Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Health visitor has made me feel shit

342 replies

elm26 · 07/06/2023 20:18

Health visitor came and all she did is criticise.

2.5 week old baby is having too much formula (4oz every 3.5-4 hours) she's hungry and I'm not going to deny her it. I should be waking her every 2 and giving her 2oz apparently. She scared the life out of me saying if I let her sleep for 3-4 hours, she could go into a deep sleep and never come out of it (cot death).

She doesn't like the play mat that we have for her (just one of those soft ones with toys above) as we have a spaniel and apparently she should never be on the floor as we have a dog including for dog hair reasons. Spaniel is 8 years old, not boisterous, we NEVER leave them in the same room together, if she's on her mat one of us sits right next to her so dog can have a sniff of her head then he wanders off to lay down. They are ALWAYS supervised. I would never want any harm to come to her and it's also my responsibility as a dog owner to make sure he's calm and not stressed too. We've kept his routine the same, I put baby in sling and walk for an hour every morning and then DH takes him out for a further 30 minutes in evening. He seems happy and settled, no jealousy or warning signs.

The dog hair, what can I do? I literally Hoover every single day (1 bed flat so only takes 5 mins max), my flat is clean (I actually have OCD), I hate clutter, my DH has been great and we've been keeping on top of everything so it's not like she walked into a state, I'm proud of my home.

She doesn't like that we use the perfect prep machine for the bottles. I explained I can't breastfeed as at first she wouldn't latch despite numerous attempts and help from midwives and secondly my milk dried up so quickly. She was a tiny 5lb 15oz when she was born because my placenta stopped working and she stopped growing. I already feel guilty enough about this and honestly, enough was enough and I chucked in the towel and moved her to Aptamil to get some food into her. She is now 1lb over her birth weight and midwives say she is thriving. HV thinks we should be using the boiling water method.

Apparently I shouldn't have a Moses basket mattress protector under the Moses basket sheet. It's not padded or thick or anything like that, it's super thin and from Mamas and Papas for Moses baskets, surely they wouldn't sell if not safe?

She doesn't like how I held her, on my chest with her head tucked to one side. I do this as skin to skin for a couple of hours a night to make her feel secure and close. She said it's dangerous in case I fall asleep. I do this around 7pm with DH in the room with me.

I just feel like utter shit now. I had 13 miscarriages, this little girl is my whole world and my DH and I have felt on top of the world since having her and really thought we were doing a great job as a team. Obviously I'm never going to know it all and I'm also a first time Mum.

I've suffered horrifically with depression and anxiety in the past including inpatient treatment in a psychiatric hospital after my 13th miscarriage for severe depression and grief.

I was so proud of myself and DH for having this content baby who's put on weight, seems super healthy and we love her so much. I've booked in to start a baby massage/yoga/first aid and music class with her starting in a couple of weeks and now I'm dreading it in case others judge me.

I'm dreading her coming back 😢

OP posts:
UCknowitall · 07/06/2023 21:31

Personally I think she was just so annoyed at you looking so fucking fabulous at 2.5 weeks PP that she was looking to pick any holes she could find.. as obviously didn't need her help !

MammaTo · 07/06/2023 21:27

Just smile and nod with health visitors.

It sounds like she’s just going very very strictly by the book unfortunately. I’ve seen a few different HV’s and ones said yes start weaning at 5 months and the next one was like under no circumstances!

So try and chalk it up to experience and go with what your baby wants.

NadjaCravensworth1 · 07/06/2023 21:27

Ps. That picture has made me very broody! You look like a gorgeous content bunch x

babyproblems · 07/06/2023 21:27

Ignore her and trust your instincts.
Request a different HV and tell her how you felt about the last one. I’m not in the UK but had a similar experience and it really knocked me- I remember the appt like it was yesterday and it literally left me an absolute mess in tears. I honestly think that day was the lowest I’ve ever been in my entire 34 years on the planet. Youre not alone in feeling as you do; and she has been very unprofessional making you feel that way.

Please ask for a different HV or don’t bother and check in with your GP or health clinic instead if you’d feel better. That’s what I did in the end- I never went back to the first one. I’m still angry about that appt now and DS is 18m!

The dog things bullshit aswell. You clearly know the risks and are rightly taking extreme caution.
Hope all the replies here pick you up and help you see the light! Congrats on your daughter. Enjoy her and believe in yourself as her mum and trust your instinct. The silver lining of living shit situations like that is that it’ll only happen to you once; from here you’ll learn to be assertive where your baby is concerned and not let anyone else tell you you’re doing a shit job. I had to find my inner strength again when DS was about 12m as nursery manager wanted to stop his bottles during the day. It was a bit of a confrontation but I stood firm and it was the right thing for him. Good luck to you and congrats xx

Justgorgeous · 07/06/2023 21:25

You are doing amazing 🌸

007DoubleOSeven · 07/06/2023 21:25

elm26 · 07/06/2023 20:18

Health visitor came and all she did is criticise.

2.5 week old baby is having too much formula (4oz every 3.5-4 hours) she's hungry and I'm not going to deny her it. I should be waking her every 2 and giving her 2oz apparently. She scared the life out of me saying if I let her sleep for 3-4 hours, she could go into a deep sleep and never come out of it (cot death).

She doesn't like the play mat that we have for her (just one of those soft ones with toys above) as we have a spaniel and apparently she should never be on the floor as we have a dog including for dog hair reasons. Spaniel is 8 years old, not boisterous, we NEVER leave them in the same room together, if she's on her mat one of us sits right next to her so dog can have a sniff of her head then he wanders off to lay down. They are ALWAYS supervised. I would never want any harm to come to her and it's also my responsibility as a dog owner to make sure he's calm and not stressed too. We've kept his routine the same, I put baby in sling and walk for an hour every morning and then DH takes him out for a further 30 minutes in evening. He seems happy and settled, no jealousy or warning signs.

The dog hair, what can I do? I literally Hoover every single day (1 bed flat so only takes 5 mins max), my flat is clean (I actually have OCD), I hate clutter, my DH has been great and we've been keeping on top of everything so it's not like she walked into a state, I'm proud of my home.

She doesn't like that we use the perfect prep machine for the bottles. I explained I can't breastfeed as at first she wouldn't latch despite numerous attempts and help from midwives and secondly my milk dried up so quickly. She was a tiny 5lb 15oz when she was born because my placenta stopped working and she stopped growing. I already feel guilty enough about this and honestly, enough was enough and I chucked in the towel and moved her to Aptamil to get some food into her. She is now 1lb over her birth weight and midwives say she is thriving. HV thinks we should be using the boiling water method.

Apparently I shouldn't have a Moses basket mattress protector under the Moses basket sheet. It's not padded or thick or anything like that, it's super thin and from Mamas and Papas for Moses baskets, surely they wouldn't sell if not safe?

She doesn't like how I held her, on my chest with her head tucked to one side. I do this as skin to skin for a couple of hours a night to make her feel secure and close. She said it's dangerous in case I fall asleep. I do this around 7pm with DH in the room with me.

I just feel like utter shit now. I had 13 miscarriages, this little girl is my whole world and my DH and I have felt on top of the world since having her and really thought we were doing a great job as a team. Obviously I'm never going to know it all and I'm also a first time Mum.

I've suffered horrifically with depression and anxiety in the past including inpatient treatment in a psychiatric hospital after my 13th miscarriage for severe depression and grief.

I was so proud of myself and DH for having this content baby who's put on weight, seems super healthy and we love her so much. I've booked in to start a baby massage/yoga/first aid and music class with her starting in a couple of weeks and now I'm dreading it in case others judge me.

I'm dreading her coming back 😢

I agree with @ejbaxa but will modify her statement to 'jealous b*tch' - I wouldn't be surprised if jealousy of a young and beautiful mother with a beautiful home played a part.

You sound like a wonderful mum.

NadjaCravensworth1 · 07/06/2023 21:24

I have had good and bad ones but this HV seems awful, you absolutely do not have to pay attention to her. Your baby seems thriving and sleeping for 3-4 hours is absolutely fine, you need some rest too! She will wake if hungry believe me. Maternity services in this country are variable in quality to say the least and tbh you sound like you've just got a really miserable one. After 13 miscarriages you are an absolute superstar, enjoy your daughter and trust your instincts. Ask for a different HV next time, I only saw mine maybe 3 times tops anyway and my daughter is 15 months now. You're doing amazing! Cherish every second x

herbygarden · 07/06/2023 21:24

Wow! You look amazing and with a newborn, I swear I was probably in a dressing gown or perhaps a hoodie at best at this point! You are doing brilliantly, ignore the HV, request a new one and please do complain, you might save someone else from meeting her. Sounds to me like you have it all completely under control and she wanted to find fault where there was none!

mayorofcasterbridge · 07/06/2023 21:23

elm26 · 07/06/2023 20:27

Thanks so much everyone. You've made me feel a little better that maybe I am doing a good job.

She was just so abrupt and rude and really made me feel stupid.

Anyway, here is a picture of my out of control dog, an unhappy baby and worst mother of the year 😂

Got to keep it lighthearted because I could easily sink back into depression and I do not want that at all.

Listen sweetheart, take what you want out of the advice and do your own thing. You must be ecstatic to finally have your little girl! You look so pretty and happy. Your baby is dotesy and your dog is lovely! Ask for a different HV. Mine was lovely (even the day my eldest chucked up all over her!! Reflux!) but she had never had a baby herself and I think that makes a difference.

I won't comment on the advice per se as I'm old lol and my youngest is 20 - plus I breastfed and all the advice about babies has changed! I had two miscarriages before I had my youngest, and can I just say, you have the heart of a lion for keeping on trying after so many!

Massive congratulations to you and enjoy every second with your precious girl! xx

user14728317878988908 · 07/06/2023 21:23

Most of what she said sounds completely ridiculous and there is absolutely nothing you've said you're doing that sounds wrong!
I don't know if the suggestion to feed your baby two hourly is due to her low birth weight but it sounds like she has gained well with what you are doing anyway.
The only thing I wouldn't mind her saying is about use of the perfect prep machine as there are claims that they can potentially cause problems. I was quite resistant to getting one but did in the end as we had been pushing the guidelines about storing made up formula and leaving it at room temperature etc (not intentionally, just trying to find easier ways with a screaming newborn) so the prep machine seemed less risky. We've not had any problems with it and that should be down to your discretion as long as you're aware of the risks.
Also the HV that came to the house at two weeks we never saw again! It was a different one we went to see at six weeks and then haven't seen anybody since!

lakesummer · 07/06/2023 21:22

kagerou · 07/06/2023 20:38

The waking every two hours advice is possibly because she was born small.

I was told to do the same thing with my early and small baby who was just over 5lbs at birth.

I was told it by both midwives and my absolutely lovely HV so I think that point does have something behind it

As for the rest it all sounds just fine (dog hair / exposure to pets is actually great for babies immunity)

I know some health professionals don't like perfect prep machines because of the risk of them going wrong or getting clogged and making the formula too watery but i would imagine you'd notice? (Not 100% sure on this as I BF)

Overall don't let her make you feel down. It's so tough in the first few weeks as they seem so tiny and fragile but you'll soon find your stride and build your confidence.

Also a massive congratulations to you and your beautiful baby girl

I was going to type this. I was told that my prem needed feeding a minimum of every three hours.

Prep machines aren't recommended by most professionals.

But don't stress too much about any of it.

Mumsgirls · 07/06/2023 21:22

Health visitors follow the research and the cover their backs. If there should be a dog attack, they can document that they have told you, otherwise they could get some blame. They tell you the ideal and then it is up to you what you do when they have gone. Most do have children, as it is usually a nine to five job and not like the ward shifts. Like any job some communicate well others not.

Gistbury · 07/06/2023 21:22

You are doing brilliantly.

She sounds horrendous and reminds me of the health visitor that made me cry after having my first. I wish I had nodded and smiled and not let it effect me but being tired and hormonal it really got me down.

Please try not to let her negativity impact you.

On a side note, the guilt I felt about not breastfeeding my first son after he had problem latching really ruined what should have been a magical time. It's a regret I'll have for life, I should have delighted in him thriving and felt no guilt.

CoffeeLover90 · 07/06/2023 21:21

Request a new health visitor. I'm no expert but I know she's talking shit.
Massive congratulations to you both, sounds like you're doing amazing. ❤
I also had a dog, he was 9 when son was born, there was never jealousy. They were never alone together either, although that was hard at times as dog was so protective he wouldn't leave DSs side.
I also have a cat. He hated him as a baby.
My hv was very down to earth, never raised concerns about the pets. DS had 4oz every 3 hours. He slept 7 hours from 6 weeks old.
I'll ask you this, how would you feel if I woke you from a lovely sleep and waved biscuits in your face? So why wake a content and fed baby every 2 hours??
I'm so angry on your behalf after everything you've already gone through.
I hope the amount of people confirming it's bull shit is reassuring you a bit.

HighlandCowbag · 07/06/2023 21:20

I lost all faith in HVs when at ds 4-6 month check (think he was about 5 months) she asked how much he was taking formula wise and I said I didn't know as EBF. So then she wanted to know how long for and how often. Said it varies tbh, 3 times overnight, numerous times during the day and she said it was too much, limit him to every 4 hours for about 20 mins each breast. Said fuck off (politely) cos I feed on demand but she argued and said he would never sleep.over night snacking 😒

She then said I would need to wean him at 6 months anyway. Asked why? 'Cos this poster here says 'give your baby breastmilk only until 6 months'. This was when they didn't want you to give solids until 6 months. Argued it didn't mean that at all, but she wouldn't have it, then tried to make me agree to a home visit at 26 weeks to discuss weaning plans. Told her she was a disgrace, complained at the front desk about her and to my GP practice. I did get a card through the door at 26 weeks saying 'health visitor called but you were out, please contact us to rearrange' but just lobbed it in the bin.

fairgame84 · 07/06/2023 21:19

Ignore her you sound like you are doing everything you should be. Our dog lies on the play mat next to our 8 month old. The baby tries to lick the dog 🤷‍♀️ our health visitor is fine about it as long as we are sitting next to them, she's got dogs herself so that probably helps.

bumpercarbarry · 07/06/2023 21:19

Don't tell them all your business, keep
It minimal. Smile, nod, say all the things she wants to hear than shut the door behind her.

WimpoleHat · 07/06/2023 21:18

See four different health visitors? Get four different opinions. That was definitely my experience. Honestly - I’d go on the front foot. Phone up, say you saw someone who’s knocked your confidence and you’d appreciate a second opinion from someone else. To be fair, if you find someone who “gets you”, they actually can be helpful.

BlueAndGreen89 · 07/06/2023 21:18

Health Visitors here were crap. I’m so lucky I had my Mum on the end of the phone to tell me everything they had told me was bullshit. I never saw the same one twice. I remember one telling me “I’ll be your HV from now one” - never saw her again. She also, weirdly, asked me tons of questions about what it was like to have a girl after having a boy because she had 5 boys and was jealous. It was strange all round. I didn’t listen to a word they said. A total waste of everyone’s time, and money, which is a real shame when the NHS is as stretched as it is.

Mummytotwonow · 07/06/2023 21:17

My husband kicked our health visitor out after 5minutes as she made me cry. Said I was feeding my baby poison using formula as I couldn’t breast feed. My husband never ever cross but three days after giving birth and no sleep how dare she talk to me like that.
You sound like you’re doing a great job! X

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 07/06/2023 21:17

She sounds awful. I wished I'd given my DD formula top ups when she was a baby as she lost weight and was very skinny and I clearly wasn't making enough breast milk but they told me to stick with the breast milk. I wished I'd ignored them. She is now 10 and happy and healthy so it's obviously fine but still. You stick with what you're doing. Sounds like you're doing a great job. Smile and nod and get her out of there as soon as you can

Lilbunnyfufu · 07/06/2023 21:17

Ds has really bad jaundice so on the advice of the doctors looking after him I was to giving him breast and formula milk to help flush out the jaundice.

The doctors put him on some feeding plan and each day we was in the hospital the amount of formula would increase by day 5 he was on 3.5oz of formula and 1.5oz breast milk.
When the health visitor come she told me he was being over fed and wouldn't listen that the doctors already had him drinking 3.5oz of formula before we even went home. She pissed me off in the end I told her to go talk with the doctors that looked after Ds and tell them he was being over fed because they are the ones that told me how much to fed him and to carry on doing the same at home.

Kdubs1981 · 07/06/2023 21:17
  1. Congratulations on your beautiful baby. It sounds like it's been a hard road.
  2. You sound like you're doing a brilliant job.
  3. I say this as a health professional- some HV are particularly badly trained and lacking in up to date knowledge of evidence based practice. I don't know why, but they are particularly bad as a profession. There are some fabulous ones, but just as many that have great gaps in skills and knowledge l
  4. Please follow your instincts (I know from experience it can be hard as a first time mum, but mum really does know best in many scenarios). You are doing nothing against guidelines and what 1000s of mums are doing right now with their new babies.
  5. Please consider making a complaint about this woman. She has belittled you and forced her stupid and inappropriate opinions on you. This is poor, poor practice and hugely unethical.
  6. Please try not to let her knock your confidence. You are smashing this.

Your point about going into a deep sleep she won't wake up from is utterly vile, inaccurate and scare mongering. It has given me the absolute rage. This alone would be enough for me to raise a complaint. The consequences of peddling such nonsense could be significant. If you have a chilled baby who SLEEPS you are a lucky woman (totally jealous)

You are doing a great job. It's her not you

MrsLully · 07/06/2023 21:16

You are doing amazing OP, absolutely smashing it. Some HVs can be such witches, and most of them are beyond useless, which is just as bad.
Ignore and continue as you are xxx

Blueskies13 · 07/06/2023 21:16

They follow a book. You don’t have to. I had similar when my youngest was small questioning the biscuit he had as a snack. Questioned his slow speech. He was just 2. At 4 he ticked every school box. Made me change his nappy in front of them. Asked why I couldn’t give him yogurt he was under a dietitian for a dairy allergy🙄 Congratulations on your baby enjoy her.