Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not have a cat because there are too many birds in my garden?

53 replies

userhank · 07/06/2023 12:31

So my mum has been looking after our cat while I've been moving house and doing my house up. It's almost ready. My cat has been with my mum for about 3 months now, really settled and gets in fine with my mums other cats.

My mum came to my new house this morning to wait for a delivery while I did the school run. When I came back, she said she noticed just how many birds there are in my garden. I have a large garden with trees also down each side which are full of nests. My house also backs on to the local park so it's full of greenery and wildlife.

Now while I know it's all part of nature, my mum questioned wether I should actually bring my cat. He is definitely a hunter and my mum thinks that while he will absolutely be in his element, the amount of birds especially he will catch will be very high and it's quite unfair.

Just to add - my mum is not trying to keep my cat. She has 3 of her own and definitely doesn't want anymore but she would be happy to carry on looking after mine.

I would of never thought of this in a million years....thoughts?

OP posts:
userhank · 07/06/2023 12:45

vincettenoir · 07/06/2023 12:38

That’s a tricky one. In your situation I would perhaps bring your cat to your new home and see how it goes.

If he likes to hunt he will likely kill the odd bird once in a blue moon, like many cats do. But if it turns out there’s a birdy bloodbath once a week or more then perhaps it will be an untenable situation. Then you can consider your options.

Yes I agree.

It has always been more more mice than birds. Our old house backed on to a field so that was easy for him.

Thing is I'm a huge animal lover and although I know it's normal, I really would find it quite upsetting.

Saying that, as I've said already, the thought never crossed my mind until my mum mentioned it!

OP posts:
Onelifeonly · 07/06/2023 12:44

Birds might get the message and move on! Seriously I've known a good few cats in my time, have two now, and catching birds is a rarity. It does happen, especially when they are young adults, but not that often. I had one cat who caught four birds all within a few months and then never again - unless she didn't bring them in anymore. 🤦‍♀️

vincettenoir · 07/06/2023 12:38

That’s a tricky one. In your situation I would perhaps bring your cat to your new home and see how it goes.

If he likes to hunt he will likely kill the odd bird once in a blue moon, like many cats do. But if it turns out there’s a birdy bloodbath once a week or more then perhaps it will be an untenable situation. Then you can consider your options.