Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Health visitor has made me feel shit

342 replies

elm26 · 07/06/2023 20:18

Health visitor came and all she did is criticise.

2.5 week old baby is having too much formula (4oz every 3.5-4 hours) she's hungry and I'm not going to deny her it. I should be waking her every 2 and giving her 2oz apparently. She scared the life out of me saying if I let her sleep for 3-4 hours, she could go into a deep sleep and never come out of it (cot death).

She doesn't like the play mat that we have for her (just one of those soft ones with toys above) as we have a spaniel and apparently she should never be on the floor as we have a dog including for dog hair reasons. Spaniel is 8 years old, not boisterous, we NEVER leave them in the same room together, if she's on her mat one of us sits right next to her so dog can have a sniff of her head then he wanders off to lay down. They are ALWAYS supervised. I would never want any harm to come to her and it's also my responsibility as a dog owner to make sure he's calm and not stressed too. We've kept his routine the same, I put baby in sling and walk for an hour every morning and then DH takes him out for a further 30 minutes in evening. He seems happy and settled, no jealousy or warning signs.

The dog hair, what can I do? I literally Hoover every single day (1 bed flat so only takes 5 mins max), my flat is clean (I actually have OCD), I hate clutter, my DH has been great and we've been keeping on top of everything so it's not like she walked into a state, I'm proud of my home.

She doesn't like that we use the perfect prep machine for the bottles. I explained I can't breastfeed as at first she wouldn't latch despite numerous attempts and help from midwives and secondly my milk dried up so quickly. She was a tiny 5lb 15oz when she was born because my placenta stopped working and she stopped growing. I already feel guilty enough about this and honestly, enough was enough and I chucked in the towel and moved her to Aptamil to get some food into her. She is now 1lb over her birth weight and midwives say she is thriving. HV thinks we should be using the boiling water method.

Apparently I shouldn't have a Moses basket mattress protector under the Moses basket sheet. It's not padded or thick or anything like that, it's super thin and from Mamas and Papas for Moses baskets, surely they wouldn't sell if not safe?

She doesn't like how I held her, on my chest with her head tucked to one side. I do this as skin to skin for a couple of hours a night to make her feel secure and close. She said it's dangerous in case I fall asleep. I do this around 7pm with DH in the room with me.

I just feel like utter shit now. I had 13 miscarriages, this little girl is my whole world and my DH and I have felt on top of the world since having her and really thought we were doing a great job as a team. Obviously I'm never going to know it all and I'm also a first time Mum.

I've suffered horrifically with depression and anxiety in the past including inpatient treatment in a psychiatric hospital after my 13th miscarriage for severe depression and grief.

I was so proud of myself and DH for having this content baby who's put on weight, seems super healthy and we love her so much. I've booked in to start a baby massage/yoga/first aid and music class with her starting in a couple of weeks and now I'm dreading it in case others judge me.

I'm dreading her coming back 😢

OP posts:
Remagirl · 07/06/2023 21:06

I agree just go with it and take any advice she offers that resonates and ignore anything you don't agree with. I had an amazing old school HV that often gave me the party line but would add, your instinct is right but I can't tell you to do that.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 07/06/2023 21:06

@elm26 First, congratulations on your rainbow baby. 💐

I am so sorry, especially after all you've been through, that you received such harsh comments from your HV. Can you request a new HV? I think I'd insist on it via their manager.

My LO was just 6.25lbs and developed a life threatening infection shortly after birth. The paediatrician and midwives after that told me the goal was to get to double birth weight quickly and to feed every 2-3 hours and wake if necessary to feed. So, I set alarms throughout the night and did that. I gave LO as much formula as baby wanted, too.

I did boil the kettle on the stove (my electric kettle shuts off at just boiling) for at least five mins so water was safely sterilized as a "just to be extra safe" measure. Immune systems are not developed so didn't take chances that way. I would then transfer water to my kettle and use it for the day as the kettle has temp settings so I could warm water to mix with formula on demand (discard after 24 hours to avoid bacteria).

I also co-slept A LOT. Skin to skin, propped up a bit, with pillows beside me as well to prevent arms dropping, but I don't tend to move when I sleep so felt very safe doing this.

I wonder if HV meant to be so harsh or if it was perceived that way as no doubt you're in a fragile state pp. A bit of both? Regardless, a new HV would be a fresh start.

You sound like you're doing great! Good instincts and bonding. Again, a very heartfelt congratulations on your much loved and dearly wanted baby. 💐💖

LittleMousewithcloggson · 07/06/2023 21:04

Sounds like you are doing a great job.
My BF who is a health visitor said they are told to warn parents to be careful about the perfect prep machines as if they aren’t looked after properly they can cause bacteria to grow and aren’t as safe as using boiling water (cooled to right temperature obviously!)
That might be why she told you that but everything else you are doing sounds great. Ask for a different one definitely. If you decide to refuse to have one - which you can - try to take your daughter to the health clinics just so no one can say they are concerned they haven’t seen your child. But keep smiling and enjoy your daughter. You’re amazing

pollykitty · 07/06/2023 21:04

You’re doing fine, she sounds like a total arsehole.

TheoTheopolis23 · 07/06/2023 21:04

I'm only going to comment on the pp machine cause everyone's covered everything else.

There was a fake scare about mould in the pipes which turned out to be carbon deposits or something.

Aside from that there was an issue myself and Lo's Dad could never figure out was kosher or not ...which was the cold water and the fact that it's only filtered and not boiled. That could be our lack of understanding.

He's and midwives can't endorse it because it's not been definitively declared as safe/as "good" as the recommended bottle make up routine.

What I would do is use the premixed bottles of formula if you can afford it. Especially at night.

Anyway, don't let her get to you. She's a twat.

Ketzele · 07/06/2023 21:03

I had one visit from a HV. She told me not to carry my baby in a sling because she would suffocate between my breasts (and claimed one had died this way just the year before in my very street!). She said babies can't breathe through their mouths. I asked what happens if they get a cold? She said you must rush them straight to A+E and hope you reach there before they suffocate!

Welcome to the club, OP! And congratulations on your beautiful baby.

bibbingo · 07/06/2023 21:03

Aww OP keep doing what you're doing, she sounds very rude. You look amazing btw!

I also have a spaniel (he was just about to turn 8 when DS was born) and DS (now 18mo) loves him Smile he actually said the dog's name before "mama" HmmGrin

StarDolphins · 07/06/2023 21:02

elm26 · 07/06/2023 20:27

Thanks so much everyone. You've made me feel a little better that maybe I am doing a good job.

She was just so abrupt and rude and really made me feel stupid.

Anyway, here is a picture of my out of control dog, an unhappy baby and worst mother of the year 😂

Got to keep it lighthearted because I could easily sink back into depression and I do not want that at all.

This picture is super lovely! Happy Mummy, happy baby & lovely calm dog being included. Keep your chin up & ask the HV not to return. You’re doing a great job!

Cutesbabasmummy · 07/06/2023 21:02

My hv was a twat! She said my baby had normal posseting when in fact he had severe reflux and needed medication. Never saw her again. Trust your mum instinct - you sound like you are doing just fine xxx

Dav1988 · 07/06/2023 21:02

Congratulations! Your daughter is beautiful - and you and your dog look lovely too. I think it’s part of their job description as many seem to have a knack to make people feel like a failure so you’re definitely not alone. But I’d definitely complain and ask for a different one. She should know your history - kindness costs nothing and she should be building your confidence.

I’m so sorry to hear about the pain you experienced before finally getting your little girl. I have struggled with my mental health to the point of hospitalisation and my midwife has reassured me how normal it is to battle with one’s mental health, especially when becoming a new mum. 💐 So please try to get a HV who will provide reassurance and make you feel like the good mum you are. All the best.

Munchyseeds2 · 07/06/2023 21:02

Honestly she sounds bonkers!!
Keep doing what you are doing, enjoy the baby and your lovely dog...you will be fine
If you have her back (not sure I would) just nod and smile

Whatifthecathatesthebaby · 07/06/2023 21:01

OP you sound like you are doing a great job. I would refuse another visit from this HV, request another one by all means but in my experience the visits don't add much value if any. Join NCT or similar and seek your answers and support elsewhere. My DD is now 6 and I don't know a single mother who had a positive experience with their HV. Enjoy your newborn, you and DH concentrate on being happy and healthy and seeking joy in your new, thriving, family.

Louoby · 07/06/2023 21:01

All I can say is wtf!!! I would refuse entry and not let her back in tbh. Health visitors are usually supportive not opinionated.
I would ring up the health visiting team and request they send someone else next time or they can not bother coming back.
It sounds like your doing a fantastic job. She's thriving and you've got nothing to feel guilty about. Well done mummy and keep up the good work. X

Hellno45 · 07/06/2023 21:00

You are doing a great job.

I'd ask for a different HV. Some are great and some not so much.

bigsquidlittlesquid · 07/06/2023 21:00

elm26 · 07/06/2023 20:27

Thanks so much everyone. You've made me feel a little better that maybe I am doing a good job.

She was just so abrupt and rude and really made me feel stupid.

Anyway, here is a picture of my out of control dog, an unhappy baby and worst mother of the year 😂

Got to keep it lighthearted because I could easily sink back into depression and I do not want that at all.

you’re so beautiful!! look at your gorgeous little baby too!! you’re doing amazing - ignore the hv they’re all full of crap x

Morechocmorechoc · 07/06/2023 21:00

You learnt a great lesson, don't have a health visitor. I had one in once, never again.

Justalittlebitduckling · 07/06/2023 20:59

This health visitor sounds terrible. Is there anyway you can have a different one?

hulahooper2 · 07/06/2023 20:58

She probably doesn’t have any children of her own , tell them to send a different hv next time and don’t allow her back in your house

Heyheyitsanotherday · 07/06/2023 20:58

Ps. Just seen your photo. Made me all teary. What a gorgeous family and a very loved baby girl 😍 enjoy every second of her and don’t let any nitwit make you doubt yourself 💕

Cherry2456 · 07/06/2023 20:58

Hi I had a prem so I also had to wake her every two hours she still
had a bit of jaundice. I formula fed her and never felt guilty for doing so, I barely made any milk. Which was a massive relief because I hated the idea of bf. I also used a Tomee tippee machine. I would do what she says/pretend apart from the two hour feed thing. In order to get rid of her for next time. Also will she see your picture on here?

First aid courses are fine people just sit there in silence usually. Don’t worry what other parents think they are probably trying to keep their eyes open because they are so tired!

catzrulz · 07/06/2023 20:58

elm26 · 07/06/2023 20:31

Thank you so much everyone I'm so grateful.

I'm just worried if I refuse their visits that they may think something dodgy is going on. I will phone and request a different HV for my next appt and make sure I mention how awful she made me feel.

This is where MN needs a like button, well done you!
Don't let her get to you, as you grow in confidence you'll look back and think why did she make me feel this way, I've got this.

ZIEVAR · 07/06/2023 20:58

Please commit your comments in writing and deliver them to the head of the H.V. service. Her behaviour was completely out of order. While it is their job to advise on the latest reseach on child devopment methods, it is not their job to undermine new mothers. They can be very helpful in liaising with other authorities, such as housing. There are very good ones around. You all look beautiful. x

Rightnowstraightaway · 07/06/2023 20:58

None of my NCT group thought the HVs were useful. One of them was made to feel like you. Her baby is fine.

Your photo is gorgeous.

I would say though that don't automatically assume that just because something is for sale, it is safe. For example, cot bumpers.

Thedogscollar · 07/06/2023 20:57

@elm26
Hi you are doing absolutely nothing wrong. I'm a midwife of 30 years you are doing everything right. Your baby is thriving you often find these little ones have a very good appetite and nothing wrong with that.
You get good and bad in every profession let them know you would like to see somebody else in the future and reasons why.
My dil's HV told her that her 1 Yr old should be walking and he had unequal leg creases so could have hip dysplasia also said he wasn't very social lol.
I checked his leg creases perfectly equal and he walked a month later. Some of them talk nonsense some are sensible and professional.
BTW you look amazing in the pic you posted. Your baby is beautiful and your dog looks so gentle. Enjoy this time don't let anyone burst your bubble. X

sparkellie · 07/06/2023 20:56

She is an idiot.
Ask for someone else. You can opt out, but hvs can be really great support if you get a decent one, so it's worth asking if there's an alternative first.
That picture is lovely, and so is your dog!