Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister and babysitting

117 replies

Notanothermoan · 07/06/2023 10:25

Hi, this may be a long one so apologies in advance. I have 3 younger sisters, we all have children. One of my sisters has a little girl (4) who we believe has severe sensory issues and is going through the rigmarole of getting a diagnosis, my sister is a lone parent, DN’s dad isn’t in the picture, our mom was a huge help before she passed away at the beginning of this year so now her only support is from us, her sisters and occasionally our dad. DN is extremely hard work - I say this in the nicest way I can. She is none verbal, can be aggressive when upset/frustrated, she doesn’t sleep, she is usually awake till 5am, she will scream the most high pitched scream when her moms leaves and this will carry on for hours, she doesn’t sit to eat any food and will only eat walking around meaning lots of food is usually trod into carpet/furniture, she is petrified of animals (dad has a dog so she hates staying with him), she won’t sleep alone so has to sleep in the bed with the adult in charge (won’t sleep with children either) and of course as she doesn’t go to sleep until 5am you are also awake with her, usually the time spent before her going to sleep she is either running back and forth around a room, making loud noises or crying/screaming loudly so the whole house is usually awake. I’m just painting a picture of her here so that you can understand why it’s a challenge to look after her, not to speak bad of her, we all think the world of her and are a very close family. My sister tends to ask for childcare a lot, she’s a little bit of a party animal, when mom was here it was every weekend, DN and mom were very close and mom knew exactly how to handle her, probably better than my sister does. Usually she will ask our sister who lives round the corner from her, however she has an 18mo and is currently due with baby no2 and has started to say no to childcare, she has never had DN overnight because she can’t cope but has now said no to daytime care too, which is understandable. My other sister has 3 children and works full time but is often happy to have her unless busy or at work, I live an hour away from my family so I am usually last resort. I’m on maternity leave until December, I have DD7 and DS who is 8 weeks, my sister has asked us if one of us could have her daughter for a week while she goes away on a girls holiday. As I’m not at work, have the older child and baby instead of baby and toddler I’m probably going to be the one who is expected to have DN. My sister can become really upset when she can’t get childcare, she will straight away pull the ‘nobody wants to watch my child because you don’t like her’ card, which is obviously not true, she will say she needs a break she is alone which I totally get. The 3 of us all have partners and support from in-laws with childcare and I totally get where she’s coming from, but what do you do in this situation? I want her to have a life and understand that she has it tough but that week would be extremely hard work.

AIBU - it’s literally a week just have the child
AINBU - it’s too much, say no

OP posts:
MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 07/06/2023 14:50

It would be a hard no from me I’m afraid. No one is entitled to holidays; with it without the children

SkyandSurf · 07/06/2023 14:43

It would be nice of you to take your niece for one night, but a week is overreaching.

Even if the child had no additional needs, providing a week of care for the sake of a holiday is a massive ask.

Your sister sounds a little immature. I mean, of course she can't take the same holidays as her child-free friends! That's not 'unfair' that's just having responsibilities.

If it was my sister I'd be offering support and providing respite if I could, but it would be two days tops so she could recharge her batteries. A whole week (especially when you have your own baby to care for) so she can drink and party like a childfree woman is not in anyone's best interest.

It's unfortunate she's not factored her own daughter's distress and separation anxiety into her plans either. What's this poor girl going to feel when her mother just doesn't return for her day after day?

Notanothermoan · 07/06/2023 14:32

A few people have mentioned about her application to mainstream school, is she able to apply to a SEN school without a diagnosis? I’m under the impression she thinks DN will attend mainstream school and then they will assess and move her.

OP posts:
SchoolShenanigans · 07/06/2023 14:32

I wouldn't look after my well behaved neice for a full week, let alone your DN.

Your sister is expecting way too much of people. I get that she needs respite, and it must be really hard for her, but a full week is way too much. I'd probably offer two nights maximum (and definitely not whist I still have a baby who's not sleeping through the night).

Notanothermoan · 07/06/2023 14:29

Belmondo · 07/06/2023 14:11

Sorry to bang the same drum OP, but do you know for sure that your sister has applied for and received a school place for your niece for this Sept? Not many mainstream schools will be able to cope with a non-verbal child who's still in nappies full-time. I'm just wondering the extent of your sister's denial of the issue...

Yes she has received a place at a mainstream school, that being said this was only done by applying through the council the same way everyone else does and I believe the school will be unaware of how DN is. I think soon she may be invited for a taster day or something and they most likely will not accept when they see her.

OP posts:
OhComeOnFFS · 07/06/2023 14:25

It's crazy that your sister has put her down for a mainstream school. That's taking a place from another child who may well have to travel further to school now. She knows full well her daughter wouldn't cope in that environment - it's not being fair to anyone.

Notanothermoan · 07/06/2023 14:20

TheSnowyOwl · 07/06/2023 11:55

From a completely different perspective here, but would that week actually benefit your sister and her ability to be in a better mindset to parent or is it just so she can get drunk and then come back and carry on exactly as she currently is? How does your DN cope with being in different environments and the change that goes with staying elsewhere? My ASD child cannot cope with it but I have another waiting for assessment who would be fine, so I think there are lots of variables to take into account. A week is a very long time if the primary caregiver is out of the country and not able to step back in quickly.

Do you know where exactly in the assessment process your DN is? I think your sister needs to be much more proactive at pushing for help. Is she seeing her GP regularly? There is plenty of support she should still be able to get whilst waiting for a formal diagnosis but she needs to really fight to get it.

That’s a definite possibility but I think it is to get drunk and have a good time. When she is asked about this her reasons were that ‘all of her friends are going on holiday and she’s the only one that can’t and it’s not fair that she’ll never get to go on a girls holiday’ - she’s the only one with a child. DN gets really upset when her mom leaves and has the worst meltdowns and nothing can calm her, this lasts hours, when she is calm she seems ok but with how she is I wouldn't be able to recognise whether she was doing ok without her mom or not. She doesn’t really show emotion if that makes sense? I’ve never been able to know how she’s feeling whether she’s happy or sad (unless crying). Im not sure 100% on the diagnosis stage but I don’t believe there’s many appointments, I haven’t heard or her going to the GP in a long while, this is something she would share with us if she did go.

OP posts:
Notanothermoan · 07/06/2023 14:12

Thank you all for your replies, and to those who have given advice on SN, respite and diagnosis. I will be honest I don’t think my sister is pushing as much as she says she is and I have mentioned this a few times to her, I think she could try harder and be a little more pushy with health professionals. She had a social worker when DN was a baby due to DV with DN’s dad, this petrified her as she was worried that they’d take the baby away so as soon as they signed her off she hasn’t wanted any social services involvement.

OP posts:
Belmondo · 07/06/2023 14:11

Sorry to bang the same drum OP, but do you know for sure that your sister has applied for and received a school place for your niece for this Sept? Not many mainstream schools will be able to cope with a non-verbal child who's still in nappies full-time. I'm just wondering the extent of your sister's denial of the issue...

Crumpleton · 07/06/2023 14:04

Notanothermoan · 07/06/2023 11:16

It is very difficult for her so we all do help as much as we can, just to clarify my sister does get time off, she will have atleast 1 or 2 nights out a month, so DN will stay with one of us overnight. She doesn’t help herself though she says she will pick DN up at one time and ends up collecting her 3/4 hours later, with mom she would often drop her off say Friday night for one night and not return till Monday morning. My sister with the 3 children missed her sons football game just a couple of weeks ago that she promised him she’d attend and doesn’t usually get to because of her job, all because she hadn’t turned up at the time she said she would.

Based on this reply I'd say no.
Having the odd night where you look after your DN so DS can have sometime to herself to recharge is one thing but your DS seems to want to party all the time.
Plus you/your DS's having her behavior impacting on your own DC/family time isn't fair to them.

Nevermind31 · 07/06/2023 13:57

Notanothermoan · 07/06/2023 11:16

It is very difficult for her so we all do help as much as we can, just to clarify my sister does get time off, she will have atleast 1 or 2 nights out a month, so DN will stay with one of us overnight. She doesn’t help herself though she says she will pick DN up at one time and ends up collecting her 3/4 hours later, with mom she would often drop her off say Friday night for one night and not return till Monday morning. My sister with the 3 children missed her sons football game just a couple of weeks ago that she promised him she’d attend and doesn’t usually get to because of her job, all because she hadn’t turned up at the time she said she would.

This alone would mean a no from me.
someone is helping you out - you are grateful, you don’t abuse it.
most parents of 4 year olds don’t have a weeklong holiday without them.
if she pulls the card of “no one likes my child” my answer would be… we like your child just fine, but are very busy with our own lives, and we don’t like how you try to abuse our offered help by being late, meaning our own children are missing out.

TheIsleOfTheLost · 07/06/2023 13:45

Most women I know don't go away for a week on holiday when they have pre-teens. Not knocking those that do, just it's not standard. I can understand that your mum was happy to look after your niece, which would have given her the stability of two care givers. Now she is being farmed out to different people and her constant person has vanished. No one wants to be sleeping different places each night. Your sister needs a big reality check on what is best for her daughter. It really doesn't sound like mainstream school is in her best interests either. If she can't cope then she won't receive education and will disrupt it for everyone else too.

Fraaahnces · 07/06/2023 13:15

You all need to come to a consensus that it’s not appropriate for her to ask any of you for this much childcare. She is being an entitled CF. You will all have to say no to her and remind her that none of you have been on holidays either.

Youvebeenmuffled · 07/06/2023 12:51

Sounds as though DN has had a difficult start in life and seems to have lost one of her main attachment figures when your mother passed. Your DS really needs to step up and put DN first, making sure she has structure, routine and security. It’s hard going, but partying is not a priority, DN is.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 07/06/2023 12:49

Notanothermoan · 07/06/2023 11:18

Ironically since having children none of us have ever had a holiday/break without the children.

What does your sister say when you point this out?

Personally I would never have another child overnight to facilitate a holiday/night out.

I have looked after friends DC overnight when they had to go to a funeral abroad, or for an afternoon when they (other friends) had a medical appointment, this type of things.

Peachy2005 · 07/06/2023 12:37

If you all keep enabling your DSis’s partying, she will never grow up. Her child needs to come first for her, just as your small children also need to come first for you.

Sparkleshine21 · 07/06/2023 12:32

I’m a single mum to an autistic child who needs me, cries if I leave her with anyone else. No way would I leave her for longer than an evening out. She’s not putting her daughters needs first

Georgyporky · 07/06/2023 12:32

StopMindlesslyScrolling · 07/06/2023 12:19

The big thing here is that your DN's parent has just walked away from his child.

If your DN had a proper father doing 50% of the parenting, then this wouldn't be an issue.

I have huge sympathy for your sister as her life must be incredibly hard, that doesn't mean that you should have to look after her child for a week though.

But objectively, looking at this issue it's the father who should be stepping up at this point; your DSis needs respite and the other parent is the obvious choice in terms of who should give it.

Read the thread.

forrestgreen · 07/06/2023 12:30

No, it would not be in the best interests of dn to be away from mum and home for that long.
Is she accessing the support she's entitled to, is there any day care that can help her. It must be awful to be in her ds position but a week away is not the answer

StopFeckingFaffing · 07/06/2023 12:25

A week long child free holiday is a luxury that most parents can only dream of

Whilst I sympathise with your sister and appreciate that life must be hard for her, it really isn't reasonable to expect you to care for DN for a whole week. A weekend maybe but a week is taking the piss!

Tryingtoconceivenumber2 · 07/06/2023 12:24

Could she compromise and perhaps go for a long weekend? It's a huge ask even if DN didn't have additional needs. The fact that she isn't collecting on time etc it sounds like she is really taking advantage of you all.

She is very lucky to have such support. My DD is 3 and my DSIS has no children and has never offered to babysit her but does spend time with her etc. Try not to let her guilt you in to this if you can't manage it. It sounds like you are all really working hard to support her.

While she is awaiting diagnosis is she able to get any support? I used to work on a playscheme years ago for SEN children and all though the holidays we collected them in the morning, took them out for the day and brought them back about 3pm. Some were as young as 3. Appreciate this does not fit in with night out child care but would be a break x

StopMindlesslyScrolling · 07/06/2023 12:19

The big thing here is that your DN's parent has just walked away from his child.

If your DN had a proper father doing 50% of the parenting, then this wouldn't be an issue.

I have huge sympathy for your sister as her life must be incredibly hard, that doesn't mean that you should have to look after her child for a week though.

But objectively, looking at this issue it's the father who should be stepping up at this point; your DSis needs respite and the other parent is the obvious choice in terms of who should give it.

EliflurtleTripanInfinite · 07/06/2023 12:12

None of my DC could cope with that. Even a week with their Dad they wouldn't cope with. It doesn't sound to me like DN is coping at all. She has one parent, and that one parent should be working on making her world a place that isn't so painful for her to live in. DN needs support. There are ways to reduce sensory overload, and it's highly likely that the babysitting is not a positive for DN. I've been through years of working out what my Autistic DC need to cope in the world, that's where her focus should be. It's heartbreaking what DN is experiencing.

littleripper · 07/06/2023 12:11

The pathology of DV, trauma, traumatised mothers and co-dependant children is beyond the reach of non professional carers. Your DS is not in any way to blame but her behaviour is re traumatising your niece and the chaotic care arrangements and lack of stability is compounding her behavioural issues. Your sister needs help. Does she have a social worker?

Aussiegirl88 · 07/06/2023 12:10

Your sisters lifestyle is what is causing issues for this child! have either of the sisters sat her down and told her it's time to pull her head in an actual be a parent, not just a weekday one. She clearly wasn't ready to have children but that's too late now and what she wants to do doesn't supercede that of being a parent 24/7. I say this as I was a teen parent, I grew up and matured well beyond my years because I had to. I had no body I couldn't even have 30 mins to myself.

You all need to tell her to reconsider this holiday it's not feasible with her lifestyle as a parent! End of!