Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's impossible to have no thoughts or internal dialogue?

143 replies

IAteAllTheTomatoes · 07/06/2023 12:55

Is it true that some people have nothing going on in their head? No thoughts, ideas, or internal dialogue?

I'm not being bitchy or talking about intelligence but I just always assumed your brain is thinking or you are silently talking to yourself? Like, will my parcel arrive today? What will I make for dinner later? Something anything? Future plans? Pondering on something in the news etc?

Someone told me yesterday there is nothing in their thoughts, except maybe music, until they are asked a question?

I would love to have no thoughts? It is possible?

I'm explaining this poorly but I suppose what I'm wondering is can people shut down their thinking and if so, how?

OP posts:
Verv · 07/06/2023 17:27

described*

Verv · 07/06/2023 17:26

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 07/06/2023 15:48

Yes like others I don't have a strong inner monologue, I also tend not to clearly imagine images. I tend to just know. So I won't think to myself 'oh I fancy a cup of tea' instead it is just a concept. My brain is a bit like a huge warehouse of filing cabinets and I just retrieve the appropriate information when needed, I don't need to listen to anything or picture anything, it is just there. Dh however will be wandering along talking out loud to himself. He will also rehearse conversations and then analyse them afterwards whereas I just tend to say what I am thinking and then stop.

As a pp said though it can be harder in a group setting when lots of others are talking to form ideas in my mind of what to say because I am listening to their ideas. I tend to find that my mouth starts talking and trying to verbalise the concept as if forms in my mind. I think for this reason I would say I am an introvert, I like quiet to work and when not working I tend to read or sleep. When I do have thoughts going through my mind it is never a positive thing.

I have an equivalent level of qualifications to dh and a fairly academic job. If anything I probably find it easier to work and think because I am less distracted and ruminate less than he does.

After my mother died, something in my head snapped, and Ive always describe it as someone went into the filing cabinets in my brain, rummaged about, and took some files away. So it's comforting to know that someone else sees their brain in the same way.

I cant run film in my head either, I can summon up an image of something or someone, but adding in movement/words is not possible for me. Flash images only.

Verv · 07/06/2023 17:24

JaneJeffer · 07/06/2023 16:47

I find this so hard to imagine.

So you can turn your brain off completely? What about your senses? How do they not trigger thoughts?

It's more like it flicks between standby mode and thinking.
My senses dont trigger thoughts, ive just looked out of my study window and my view is a huge clematis in full bloom, just saw it, it looks lovely, but it didnt take my brain off standby and into thinking something about it.

Createausername1970 · 07/06/2023 17:14

I don't know if I would describe it as a monologue - that implies order.

I have a muddle in my head, and I flit between them.

Did I feed the dog? Why is the floor sticky? Oh God, I didn't send that email. Oooh nice cup of tea. Did I feed the dog? Shall I defrost chicken or sausages? Oh, mustn't forget my Wordle. Need to ask my boss about the insurance letter. Did I remember to reinsure our car. Did I feed the dog. Oooh nice cup of tea.

Some of it is words, my voice in my head. Some of it is pictures, like the Wordle logo.
Some of it is flashes of colour, like the colouring in my dog's coat.

Curseofthenation · 07/06/2023 17:09

I didn't say all people with an inner monologue use it to read! I said that it had been mentioned in this thread that some people read this way. I think it's time to let this lie, we aren't getting anywhere.

the80sweregreat · 07/06/2023 16:58

I'm always thinking the worst , so maybe my internal monologue isn't a good thing!
I often say something , then might replay it over in my mind too in case I upset that person!

steppemum · 07/06/2023 16:55

I wonder how this relates to anxiety?

I have a couple of friends who have anxiety and one of the phrases they use is that they overthink things. With one of them, when encouraging them in something, one comment is always - but what if....

Please don't misunderstand me, I am not saying that inner monologue = anxiety, but I wonder if that is where her - but what if... is coming from, like an inner monolgue that is malfunctioning/switched into overdrive?

Atnilpoe · 07/06/2023 16:52

Sorry to pick on you @Curseofthenation but why do you assume that people with an internal monologue read in it? I certainly don’t. I can but mostly won’t do so.

RoseslnTheHospital · 07/06/2023 16:51

Curseofthenation · 07/06/2023 16:43

@RoseslnTheHospital I'm sorry if I caused you any offence. It just seems less efficient as a thinking process to me because I don't think that way but that doesn't mean I think that people with inner monologues are slow thinkers. A process can be more labour intensive without taking any or much more time.

As other posters have mentioned people that read using an inner voice are generally slower as a result than people that just absorb the words. It might be that the people that have inner monologues take in more because they have more time to process it. I'm sure there are pros and cons to both sides in many different ways.

But it's not more labour intensive... that's your erroneous impression.

Having an inner monologue doesn't mean that reading is also done with an "internal voice". That's not how I read for example, I "just absorb the words" as words, as you say.

Having an inner monologue doesn't take more time to process things. It's just different.

steppemum · 07/06/2023 16:49

This is so interesting.
I am an extrovert and very verbal.

But I don't have a constant internal monologue, when I walk the dog for example, for some of the time I am actively thinking. Thinking about a situation, sometimes verbalising that in my head (how would I explain that to that person).
Then for a mile or so I might just be pottering along, looking at trees and clouds and listening to the birds.

I don't 'think things through' before I say them. I don't know how you would do that while the other person is talking. But I do sometimes think about it in advance if I have a difficult conversation coming.

If I am home alone, I tend to have radio/music/tv on. I find it soothing, because provides white noise (although I do actually listen to it)

If there is no radio on, I can be thinking actively (like planning something) or I can be drifting, eg sewing and letting my thoughts wander, and be fuzzy, unclear, which is relaxing.

I would find it exhausting to have a constant monolgue.

Atnilpoe · 07/06/2023 16:48

Reading the thread it is very weird to me that some people seem to feel superior about their “way” of doing it! Rather than it just being human difference!

I have an internal monologue @Curseofthenation but I don’t use it to plan out what I say in advance- unless there’s a specific reason to take care in constructing something. Words come out of my mouth without having “heard” them in my brain first. My work is public speaking related and taking is actually an area where I have “flow”. I can read transcripts of what I said after the event and be amazed that all that came out so coherently without me “thinking” any of it.

JaneJeffer · 07/06/2023 16:47

Verv · 07/06/2023 15:31

I am one of the people who doesnt have an internal monologue. It actually surprised me that some peoples brains are constantly twittering at them. It would drive me round the bend.

I have an occasional thought that pops up like "I need to remember to stick a wash on later", but they're noticeable by their infrequency if that makes sense.
Its not like a completely empty brain though, I can think things through and am thinking (obviously) while writing this but I call the thoughts into my head, and once ive finished my thinking my brain goes back to being quiet with no white noise chit chat inside it.

I dont overtly think "I fancy a cup of tea", but I autopilot to the kettle instead. it isnt a brain conversation in that sense.

this might be of interest - https://mymodernmet.com/inner-monologue/

I find this so hard to imagine.

So you can turn your brain off completely? What about your senses? How do they not trigger thoughts?

behaveasbefitsthesituationwillyas · 07/06/2023 16:47

The chatter in my head is constant, but weirdly, I don’t find it exhausting. It’s often soothing for me. There’s nothing I like more than a good chat in my own head…😂 but my internal monologue isn’t negative/ I don’t have intrusive thoughts which must make a difference.

Yes, I find it soothing too. I can't imagine any other way I guess.

behaveasbefitsthesituationwillyas · 07/06/2023 16:45

HaveWeGotAnyCake · 07/06/2023 13:09

My brain never switches off! I have thoughts, tunes, daydreams, ideas, memories, etc., all day - right up until I fall asleep

I am the same! I have mostly daydreams, long running storylines going on in my head that have no basis in reality, like novels. They take up a lot of my brain's energy - images, music, feelings etc. I can be at work but a part of my brain is still on this, 24/7, in the background.

My thoughts based on reality are usually short and instinctive, like picturing a baked potato for dinner, rather than think a whole sentence about it.

Confuzzlediddled · 07/06/2023 16:44

No internal monologue doesn't equal not thinking!

I have no monologue, no voices, no sound and I am far from "stopping thinking" just because I'm not having a conversation in my head doesn't mean I'm not intelligent. Same with "seeing" I have no pictures in my head either, if I close my eyes I just see black.

It took until my 40s to realise other people are different.

Curseofthenation · 07/06/2023 16:43

@RoseslnTheHospital I'm sorry if I caused you any offence. It just seems less efficient as a thinking process to me because I don't think that way but that doesn't mean I think that people with inner monologues are slow thinkers. A process can be more labour intensive without taking any or much more time.

As other posters have mentioned people that read using an inner voice are generally slower as a result than people that just absorb the words. It might be that the people that have inner monologues take in more because they have more time to process it. I'm sure there are pros and cons to both sides in many different ways.

MovinGroovinBarbie · 07/06/2023 16:37

Well, I imagine it's the difference between introspection and living completely in the moment.

Animals obviously have thoughts but the vast majority don't reflect on things I'd imagine.

Atnilpoe · 07/06/2023 16:35

The thing I think is mad, is that I often have my internal monologue chattering away - in a voice I can “hear” simultaneously to just thinking in a conceptual way. The power of the human brain really blows me away.

The chatter in my head is constant, but weirdly, I don’t find it exhausting. It’s often soothing for me. There’s nothing I like more than a good chat in my own head…😂 but my internal monologue isn’t negative/ I don’t have intrusive thoughts which must make a difference.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 07/06/2023 16:34

It's very possible. Part of the aphantasia spectrum I think.

Some people think in feelings/senses not words.

RoseslnTheHospital · 07/06/2023 16:28

Curseofthenation · 07/06/2023 16:19

@RoseslnTheHospital My thoughts aren't painted and don't gradually appear, they flash up like photos. So if I'm having a debate with someone and I read something in a book then my brain will flash a photo of the book up and I'll recall the information but just say it rather than hear words in my head. Surely you can't be thinking each of the words in your head all exactly at the same time or else it would just be noise? The difference may be minor if the thought is simple, but for complex thought it just seems less efficient. I'm not saying it means your a slow thinker!

The implication of saying that "for complex thought it just seems less efficient" is that it is slower... unless you're meaning something else by "less efficient"?

What I am saying that it is likely to be pretty similar for either process, because that's the way each individual thinks, and works for them. Not better, worse, more efficient or less efficient. The way you describe my thought process is not right, by the way. And it is as instant as your flashing of a photo and then talking about what you "see". The thoughts are not "noise" but I doubt I could explain it to you as you literally don't think that way.

the80sweregreat · 07/06/2023 16:24

I'm constantly thinking of my next move or what what I'm going to say to someone and I talk through my movements in my head too
So, it's get up
Shower
Dry hair
Tidy up
Have tea , breakfast etc.
And I'll make a mental list as I go through each part.
I can also picture things in my head too
I thought everyone done this ? Or maybe I do overthink things ?

ohdelay · 07/06/2023 16:24

I have no internal monologue and can have long Homer Simpson moments when I'm on pause or at rest. I watched Hi Ren recently and was fascinated by his voices as I genuinely don't have that. All my "voices" are in sync and tend to agree when actually doing something or just lull when I'm not.

Presentideasplease · 07/06/2023 16:21

Hazelnuttella · 07/06/2023 13:00

I have thoughts, but some people apparently monologue/narrate constantly, which seems exhausting

This is me! Yep - it’s exhausting!

Curseofthenation · 07/06/2023 16:20

You're

Curseofthenation · 07/06/2023 16:19

@RoseslnTheHospital My thoughts aren't painted and don't gradually appear, they flash up like photos. So if I'm having a debate with someone and I read something in a book then my brain will flash a photo of the book up and I'll recall the information but just say it rather than hear words in my head. Surely you can't be thinking each of the words in your head all exactly at the same time or else it would just be noise? The difference may be minor if the thought is simple, but for complex thought it just seems less efficient. I'm not saying it means your a slow thinker!