Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my husband to tell anyone I'm pregnant?

382 replies

whiteslemonade · 07/06/2023 15:31

Hi - new user here, asking for some perspective.

I'm 16 weeks pregnant, first child. It's taken me a while to get my head round the pregnancy - it happened much faster than I was expecting for various reasons, so although we were open to getting pregnant, it has been very disorientating for me and once I actually had a positive test I wasn't sure what I wanted to do. Anyway, we're continuing with the pregnancy and I'm now 16 weeks.

I haven't told anyone, apart from my line manager at work. We're geographically far from our families and haven't seen them since I was around 8 weeks, so obviously not showing, and I haven't got much of a bump yet anyway. I feel a really, really strong pull to keep this private for a while yet - hopefully until after the anatomy scan. Then I will start telling our Mum's etc. and maybe husband's siblings if I feel ready. I am a very private person anyway about things, I don't want people to know until we know the baby is okay (or at least we know as much as we can until it's here), and this feels like a time for me and my husband to adjust to this stage of life. I can't explain how I feel, I just feel a need for this to be our business for a little longer still.

My husband really wants us to tell our Mum's and his siblings. He thinks they will be very hurt/will want to support us/will be confused, and that to him is more important than my comfort and privacy. I have read/seen that some people don't announce to anyone until they've given birth, so waiting until 20 weeks doesn't seem that bad! It's starting to cause problems between us as he is fixated on this, says it feels like a lie whenever he speaks to his mum or I speak to mine.

I think at this stage I'm the one who has the final say, as I am the one going through it. Any opinions? What can I say to him to make him understand?

OP posts:
Yourcatisnotsorry · 08/06/2023 19:25

For various reasons I also didn’t tell people (including close family) until 16 weeks (we had a private scan). I have work colleagues who told me the day after they took a test so it’s very much each to their own. I think it might damage your/his relationship with the grandparents not to tell them but I can understand why you want it private for now. Neither of you are being unreasonable. Can you agree a date to let th know and a nice way to do it, a card with a scan picture in, a grandparent present or something. There is always a chance they find out (someone spots you at the doctors or notices a pregnancy book in your bag for example - both of these happened to me as the person noticing someone’s pregnancy) and they could be very upset. you’ll realise how important supportive grandparents are when you have a baby so including them in your special news is important I think.

Lilacrose27 · 08/06/2023 19:23

I see it from both sides but I do think that you’re being slightly unreasonable. I appreciate it’s your body but at the same time it’s both of you that created that child he’s clearly very excited about the fact that he’s going to be a dad and if he wants to tell people he should be allowed to. just because you are carrying the baby doesn’t mean you automatically get to make every decision it should be a mutual decision and sometimes compromises need to be made.

I told my close family and friends that I was pregnant and miscarried and was so grateful for the support I received and that I didn’t have to go through it on my own. I then got pregnant again not long after and we told close friends and family again, my partner always asked if he could tell certain people certain things and still does now as my pregnancy is progressing and I think that he gets equal say on things because he helped create the child.

once the child is born are you going to allow your partner to make decisions or will he still have to consult you first? because in my opinion it’s no different to that. It sounds like you’re unsure about the pregnancy in the first place and to be honest it might be nice for you to have the support, if you keep it from people and they find out that you didn’t want to tell them they may take offence and it may cause issues in the future again I’m
speaking from experience.

Bekstar · 08/06/2023 19:23

If your mum or his is a more than once time mum themselves I'll tell you now they'll sniff that baby out like a fish supper at the Seaside. I kind of agree with both we come from a large family and I told my mum early on at about 3 weeks. His mum isn't on the scene but we did email her to let her know at 20 weeks most people had guessed between 16-20 weeks anyway. We did our official announcement at 20 weeks. I can see why he wants to tell his mum could you not compromise and say mums only till 20 weeks ask them not to announce as you'd like to announce it yourself at 20 weeks.

laylababe5 · 08/06/2023 19:23

bibbityboppityboo · 07/06/2023 15:43

Ooo tough one!

I can definitely see your side of things, but also his - it's exciting and a huge part of your lives, it is understandable he wants to be able to tell those people closest to him.

In the family members positions, I'd think 20+ weeks would be a slightly unusual time to tell people but I'd have zero feelings apart from happiness for the couple.

Could he tell his parents and siblings and you not tell yours? That's a sort of 50/50 compromise?

I would be so angry if I found out my daughter was pregnant and the father's Mum knew weeks before I did! I think tell both sets of parents and swear them to secrecy until after the 20 week scan. But as OP said they won't be seeing them in person for a while and I do think this kind of news is lovely to tell in person. I loved seeing the look on my Mum's face when I told her and getting all the hugs 🥰

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 08/06/2023 19:17

Sapphire387 · 07/06/2023 15:34

This is a bit of a red flag re: your husband. You need him to have your back at a vulnerable time. For example, you will need him to advocate for you during birth, and gatekeep visitors afterwards while you are recovering. At the moment, baby is a part of your body. You are not public property and what you say, goes.

How is it a red flag to want to inform his mother and siblings? He is not saying he wants to plaster it all over social media etc he is asking to tell his close family members and you conclude it’s a red flag which means he will not advocate for her etc. the way people on mumsnet take things to the next level is alarming.

7eleven · 08/06/2023 18:59

Your body, you get to decide.

PonkyPonky · 08/06/2023 18:45

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable, however… I do think you should look for a compromise. You want 4 more weeks and he wants zero so why not meet in the middle at 2 weeks? I say this as someone keen to wait as long as possible for very similar reasons but the day has to come eventually and it allows both of you to get some much needed support from your families. I also felt very much better about everything once it wasn’t a secret anymore

whycantmenfindstuff · 08/06/2023 18:20

I do understand the need to keep it private from random people, distant friends but not parents

PeloMom · 08/06/2023 18:03

I can relate to a lot of what you are saying - from the mixed/ complicated feelings when it happened faster than expected etc, sharing the info, etc. My experience was that I went on to developing prenatal and later on postnatal anxiety/ depression as a result (maybe something to keep an eye on). I don’t think you’re being unreasonable- if you need more time, you need more time. Whether it’s 16 weeks or 26 makes no difference as most people would have shared with their families by 12-14 weeks. You can always say you wanted to first make sure everything is going well and baby is healthy if you feel like you want to explain your decision (you don’t have to).

Twentytwothousand · 08/06/2023 17:54

It’s your call and I don’t think 20 weeks is unreasonable at all. I told my mum at 13 weeks and asked her not to tell. She told her friends and then we had to have an amniocentesis as certain tests were a bit worrying so I was incredibly pissed off she’d betrayed my trust and had a load of virtual strangers “worrying”. But I do think you need to get your round being pregnant at all. You sound slightly in denial. It is a major head f*#% but, all being well, there will be a baby and you and DH need to get onto the same page on lots of pregnancy and baby related issues. Kids are great. Best thing I’ve ever accomplished but the change in your life is profound so make sure you’re not reluctant to tell people because it isn’t “real” if that makes sense. It is real. Your DH is just very excited “look what I did” - it’s natural

Middlelanehogger · 08/06/2023 13:18

@Thesunnymood exactly, treating family as essentially uninvolved strangers who have no right to know anything about your personal life is all very well and good, but don't be surprised when they get the message and don't want to be involved in your life down the track when you need them

overwork · 08/06/2023 13:07

Anyone who would be upset about not knowing about someone's pregnancy before that person is ready to tell them is absolutely being unfair to the pregnant person, who has enough going on with their changing body and hormones without having to worry about how others will feel over something really quite trivial. So yes, I'll very much enjoy my sane normal relatives who would do nothing of the sort

adriftinadenofvipers · 08/06/2023 12:56

overwork · 08/06/2023 12:51

We didn't tell anyone (bar my line manager) until 22 weeks. Similar-ish situation, except that we were not trying, so it took an awfully long time to get our own heads around it.
We also knew that we wouldn't continue the pregnancy if there big complications at the anomaly scan, so we felt that we had plenty of reasons not tell.
We told all family, in person, around the same time and they were all thrilled for us. No one got offended or hurt or cross that we'd 'lied' to them, I can only guess that's because our relatives are sane and don't expect autonomy over my life and body.
They are all now fully involved with the idea of their grandchild / niece or nephew (it's not arrived yet) and making plans to spend time with us when it arrives

Well kudos on the “sane” relatives… 🙄

Hollyppp · 08/06/2023 12:54

drpet49 · 07/06/2023 22:49

This. I imagine OP will be one of those ridiculous women who insists on not having visitors for months after the baby is born.

I agree, If OP is this precious at just pregnancy stage she’s gonna be in for one hell of a ride with giving birth, feeding, sleep issues, recovering, early motherhood, motherhood in general!!

overwork · 08/06/2023 12:51

We didn't tell anyone (bar my line manager) until 22 weeks. Similar-ish situation, except that we were not trying, so it took an awfully long time to get our own heads around it.
We also knew that we wouldn't continue the pregnancy if there big complications at the anomaly scan, so we felt that we had plenty of reasons not tell.
We told all family, in person, around the same time and they were all thrilled for us. No one got offended or hurt or cross that we'd 'lied' to them, I can only guess that's because our relatives are sane and don't expect autonomy over my life and body.
They are all now fully involved with the idea of their grandchild / niece or nephew (it's not arrived yet) and making plans to spend time with us when it arrives

CurlewKate · 08/06/2023 12:45

Personally, I wasn't vulnerable after I gave birth, and needed neither advocate nor gatekeeper. I needed, and was lucky enough to have, a friend, cheerleader and co parent.

adriftinadenofvipers · 08/06/2023 12:38

fucktonofcats · 08/06/2023 01:47

I do hope you wouldn't consider judging a woman for deciding what to do with her own body.

In these circumstances I absolutely would!!

This is just bonkers quite frankly.

Thesunnymood · 08/06/2023 12:26

We had someone in a family who did this. Family members were quite hurt and quite frankly, it showed on relationship after. It's simply now more acquaintance relationship than family. Dc still get presents etc but not much contact because the family just isn't that close. It's usually also not just the pregnancy but other things around child where family was treated like some random distant mates.

It's his baby too. It's crass not to allow him to say it to his family. Totally different to abortion decision....

WickedSerious · 08/06/2023 12:16

phoenixrosehere · 08/06/2023 09:43

If my DH was diagnosed with cancer, I would still respect his wishes because it’s his body. They are other ways to access support that doesn’t involve telling family and friends. Many of us are on MN anonymously, are we not?

When my DP's cancer was diagnosed we didn't tell a soul until we knew exactly what we were dealing with.Once we knew the cancer hadn't spread and what treatment was required we told his parents and our adult DC.
The only other people who knew were DP's manager and several of his colleagues.
I was almost five months pregnant with our DS before we told anyone and it was four months before we announced that our DD was on the way.

I wanted to minimise the amount of time I spent listening to horror stories about childbirth and nonsense like how fat/tired/ill I'd be by the time I was six months gone.

phoenixrosehere · 08/06/2023 09:43

sandyhappypeople · 08/06/2023 09:33

I think all the people saying her body, her choice, no exception, need to think about if it was the other way round? Say he was diagnosed with cancer, but decided he didn’t want anyone else to know, it’s his choice so would be respected. But, assuming a loving family on both sides, it would be extremely isolating for the partner to have to go through all that alone and also keep that secret, the role of supporting partner is often a thankless, lonely place at the best of times.

My point earlier, was that there should be a good reason to inflict that on your partner, and this is the important bit: if you can’t verbalise those reasons to your partner, you should think about why you’re REALLY imposing those restrictions in the first place, saying ‘because I said so’ isn’t really good enough.

If my DH was diagnosed with cancer, I would still respect his wishes because it’s his body. They are other ways to access support that doesn’t involve telling family and friends. Many of us are on MN anonymously, are we not?

GrinAndVomit · 08/06/2023 09:39

GrinAndVomit · 08/06/2023 09:36

I still believe she should not tell anyone if that is what he had asked for even in this scenario.
She would have to access professional support

sorry, my message got cut short.

The OP has requested a further month until her anomaly scan.

In your scenario, if the husband with cancer asked for his wife to not tell family until further tests had been done a few weeks later and they knew more information, yes, I’d absolutely expect her to keep his confidence.

phoenixrosehere · 08/06/2023 09:38

Sapphire387 · 08/06/2023 08:03

Yes, but it's not about you, in that instance. You're not the one having the baby. Your feelings are not paramount.

Personally I would be happy with being told whenever my daughter/DIL felt ready. I would hate to think someone felt pressured to share the news earlier than they wanted to for fear of offending me. How awful.

Agree.

I know some of DH’s side were annoyed when we didn’t tell them the second time around until after the 20 week scan with our second and we quickly pointed out how they behaved with our first and how unsupportive they were the first time after our anomaly scan where there was a possible issue. They have a tendency to hear but not listen or consider what they’re saying and how not everything deserves an opinion.

We told my parents after them both times and they were excited and supportive. There was no question on why didn’t you inform us sooner, more on when they think they would be able to come and visit and if we were going to find out the gender or wait and see.

GrinAndVomit · 08/06/2023 09:36

sandyhappypeople · 08/06/2023 09:33

I think all the people saying her body, her choice, no exception, need to think about if it was the other way round? Say he was diagnosed with cancer, but decided he didn’t want anyone else to know, it’s his choice so would be respected. But, assuming a loving family on both sides, it would be extremely isolating for the partner to have to go through all that alone and also keep that secret, the role of supporting partner is often a thankless, lonely place at the best of times.

My point earlier, was that there should be a good reason to inflict that on your partner, and this is the important bit: if you can’t verbalise those reasons to your partner, you should think about why you’re REALLY imposing those restrictions in the first place, saying ‘because I said so’ isn’t really good enough.

I still believe she should not tell anyone if that is what he had asked for even in this scenario.
She would have to access professional support

sandyhappypeople · 08/06/2023 09:33

I think all the people saying her body, her choice, no exception, need to think about if it was the other way round? Say he was diagnosed with cancer, but decided he didn’t want anyone else to know, it’s his choice so would be respected. But, assuming a loving family on both sides, it would be extremely isolating for the partner to have to go through all that alone and also keep that secret, the role of supporting partner is often a thankless, lonely place at the best of times.

My point earlier, was that there should be a good reason to inflict that on your partner, and this is the important bit: if you can’t verbalise those reasons to your partner, you should think about why you’re REALLY imposing those restrictions in the first place, saying ‘because I said so’ isn’t really good enough.

ejbaxa · 08/06/2023 09:27

I think it’s fine to want to do this your way, but I would just say that you probably ought to acknowledge that it is far from the “standard” way to do it. I would also just say that if a close relative of mine told me about a pregnancy at 20 weeks, I wouldn’t be offended or kick off about it but I would think that we were not as close as I thought.