Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About family who live a long way away coming home

59 replies

HeppaHippo · 07/06/2023 19:27

I live at home with my mother. It's due to limited accommodations and costs. I don't ake advantage of living at home and I help my mother.

There's a situation deleveloping and I can't help but think she being unreasonable.

I have a sibling who is living abroad. He is on another contintent. We don't see each other often due to costs and distance involved. He has a wife and child together too. I love my niece with all my heart. The distance and costs are so very hard. We are lucky if we see each other once every 4 years.

My brother has plans to come on holidays. He would love to stay at home but my mother is being awkward. He and his family will be staying with a friend. They are not rich and can't afford hotel or other traditional holiday stays on top of flights and time off work. They need the help of family and friends. Thank good his friend is stepping up.

There is large spare room at home but my mother is making excuses to not accommodate them.

I feel hurt by this. They are family and she's making no effort for the week that they will be at home. It's a week. If feels as if my mother has demoted my niece - her grandchild and her mother and my brother to be some other type of distance relative instead of closer family. We met the lady before and she's down to earth.

I am actually hurt how they are staying somewhere else instead of coming home because my mother is making excuses about our home. It's an old build but it's livable.

I don't understand this. My niece her grandchild lives across the world. We don't see her and my mother nearly feels heartbroken with the idea of them coming.

My mother already said we can see them by going on the bus into town every day and we can see them that way.

We live a world apart.

AIBU. Hosting them would never fall on her back. I would help. I already helped and bought a bed and bedding on the chance she changes her mind.

Should I keep a relaxed attitude and prepare the house for guests anyways on the off chance once they get here and she sees them,she might change her mind. I don't know if she will change her mind. It seems as if she is resenting my brother's family and she doesn't want them staying at home as a family.

OP posts:
CC4712 · 08/06/2023 10:17

I'm sure I've read this thread before. Did you post about this exact same 'issue' before OP?

Why do you care so much that they need to stay in the family home??? You are coming across as very bizarre OP! Its your mums house and your brother is an adult. Let them stay where they like. If you get to seem them when here, then great- that is the main thing- not where they sleep!

Gymmum82 · 08/06/2023 10:16

Honestly screw your mum. You rent an air b&b for you and your brothers family locally. If you can afford to. You stay all together. You go out on trips with them. You make time and effort for them. Sod your mum. If she can’t be bothered to make any effort that’s on her. You enjoy your time with your family and leave your mother to be miserable on her own.
If you can’t afford to rent a place then you get up early and meet them leave your mum in bed. She’s a grown adult capable of making her own decisions. It sounds like she just can’t be arsed to make the effort and that’s on her

theleafandnotthetree · 08/06/2023 10:11

I think this is desperately sad and hurtful for you and most especially for your brother, it's unfathomable to be honest. Are there things you could do to make the house more to a standard where this can less readily be used as an excuse? Plant some flowers in the garden, buy some simple garden furniture (second hand if necessary), steam clean the carpets etc. I rarely argue with my mother and try and respect her right to live as she sees fit - and she is very stubborn woman - but there have been hills where I have been prepared to die on and I think this is one for you. It is also YOUR home and your family, surely you get some say? What a foolish woman not to open her home and heart to her own son and his family, even if they were awful you would do it out of a sense of duty.

HeppaHippo · 08/06/2023 10:07

rookiemere · 08/06/2023 09:50

Is there a possibility that you can stay in town for the week with a friend? You can't make your DM open her house up, but equally you do seem to be turning this into quite the drama, go without your DM is she's not up in time for the bus.

There's no drama. My mother is not willing to make an effort when her grandchild comes home.

That's gut wrenching.

She won't allow them to stay.
She won't allow a dinner at home.
She will hardly get up for the bus.

She wants things her way or no way at all without factoring in anyone else.

They are spending thousands on tickets to come home just to not be allowed home except for a cup of tea maybe here or there. And what my mother is saying is excuses. The home is looking so much more better.

My decided she wants day trips around the city with them only when the time comes she probably won't even get up. She could at least meet them half way.

OP posts:
HeppaHippo · 08/06/2023 10:00

rookiemere · 08/06/2023 09:50

Is there a possibility that you can stay in town for the week with a friend? You can't make your DM open her house up, but equally you do seem to be turning this into quite the drama, go without your DM is she's not up in time for the bus.

If she's not up and ready in time, I am not waiting for her nor will I entertain or requests to wait for her. They are only 'home' for a short time.

OP posts:
HeppaHippo · 08/06/2023 09:59

Hoppinggreen · 08/06/2023 09:37

It’s your Mums house, whatever you or anyone else thinks she does not feel comfortable hosting. Whether that’s due to Anxiety or anything else her feelings are valid and you shouldn’t try and steam roller her.
I agree it’s a shame and it would be nice to have your brother and his family visit but it’s not your place to insist your Mum do something that for whatever reason she really doesn’t want to

It's not really hosting though. It's my brother. It's his family home. He doesn't expect to be waited on hand and foot and toured around the place like tourists. It's his family home. There's very little hosting involved. Just a bed and a roof over their heads. I am at home to help too. She doesn't have to dip into her pockets once.

It's so sad that they are coming so close to home and she can't even tolerate even a weekend stay.

They live on the other side of the world and we never get to see them. Even a weekend stay is not a huge hardship.

OP posts:
rookiemere · 08/06/2023 09:50

Is there a possibility that you can stay in town for the week with a friend? You can't make your DM open her house up, but equally you do seem to be turning this into quite the drama, go without your DM is she's not up in time for the bus.

Hoppinggreen · 08/06/2023 09:37

HeppaHippo · 08/06/2023 09:15

She won't even allow a meal at home. She just doesn't want anyone. The place is not that bad. It's just not a show house.

It’s your Mums house, whatever you or anyone else thinks she does not feel comfortable hosting. Whether that’s due to Anxiety or anything else her feelings are valid and you shouldn’t try and steam roller her.
I agree it’s a shame and it would be nice to have your brother and his family visit but it’s not your place to insist your Mum do something that for whatever reason she really doesn’t want to

HeppaHippo · 08/06/2023 09:15

IamSmarticus · 08/06/2023 08:32

You have posted about this before, your mum doesn't want them to see the state of her house if I remember correctly.

At the end of the day, if your mum doesn't want visitors staying for a week (even if it is her son and family) then it is her house and she has the right to say no. I am not sure whty you feel hurt! Your brother is still coming over, you will still see them. Perhaps they can come over to the house for a meal or a quick visit but not actually stay?

She won't even allow a meal at home. She just doesn't want anyone. The place is not that bad. It's just not a show house.

OP posts:
HeppaHippo · 08/06/2023 09:12

lovemelongtime · 08/06/2023 08:27

I think you need a frank conversation to the tune that if she goes ahead and doesn't host then, she risk alternating then and not seeing them again. She has a lot to lose this way and a lot to gain by hosting. You can't build relationships meeting in town centre.

She can't comprehend and she doesn't care. She wants to reject the family from staying at home.

She has a scenario built in her mind that she will meet them every day in the city and she expects me to go along with this. It's just my brother is an earlier riser and none of this is going to work. I had plans a few months ago with my mother to go into the city but she slept through the alarm.

My family will be nearly on our doorstep and we will be lucky if we see them once or twice in a week.

It's stomach churning.

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 08/06/2023 09:11

You are doing the right thing in organising beds for them all.
If they stay just two or three nights it will be special.

Tell your mother that you are having them as your guests.

HeppaHippo · 08/06/2023 09:05

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/06/2023 08:27

HeppaHippo · Today 08:18
MrsSkylerWhite · Today 08:17

How old is your mum?

“Early 70s”

Hows her health? Is she robust or frail?

She's not frail by any means. She likes to walk every day.

OP posts:
HeppaHippo · 08/06/2023 09:04

Presentideasplease · 08/06/2023 08:23

When I first read your OP I thought perhaps your mum is embarrassed of the state of the home?

Do your brother and his wife have a more “put together” house? Has your house declined a bit over the years? You say it’s still liveable, which implies it’s not in an amazing state?

Was your mum house proud when you were young?

This. It's an older build. The house did decline over the years due to poverty when I was small. It's not bad now. 15 years ago when I started working, I paid for a new kitchen and sitting room and bathroom. I know those rooms are not new any more. But it's not bad. My mother neglected the grass and that was overgrown but over the past year I was working on it. The place is looking better than ever. It's just not a show house from a magazine or TV. It doesn't look like neighbours houses where neighbours have garden furniture and blooming flower pots.

OP posts:
IamSmarticus · 08/06/2023 08:32

You have posted about this before, your mum doesn't want them to see the state of her house if I remember correctly.

At the end of the day, if your mum doesn't want visitors staying for a week (even if it is her son and family) then it is her house and she has the right to say no. I am not sure whty you feel hurt! Your brother is still coming over, you will still see them. Perhaps they can come over to the house for a meal or a quick visit but not actually stay?

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/06/2023 08:27

HeppaHippo · Today 08:18
MrsSkylerWhite · Today 08:17

How old is your mum?

“Early 70s”

Hows her health? Is she robust or frail?

lovemelongtime · 08/06/2023 08:27

I think you need a frank conversation to the tune that if she goes ahead and doesn't host then, she risk alternating then and not seeing them again. She has a lot to lose this way and a lot to gain by hosting. You can't build relationships meeting in town centre.

Presentideasplease · 08/06/2023 08:23

When I first read your OP I thought perhaps your mum is embarrassed of the state of the home?

Do your brother and his wife have a more “put together” house? Has your house declined a bit over the years? You say it’s still liveable, which implies it’s not in an amazing state?

Was your mum house proud when you were young?

Hoppinggreen · 08/06/2023 08:21

Have you posted about this before?
If it was you and I remember correctly your Mum seems to have anxiety about the condition of her house and doesn’t want visitors to stay.
Its her house so her choice at the end of the day

HeppaHippo · 08/06/2023 08:18

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/06/2023 08:17

How old is your mum?

Early 70s

OP posts:
HeppaHippo · 08/06/2023 08:18

Nagado · 07/06/2023 21:54

Could she be embarrassed about your home? She’s ok with your brother being there because he’s familiar and won’t judge but seems quite intent on keeping his wife and daughter away from the home. If she’s talking about smells etc, maybe she’s worried it won’t be up to scratch or posh enough for your brother’s family?

I think this might be it.

This is very difficult because we don't see them from one end of the year to the next and she's literally rejecting them from our home and to spend as little time with them as possible when they are close by. She wants to control the situation by seeing them in the city for day trips but there's only so much of the city we can see.
The home is not bad.

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 08/06/2023 08:17

How old is your mum?

HeppaHippo · 08/06/2023 08:15

CC4712 · 07/06/2023 21:52

How big is your mums house? Is there enough space to accommodate your brother, SIL, a child and both you and your mum not feel squashed in the house? Is your mum worried about how tidy her house is? How much mess a child will cause? Has your mum stayed in their home abroad and is comparing?

If I was trying to shoehorn into a tiny house- I'd personally prefer to stay in a hotel/friends place to have space, but then enjoy to the time with family. What reason does your mum give for not having them in her home?

It's a 4 bed. The rooms are big. The kitchen, bathroom is big. So is the sitting room. The spare room is also big. There is plenty of space and I am sure we wouldn't be all the time at home.

She's a big child now so I don't know how much mess.

We went to them before and at the time they were renting an apartment. It was 2 bed. Probably and 80s build. It was nice place. They made space for us.

They have a new house now. New since about 2019. I wasn't in their new place but i would describe it as cosy. According to the virtual footage I saw.

My sister in law in not a bad person and she's very down to earth.

She's making excuses about all sorts of reasons. The room is not suitable. There's a smell. There is no smell. She's being paranoid with a touch of ocd I reckon. She doesn't have ocd by the way.

OP posts:
Nagado · 07/06/2023 21:54

Could she be embarrassed about your home? She’s ok with your brother being there because he’s familiar and won’t judge but seems quite intent on keeping his wife and daughter away from the home. If she’s talking about smells etc, maybe she’s worried it won’t be up to scratch or posh enough for your brother’s family?

CC4712 · 07/06/2023 21:52

How big is your mums house? Is there enough space to accommodate your brother, SIL, a child and both you and your mum not feel squashed in the house? Is your mum worried about how tidy her house is? How much mess a child will cause? Has your mum stayed in their home abroad and is comparing?

If I was trying to shoehorn into a tiny house- I'd personally prefer to stay in a hotel/friends place to have space, but then enjoy to the time with family. What reason does your mum give for not having them in her home?

HeppaHippo · 07/06/2023 21:43

batsandeggs · 07/06/2023 21:40

Just out of interest, how often do they keep in touch with your mum?

They phone phone regularly and my sister in law is great at technology. She's the lady who sends me pictures and I show them to my mother. If it was up to my brother we would only hear from them a few times a year. Maybe 3 or 4 times a year.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread