Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School bully awarded prize for respect & determination

87 replies

cobicat · 07/06/2023 15:35

A child at my DS's school has just won an award (nominated by staff members) for being a role model. This child is in my dc's year and has literally been a bully since primary school, routinely sneering at and mocking other kids etc.

DS says that the subject teachers often fawn over them because they are in a 'popular' clique and quite charismatic in class.

I remember something similar happening at my younger dd's school. Neither of my dcs were personally bullied by these bullies, but they witnessed them frequently targeting others. I think it sends an uncomfortable message to victims when children like this are celebrated.

AIBU to think that this isn't uncommon and that many schools seem oblivious to what is really going on?

OP posts:
WheelsUp · 07/06/2023 15:59

Weal · 07/06/2023 15:52

I do understand the frustration. I think we all know through our own childhood and our children’s, of people who were unkind but somehow managed to do well. However again why do you think your children’s perception of the situation is more accurate than that of the teachers?

The teachers may well have developed a strategy to manage this child which involves them building a good relationship with him, giving praise when there is something to praise etc. to a child this may well look like favouritism but in reality it could be a planned strategy to work with him?

In an ideal world the kids who come back to school despite being bullied are the ones who should be applauded for resilience and strength.

Onheretoomuch · 07/06/2023 15:57

I agree a lot of the time teachers are unaware of what children are saying and doing out of ear shot/sight. Bullies are very good at being charming and personable when they want to be. I wish some teachers were better at reading between the lines. I don’t believe in rewarding children to improve poor behaviour. In my experience it just makes things worse and sends out the wrong message to everyone.

Akitasmum · 07/06/2023 15:54

My grandson has been bullied since grade 2. Last week the bully punched him in the face. The school’s reaction was “well he said he was sorry. Stay away from him.” It’s so frustrating. They are both 12 now.

Pennn · 07/06/2023 15:54

BigCheekBitch · 07/06/2023 15:47

Child with significant behavioural needs that weren't supported ends up in prison. Great!

Wonder if you’d be quite so sympathetic if
a) it was your child he stabbed with a broken ruler
b) it was your child who got hit in the face with a flying chair
c) it was your child he head butted at the age of 10
d) it was your daughter he beat up and threatened to kill at the age of 17
e) it was your husband who got called a “pa**i cunt” for trying to stop him beating up another girl

But yeah, poor lad 🙄 he’s where he belongs. Horrible piece of shit he is.

Weal · 07/06/2023 15:52

cobicat · 07/06/2023 15:46

How much do you actually know about this child’s behaviour? Given your children are neither his friend or have been bullied by him? Maybe the school teacher know him better, and have perceived something they want to reward?

To be honest, I've never met the child, I only know what dc has told me over the years about them being a bully. I think it's slightly different to naughty primary school kids getting 'star of the week' to promote better behaviour, I think it's a case of the teachers genuinely finding this child charming & not realising how they treat some other students.

I do understand the frustration. I think we all know through our own childhood and our children’s, of people who were unkind but somehow managed to do well. However again why do you think your children’s perception of the situation is more accurate than that of the teachers?

The teachers may well have developed a strategy to manage this child which involves them building a good relationship with him, giving praise when there is something to praise etc. to a child this may well look like favouritism but in reality it could be a planned strategy to work with him?

prettypoki · 07/06/2023 15:49

Teach your child to channel their sense of injustice

prettypoki · 07/06/2023 15:49

Pennn · 07/06/2023 15:39

Yeah it happened at my kids school too. The class “problem child” (let’s call him Damian). Used to constantly disrupt the class, throw chairs around, rip up other people’s work and attack other kids.

He was constantly up for awards at the end of term - including the role model award. The teachers loved him, often said he was a “character”.

He’s in prison now so alls well that ends well.

Ha! See OP these awards and stuff don't really matter at the end of the day. It is tough and it upsets the kids but look at the bigger picture.

BigCheekBitch · 07/06/2023 15:47

Pennn · 07/06/2023 15:39

Yeah it happened at my kids school too. The class “problem child” (let’s call him Damian). Used to constantly disrupt the class, throw chairs around, rip up other people’s work and attack other kids.

He was constantly up for awards at the end of term - including the role model award. The teachers loved him, often said he was a “character”.

He’s in prison now so alls well that ends well.

Child with significant behavioural needs that weren't supported ends up in prison. Great!

cobicat · 07/06/2023 15:46

How much do you actually know about this child’s behaviour? Given your children are neither his friend or have been bullied by him? Maybe the school teacher know him better, and have perceived something they want to reward?

To be honest, I've never met the child, I only know what dc has told me over the years about them being a bully. I think it's slightly different to naughty primary school kids getting 'star of the week' to promote better behaviour, I think it's a case of the teachers genuinely finding this child charming & not realising how they treat some other students.

OP posts:
WheelsUp · 07/06/2023 15:41

I think that the schools know but they think that awards for kids who behave like this has an effect on their behaviour.

Pennn · 07/06/2023 15:39

Yeah it happened at my kids school too. The class “problem child” (let’s call him Damian). Used to constantly disrupt the class, throw chairs around, rip up other people’s work and attack other kids.

He was constantly up for awards at the end of term - including the role model award. The teachers loved him, often said he was a “character”.

He’s in prison now so alls well that ends well.

Weal · 07/06/2023 15:39

How much do you actually know about this child’s behaviour? Given your children are neither his friend or have been bullied by him? Maybe the school teacher know him better, and have perceived something they want to reward?

I know sometimes even children with challenging behaviour get praised, because even those with the worse behaviour still have things they do well at and praise is often used as encouragement or recognition of their more positive behaviour.

Swipe left for the next trending thread