Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School bully awarded prize for respect & determination

87 replies

cobicat · 07/06/2023 15:35

A child at my DS's school has just won an award (nominated by staff members) for being a role model. This child is in my dc's year and has literally been a bully since primary school, routinely sneering at and mocking other kids etc.

DS says that the subject teachers often fawn over them because they are in a 'popular' clique and quite charismatic in class.

I remember something similar happening at my younger dd's school. Neither of my dcs were personally bullied by these bullies, but they witnessed them frequently targeting others. I think it sends an uncomfortable message to victims when children like this are celebrated.

AIBU to think that this isn't uncommon and that many schools seem oblivious to what is really going on?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LostAtTheCrossRoad · 10/06/2023 13:28

Most schools don't truly give a damn as long as academic standards are met and the behaviour isn't disruptive in class. They couldn't care less what happens on the playground or on the way to & from school if they don't see it. There's too much other crap to deal with anyway so they'll ignore everything they can for a long as they can. You get the odd teacher who takes things seriously, but mostly senior management all deny there's any bullying going on or try and blame the bullied child somehow. It's immensely common, shitty behaviour.

cobicat · 10/06/2023 13:00

Often the most destructive bullies - the really clever ones, who do the most damage and can cut deepest, emotionally - are not. They're the "cool kids", the "popular kids", often top set, often from well-off homes. Teachers often like them, choose them, as they can turn on the charm when it suits.

At my younger dd's Prep, a girl like this was literally chosen to be the 'poster child', appearing on all the marketing materials for the school throughout the county! God only knows what the victims of her covert nastiness felt seeing that!

OP posts:
YorkshirePuddingsGreatestFan · 09/06/2023 20:28

Happened in my daughters school. One girl was disruptive and often punched/kicked/pulled hair of the other children. They threatened to ban her from the Christmas nativity.

Girl was upset about that and so was angelic for a week or so. They reinstated her back into the Christmas play.

She originally was a sheep along with my daughter and another girl. As a reward, they made her role head sheep and instead of the three of them dancing in a circle on all fours, mean girl was standing up while daughter and other girl crawled around her on all fours.

Mean girl used that to continually tell daughter and other girl she was superior to them 🙄

SchoolGoss0523 · 09/06/2023 20:02

It seems a lot assume the bullies in situations like this are disruptive, troubled or "little shits".

Often the most destructive bullies - the really clever ones, who do the most damage and can cut deepest, emotionally - are not. They're the "cool kids", the "popular kids", often top set, often from well-off homes. Teachers often like them, choose them, as they can turn on the charm when it suits.

And those they target, often unprovoked, are seen as having "asked for it" or been "weird" or "pathetic".

Sad thing is, it's the way the world is. But for the bullies to be lauded as respectful and kind really is a final insult to those they've made feel like shit over the years. In a few years they'll be supporting mental health and diversity on social media.

Wouldlovetobeinthesun · 09/06/2023 05:07

My DC school had a boy who's DM is a well known athlete and TV personality. Her son was a known bully there; assaulting and verbally attacking other pupils plus smashing up younger pupils belongings. He won an award too and his only sanction was to miss a school outing. Parent status definitely worked in his favour.

marcopront · 09/06/2023 05:05

@Phos

Yeah but he didn’t get an intervention did he. He got preferential treatment.

The person you were replying to had suggested he should have had an intervention not what actually happened.

Mothership4two · 09/06/2023 05:03

Bully at DS's secondary school was made head boy. DS thought this was because he got on well with the head and she thought that he had 'turned himself around'. DS said he hadn't and he joked about it. DS was not directly bullied by him but was cold shouldered for standing up for younger ones.

mids2019 · 09/06/2023 04:54

I don't think playing the SEN card helps. The effects of bullying are literally life changing and unfortunatly we need to remove these children from main school education as many posters above have advocated. Violence is violence no matter the route cause and in adult life such behaviour has penalties. Trying to justify malicious behaviour through neurological difficulties and such like only penalised the victim ultimately.

Phos · 09/06/2023 04:13

marcopront · 08/06/2023 05:03

@Phos

or perhaps if his shitty behaviour had been punished, rather than rewarded, he’d have learnt about consequences

What do you think an intervention is?

Yeah but he didn’t get an intervention did he. He got preferential treatment.

Akitasmum · 08/06/2023 22:56

PrinceHaz · 07/06/2023 17:05

Surely this incident should be taken further. I’d encourage your grandchild’s parents to pursue this with the governors and LEA if school won’t keep him safe.

We are not in the Uk. In Canada so my daughter went to the school liaison officer (police) and reported it. They spoke to bully and have arranged counselling for my grandson.

CrackedSkull · 08/06/2023 19:13

Often the teachers are scared of the parents of bullies and don't want the aggro that comes with disciplining the child . Some teachers are just plain selfish and just want a quiet life so will brush it all under the carpet. Bullies can be very clever good at recruiting others to do their dirty work or are very sly , very good at not getting caught by adults who think they are great because bullies can be charismatic and charming and good at getting their own way .

IamAlso4eels · 08/06/2023 18:35

Bringabrolly · 08/06/2023 05:50

Perhaps if the bully had been removed from the school once the chair chucking started then far fewer kids would bear the mental scars of bullying.

Behavioural issues that severe are a barrier to learning so fit the scope of SEN support, most children in this situation won't be experiencing the behavioural issues in isolation and they will mostly likely be related to some sort of neurodevelopment condition.

Children who have their needs identified at an early stage and receive the right SEN interventions have better outcomes than those that don't. Getting the right interventions in place can prevent the chair chucking and the bullying before it ever starts - and of course not all children with SEN are bullies or chair chuckers, my point though is that children with unidentified and unsupported needs are more likely to display negative behaviours.

When a child is at the chair hucking stage it isn't just a case of removing them from the school either, it's nowhere near as simple as that and that's especially so if a child does have identified SEN.

If you want any education system where all children receive appropriate support and timely interventions then write to your MP and tell them to push for better funding.

cobicat · 08/06/2023 08:24

MyMachineAndMe · 08/06/2023 07:41

If you have never met the child, you cannot judge. You only have your own child's poor opinion of them, which could very easily be completely unjustified.

Yes - but you are ignoring the fact that I've known my own child for 16 years, so I've had ample opportunity to get to know them! I consider my child's judgment to be generally very fair.

OP posts:
MyMachineAndMe · 08/06/2023 07:41

cobicat · 07/06/2023 15:46

How much do you actually know about this child’s behaviour? Given your children are neither his friend or have been bullied by him? Maybe the school teacher know him better, and have perceived something they want to reward?

To be honest, I've never met the child, I only know what dc has told me over the years about them being a bully. I think it's slightly different to naughty primary school kids getting 'star of the week' to promote better behaviour, I think it's a case of the teachers genuinely finding this child charming & not realising how they treat some other students.

If you have never met the child, you cannot judge. You only have your own child's poor opinion of them, which could very easily be completely unjustified.

eurochick · 08/06/2023 07:08

This happened with my child's bully last year. I was bloody livid.

CoffeeCantata · 08/06/2023 07:08

OP, I sympathise.

Two uncomfortable things I've learned after a career in education:

  1. I agree with a pp who said that, depressingly, some bullies are superficially attractive and charismatic. A good 80% of the population, both adults and children, will fall for this and they'll be the popular ones. So unfair.

  2. From hearing some disturbing staffroom conversations over the years I've realised that some teachers are sympathetic to bullies - who knows - maybe they were bullies themselves - and cut them a lot of slack. I heard a lot of victim-blaming on the lines of 'Yeah, but you can see why they pick on them, can't you?'

I remember walking up to my classroom and overhearing the 'golden girl' being absolutely vile to a classmate with mild learning difficulties. I made sure she knew I'd heard what she said and that my opinion of her was changed by it - she was on track for Oxbridge and very popular - knowing someone had got her number wasn't going to dent her supreme confidence. But at least she knew I knew! She was an expert at showing an attractive face to adults.

IHeartGeneHunt · 08/06/2023 07:02

The bullies in my secondary school were made "Mentors" and we were supposed to go to them and report any bullying.

Seddon · 08/06/2023 06:19

I meant to add, one of my kids could be a right shit in primary school, not nasty to others but an annoying disruptive little bugger, and the odd bit of praise and acknowledgement of his good traits made a world of difference.

Seddon · 08/06/2023 06:17

Is this a significant award or one of the weekly ones that eventually get dished out to everyone?

Maybe they feel that recognising and rewarding good behaviour is an important strategy in tackling the bad behaviour and that the whole child can't be defined by their worst attributes?

Museya15 · 08/06/2023 06:13

Yes, we have one of them at my dd school, sweet as pie though In front of teachers and other adults, a horror in the playground and tells black children they can't play in her circle of friends. It's hard to watch how she is rewarded each year.

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 08/06/2023 06:11

Bringabrolly · 08/06/2023 05:59

A child’s perception of the situation matters though, it really matters.

my child was bullied, and what depressed her more than the bullying was that the teachers did nothing whatsoever. The ‘child had a terrible home life’ blah, blah, blah. (Not my problem. That doesn’t excuse him assaulting my child on a daily basis!). The teachers weren’t doing nothing, they were trying (totally ineffective) interventions but because my child didn’t see that he thought nothing was happening (and to be fair from where he was he was still getting hit on a daily basis…). Children’s perceptions of situations matter. If they think a bully is getting away scot free then they will rightly think that’s unfair.

Children who regularly physically assault staff and other kids need to be removed from our schools and taught somewhere where their emotional needs are being addressed too. Teachers time shouldn’t been taken up with trying to tame unruly kids. Our kids should feel safe at school. There is a reason why kids have such poor mental health and bullying is a big part of it.

I do agree but what do you want the teachers to do?

I had a friend at school who was autistic. Noone (Inc teachers) knew until we were about 14 and I'd been in the same class as her since nursery.

She was a "naughty" child and would often have meltdowns. There were consequences for her sometimes dangerous and threatening behaviour but they were different consequences to those someone NT might have faced (e.g they wouldn't exclude her because then she'd struggle returning to the classroom).

Should the teachers have ignored her distress so the rest of the school perceived her as the same as everyone else?

Or is it a parent's responsibility to say "you remember that talk your form tutor gave you and she explained that Lara is autistic? Well that means she needs different interventions and different consequences for her behaviour to help her learn."

Polari · 08/06/2023 06:10

I know so many instances of bullying in schools and the bullies have always come out best even when they were 'punished' by the school.

My friends dd took an od after being bullied. A year later she too sat at a gcse ceremony and watched one of the bullies get an award for community and citizenship bollocks.

The teachers knew full well what had happened.

Bringabrolly · 08/06/2023 05:59

Weal · 07/06/2023 15:52

I do understand the frustration. I think we all know through our own childhood and our children’s, of people who were unkind but somehow managed to do well. However again why do you think your children’s perception of the situation is more accurate than that of the teachers?

The teachers may well have developed a strategy to manage this child which involves them building a good relationship with him, giving praise when there is something to praise etc. to a child this may well look like favouritism but in reality it could be a planned strategy to work with him?

A child’s perception of the situation matters though, it really matters.

my child was bullied, and what depressed her more than the bullying was that the teachers did nothing whatsoever. The ‘child had a terrible home life’ blah, blah, blah. (Not my problem. That doesn’t excuse him assaulting my child on a daily basis!). The teachers weren’t doing nothing, they were trying (totally ineffective) interventions but because my child didn’t see that he thought nothing was happening (and to be fair from where he was he was still getting hit on a daily basis…). Children’s perceptions of situations matter. If they think a bully is getting away scot free then they will rightly think that’s unfair.

Children who regularly physically assault staff and other kids need to be removed from our schools and taught somewhere where their emotional needs are being addressed too. Teachers time shouldn’t been taken up with trying to tame unruly kids. Our kids should feel safe at school. There is a reason why kids have such poor mental health and bullying is a big part of it.

Heytheredeliah · 08/06/2023 05:56

Bringabrolly · 08/06/2023 05:50

Perhaps if the bully had been removed from the school once the chair chucking started then far fewer kids would bear the mental scars of bullying.

Totally agree. He should have been expelled. I hate it when teachers describe these naughty kids as special or characters. Nope they are just little shits.

BookishBabe · 08/06/2023 05:51

Unfortunately, it just seems to be the way it is.

A very popular boy in my school followed me home from school when we were 15 throwing rocks at me, spitting at me and hurling insults with his mates. He was definitely the ring leader. He was nominated and won prom King (popularity contest) by the staff the year after.

Very few people would be able to bully/steal/trick people if they were not charismatic, because they need enough people on their side and to believe them to get away with their shitty behaviour.