Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Health visitor has made me feel shit

342 replies

elm26 · 07/06/2023 20:18

Health visitor came and all she did is criticise.

2.5 week old baby is having too much formula (4oz every 3.5-4 hours) she's hungry and I'm not going to deny her it. I should be waking her every 2 and giving her 2oz apparently. She scared the life out of me saying if I let her sleep for 3-4 hours, she could go into a deep sleep and never come out of it (cot death).

She doesn't like the play mat that we have for her (just one of those soft ones with toys above) as we have a spaniel and apparently she should never be on the floor as we have a dog including for dog hair reasons. Spaniel is 8 years old, not boisterous, we NEVER leave them in the same room together, if she's on her mat one of us sits right next to her so dog can have a sniff of her head then he wanders off to lay down. They are ALWAYS supervised. I would never want any harm to come to her and it's also my responsibility as a dog owner to make sure he's calm and not stressed too. We've kept his routine the same, I put baby in sling and walk for an hour every morning and then DH takes him out for a further 30 minutes in evening. He seems happy and settled, no jealousy or warning signs.

The dog hair, what can I do? I literally Hoover every single day (1 bed flat so only takes 5 mins max), my flat is clean (I actually have OCD), I hate clutter, my DH has been great and we've been keeping on top of everything so it's not like she walked into a state, I'm proud of my home.

She doesn't like that we use the perfect prep machine for the bottles. I explained I can't breastfeed as at first she wouldn't latch despite numerous attempts and help from midwives and secondly my milk dried up so quickly. She was a tiny 5lb 15oz when she was born because my placenta stopped working and she stopped growing. I already feel guilty enough about this and honestly, enough was enough and I chucked in the towel and moved her to Aptamil to get some food into her. She is now 1lb over her birth weight and midwives say she is thriving. HV thinks we should be using the boiling water method.

Apparently I shouldn't have a Moses basket mattress protector under the Moses basket sheet. It's not padded or thick or anything like that, it's super thin and from Mamas and Papas for Moses baskets, surely they wouldn't sell if not safe?

She doesn't like how I held her, on my chest with her head tucked to one side. I do this as skin to skin for a couple of hours a night to make her feel secure and close. She said it's dangerous in case I fall asleep. I do this around 7pm with DH in the room with me.

I just feel like utter shit now. I had 13 miscarriages, this little girl is my whole world and my DH and I have felt on top of the world since having her and really thought we were doing a great job as a team. Obviously I'm never going to know it all and I'm also a first time Mum.

I've suffered horrifically with depression and anxiety in the past including inpatient treatment in a psychiatric hospital after my 13th miscarriage for severe depression and grief.

I was so proud of myself and DH for having this content baby who's put on weight, seems super healthy and we love her so much. I've booked in to start a baby massage/yoga/first aid and music class with her starting in a couple of weeks and now I'm dreading it in case others judge me.

I'm dreading her coming back 😢

OP posts:
OfTheNight · 08/06/2023 08:45

Tell her not to bother coming back! Honestly OP, she’s just waffling nonsense.

I was really lucky with my HV as she was lovely. We have a Labrador who was 2 when DS was born and the shedding 😱. But HV didn’t bat an eyelid and instead concentrated on how the dog could help me battle me PND and how, in the future, she would be a great playmate for DS. She was right as they’re inseparable.

You’re doing amazing! Just keep going 💐

SunnySaturdayMorning · 08/06/2023 08:38

londonrach · 08/06/2023 08:31

Op out of the HV. My HV set up my perfect prep for me. MN seemed shocked when I've mentioned it before but the HV in our area support the mum. Your HV isn't doing that. She sounds awful. You are doing so well. Congratulations on your little girl and keep doing what you are x

No health professional should “support” a mum when it comes to unsafe practices. That isn’t doing their job and your HV was in the wrong.

They're not there to be your friend, they’re there to advise you on what’s safe and what isn’t, and then if you choose to take the risk with your baby that’s on you.

londonrach · 08/06/2023 08:31

Op out of the HV. My HV set up my perfect prep for me. MN seemed shocked when I've mentioned it before but the HV in our area support the mum. Your HV isn't doing that. She sounds awful. You are doing so well. Congratulations on your little girl and keep doing what you are x

lemonaddde · 08/06/2023 08:24

Think of it the other way. If your child had died of SIDs and she didn't warn you, what then. I do agree with what you say about not being condescending and just letting you know the facts.


That was my issue.

Not that she did her job and warned me of the facts.

It was her tone, her patronising nature and the fact she specifically said "you are putting your baby at risk of SIDS".

Looking at the picture as a whole I was absolutely not putting my baby at risk of SIDS. I was going against their guidance to avoid putting her at risk by using an unsafe moses basket just to be slightly closer to me at night. Not everyone has unlimited space and can fit a full size cot in their bedroom.

It's all guidance and advice, not the law. Everyone should be able to use the guidance to make informed decisions without the HV mafia sticking their neb in and making already vulnerable women feel bad. They should be supportive and kind, and save their aggressive nature for genuinely dangerous and unsafe choices.

elm26 · 08/06/2023 06:25

I'm quite relieved that DDog isn't that phased by her, he'll give her a lick and sniff on top of her head then goes away to get his bone or bring her a toy which he doesn't understand she can't throw for him yet 😂 I know everyone says it but I do feel lucky to have a calm, happy to go with the flow, low needs dog. As long as he's fed, walked and we make sure that whoever doesn't have the baby in the evening plays with him for a bit, fusses him with cuddles, he seems his usual happy self. When baby cries he takes himself to his bed as if to say "f%#k this" 🤣 up until he was about 6 he was your typical nutty high energy spaniel so he's definitely calmed with age. We bought some puppy training treats too so when he's gentle with her we reward him with one (didn't want to overload him with his adult dog treats) so I'm hoping to carry on the healthy and happy dog routine and hopefully they develop a safe bond overtime. I grew up with rescue dogs so I just love them.

I'm worried about saying I don't want another HV as I was under the perinatal mental health team during pregnancy and they were fantastic, I got so much support and felt like they really listened to my concerns about PND etc due to my history, I didn't feel judged like I did by the HV. The consultant for mental health in pregnancy and post partum calls once a week to check on me and to ask if I feel like I need an adjustment on my antidepressants, or if I just need to chat or have some counselling. She will do this for 6 weeks after birth and then I can self refer back to them until baby is a year old so that's a relief. I feel great and healthier than I've been in years in terms or my mind and mental health. I will definitely call and ask for a different HV and my last visit should be next month anyway and then hopefully I'll see the back of them.

Our local church does baby weigh clinics on a Monday from 9-11:30 so I will take her to those, from the wounds of it you can have a cuppa and chat to other mums whilst there too and I'm really looking forward to starting the classes in a couple of weeks. I feel really positive today after all of your advice and comments and I can't thank you all enough. Mumsnet really can be amazing.

My Mum is an alcoholic and was a drug addict too, my grandparents raised me so I'm determined to give my daughter the life I didn't have with my Mum and I think the comments from the HV made me feel like I was failing.

DH did all of the night feeds last night and is going into work a bit later so I had a good 8 hour sleep which has really helped my mood.

OP posts:
TeddyBeans · 08/06/2023 06:25

Just to add to the chorus - you're doing amazing! DD is 3 months old and we've been doing everything you do (including the dog, my parents have one!) with no hint of trouble yet. I only saw a HV once for a home visit after DD was born and then for a 6 week check. Haven't seen or heard from one since and was the same with DS 5 years ago until it was time for his development checks. Completely optional service ime!

Doingmybest12 · 08/06/2023 06:19

It sounds to me she was running through her list of advice , dog in house ,say this,tick. Moses basket say this, tick. Etc. It sounds like she needed better people skills if you feel like this afterwards. Don't take it personally. Lots of professionals (need to) cover their own backs. Hope you can see it in this context.

elm26 · 08/06/2023 06:11

Also, thank you for all your compliments on how well I look. Luckily for me I have a fantastic DH who makes sure I get an hour or more to myself each day to shower, wash hair, put a bit of make up on if we are going out. We were heading to a family BBQ when that photo was taken and now he's back to work, I live in shorts or yoga bottoms with my hair shoved on top of my head to walk the dog/look after bubs until he's home and I can have a soak in the bath etc 😂 I do not look like that every day! X

OP posts:
elm26 · 08/06/2023 06:08

MyTruthIsOut · 08/06/2023 06:02

As someone who used to work with a HV Team, a lot of those things they ask or talk about are part of a tick-box exercise as the paperwork they follows tell them what they have to discuss/say and they usually have to tick their paperwork to say they’ve had those discussion with you. So although your feelings are valid please take heart that your HV may not have even believe 50% of what she was saying to you, but had to say it as that’s what’s professionally expected of her and what she is required to to document in her notes.

With regards to the feeding, all I would suggest, if you don’t already, is use the Paced Feeding Technique with your baby as that manner of feeding is “baby led” and allows the baby to take how much volume they want, whereas when babies are fed in the traditional manner (lead back in their parents arms with the bottle tilted) they can overfed which can be a trigger for vomiting and reflux symptoms, and longer periods of sleep. There are lots of good videos on YouTube about how to bottle feed this way if you haven’t been doing so already. Mind you, if the Health Visitor was doing her job properly and was concerned about your baby’s feeding pattern she should have already spoke to you about this.

I only advise this is for, alongside the reasons above, is it means that if your daughter continues to take that volume of milk then you can tell your HV that you use the Paced bottle feeding feeding technique to ensure the feed is baby led, and that your baby is actively choosing to have that amount of milk and therefore she obviously needs it and so you won’t be restricting her intake.

As another poster said, the HV service isn’t a requirement so you don’t have to see them, but they can also have some benefits. I think it’s just a case of finding one that you click with and one that you find supportive and so definitely ask for another one and see if you have a better experience with her.

And onto more positive things, many congratulations on finally getting your precious baby. It sounds like you’ve had a really traumatic time in order to get to this point and you must finally be on cloud 9…..so please don’t let this HV ruin the experience of new parenthood for you!!

Your dog is absolutely gorgeous!!! And I’m very jealous of how gorgeous you look too so soon after having a baby….I think I looked like crap for about 4 months 😂

We were shown how to do this my midwife, so she's sat partially upright with teat not full of milk but half full so she has to work harder for the milk. It can create more wind but isn't a problem if we wind her regularly which we do. She's never sick and sometimes she'll only take 3oz, others she'll finish the whole bottle so I definitely agree with you there. I'd rather be lead by DD than force milk into her and make her sick/over loaded for her little tummy. Thank you ☺️

OP posts:
MyTruthIsOut · 08/06/2023 06:02

As someone who used to work with a HV Team, a lot of those things they ask or talk about are part of a tick-box exercise as the paperwork they follows tell them what they have to discuss/say and they usually have to tick their paperwork to say they’ve had those discussion with you. So although your feelings are valid please take heart that your HV may not have even believe 50% of what she was saying to you, but had to say it as that’s what’s professionally expected of her and what she is required to to document in her notes.

With regards to the feeding, all I would suggest, if you don’t already, is use the Paced Feeding Technique with your baby as that manner of feeding is “baby led” and allows the baby to take how much volume they want, whereas when babies are fed in the traditional manner (lead back in their parents arms with the bottle tilted) they can overfed which can be a trigger for vomiting and reflux symptoms, and longer periods of sleep. There are lots of good videos on YouTube about how to bottle feed this way if you haven’t been doing so already. Mind you, if the Health Visitor was doing her job properly and was concerned about your baby’s feeding pattern she should have already spoke to you about this.

I only advise this is for, alongside the reasons above, is it means that if your daughter continues to take that volume of milk then you can tell your HV that you use the Paced bottle feeding feeding technique to ensure the feed is baby led, and that your baby is actively choosing to have that amount of milk and therefore she obviously needs it and so you won’t be restricting her intake.

As another poster said, the HV service isn’t a requirement so you don’t have to see them, but they can also have some benefits. I think it’s just a case of finding one that you click with and one that you find supportive and so definitely ask for another one and see if you have a better experience with her.

And onto more positive things, many congratulations on finally getting your precious baby. It sounds like you’ve had a really traumatic time in order to get to this point and you must finally be on cloud 9…..so please don’t let this HV ruin the experience of new parenthood for you!!

Your dog is absolutely gorgeous!!! And I’m very jealous of how gorgeous you look too so soon after having a baby….I think I looked like crap for about 4 months 😂

elm26 · 08/06/2023 05:44

Also so sorry for everyone else who's been made to feel like crap, our hormones are everywhere and we are all doing our best. If there is obvious danger or neglect I completely understand but from what everyone has commented and my own experience, there is none of that and a majority of them seem to be on a power trip x

OP posts:
elm26 · 08/06/2023 05:43

Forgot to say for the first week she was fed every 2 hours due to her low birth weight at 39 weeks but as no jaundice and because she only lost 5g then put it on plus some, the midwife said we could start leaving longer periods 😊

OP posts:
elm26 · 08/06/2023 05:42

Wow, laid in bed in tears reading all of your experiences and stories, words of encouragement and just genuine kindness. Thank you all so much.

I'll just address a few comments, the perfect prep machine will be cleaned regularly and the filters replaced as needed even though it says it's the perfect temperature I still test a bit on back of my hand just in case there's a malfunction somewhere.

I tried for a baby for 9 years so did a lot of research in that time. I know that cot bumpers, toys in the cot/Moses, letting baby sleep on the sleep pod things (I don't have one) are massive no no's.

During the night feeds, as soon as she's fed and winded, we put her straight back in her Moses so no risk of falling asleep with her. I'm terrified to co sleep and she seems content in her basket.

Thank you again everyone for your lovely words x

OP posts:
SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 08/06/2023 03:34

I'm sorry you've had such a crap experience with the HV. I had 2 different ones and they were fantastic. Especially as I was a single mum from day one without much support.

You sound like you're doing a fab job. You know you can request a different HV, don't you?

AngelAurora · 08/06/2023 03:25

elm26 · 07/06/2023 20:27

Thanks so much everyone. You've made me feel a little better that maybe I am doing a good job.

She was just so abrupt and rude and really made me feel stupid.

Anyway, here is a picture of my out of control dog, an unhappy baby and worst mother of the year 😂

Got to keep it lighthearted because I could easily sink back into depression and I do not want that at all.

Beautiful, little one turning head towards the dog. You are doing amazing OP, Congratulations Flowers

AngelAurora · 08/06/2023 03:15

Don't have her back and tell them exactly why.

My2pence2day · 08/06/2023 03:03

lemonaddde · 08/06/2023 02:45

I've had a variety of health visitors over the years. Some were amazing and others were utterly shite at their job.

I moved my daughter to her own room at 5 months (guidance states 6 months to do this).

Her moses basket became unsafe and unusable.

She filled it from the top of her head to her toes and was wriggling down to the bottom so her legs were hanging out and it was tilting downwards.

I had no space for anything larger in my bedroom and I thought for the sake of 4 weeks it was pointless buying anything else in any event when she had a cotbed ready to use.

Well you'd think I'd pegged her on a washing line to sleep.

At a routine check up HV asked how sleep was going so I mentioned she was sleeping much better in her cot and explained the noses basket situation.

I was told I was putting her at risk of SIDS.
She needed my breathing pattern to regulate her own.
It was unsafe to leave her sleeping unsupervised. (They are technically unsupervised anyway when we are sleeping?!)
I should consider buying another crib and shoehorning it into my bedroom.
I should consider buying a camp bed/airbed or just sleep on the floor of her bedroom for a month.

Utter madness. She was 5 months not 5 days.

I had the baby monitor switched on
The doors were always wide open
The actual distance from my bed to her cot was THREE METERS despite being in different bedrooms.
Cot was on the opposite side of the room to radiators and windows and the room temperature was fine (spring time so not too hot or cold)
Always put her feet to the bottom and used a gro bag that fitted well rather than loose blankets.
No pillows, no bumpers, no bedding, just a fitted sheet.
I'd clearly done my research and applied it to our living situation and made an informed choice.

She was so patronising and clearly lacked the common sense to deviate from the rule book and consider the wording of the advice she was giving on a person by person basis.

She could have just said I have to remind you that current guidance states 6 months onwards is the safest time to move them to their own room, please make sure you are doing X, Y and Z and be aware of safe sleeping guidance. She's still done her job and told me correct guidance, without telling me I will potentially kill my baby.

It is handy to have a HV contact, if you ever need advice further down the line about general development/weaning that kind of thing. If you have a decent HV they can be really supportive and useful for signposting other services you may need.

I would put in a complaint about her and request a different person. It would also put your mind at rest about not wanting to come across like you are refusing the service/feeling like you look suspicious. Perhaps do it by email and keep it factual. She has got a job to do, and she has to advise you on certain things, but there is absolutely a way to do it without being condescending and fear inducing.

I really wouldn't allow her in your home again.

Think of it the other way. If your child had died of SIDs and she didn't warn you, what then. I do agree with what you say about not being condescending and just letting you know the facts.

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 08/06/2023 02:57

As a midwife, I want to say it sounds like you have everything as it is supposed to be

pinkksugarmouse · 08/06/2023 02:51

I would advise against making a complaint professionals in child care: health visitors, teachers, nursery staff are very quick to report anything that could be seen as “failure to engage.”
If you can have someone there with you on her visits a family member, friend even a neighbour she might be more polite with a 3rd party. Nod, smile, acknowledge she’s a nasty piece of work with issues that are nothing to do with you as a mother.
After a few more weeks. Say thank you so much for all your help but my mum/MIL/sister are going to be here to help now but I am happy that if I need more help I won’t hesitate to ask.

lemonaddde · 08/06/2023 02:45

I've had a variety of health visitors over the years. Some were amazing and others were utterly shite at their job.

I moved my daughter to her own room at 5 months (guidance states 6 months to do this).

Her moses basket became unsafe and unusable.

She filled it from the top of her head to her toes and was wriggling down to the bottom so her legs were hanging out and it was tilting downwards.

I had no space for anything larger in my bedroom and I thought for the sake of 4 weeks it was pointless buying anything else in any event when she had a cotbed ready to use.

Well you'd think I'd pegged her on a washing line to sleep.

At a routine check up HV asked how sleep was going so I mentioned she was sleeping much better in her cot and explained the noses basket situation.

I was told I was putting her at risk of SIDS.
She needed my breathing pattern to regulate her own.
It was unsafe to leave her sleeping unsupervised. (They are technically unsupervised anyway when we are sleeping?!)
I should consider buying another crib and shoehorning it into my bedroom.
I should consider buying a camp bed/airbed or just sleep on the floor of her bedroom for a month.

Utter madness. She was 5 months not 5 days.

I had the baby monitor switched on
The doors were always wide open
The actual distance from my bed to her cot was THREE METERS despite being in different bedrooms.
Cot was on the opposite side of the room to radiators and windows and the room temperature was fine (spring time so not too hot or cold)
Always put her feet to the bottom and used a gro bag that fitted well rather than loose blankets.
No pillows, no bumpers, no bedding, just a fitted sheet.
I'd clearly done my research and applied it to our living situation and made an informed choice.

She was so patronising and clearly lacked the common sense to deviate from the rule book and consider the wording of the advice she was giving on a person by person basis.

She could have just said I have to remind you that current guidance states 6 months onwards is the safest time to move them to their own room, please make sure you are doing X, Y and Z and be aware of safe sleeping guidance. She's still done her job and told me correct guidance, without telling me I will potentially kill my baby.

It is handy to have a HV contact, if you ever need advice further down the line about general development/weaning that kind of thing. If you have a decent HV they can be really supportive and useful for signposting other services you may need.

I would put in a complaint about her and request a different person. It would also put your mind at rest about not wanting to come across like you are refusing the service/feeling like you look suspicious. Perhaps do it by email and keep it factual. She has got a job to do, and she has to advise you on certain things, but there is absolutely a way to do it without being condescending and fear inducing.

I really wouldn't allow her in your home again.

Groutyonehereagain · 08/06/2023 01:56

On Mumsnet, HVs are hated more than dogs, and dogs are really hated, so you’ve come to the right place @elm26. 😂

Anyway, YABU to look so fabulous. Congratulations on the birth of your baby. 💐

quirkysitcom · 08/06/2023 01:45

My first baby was also 5lb 15oz, born a little early due to him not growing because of my placenta too so sounds very relatable. I also formula fed and went through hell from people judging and commenting for the entire first year.
My first health visitor wasn't great and I felt like you've described. But her replacement was the loveliest woman ever! She helped me when I experienced PND and helped me access support when my child stopped gaining weight and required prescription formula.
There are some incredible HV's and some incredibly terrible ones too.
Please don't take her words to heart. Your daughter will be ok and she will thrive because you and your husband are doing your best which is all any good parent can do.
My son is now 12, really healthy, still a beanpole and full of energy and silliness. You have got this, you're doing great.

tanitani · 08/06/2023 01:33

I don't often comment but PLEASE request a different visitor. If midwives are happy - sounds like you're a really safe, aware and caring mum!
If you feel brave enough - file a complaint as she may be treating mums like this in general.

Also - I did not look half as good as you just after having a baby! You look fantastic!
If baby is hungry - giving her milk is fine! I had doctors tell me I was giving son too much milk so we reduced and he was hungry, ended up really stressful because he then couldn't sleep because he was so hungry.

Honestly sounds like you couldn't be a better mum if you tried - baby girl is lucky to have you.

VintageBlossomHill · 08/06/2023 01:16

OMG you, your beautiful little girl and your dog look absolutely gorgeous happy and healthy and you sound like an amazing mum.

Go with your gut, hold your baby and feed your baby when she’s hungry whatever way works for you both. If she’s content and steadily gaining weight you’re doing great.

i had twins, one was tiny at birth, thankfully very healthy, good feeder and sleeper but was incredibly slow to gain weight - even now at 7, he’s a great eater, small for his age but v healthy, sharp as a knifeand very sporty.

when they were 6 months I had a scheduled visit from a HV and a trainee. I had met the HV before and she had been not overly friendly.but ok.We had just started weaning, he wasn’t overly keen and I asked for advice and they ripped me to shreds - apparently baby rice was the devils food. The student also claimed he was ‘covered in eczema ‘, they got me a prescription for shedload washes and ointments. His skin was flawless - my lovely GP had always remarked on my kids skin asking what I used to look after them. She checked him over that evening and confirmed that his skin was perfect. I cried after their visit. I’m not a young mum and fairly confident and they really knocked me for 6. I often said that I wonderedwhat effect would a visit like that have on a young girl or someone with depression. - bitches.

Ring your GP and say you want a different HV (because your current is a bit of a dick) because it’s affecting your mental health.

Teenagehorrorbag · 08/06/2023 00:42

Midiwidi · 08/06/2023 00:20

Please don’t prop a bottle up- risk of choking or microwave a bottle, they can have hot spots and cause burns- totally NOT fine.
making up bottles is ok as long as they are prepared correctly, stored in fridge and discharged after 24 hours.

lots have changed in 15 years with sound health promotion advice which I believe was given by the HV in this case.

Actually - 15 years ago those things were still warned about. It wasn't the dark ages.....:-)

With twins you don't have much choice re propping up bottles with blankets, but if you are right beside them and hovering so you can act if anything goes wrong then the choking risk must be no different than any other scenario.

Also we were all warned about microwaving bottles due to hot spots - that hasn't changed either. But the nurses said if you are careful not to overheat the bottles and allow them time to stabilise and shake them well it was fine. We aren't all idiots. I agree you need to know and understand the risks. Bear in mind I was only heating to room temp not any hotter, but you are right about the need to be aware.