Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister and babysitting

117 replies

Notanothermoan · 07/06/2023 10:25

Hi, this may be a long one so apologies in advance. I have 3 younger sisters, we all have children. One of my sisters has a little girl (4) who we believe has severe sensory issues and is going through the rigmarole of getting a diagnosis, my sister is a lone parent, DN’s dad isn’t in the picture, our mom was a huge help before she passed away at the beginning of this year so now her only support is from us, her sisters and occasionally our dad. DN is extremely hard work - I say this in the nicest way I can. She is none verbal, can be aggressive when upset/frustrated, she doesn’t sleep, she is usually awake till 5am, she will scream the most high pitched scream when her moms leaves and this will carry on for hours, she doesn’t sit to eat any food and will only eat walking around meaning lots of food is usually trod into carpet/furniture, she is petrified of animals (dad has a dog so she hates staying with him), she won’t sleep alone so has to sleep in the bed with the adult in charge (won’t sleep with children either) and of course as she doesn’t go to sleep until 5am you are also awake with her, usually the time spent before her going to sleep she is either running back and forth around a room, making loud noises or crying/screaming loudly so the whole house is usually awake. I’m just painting a picture of her here so that you can understand why it’s a challenge to look after her, not to speak bad of her, we all think the world of her and are a very close family. My sister tends to ask for childcare a lot, she’s a little bit of a party animal, when mom was here it was every weekend, DN and mom were very close and mom knew exactly how to handle her, probably better than my sister does. Usually she will ask our sister who lives round the corner from her, however she has an 18mo and is currently due with baby no2 and has started to say no to childcare, she has never had DN overnight because she can’t cope but has now said no to daytime care too, which is understandable. My other sister has 3 children and works full time but is often happy to have her unless busy or at work, I live an hour away from my family so I am usually last resort. I’m on maternity leave until December, I have DD7 and DS who is 8 weeks, my sister has asked us if one of us could have her daughter for a week while she goes away on a girls holiday. As I’m not at work, have the older child and baby instead of baby and toddler I’m probably going to be the one who is expected to have DN. My sister can become really upset when she can’t get childcare, she will straight away pull the ‘nobody wants to watch my child because you don’t like her’ card, which is obviously not true, she will say she needs a break she is alone which I totally get. The 3 of us all have partners and support from in-laws with childcare and I totally get where she’s coming from, but what do you do in this situation? I want her to have a life and understand that she has it tough but that week would be extremely hard work.

AIBU - it’s literally a week just have the child
AINBU - it’s too much, say no

OP posts:
Grumpy101 · 07/06/2023 20:01

Absolutely not unreasonable. It sounds like she's very immature, did she have her daughter young? She needs to be left to her own devices tbh, no parent of a 4 year old gets to have a week off on holiday.

Mummyoflittledragon · 07/06/2023 19:32

i wouldn’t take your dn, no, absolutely not. It sounds as though a call to social services would be really helpful for your sister, to help her with signposting. Or to contact her GP. That is something to consider.

Littledogball · 07/06/2023 19:27

I hope your sister has told the school all about her needs. It's unfair if she turns up with her and the school are unaware and unable to keep her safe.

KTheGrey · 07/06/2023 19:22

Your sister has very high expectations of all of her sisters and used to have the same of your Mum. You don't mention your sister ever contributing anything to anybody else's life, though, unless claiming that her life is unfair counts. I wouldn't feel bad about saying no. Everything else aside, a week is a long stint of childcare.

Notanothermoan · 07/06/2023 19:06

Daleksatemyshed · 07/06/2023 15:09

Your Sister has had a bad time, DV and a child with SN is a lot to cope with. Do you think she's in denial about her DC's needs? When she doesn't come to pick her up when she should goes does anyone say something ?

She usually sleeps through and doesn’t answer her phone. When she did this with mom she knew she could get away with it, mom would never agree to a whole weekend every week but would have her overnight so atleast every other week she’d not turn up and then would turn her phone off/block numbers. Would constantly tell mom to say no but that would cause arguments so she would and then the same would happen again:

OP posts:
BelindaBears · 07/06/2023 17:25

There is absolutely no way I’d mind my niece for a week to enable my sister to go on a girls holiday. It’s too big an ask.

momonpurpose · 07/06/2023 16:59

Your sister needs to grow up. Party time is over once you are a parent. Also this an absolutely impossible situation to sustain. Fear of social service or not she needs to get with the program and get help for her daughter and herself. It's incredibly selfish to put her need for partying over her daughter's need for help

TheCatterall · 07/06/2023 16:07

As others have said. Having a child with additional needs is hard. But that’s tough titties.

she needs to start properly parenting rather than fobbing her off on willing relatives so
she can go out on the lash.

her daughter needs the structure and comfort of a routine. Not the instability of being carted around like an unwanted object from pillar to post.

if your sister liaised more with social services and other professionals maybe she’d get better support, respite, assessment etc.

Your sisters immature and unreliable behaviour would also be a NO from me. You can’t rely on her to turn up on time to
Collect her own child?!

If shes so unhappy then maybe she should look at having her daughter placed on foster care.

I was 18 when I had my eldest and there was no overnight support and certainly no girls holidays for a weekend let alone a week. All my holidays were with my children and often in a tent or borrowing folks caravan etc.

You all need as a a family to stop letting her emotionally blackmail you. She needs to learn it won’t work and that whilst you love them both she needs a tough love approach and to parent her child better. Her Daughter deserves a better mother than the one you are describing.

Weal · 07/06/2023 16:06

Is your niece currently at nursery or preschool. Given her needs I would have thought they or the health visitors would have been fixing advice regarding education or linking with the school she is due to go to.

On the topic of your post- no YANBU to say no to looking after your niece for a week so she can go on holiday. I’ve never been away a whole week without my children and I don’t get 1-2 nights a month away either. I think what you and your sisters support with already is enough given you have your own small children.

I would encourage your sister to contact social care and ask for a social worker from the disabled children’s team. If her child has significant needs it likely will increase with her age. They can help with linking with schools, respite and transition to adulthood services etc. they might also pick up on things to help in the home eg making the sleep space safe for when she is awake, developing strategies for managing her needs etc.

Isolationendurance · 07/06/2023 15:57

As hard as it is, your sister needs to accept that her mum has gone and her lifestyle needs to change.

Crumpleton · 07/06/2023 15:53

Notanothermoan · 07/06/2023 14:32

A few people have mentioned about her application to mainstream school, is she able to apply to a SEN school without a diagnosis? I’m under the impression she thinks DN will attend mainstream school and then they will assess and move her.

DN hasn't been actually been diagnosed yet?

Surely it's in your DS interest to get her DD diagnosed in order to get the best advice/help that is available for your DN.

zoomiesdrivememad · 07/06/2023 15:49

I feel sorry for your niece, she needs stability and I also feel sorry for your sister, she has this day in day out so obviously needs a break.

I don't feel a weeks girls holiday should be a break though.

1-2 nights a month should be suffice and she really should be understanding. Looking after a SEN child is hard for the parent, and especially hard for non parents.

SkyandSurf · 07/06/2023 15:44

She's pre-verbal and wears nappies - how is a classroom teacher in a mainstream school going to manage that at all? What benefit will DN get from that experience?

It doesn't sound like your sister is coping if she hasn't even put a plan in place for schooling.

inloveandmarried · 07/06/2023 15:29

I should add, this is Disability Team Social worker not Child Protection Social Worker.

This is not the same as the Social worker who would have been involved in the beginning with DV issues.

Jules912 · 07/06/2023 15:26

Notanothermoan · 07/06/2023 14:32

A few people have mentioned about her application to mainstream school, is she able to apply to a SEN school without a diagnosis? I’m under the impression she thinks DN will attend mainstream school and then they will assess and move her.

TBF SEN school places are like hens teeth and a lot of councils try to push mainstream as a) it's cheaper and b) see above. I'm guessing she isn't in nursery or such high level of needs would've been flagged up before now and an application made for an ECHP (your sister should do this now but it's already too late for it to be done by September). I feel sorry for the school if they've not even had a discussion about her needs, mainstream schools get a tiny amount of additional funding to cover 'mild' SEN needs where the child can copy with the normal differentiation of work and standard staffing ratios.

inloveandmarried · 07/06/2023 15:26

She needs a social care assessment for the daughter urgently and a carers assessment for your sister.

This will identify the ongoing issues and she will have access to funding through Social services. They will be looking to stop the home situation breaking down.

As sadly your mum who was an additional carer has passed away, now is the time to get this assessed.

She needs a social worker and access to help. You are not in a reasonable position to step up to do this.

ohtowinthelottery · 07/06/2023 15:25

I'm sorry but your sister is failing your DN massively. She honestly sounds ill equipped to cope with a child let alone one with SN.

She needs to start prioritising her daughter, getting her properly assessed and into the right school - although she's left that too late for September. I should imagine your DN will be out of school again after week 1 in mainstream if she has all the issues you've described - it'll be another change of environment which she won't cope with and which will intensify her behaviour.
I think you siblings and your DF need to sit your DS down and have an adult conversation about what DN needs - and it's not being abandoned by her mother on a regular basis. If she can get DN the professional support she needs then maybe things will settle down and then DS can have her 'girlies' holiday.

aloris · 07/06/2023 15:18

Your sister has actually had quite a lot of time off and regular support from family between your mum, your dad, and you (her siblings). I understand her need for support might be different than a mum of a neurotypical child, but even so, she's had regular overnight respite. That's something many, many mothers never have. Now she wants an entire week off, given by you, who already are caring for a newborn! So in addition to a tiny baby who breaks up your sleep into 1 hour sessions, you'll also be up all night till 5 am? It's far too much to ask of you.

As you point out, her unreliability is also a factor here. I would not look kindly on giving someone else free overnight babysitting, only for them to return late so I miss my own child's event. That is extremely selfish and callous of her.

Daleksatemyshed · 07/06/2023 15:09

Your Sister has had a bad time, DV and a child with SN is a lot to cope with. Do you think she's in denial about her DC's needs? When she doesn't come to pick her up when she should goes does anyone say something ?

Ponderingwindow · 07/06/2023 15:08

Your sister does need breaks, but she doesn’t need random overnights and weeks away, those are wants. Your niece is going to act out even more when her schedule is disrupted so much. Maybe your family could set up a couple of regular blocks each week of childcare so your sister knows she will have a break and your niece will develop a predictable routine. I would probably not include overnights for now as it is too stressful for the babysitters and probably for the niece as well.

Newtt · 07/06/2023 15:06

If DN is sensitive, how would the baby crying etc effect her?
Would DN be distressed by baby crying and hence scream more, upsetting baby and older DC etc…. This cycle could lead to a traumatic week for your entire family.

I think you have to decline looking after DN.

I do hope the school she will attend are able to speed up getting some help and support in place for both of them!

billy1966 · 07/06/2023 15:00

Op, have you considered the affect a child screaming for hours on end for a week would have on your children?

It doesn't seem realistic, particularly as you have a new baby.

It would be a no from me too.

workemails · 07/06/2023 14:58

I would just explain you do not feel you are equip to deal with DN and her needs. For an hour, maybe, but not for a week. If she "pulls the card" just call her out and ask why she is trying to use manipulation to get her own way. You have said no as you do not feel you could cope. Why cant she accept that. See what she says. Also maybe suggest she look into getting respite care with a qualified child carer to look after DN for the week.

Mumof4alsoabonus · 07/06/2023 14:57

Notanothermoan · 07/06/2023 14:32

A few people have mentioned about her application to mainstream school, is she able to apply to a SEN school without a diagnosis? I’m under the impression she thinks DN will attend mainstream school and then they will assess and move her.

She needs a statement of educational needs done. She should have been referred to an educational psychologist before now. You don’t need a diagnosis, just it to be known that this child has extra support needs. She won’t be the 1st child sent to mainstream where it isn’t appropriate tbh. It’s also easy for people to talk about outside support, but it’s minimal.
That said you need to push for these things and follow them up. It’s hard enough when you fight for them, little will be handed to her. This child needs someone to advocate for her.
I had full sympathy with your sister in your 1st post. My son is autistic with sensory needs etc. He was non/pre verbal until about 5/6. He also barely slept for 6yrs screaming like you describe your niece. He’s settled a lot from he was able to express himself more. He’s 8 now and while still difficult not nearly as much so. Plus everything’s easier now we get sleep. I have a partner though he took no part in the night wakenings, at least he could take him in the evenings. We have no outside support though and my child has never spent a night away.
Your sister needs help and support but it sounds like she gets that and takes advantage a bit. I don’t blame her and while yous find it hard she has it 24/7. You go out of your mind a bit with it tbh. Pure exhaustion and not thinking straight. Everything becomes a struggle.
That said I couldn’t have coped with my own child and a new baby, so there’s no way I would expect someone else to. I think you should say no, and have no guilt for it, it’s too much.
I understand her reluctance with social workers, I feel the same tbh. But I’m assured disability social workers are different. She could get direct payments to pay someone, arrange respite etc. She can’t carry on as she is. Has she claimed dla? You don’t need a diagnosis for it either.

bjrce · 07/06/2023 14:55

I am sorry OP but you DS needs to GTFU!

The very fact you state the DD gets so stressed when she leaves her with anyone, any mother worth her salt wouldn't dream of handing out the child at every opportunity and that what she appears to be doing.

She needs to provide a stable environment for the DD.

I know life as a single parent must be very challenging and with the child's additional needs, but your DS needs to cope onto herself, this bullshit, "I'll never get a single girls holiday" FFS! she's not like her friends now, she has a child to look after and be responsible for.

Its obvious from your example she really abused the help and support your DM provided before she passed away.

You are on Maternity leave, not a holiday, you have your hands full with two little ones. I'll bet she plays the card, because she's a single mother with a special needs child, there isn't a hope in hell she's ever offered to mind any of her sisters children, Oh but you have husbands to support you, poor little me!

I agree with PPs she a CF! Be warned if you give into her this time - she'll come back with requests for weekends/ single holidays again next year, because she needs a break!!
In this instance if she wants to get angry and use the poor me card, I'd just let her get on with it..