Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's impossible to have no thoughts or internal dialogue?

143 replies

IAteAllTheTomatoes · 07/06/2023 12:55

Is it true that some people have nothing going on in their head? No thoughts, ideas, or internal dialogue?

I'm not being bitchy or talking about intelligence but I just always assumed your brain is thinking or you are silently talking to yourself? Like, will my parcel arrive today? What will I make for dinner later? Something anything? Future plans? Pondering on something in the news etc?

Someone told me yesterday there is nothing in their thoughts, except maybe music, until they are asked a question?

I would love to have no thoughts? It is possible?

I'm explaining this poorly but I suppose what I'm wondering is can people shut down their thinking and if so, how?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thecatinthetwat · 14/07/2023 18:40

Wow, I’m amazed at the variation. Sometimes when I’m away my internal dialogue will change to the accent of the place I am eg welsh. It’s weird because the dialogue doesn’t exactly have any accent, until it suddenly does.

Howls · 14/07/2023 17:52

@Qilin try listening to a sound (not music, it can be too varied and distracting) on YouTube (can get white noise type things, or a single frequency) and focus on that.
Your thoughts will butt in, but when you notice it let them go and focus on the noise again, and keep doing that.
I found it took a week before I started to get to grips with it, but it’s definitely worth it.

Howls · 14/07/2023 17:45

Meditation does this for me, it’s like finding the key to mindfulness.
My default setting is chronic overthinking, like constant worried thoughts muddling around all the time.
When I get in the swing of meditating it’s like it switches that part of my brain off, so that unless I’m actively thinking of something I’m just taking in my surroundings, usually appreciatively.

Qilin · 14/07/2023 17:41

My mind is a constant internal monologue whilst awake.
It's all words though. I can't picture things, as in an actual image when I close my eyes.

The monologue is there all the time whether my eyes are open or closed.

I've tried meditation briefly but no,idea how you get your mind to go blank. I then just end up,with an internal monologue of me telling myself to think of nothing, on loop!

I don't know how much I dream however, so maybe it stops then.

Annaishere · 14/07/2023 17:31

The only time I’ve been able to do this for more than a few minutes was as a young child and once when I did a type of chakra meditation. It was absolutely blissful and I would only have a thought with deliberate effort. I’ve not been able to repeat it

Verv · 14/07/2023 17:27

@IAteAllTheTomatoes Standby mode when not doing anything in particular comes naturallly to me.
I dont know if you can relate to driving somewhere and you just sort of arrive because it's almost an autopilot? It's like that but when I need to think, I do.

Tryingtogetonwithit · 14/07/2023 00:05

Another constant monologuer here, I also visualise numbers of I'm adding something up, or words on a list. I can picture what a person was wearing the last 3 or 4 times seen them but do not remember faces 😂 the brain is a weird thing I try not to think t lo much about how it works.

Appalonia · 13/07/2023 23:46

Years ago I went on a 3 day silent meditation retreat. It was hard at the time, but afterwards I had some blissful hours of a clear mind. Unfortunately a few hours of London stress and my mind was chattering away as normal!

Saschka · 13/07/2023 23:24

Can I ask the posters who say the find it easy to clear their mind or that they can be on stand by etc, do you have a way of doing this or does it just happen naturally?

I am either focusing intently on something else which is taking all of my attention (like work, or playing tennis, or finding my way somewhere new). Or I am deliberately relaxing by staring at the sky, or something in nature, or focusing on my breathing if I am exercising.

I use audiobooks to help me sleep, because I don’t have any active thoughts in my head if I’m listening to somebody else talking.

Saschka · 13/07/2023 23:20

Sometimes I do, and sometimes I don’t. I find it more restful when I don’t, honestly. Thinking of what I’m making for dinner and how annoying my work project is isn’t exactly riveting.

TwitTwoodiniEscapeOwlogist · 09/06/2023 19:44

I usually don't have an inner dialogue, sometimes I do, but most of the time I'm observing and taking things in without any inner verbalisation.

When I was in primary school I often remember pretending to be a cat while walking along, (I was an odd child), and trying experience what it was like to see things but not have language to put them into. Maybe it stuck, because now that's my normal way of being.

I have a very good visual imagination, (I paint), but my memory is TERRIBLE (perhaps because I don't internally verbalise what I experience). I'm quite intelligent I think, but possible mildly autistic, and I have real problems recognising faces and remembering names.

I sometimes suffer from insomnia, and when I wake up in the night I do lie there with voices in my head talking and expressing worries etc. And I hate that, it just feels so noisy and anxious and not calm.

Outnumberedmummy2022 · 09/06/2023 19:16

Omg I heard this too and I can’t wrap my head around it

Ibizamumof4 · 08/06/2023 21:07

Sometimes it’s pictures , sometimes it’s an internal monologue , but I am always thinking something surely everyone is as the brain is conscious ?

Cherryflavouranything · 08/06/2023 10:42

ComtesseDeSpair · 07/06/2023 13:45

I think that rehearsing what you’re going to say beforehand is more a feature of anxiety than ordinary thought processes. With the exception of e.g. planned public speaking or an important meeting where you need to make sure you have everything you want to say ready be clear how you’re going to phrase it to reinforce it, most people don’t actively “think” about what they’re going to say or try it out in their heads.

Initially I was affronted by this 😂 but on reflection, I think you’re right. I have autism and a big worry of mine is offending people / hurting someone’s feelings by saying the wrong thing. So that’s probably why I do it.

Mxflamingnoravera · 07/06/2023 19:51

I'm an introvert with a strong internal monologue. I found transcendental meditation quiets it to non existent. Mantra based meditations seem to do this for many people. The 20 minutes of TM is an oasis of quiet and almost blissful.

IAteAllTheTomatoes · 07/06/2023 18:13

Can I ask the posters who say the find it easy to clear their mind or that they can be on stand by etc, do you have a way of doing this or does it just happen naturally?

I am fascinated by it and until yesterday just assumed (clearly incorrectly) that it was the same for everyone else?

My thoughts/inner dialogue doesn't distress me or bother me and doesn't cause me any problems but I do think that switching off sometimes might be nice.

The only times I can thing of that I am totally focused is on occasions like an emergency or if someone is talking to me about something important yo them, stress, worry, grief etc, where I really am listening and wanting to help, at a music concert, during sex or actually on a flight.

I find flying so therapeutic - no work, no phone, no real timelines that matter, zero distraction and I am completely chilled, almost blissfully zombie like - friends have said it's like I get holiday brain. My decision making which is usually instant becomes more relaxed, I literally just chill but I'm not stressed ordinarily, just more rapid thinking

OP posts:
Wailywailywaily · 07/06/2023 18:08

I have a sort of infinity loop carousel of thoughts that i use to pop things on that I want to consider. Some thoughts are on there for years and some are resolved very quickly and taken off the loop. Sometimes the carousel is going quite fast most of the time it’s just wiring in the background, I’m aware of it but not actively tending to the thoughts. I very rarely overthink things, they just go on the carousel loop until they are resolved.
my thought carousel is very repetitive when I dream, it just returns again and again to the same thought/ image.
I do have a constant dialogue as well but I don’t find it tiring. It’s just there all the time.

AuntieEmm · 07/06/2023 18:03

Bluey18 · 07/06/2023 13:50

This is me. No images. No inner dialogue. It's like a computer with the monitor switched off. No images, no sound. But there is definitely stuff going on there and data being processed! People tell me I'm intelligent. I can read and retain written info very well. I am terrible for remembering faces obviously.
I sometimes feel sad that I can't picture things (loved ones mainly) but I'm not sorry to have no inner voice, sounds like hell to me.

Me too, it's called Aphantasia. I find it very peaceful, although not being able to put names to faces is a big frustration.

PetitPorpoise · 07/06/2023 17:54

I use podcasts to drown out my own thoughts.

I'm often having heated discussions with other people in my head.

Hoolihan · 07/06/2023 17:49

No voice or pictures here either. Like pp my brain gives me thoughts/concepts and I love thinking about things but I also find it relatively easy to clear my mind during yoga etc. I have a friend who says he has a literal voice chattering all the time in her head which sounds totally awful to me!

the80sweregreat · 07/06/2023 17:35

If someone tells me to meet somewhere I know well , I'll immediately picture the building in my head!

ForeverTeach · 07/06/2023 17:35

This is so interesting. I don’t have a monologue running in my head. I have thoughts like I have to print that later then it goes but nothing in between. I also as another poster have nothing when I close my eyes just darkness. If I try to imagine a flower I do t get a picture I just know what a flower looks like. I also don’t remember my life prior to 15 either, it’s so weird. I would love to have a photographic memory though.

Castleintheclouds · 07/06/2023 17:34

JassyRadlett · 07/06/2023 13:19

I don't have an inner monologue. I have a fuckload of thoughts but they're not narrated as such - there is no inner voice that I 'hear'; I understand that for others it's more like hearing the actual words internally. For me, it's more conceptual rather than words.

It blew my mind when I realised that in books, where people's thoughts are written as dialogue, that is actually how some people hear their thoughts rather than a literary technique.

I don't talk to myself. I don't think 'shall I have a cup of tea' in words; the concept/idea of having a cup of tea comes into my head.

Interestingly, I'm in a profession that relies on excellent writing and public speaking skills, and I do a lot of creative writing, so the lack of an internal monologue hasn't been an impediment!

This is me too. My subconscious hums along in the distant background sorting everything (all thoughts, worries and emotions) out conceptually and words don't even come into it until I need to communicate with someone else through speech or writing. Occasionally an unfinished concern pops into my main brain and I either communicate about it to someone else or send it back to my subconscious to get better organised. My role at work is all about communication!

Angelofthenortheast · 07/06/2023 17:34

Everyone has thoughts, but not necessarily in words. My thoughts are in more abstract senses and images.

If I wondered when my parcel will arrive, I'd suddenly have the image of the parcel in my mind and a sense of anticipation, but not literally the words "where's my parcel" in my head.

Can't you have thoughts without words??

MyMachineAndMe · 07/06/2023 17:32

I rarely see images in my mind - I tend to describe things to myself instead and if I do manage to see an image, it's like a faded photograph seen through a muddy, out of focus lens.

I do talk to myself in my mind but don't have constant dialogue. I have a very quiet mind and can go several hours without thinking anything.