Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Health visitor has made me feel shit

342 replies

elm26 · 07/06/2023 20:18

Health visitor came and all she did is criticise.

2.5 week old baby is having too much formula (4oz every 3.5-4 hours) she's hungry and I'm not going to deny her it. I should be waking her every 2 and giving her 2oz apparently. She scared the life out of me saying if I let her sleep for 3-4 hours, she could go into a deep sleep and never come out of it (cot death).

She doesn't like the play mat that we have for her (just one of those soft ones with toys above) as we have a spaniel and apparently she should never be on the floor as we have a dog including for dog hair reasons. Spaniel is 8 years old, not boisterous, we NEVER leave them in the same room together, if she's on her mat one of us sits right next to her so dog can have a sniff of her head then he wanders off to lay down. They are ALWAYS supervised. I would never want any harm to come to her and it's also my responsibility as a dog owner to make sure he's calm and not stressed too. We've kept his routine the same, I put baby in sling and walk for an hour every morning and then DH takes him out for a further 30 minutes in evening. He seems happy and settled, no jealousy or warning signs.

The dog hair, what can I do? I literally Hoover every single day (1 bed flat so only takes 5 mins max), my flat is clean (I actually have OCD), I hate clutter, my DH has been great and we've been keeping on top of everything so it's not like she walked into a state, I'm proud of my home.

She doesn't like that we use the perfect prep machine for the bottles. I explained I can't breastfeed as at first she wouldn't latch despite numerous attempts and help from midwives and secondly my milk dried up so quickly. She was a tiny 5lb 15oz when she was born because my placenta stopped working and she stopped growing. I already feel guilty enough about this and honestly, enough was enough and I chucked in the towel and moved her to Aptamil to get some food into her. She is now 1lb over her birth weight and midwives say she is thriving. HV thinks we should be using the boiling water method.

Apparently I shouldn't have a Moses basket mattress protector under the Moses basket sheet. It's not padded or thick or anything like that, it's super thin and from Mamas and Papas for Moses baskets, surely they wouldn't sell if not safe?

She doesn't like how I held her, on my chest with her head tucked to one side. I do this as skin to skin for a couple of hours a night to make her feel secure and close. She said it's dangerous in case I fall asleep. I do this around 7pm with DH in the room with me.

I just feel like utter shit now. I had 13 miscarriages, this little girl is my whole world and my DH and I have felt on top of the world since having her and really thought we were doing a great job as a team. Obviously I'm never going to know it all and I'm also a first time Mum.

I've suffered horrifically with depression and anxiety in the past including inpatient treatment in a psychiatric hospital after my 13th miscarriage for severe depression and grief.

I was so proud of myself and DH for having this content baby who's put on weight, seems super healthy and we love her so much. I've booked in to start a baby massage/yoga/first aid and music class with her starting in a couple of weeks and now I'm dreading it in case others judge me.

I'm dreading her coming back 😢

OP posts:
Dogbasket · 07/06/2023 22:31

You poor thing! I am so cross for you. I’m in my 50s and my advice is really don’t worry about being nice all the time, you are under no obligation to let a HV into your home. This person sounds deeply unpleasant. Trust your own mothering instincts and enjoy your baby.

I have 3 grown up kids and had one nasty HV, one sensible HV and didn’t bother the third time. For the third one I just had the baby weighed at local clinic (it had a regular come weigh your baby session with midwives or nurses can’t remember).

Seems to me you are doing a great job.

Museya15 · 07/06/2023 22:30

I bet you're doing great, thats really awful she was so picky. I remember the HV asking me if I was going to get rid of my cats as they spread disease, I still have my cats, they sniffed my newborn, she played on the carpet, never had a problem.

ToneDeath · 07/06/2023 22:30

I don't have much to add that hasn't been said but I just wanted to stop by and say that you look bloody amazing. 2.5 weeks pp, I looked more like your dog.

RobertJohnsonsShoes · 07/06/2023 22:28

I was open to the mental health team when pregnant. Refused to see any health visitors after the initial couple of months after birth. No repercussions here! Similar experience to you and just decided I wasn't going through that again.

lindyloo57 · 07/06/2023 22:28

You're doing a great job, the every 2 hour feeds could be because your baby is light in weight, when I had my daughter, she only weight 3.5 pounds born 6 weeks early, when I could take her home when she weighed 5lbs, I had to feed every 2 hours small meals , as a normal feed she would bring in all up, the midwife said because she is small her tummy couldn't take a full feed yet.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 07/06/2023 22:28

When I had DD1 I was asked to show the HV how I made up bottles.
With DD2, another made an unkind/unhelpful remark and I literally showed her the door.
The same one told a friend of mine thar her house was too tidy, she wouldn't be able to keep it up, and it was a sign of pnd. This was a woman who had had numerous miscarriages and literally had spent 12 weeks in hospital on bed rest.
Honestly, it sounds like you are doing brilliantly. Keep on doing it.

Starlightstarbright1 · 07/06/2023 22:27

What a stunning photo …

I had a mh history prior to giving birth so get why you want to not look suspicious .

I had 4 Hv’s in my Ds’s first 2 years for various reasons one left- one was dire but then moved twice . They alll I would say we’re different. The third was amazing.. so they do vary..

trust your instincts .

my Ds had jaundice so needed waking every 3 hours 2 seems excessive. If baby keeping down the 3 1/2 oz if they are you are fine

..
Enjoy the baby you have wanted so badly

Ivyiris · 07/06/2023 22:25

You are doing amazing. I would request another HV and make a complaint.

Perfectpeonies · 07/06/2023 22:24

Absolutely shocked at the quite frankly dangerous advice being spouted on this thread. Please op, use reputable sources to research further regarding feeding amounts and frequency, mattress protecter and the prep machine.

pitterypattery00 · 07/06/2023 22:22

Ask for a different HV, they are really not all like this. Mine was a fantastic support and immediately took steps to address the feeding issues we were having - which the midwives had been no help with at all.

The advice to wake baby after a couple of hours to feed may well be because your baby was low birth weight. I'm no expert, but I do know of others given that advice and their babies were small/premature.

You're doing an amazing job, don't let this one person put you off asking for help/advice if you need it.

madeleine85 · 07/06/2023 22:21

What a beautiful little family, congratulations OP!! You have one very proud looking pup sibling :)

BotterMon · 07/06/2023 22:21

Beautiful photo OP - you're doing great! Health visitor sounds like a miserable so and so and also talks shite.

Maray1967 · 07/06/2023 22:20

What on earth have I just read? Babies to be woken and fed every two hours? Utter nonsense. I had mine on every 3 to 4 hours within about a week of birth. My excellent HV taught me how to stretch the gap between feeds at night so by 4 weeks I could get 5-6 hours of sleep in, with DS1 at least. Mine were on only 6 or 7 bottles but of 4 or more ounces each time very early. My HV was supportive and very practical - yours sounds awful.

I don’t know anything about perfect prep machines other than my niece has one for her baby. The HV can give her views - but I’d just crack on, if I were you.

HV with DS2 was useless- frightened the life out of me after measuring his head at 8 months and saying it was too small only for specialist to say he was fine. If I’d had a third I would have avoided visits.

Scirocco · 07/06/2023 22:19

She sounds awful and honestly it sounds like you're a great mum! Your little girl and your dog look so cute. Ignore her, complain if you feel up to it, and go along to your planned activities where you'll meet lots more of us who have had similarly awful HV experiences!

Hiddenvoice · 07/06/2023 22:19

As pp said, please ignore her! I had two hv’s, the first one hated the perfect prep machine and the explained how to ‘properly make bottles’. The second one said she didn’t mind it but actually showed me how to properly clean it to avoid any bacteria build up. She then offered advice on how to feed on demand as my baby didn’t show any feeding queues.

I was told that once my baby has regained her lair birth weight then I could do responsive feeding. So if she was asleep then I’d let her sleep and feed her when she woke up. If she wanted more milk an hour after feeding then give it to her. My hv actively encouraged me not to wake my baby for milk unless she wasn’t feeding and gaining weight.

I also have a dog and had a soft playmat on the floor. The hv just did the normal friendly reminder to not let the dog lie on the mat and to always keep watch. She said it was a tick box that they had to complete but as she got to know us, she realised that the dog and babt were never left alone and that my dog liked to keep herself separate.

The most important thing is that your hv should never have made you feel that way today. She may have been saying things in too harsh a tone and giving some outdated advice but really, there was no need tk upset you.
You can opt out of hv but I would suggest you sleep on it and then contact the hv department and ask to speak to someone else. You can ask to change hv. My friend asked to change for a very similar reason, it wasn’t questioned when she explained how awful she had been feeling. The next time someone new came out and they gelled much better.

sr92 · 07/06/2023 22:16

HV can be idiots. Some of them are so stuck in old wives tales and such old ways. Please don't listen to any of the advice she's given. This is coming from a mum of 2 and you will always come across the odd person like this. Don't be disheartened mama! And you most likely won't be seeing her again, so many HV are changing every appointment. As long as baby is fed and happy and safe that's all that matters! Please if you need to talk more you can always phone and request to see another HV for peace of mind and I'm sure the next one will be lovely!

MrsO3 · 07/06/2023 22:15

I’m SO sorry this has happened, she sounds awful. However, she is so irrelevant, honestly. You’re 2.5 weeks into this crazy but beautiful journey called motherhood. Everything feels overwhelming, including this incredibly horrible woman coming into your home and criticising you but I can tell you now that in 10 years time, even 1 year’s time, maybe even in 3 month’s time, you will look back and think to yourself “why did I let her bother me?” Only YOU are your baby’s mum and YOU know best. You’ve got this, keep going and as hard as it is PLEASE don’t let her get you down x

Sunshineishere1988 · 07/06/2023 22:15

My Health Visitor loved the prep machine (it had just come out when we got one and she was amazed by it). I bottle fed, Health Vistor never said anything and both kids slept on their front from when I knew they could easily move their heads (they would not sleep any other way). They still sleep exactly the same way years down the line.

Absolutely do not let her back in, get your DH to write an email listing everything you have said (you enjoy your time with your baby, dont waste a second stressing over this opinionated person) and tell them you will only see another Health Visitor (if you need one at all). It sounds like you are doing brilliant job as it is.

Heatherjayne1972 · 07/06/2023 22:14

HV visits are not compulsory

sounds like your doing fantastically
nothing wrong with anything you said you’re doing op
you are mummy -you know your baby better than anyone
keep doing what you’re doing

Perfectpeonies · 07/06/2023 22:14

Midiwidi · 07/06/2023 21:56

I’m a healthcare professional not HV but do a similar role, not in UK. Your HV is offering good advice just maybe her approach is a bit harsh.
i would say before you discard that valuable support research her advice.
perfect prep machines are not advised where I live either. If made correctly with the cooled boiled water method you know that the water is hot enough to kill bacteria that can multiply in the formula when you open the container, as it’s no longer sterile. The temperature is not guaranteed with the machines. The tubing can become contaminated but you can’t see it as they are internal. Several cases of machines found to have black mould in the tubing.

4 oz of formula is a large volume for a baby born less than 6 lbs. And 4 hours is a long time as their digestive systems are very quick.

look up the advice from the Lulaby trust on bedding advice. takes seconds to change a bed sheet.

I would rather see a house with a bit of mess than a spotless house. Babies come with clutter and I’d rather mums spend time playing with their babies than cleaning a house before I visit.

lying on your chest is technically them sleeping on their tummy and it’s well known that sleeping on their tummy’s can increase the risk of SIDS significantly (unfortunately this can happen when on parents chests too).

dogs are unpredictable and she’s right to offer words of caution. I find the cry of a baby can be distressing and dogs even more so, not leaving them alone is wise but she needs to advise you.

Congratulations on your baby and try enjoy your time together. Please talk to your Gp if your anxiety worsens, unfortunately your higher risk of postnatal depression if you have a history.

I would give her a second chance. She’s trained to assess how your baby grows and develops for the next few years.
Each week for example I send at least one referral for suspected Autism, the earlier it’s identified the better the outcome for the child and the right services get involved.

I hope I am not scaring you , just reassuring you that your HV is providing safe health promotion advice.

and this. All excellent advice

Tappetytap · 07/06/2023 22:13

Nod and smile. Nod and smile. Then ignore everything she's said and go with your mothers instinct. Gets them out the door quicker and they leave you alone. I had an extremely patronising HV on my first. The second and third babies I'd moved house and that team was absolutely wonderful. Really supportive and not patronising in the slightest. It's the luck of the drawer but she needs to get back in her box. Definitely complain about how she made you feel.

Perfectpeonies · 07/06/2023 22:10

ReadingSoManyThreads · 07/06/2023 21:55

Hi @elm26 , congratulations on your beautiful new baby.

Believe me, I am NO fan of HV's, they talk so much shite, however, there are a couple of points that she is right on. Firstly, I say this as a qualified Food Safety Consultant, Perfect Prep machines are dangerous and have been proven so via laboratory testing. It is imperative that the bacteria within the formula powder are killed which is why using boiling water from the kettle is the safest method. This is to prevent your little baby getting food poisoning from the formula as it does contain food poisoning bacteria prior to it being sterilised with the boiling water.

Secondly, babies should be fed little and often, this is to prevent SIDS. 4oz is way too much to give a newborn as a feed. At two weeks old, 2oz every 2 hours is much safer. When babies are overfed formula, they can go into a very deep sleep due to their little bodies struggling to process such a big feed and this prevents them from waking frequently. Waking frequently is an inbuilt protection to prevent SIDS.

I hope you do not take offense to this information, I just felt it was too important not to comment.

Wishing you well.

Please heed this advice. I would also remove the mattered protecter. Many many companies sell things that are unsafe, please don’t make the mistake of believing that just because something is sold = safe.

Tophy124 · 07/06/2023 22:08

Perfect prep machines are dangerous! Google the lawsuits. I’d switch to the boiling water method. Otherwise everything else sounds ok!

DoingSomethingUnholy · 07/06/2023 22:07

Mumtobabyhavoc · 07/06/2023 21:06

@elm26 First, congratulations on your rainbow baby. 💐

I am so sorry, especially after all you've been through, that you received such harsh comments from your HV. Can you request a new HV? I think I'd insist on it via their manager.

My LO was just 6.25lbs and developed a life threatening infection shortly after birth. The paediatrician and midwives after that told me the goal was to get to double birth weight quickly and to feed every 2-3 hours and wake if necessary to feed. So, I set alarms throughout the night and did that. I gave LO as much formula as baby wanted, too.

I did boil the kettle on the stove (my electric kettle shuts off at just boiling) for at least five mins so water was safely sterilized as a "just to be extra safe" measure. Immune systems are not developed so didn't take chances that way. I would then transfer water to my kettle and use it for the day as the kettle has temp settings so I could warm water to mix with formula on demand (discard after 24 hours to avoid bacteria).

I also co-slept A LOT. Skin to skin, propped up a bit, with pillows beside me as well to prevent arms dropping, but I don't tend to move when I sleep so felt very safe doing this.

I wonder if HV meant to be so harsh or if it was perceived that way as no doubt you're in a fragile state pp. A bit of both? Regardless, a new HV would be a fresh start.

You sound like you're doing great! Good instincts and bonding. Again, a very heartfelt congratulations on your much loved and dearly wanted baby. 💐💖

I didn't formula feed (well I did top one of my kids up with 1 feed a day when I had a bumpy start for a few weeks) but even i know that you aren't meant to use pre-boiled/reheated water. It needs to be 70 degrees when you mix with the formula and the water should be fresh from the tap and only boiled once, then feed made. Boiling water for 5 minutes to transfer to a kettle, let it cool again, then reheat to mix with formula repeatedly throughout the day really isn't the safest way to make formula 😬.

ginswinger · 07/06/2023 22:07

I don't know if this is going to help but on one of my HV visits, I managed to lock myself out of my house with my 1 week old fast asleep in the middle of my bed. HV arrived literally as the front door slammed with me on the wrong side (I was putting some rubbish in the bin). A kind man was roped in to shimmy over the back fence and through a window to open the back door.

You are doing an amazing job xxx

Swipe left for the next trending thread