

thisisasurvivor · 07/06/2023 21:11

Saying all of this to you could put you over the edge

It's very unfair

Like if she saw something really wrong then yes - say something

Otherwise get out of the house and stay quiet

sleepsforwimps1 · 07/06/2023 21:10

Your doing great OP. Change HV. I did for my fourth DC after she was the HV for my third DC and was horrible. Didn't listen to anything I was concerned about (signs of a CMP allergy that the first two had had) told me it was colic, I knew it wasn't and got it sorted myself but when DC 4 came I rang when I got a letter to say the HV was coming out and asked if it was the same one.... it was so asked if I could change as I didn't get on with her. Wasn't an issue at all and the one I have for DC four is amazing. My first was also a pre term tiny (5lb 14) who lost weight so I was encouraged to wake her for feeds but only until she has got back up to birth weight. With all the rest I have fed on demand as you have been doing. Congratulations and enjoy

pickledandpuzzled · 07/06/2023 21:10

elm26 · 07/06/2023 20:18

Health visitor came and all she did is criticise.

2.5 week old baby is having too much formula (4oz every 3.5-4 hours) she's hungry and I'm not going to deny her it. I should be waking her every 2 and giving her 2oz apparently. She scared the life out of me saying if I let her sleep for 3-4 hours, she could go into a deep sleep and never come out of it (cot death).

She doesn't like the play mat that we have for her (just one of those soft ones with toys above) as we have a spaniel and apparently she should never be on the floor as we have a dog including for dog hair reasons. Spaniel is 8 years old, not boisterous, we NEVER leave them in the same room together, if she's on her mat one of us sits right next to her so dog can have a sniff of her head then he wanders off to lay down. They are ALWAYS supervised. I would never want any harm to come to her and it's also my responsibility as a dog owner to make sure he's calm and not stressed too. We've kept his routine the same, I put baby in sling and walk for an hour every morning and then DH takes him out for a further 30 minutes in evening. He seems happy and settled, no jealousy or warning signs.

The dog hair, what can I do? I literally Hoover every single day (1 bed flat so only takes 5 mins max), my flat is clean (I actually have OCD), I hate clutter, my DH has been great and we've been keeping on top of everything so it's not like she walked into a state, I'm proud of my home.

She doesn't like that we use the perfect prep machine for the bottles. I explained I can't breastfeed as at first she wouldn't latch despite numerous attempts and help from midwives and secondly my milk dried up so quickly. She was a tiny 5lb 15oz when she was born because my placenta stopped working and she stopped growing. I already feel guilty enough about this and honestly, enough was enough and I chucked in the towel and moved her to Aptamil to get some food into her. She is now 1lb over her birth weight and midwives say she is thriving. HV thinks we should be using the boiling water method.

Apparently I shouldn't have a Moses basket mattress protector under the Moses basket sheet. It's not padded or thick or anything like that, it's super thin and from Mamas and Papas for Moses baskets, surely they wouldn't sell if not safe?

She doesn't like how I held her, on my chest with her head tucked to one side. I do this as skin to skin for a couple of hours a night to make her feel secure and close. She said it's dangerous in case I fall asleep. I do this around 7pm with DH in the room with me.

I just feel like utter shit now. I had 13 miscarriages, this little girl is my whole world and my DH and I have felt on top of the world since having her and really thought we were doing a great job as a team. Obviously I'm never going to know it all and I'm also a first time Mum.

I've suffered horrifically with depression and anxiety in the past including inpatient treatment in a psychiatric hospital after my 13th miscarriage for severe depression and grief.

I was so proud of myself and DH for having this content baby who's put on weight, seems super healthy and we love her so much. I've booked in to start a baby massage/yoga/first aid and music class with her starting in a couple of weeks and now I'm dreading it in case others judge me.

I'm dreading her coming back 😢

Op congratulations on your beautiful baby! You've been brave to persevere so far!

Re feeding, do get more advice. If your baby was very small, or prem, she may have different needs from other babies.

I had a teeny baby that needed to be fed every two hours. He may not have been strong enough to wake and cry if he didn't have enough.
Ditto my very big baby. I was warned not to let him sleep through in case he had trouble controlling his blood sugar levels.

So very big or very small/prem babies have different feeding needs from the average baby.

Everything else she's being completely unreasonable about.

Oblomov23 · 07/06/2023 21:10

She sounds awful. My first one was, awful.

AD1996 · 07/06/2023 21:10

She’s talking absolute shit OP, request a new one.
you sound like an absolutely amazing mother ❤️
With the prep machine - they are not allowed to recommend it, as some babies have had issues with them. However if you clean it once a week, change the filter when prompted by the machine then the risk is very minimal, my DS is now 18 months old and we did not have an issue.
You are doing beautifully 💐

thisisasurvivor · 07/06/2023 21:10

Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 07/06/2023 20:20

She's talking crap. Nod and smile and get her out as soon as possible.

Sounds like you're doing a great job.

I was so relieved when we were past the age of health visitors, many of whom have never had their own children.

Report her for making you feel terrible

She is indeed talking crap

I hate how they do this 💩

PurplePansy05 · 07/06/2023 21:10

OP, I had recurrent miscarriages that wrecked my mental health too. Like you, when I finally had my little boy, I came across some really bad midwives and HVs. I'll never forget one of the HVs (as there was no consistency) was my former midwife who was utterly shit when I was going through MCs. I requested a different HV. Not sure if my next one was better though, tbh.

My DS is nearly 2 now and I don't look at them and that period of my life fondly. Most of them have no bloody clue how poorly they come across and zero training or even empathy in dealing with first time mums following earlier losses. Their criticism, no matter how well-intended, can have a terrible impact on you.

Easier said than done, but please don't take this to heart, don't make the same mistake I have allowed to happen. You've suffered enough and it's time for you to breathe out and enjoy this time as much as you can. Big hugs xxx

BeverlyHa · 07/06/2023 21:10

I think this deserves reporting on your behalf. All this sounds totally bonkers.
Can you report it?

Dav1988 · 07/06/2023 21:08

Forgot to say my friend had a very annoying HV - who loved talking about how experienced and knowledgeable she was - who repeatedly called ‘prolactin’ ‘prolaXin’ when discussing breastfeeding. Perhaps minor but even I know that’s wrong and I’m definitely nothing to do with being a HV… So a testament to how they really can be full of shit when they seem to relish telling us that they are the fountain of wisdom.

Brightredtulips · 07/06/2023 21:08

Congratulations.You are doing great. You are a great mum. All these points that have been raised are meaningless. Your baby is probably having a growth spurt considering her size at birth. A lot of them point out negatives as makes them seem like they've done something. How old was she? Is she a mother? The best advice you can get is from a mother like an older aunt, mother, friend etc. Your baby is fed and loved. YOU ARE A GOOD MOTHER.

Malbecfan · 07/06/2023 21:07

You look AMAZING! You are doing a great job. My HV was completely shit almost 24 years ago. Insinuated I was starving BF DD1 (obviously complete bollocks). DD1 will be 24 in July, she is 5' tall, weighs around 7.5 stone , has a gorgeous slim figure, is as strong as an ox and dances and coxes successfully for her Cambridge college. Yes, she's petite but bright as anything. Well that doesn't fit the lines on the sodding red book, so HV dispensed her worldly "wisdom". I know just how you feel because that was me, but my wonderful dad had my back and shoved HV back in her box.

I did get my own back later when DD2 came along and I cared less about HV's nonsense, but that's another story. You keep on as you are OP and enjoy your gorgeous DC

Duckswaddle · 07/06/2023 21:07

Yeah in my experience health visitors are there to make you feel like complete shit.
Ignore and carry on doing what’s best for you 😊

spudulike1 · 07/06/2023 21:07

You look radiant and your family look content. Do what is working and ignore that ridiculous woman. I had a dog that was less than a year when we had our last, unexpected, baby. We had a baby mat like you describe and the dog never once went near it or caused a problem. Ignore her and enjoy you beautiful baby

Onceuponaheartache · 07/06/2023 21:07

Honestly the HV is a witch. Mine told me that my BF baby was overweight and needed to be put on a diet at 4 weeks old.

That baby is now nearly 10 and only just weighs 27kg. She is anything but overweight.

Ignore her. Inform your GP that you want a new HV and move on.

You are doing an amazing job!!!