Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my husband to tell anyone I'm pregnant?

382 replies

whiteslemonade · 07/06/2023 15:31

Hi - new user here, asking for some perspective.

I'm 16 weeks pregnant, first child. It's taken me a while to get my head round the pregnancy - it happened much faster than I was expecting for various reasons, so although we were open to getting pregnant, it has been very disorientating for me and once I actually had a positive test I wasn't sure what I wanted to do. Anyway, we're continuing with the pregnancy and I'm now 16 weeks.

I haven't told anyone, apart from my line manager at work. We're geographically far from our families and haven't seen them since I was around 8 weeks, so obviously not showing, and I haven't got much of a bump yet anyway. I feel a really, really strong pull to keep this private for a while yet - hopefully until after the anatomy scan. Then I will start telling our Mum's etc. and maybe husband's siblings if I feel ready. I am a very private person anyway about things, I don't want people to know until we know the baby is okay (or at least we know as much as we can until it's here), and this feels like a time for me and my husband to adjust to this stage of life. I can't explain how I feel, I just feel a need for this to be our business for a little longer still.

My husband really wants us to tell our Mum's and his siblings. He thinks they will be very hurt/will want to support us/will be confused, and that to him is more important than my comfort and privacy. I have read/seen that some people don't announce to anyone until they've given birth, so waiting until 20 weeks doesn't seem that bad! It's starting to cause problems between us as he is fixated on this, says it feels like a lie whenever he speaks to his mum or I speak to mine.

I think at this stage I'm the one who has the final say, as I am the one going through it. Any opinions? What can I say to him to make him understand?

OP posts:
FlyingHighFlyingLow · 08/06/2023 09:18

sparkellie · 08/06/2023 09:07

But then would the father be allowed support if she did choose a late termination? Or not allowed to tell anyone and suffer the grief alone as its not his body??

OP said she would find it easier to tell people after the termination if something wrong at 20 weeks and have the support from them then, which confuses me! OP said wants to wait until 20 week scan to check all ok but what's the problem if you're going to tell them anyway?

sparkellie · 08/06/2023 09:07

But then would the father be allowed support if she did choose a late termination? Or not allowed to tell anyone and suffer the grief alone as its not his body??

sparkellie · 08/06/2023 09:00

He should be able to tell his family if he wants. Even if you prefer not to know if he does so. He has every right to support through the pregnancy and any complications. The fact that you want him to be your support through this but he's allowed noone doesn't sit well with me.

brunettemic · 08/06/2023 08:46

Sapphire387 · 08/06/2023 08:04

Errrrr no. The man's role is a supportive one. Supporting his pregnant wife/partner. This means listening to and respecting her wishes with regards to the pregnancy.

No, it’s to work in partnership, not to be subject to a dictatorship.

Sapphire387 · 08/06/2023 08:04

brunettemic · 07/06/2023 23:03

All these posts about how OP is the only one that matters…so when OP is tired later in pregnancy are we all agreed that her DH can simply ignore that and go to the pub with his mates? If he and his views or feelings don’t matter because he’s not pregnant then he doesn’t need to be involved until the baby is born at the very earliest. In fact, as he’s not carrying the baby, he can probably simply absolve himself of all responsibility and be exempt from blame.

Errrrr no. The man's role is a supportive one. Supporting his pregnant wife/partner. This means listening to and respecting her wishes with regards to the pregnancy.

Sapphire387 · 08/06/2023 08:03

SchoolShenanigans · 07/06/2023 22:21

I'd be hurt if my child only told me at 20wks. It just feels very secretive and stand offish to me.

Yes, but it's not about you, in that instance. You're not the one having the baby. Your feelings are not paramount.

Personally I would be happy with being told whenever my daughter/DIL felt ready. I would hate to think someone felt pressured to share the news earlier than they wanted to for fear of offending me. How awful.

Sapphire387 · 08/06/2023 08:01

FarmGirl78 · 07/06/2023 22:13

Whoa there, hold up, he's not said he's GOING to tell his parents, he's said he WANTS to tell his parents. He's stating his wishes. I think its a bigger red flag that you think men should feel forced to hide their feelings and bottle things up.

Won't somebody think of the MEN?!

Jesus Christ, I have heard it all on this thread.

OP's husband can state what he wants, of course he can. If OP says no, in this case, he should listen. As we're talking about her body.

As OP has posted here, I am guessing her husband is not wanting to respect her wishes, but thinks his wish to tell his mother should override that.

Sapphire387 · 08/06/2023 07:57

Kiwano · 08/06/2023 00:10

I wonder how you'd feel if this was the other way round, and it was the father who wanted to keep things quiet and the mother who wanted to announce it. There's clearly a case for arguing that women don't have the right to share their partner's sexual and medical information. But what if that prevented the woman from seeking support from her relatives or friends?

That's quite obvious. The woman is pregnant. If she wants to tell people SHE is pregnant, that is up to her. Of course couples should discuss this stuff, but ultimately the woman takes precedence as she is the one carrying the baby.

fucktonofcats · 08/06/2023 01:47

adriftinadenofvipers · 08/06/2023 01:36

I do hope you wouldn't consider terminating your pregnancy at this point other than foetal abnormality?

I do hope you wouldn't consider judging a woman for deciding what to do with her own body.

adriftinadenofvipers · 08/06/2023 01:36

I do hope you wouldn't consider terminating your pregnancy at this point other than foetal abnormality?

sandyhappypeople · 08/06/2023 00:30

whiteslemonade · 07/06/2023 16:40

@Maray1967 @Cheeseplantt - I'm glad everyone was supportive! This is what I'm confused about with other posters who are talking about being upset and offended, would anyone genuinely be nasty to a pregnant woman and her husband about this? I can't imagine being that self-centred about someone else's baby news.

Why would they be nasty? they're more likely to be hurt but I doubt they would even say anything, even if they did feel upset about not being told sooner? I think 20 weeks for medical reasons is perfectly normal when it comes to most of the family but not telling your respective mums sounds quite odd and controlling to me personally.

I get where your husband is coming from, I think the compromise would be to let him tell his mum, surely if anything was to go wrong he would be the one to tell them so not sure why you would feel so strongly about them knowing at this stage, I fully understand YOU not wanting to share with your family as that is fully your choice, but I thinks it's inconsiderate to stipulate that he can't when it's his child too. It sounds like it's been a strange time for both of you and he may feel like he needs his family support, but you're denying him that by insisting on it being a big secret. He may even be worried that instead of them being happy at the news when told, they'll be disappointed with him.

I don't want this to sound horrible, as it's a delicate subject but if I'm being perfectly honest it sounds to me that you're not 100% sure about this pregnancy at all and it almost sounds like you'd rather not tell people in case you decide to change your mind about the pregnancy, regardless of what the scan shows at 20 weeks.

I think a blanket ban on the other person doing something (whatever that is) in a relationship is only okay if you've got a genuine reason for it that you can express and they can understand, this 'because I said so' routine is a cop-out and he obviously doesn't fully understand your hesitation.

FWIW I wouldn't accept a 'because I said so' from my partner if I didn't agree with him about something, it's not how a healthy relationship with effective communication should work.

Kiwano · 08/06/2023 00:10

Sapphire387 · 07/06/2023 15:43

Oh dear. How dare a silly little woman ask her husband not to share her medical info? Perhaps you should be questioning what sort of a man knows his wife is uncomfortable but just says I don't really care, I want to tell my mum? Not nice.

I wonder how you'd feel if this was the other way round, and it was the father who wanted to keep things quiet and the mother who wanted to announce it. There's clearly a case for arguing that women don't have the right to share their partner's sexual and medical information. But what if that prevented the woman from seeking support from her relatives or friends?

Kiwano · 08/06/2023 00:07

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 07/06/2023 17:04

He should have absolutely no say while the baby is inside her body, no.

Giving a man rights over a baby in-utero, gives him rights over the woman’s body. A terrifying prospect, I’m sure you’d agree.

This isn't about him having rights over the baby. It's about his own right to talk to his family about his forthcoming child. It's not in the least terrifying.

Middlelanehogger · 07/06/2023 23:34

drpet49 · 07/06/2023 22:49

This. I imagine OP will be one of those ridiculous women who insists on not having visitors for months after the baby is born.

"I'm just such a private person..."

Middlelanehogger · 07/06/2023 23:32

Why is everyone talking about men having ownership over their partners' bodies all over this thread.

OP's partner isn't forcing her to get an abortion or continue the pregnancy, it's a completely irrelevant tangent.

OP doesn't have ownership over her partner's tongue by the same logic - so why should she control what he says with it?

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 07/06/2023 23:12

Sone posters seem to not be able to imagine beyond their own excitable feelings around pregnancies. It is a hugely complex time, and the OP’s feelings around it should be respected and yes, do take huge precedence.

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 07/06/2023 23:09

GrinAndVomit · 07/06/2023 18:17

Ok, just using your example:

Who gets to choose if she breastfeeds then?

Indeed. Or how the baby is born. If my husband tried to force me to conform or behave a certain way during pregnancy, he’d have regretted it.

Men really need to take a step back during pregnancy. Their role is simply to make the mother of their child as comfortable as possible. That is it. Their time to have some functional input is once the baby is born and everyone is good to go. Though their role retains a supporting aspect until the mother has recovered.

The handmaiden MRAs worry me.

brunettemic · 07/06/2023 23:03

All these posts about how OP is the only one that matters…so when OP is tired later in pregnancy are we all agreed that her DH can simply ignore that and go to the pub with his mates? If he and his views or feelings don’t matter because he’s not pregnant then he doesn’t need to be involved until the baby is born at the very earliest. In fact, as he’s not carrying the baby, he can probably simply absolve himself of all responsibility and be exempt from blame.

Purplepeaches123 · 07/06/2023 22:55

I think another 4 weeks is not that big a deal. We didn’t tell anyone until after our first scan with our first which back then was the 20 week one. I just wanted to be sure everything was ok With the other children first scans were 12 weeks so most people knew then. No one knew before that though.

brunettemic · 07/06/2023 22:53

YABU as you clearly want it all on your terms. You even say “ours mums and maybe his siblings”. Sure it’s fine to agree a time to tell people, we did it after the first scan.

drpet49 · 07/06/2023 22:49

neilyoungismyhero · 07/06/2023 18:01

Without his input she wouldn't have a baby in her belly. Poor bloke is itching to share the wonderful news with his mum and siblings and the OP seems to want to keep it a huge secret...why do her wishes come before his..it's not just her child.

This. I imagine OP will be one of those ridiculous women who insists on not having visitors for months after the baby is born.

arecklessmanor · 07/06/2023 22:37

@SchoolShenanigans my mum was over the moon when I told her at 6 months pregnant.
She was so excited she didn't have to wait too long to meet her grandchild. And she was equally over the moon when siblings told her earlier in pregnancies.
I didn't expect anything less of her, nor for her to make my pregnancy about her and what I felt comfortable with.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 07/06/2023 22:34

@whiteslemonade I'm sad to see how many people think you're being unreasonable. I absolutely agree with you. Please do not get upset over the comments. I only told my family about my first pregnancy when I was around 4 months pregnant, then didn't tell DH's family until a week before my due date (there were issues with them at the time and hadn't wanted them to spoil my pregnancy - wish we hadn't told them at all as of course they spoilt the end of it).

Anyway, ended up with a traumatic birth with my first, so didn't tell my family I was pregnant with number two until I was 6 months gone, then didn't tell any of DH's family or any of our friends until a week after the birth. When we told them, we explained that it was because of my birth trauma and my wishes for it to be kept secret, so that no one would be annoyed at my DH. Everyone was thankfully understanding.

I too am a very private person, and as far as I'm concerned, what's going on in your uterus is your business and your husband should respect that. You're only asking him to wait another 4 weeks, which is hardly anything. If his family have an issue with finding out half-way through, that's your business. Just explain how you wanted to tell everyone in person and after you knew baby was healthy at the anomaly scan.

Honestly, if anyone has an issue with it, that's on them. Not everyone is a big announcer when it comes to pregnancies and some people just can't get their head around that strangely.

SchoolShenanigans · 07/06/2023 22:21

I'd be hurt if my child only told me at 20wks. It just feels very secretive and stand offish to me.

FarmGirl78 · 07/06/2023 22:13

Sapphire387 · 07/06/2023 15:43

Oh dear. How dare a silly little woman ask her husband not to share her medical info? Perhaps you should be questioning what sort of a man knows his wife is uncomfortable but just says I don't really care, I want to tell my mum? Not nice.

Whoa there, hold up, he's not said he's GOING to tell his parents, he's said he WANTS to tell his parents. He's stating his wishes. I think its a bigger red flag that you think men should feel forced to hide their feelings and bottle things up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread