Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Accused of being nasty for the sake of it.

60 replies

Orlabean · 07/06/2023 15:13

Just before the pandemic my cousin got married in another continent. Cousin and her husband are well off and were generous to pay for tickets and hotels.

At the very very last minute I decided I couldn't go. To state that I was incredibly ill would be an understatement. I was almost admitted to a private psychiatric clinic due to depression, suicidal ideation, self-medicating with alcohol, bulimia etc. I was a high achiever who basically just crashed and burned when "success" turned out to be meaningless to me. I went to one of the best grammar schools in the country, then on to Oxford and lost the will to live when I started my grad scheme.

Cousin was very hurt as you would expect, she didn't know the extent of my issues but we've recently tried reconciling. Didn't speak for a long time.

I went to this cousin's house over the weekend, knew it was going to be very awkward initially, but had a good time overall. One of the family members she has become close to (started friendship at wedding) thought it was her place to tell me what I did "wasn't really on, was it?"

I simply told I've apologied to cousin and that I was confused as to why she felt it was her place to admonish me. I said you are perfect stranger to me and I really don't care to share the details behind why I couldn't make it as she is not anyone to me.

It was like an actual bomb exploding, everyone went quiet and the atmosphere changed. Im so over placating all the time. As a reformed people pleaser who kept quiet for years and years, it always seems I'm the only person on the planet who isn't allowed to say anything non-pleasant.

The person who made the comment is an in law and the person they are married to shared with a family member not in attendance that I was despicably rude.

I know it wasn't a kind thing to say ofc but was it THAT bad to be gossiping about it?

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
candlesflamesandbrooms · 08/06/2023 11:36

@Nicecow I get what your saying. But you realise that inserting yourself into a situation (that didn't involve you and you don't need to make a comment) makes you the rude person and the person setting up this dynamic right ?

Op wasn't responding to air. No one knows what a single person is facing at any time, kindness and the assumption that op isn't a complete knobber should be a basic.

I would understand someone saying why didn't you come to wedding ? I heard bride was upset. And pausing and listening to the response.

But making a passive aggressive comment is brave, it's cowardly. And sometimes people bite back..

Saz12 · 08/06/2023 00:14

If you didnt explain how unwell you were, what reason dos you give for not going?
If cousin & her wider family just got some wiahy-washy excuse, then they might be pissy that you were "busy at work" so didnt attend, even though thwyd spent £x-hundred on you.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 07/06/2023 23:37

She was deliberately being snide and deserved a stronger retort than she received YANBU

Weal · 07/06/2023 23:34

Personally I think good on you. Your cousin and you have been reconciling and you are both adults capable of communicating and addressing the issue between you.

This woman has nothing to do with the situation and should have kept her nose out. I don’t think your response was rude actually, I think it was direct and assertive.

Does your cousin know how unwell you were. Seems unfair to give someone grief for not attending because they were in mental health crisis.

Nicecow · 07/06/2023 23:27

Lacucuracha · 07/06/2023 15:26

But the in law IS a stranger to OP. Why is telling the truth rude? It's not her place to comment on OP's non-attendance.

This is something I might do if I was feeling brave and trying to 'stand up' for my cousin (even though yes it's none of my business, and if I didn't actually know the situation and just thought OP couldn't be bothered, and especially if she didn't offer to cover costs etc). Not saying it's right, but just pointing out why someone might do this. OPs situation is extreme and I'm assuming most probably thought it was a last minute cancellation for selfish reasons. I wouldn't worry about it OP, just clear it with your cousin who obviously still cares for you

candlesflamesandbrooms · 07/06/2023 23:17

Grumpy101 · 07/06/2023 19:39

@candlesflamesandbrooms I think family who have probably had to listen to the bride/groom being upset about it do have a right to say something. The bride is not some individual living in isolation and it's pretty normal for family to say something in this instance. It could have been solved very easily by the OP saying she had some very difficult health issues at the time which she didn't have the strength to go into and that she of course was also sad she couldn't make it.

Fine to tell someone it's none of their business. But also fine for them to consider you rude, that's my point.

Frankly it wasn't their place to say anything they didn't lose out, it wasn't their wedding , they were doing it to make themselves feel big.

That in my book is shit stirring. Most people with a ounce of common sense know there's two sides to every story and don't blindly start drama on someone's behalf.Some people seem to love looking for trouble and act shocked when they find it.

It's fine for them to think ops rude, I personally think actually they are saying it because they were embarrassed and op showed them up. Good.

Don't start a fight (which this person did by inserting herself into something that wasn't about her) and the. complain when someone finishes it and you end up worse off

If I was watching that I would have thought the person who made the comment (who didn't need to) was incredibly rude and my sympathy would be with the person who was having a serious mental crisis (and received inpatient help?!) and not the shit stirrers hurt ego.

Op honestly some people like to get "involved" in other peoples fights and make nasty comments because their lives are boring and they love the drama. Do you really care what this type of person thinks of you ?

Instead of worrying what other people think of you, flip it around and think actually what do I think of this person. And act accordingly.

frazzledasarock · 07/06/2023 20:09

Well the in law made it her business to be rude to you without details of your reason for being absent from cousins wedding. And she got a fitting reply.

I wouldn’t apologise either. I wouldn’t give it any more thought. Anyone who comes at you to tell you off, tell them to mind their own business you’ve sorted it with your cousin. Nothing to do with anyone else.

5128gap · 07/06/2023 20:01

This branch of your family sound like harder work than you need OP.
To be still be making a drama about one cousin who couldn't attend a wedding for health reasons, not speaking, other people involving themselves...its way too intense.
You did right to speak up for yourself, but unfortunately these people seem to enjoy an excuse for offense and bad feeling.
For your own wellbeing, you should probably distance yourselves from them all, as it will be drama after crisis, fall out after upset, and you don't need that.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 07/06/2023 19:51

Tbh while you don't have to share details with anyone I wouldn't just said you had a severe episode of I'll health and simply couldn't ever have made it.

Surely saying it was due to your health would make all the drama go away?

Grumpy101 · 07/06/2023 19:39

@candlesflamesandbrooms I think family who have probably had to listen to the bride/groom being upset about it do have a right to say something. The bride is not some individual living in isolation and it's pretty normal for family to say something in this instance. It could have been solved very easily by the OP saying she had some very difficult health issues at the time which she didn't have the strength to go into and that she of course was also sad she couldn't make it.

Fine to tell someone it's none of their business. But also fine for them to consider you rude, that's my point.

Createausername1970 · 07/06/2023 19:05

The just of what you said was fair enough, maybe it could have phrased differently.

But have you actually told the bride and groom the full extent of why you couldn't attend? If not, and if you feel able to face up to it now, could you explain to them exactly what happened, your mum hiding sharp implements and guarding you at night to keep you safe etc. You could say you don't want this common knowledge, but now you are coming to terms with it yourself you felt they deserved an explanation, and you realise you may have inadvertently upset nosey baggage, but you were taken off guard by such a direct comment as it's still a difficult subject for you to deal with.

candlesflamesandbrooms · 07/06/2023 18:45

Grumpy101 · 07/06/2023 17:36

There is a massive difference between being a people pleaser and explaining yourself in such a situation.

It's fine to not explain yourself. But you have to deal with the consequences of appearing rude then. You can't be rude to someone and be surprised when they pull you up on your behaviour. It goes both ways!

You didn't explain to the bride at the time what the reason was and it would have looked like you didn't feel like going. Of course she was upset and it would have cast a shadow on the event. And if that relative didn't know the background either, she was right to think you were rude and is right to be annoyed with you.

Why ? Why does some random have the right to be annoyed. Sure the bride when she didn't know ? But some random person who isn't entitled to know what went down.

Who is actually that entitled to think like this ?!? 🤯

The problem is when you make a passive aggressive comment about something you have absolutely zero about or stick your nose where it doesn't belong, you should expect someone one day might be to rightly be rude back or knock that nose right out of joint.
It's a risk you take.

Second thought you must actually be joking, like literally pulling everyone's chain. No one in RL can be that oblivious or that entitled to think they have right to comment on a situation that didn't impact them (since this person who was rude to op wasn't the bride) and sounds like they were shit stirring.

CrackedSkull · 07/06/2023 18:09

I would have said I don't want to go there thank you as it's personal and them just got up and walked away . Or said nothing . And Got up and walked away .

Inkyblue123 · 07/06/2023 17:43

She had it coming - she should mind her own business. Stop mulling this over - it’s not good for your mental health. And if anybody asks tell them the same. Thankyou for enquiring but I don’t wish to discuss this with you, it’s very personal

BreviloquentBastard · 07/06/2023 17:41

Nah, good for you. It was none of her business and she was rude to you bringing it up and telling you off in front of people like you're a child. If you and your cousin feel you've squared it away the nosy bint had no business dragging it up again.

As a fellow reformed people pleaser, I applaud you for showing your teeth.

Grumpy101 · 07/06/2023 17:36

There is a massive difference between being a people pleaser and explaining yourself in such a situation.

It's fine to not explain yourself. But you have to deal with the consequences of appearing rude then. You can't be rude to someone and be surprised when they pull you up on your behaviour. It goes both ways!

You didn't explain to the bride at the time what the reason was and it would have looked like you didn't feel like going. Of course she was upset and it would have cast a shadow on the event. And if that relative didn't know the background either, she was right to think you were rude and is right to be annoyed with you.

Kiwano · 07/06/2023 17:22

Congratulations on standing up for yourself. She had no business telling you off - it wasn't her wedding or her money, and she certainly had no right to demand that you account for yourself. I wonder if she would have felt it appropriate to tell someone off for not coming to the wedding if the reason for them being unable to go was a physical illness? She was certainly the one being rude.

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 07/06/2023 17:10

Orlabean · 07/06/2023 15:28

I could have taken a softer approach. But i'm sick to the back teeth of always apologising tbh.

You shouldn't have taken a softer approach. She was rude to you, she got it right back. If she doesn't like plain speaking then she should refrain from doing it herself.

FarmGirl78 · 07/06/2023 16:52

Orlabean · 07/06/2023 15:28

I could have taken a softer approach. But i'm sick to the back teeth of always apologising tbh.

I think there's an ocean of difference between apologising, and explanating.

If you didn't give the Bride a quick heads up (or get your Mum to) that your change of heart was due to medical reasons beyond your control its understandable that the Bride might be ranting to friends about it. Unless I've missed it, it looks like from her point of view you just decided not to go on a whim.

This other person ranting at you was unnecessary, but I can totally see how it happened. I'm glad you've decided not to be a people pleaser or get walked over, but you could easily have nipped this in the bud before it started. Rather than being a people pleaser you've now put yourself in the position of being a people dis-pleaser.

GCalltheway · 07/06/2023 16:40

That is massive progress congratulations and don’t you dare feel bad!!!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Campervangirl · 07/06/2023 16:24

Funny how when you stick up for yourself you're labelled/called despicably rude 🙄
The relative had no business calling you out.
Unfortunately for them they obviously didn't expect you to give it straight back to them, they'll have expected you, as a self confessed people pleaser, to roll over and take their shit then they can walk away with a "that told her" attitude.
Good for you for sticking up for yourself, feels don't it?

REP22 · 07/06/2023 16:20

You don't sound nasty at all. It is absolutely no business of this person's why you weren't able to go to the wedding, nor is it their place to rebuke you for it. It's between you and your cousin and nobody else.

Please don't beat yourself up. I have been in a very similar place to the one you were in at the time; it's impossible to overstate how debilitating and life-shattering it is.

(FWIW, you possibly did the best thing at the time for all concerned, not just yourself - I went to a big wedding when I was at one of my worst points in my own situation and made an utter, UTTER tool of myself in front of many. You saved yourself - and your cousin - from having to live with that. This probably doesn't help much, but I hope it's of at least some use in making you feel a bit better).

I hope you are in a better place these days, and wish you much happiness and health to come.

2bazookas · 07/06/2023 16:19

MichelleScarn · 07/06/2023 16:12

Where did the inlaw tell op she was rude? From what ive read, she was told the last minute cancellation 'wasn't on', am sure that's what's said on most wedding threads when people do this.

Don't comment if you've not read the OP. Its in the first post.

The person who made the comment is an in law and the person they are married to shared with a family member not in attendance that I was despicably rude.

2bazookas · 07/06/2023 16:15

Good for you: you were admirably restrained.

Darkandstormynite · 07/06/2023 16:15

Good on you OP!

It sounds like a lot more uncomfortable conversations need to happen in your family. It's possible that the culture of 'don't rock the boat' may have actually contributed to making you ill.

Change is always uncomfortable but you are building a better future for your mental health by being true to your own feelings.

Don't give nosy bitch a second thought, she just got her arse handed to her and it may make her think twice in the future. In your shoes, if anyone tried to pull me up on it I'd double down and say 'I wasn't willing to discuss my private business with a stranger'.

Swipe left for the next trending thread