Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not taking my children to see their grandparents?

342 replies

Herringbone1 · 06/06/2023 23:57

For context my children are primary school age. We have a busy life (like most parents with young children) activities, full time jobs then throw in housework, trying to shoehorn in some family days together etc. leaves very little time for much else. Grandparents are retired and do very little aside from casual hobbies. Don’t drive. Live around an hour away but make very little effort to have a relationship with their grandsons. No significant health issues that would prevent them from visiting.

AIBU I’m not taking my children on a 2 hour round trip to see them when they make such little effort? I feel guilty thinking well maybe I should try more but I then I think well why can’t they get public transport to come see us? Why is it my responsibility to encourage their relationship? They made the choice not to drive, not me.

OP posts:
Hayliebells · 09/06/2023 06:45

YANBU. From everything you've posted it does sound like your parents just aren't that bothered, which is sad, but you can't force a relationship. I'd just visit as much as you'd feel comfortable with, not out of obligation, but as much as you want to. If they wanted to see you more often they'd visit, or at least make noises about it.

moonlitwalks · 09/06/2023 06:39

MistyMountainTop · 08/06/2023 21:01

Both my parents are dead, one very recently. I have no guilt! Maybe you do...

Yup- same here. I have zero guilt. You cant force parents to make an effort with their grandchildren. We all have free will and we are all in control of the choices we make. If they choose to make no effort then thats on them.

Advicerequest · 09/06/2023 06:35

Depends on your notion of family? My grandparents rarely came to see us and we're hands off yet every week we'd be driven an hour to see them as it's the culture of my dads family to value these ties.

GrinAndVomit · 09/06/2023 06:33

GrinAndVomit · 09/06/2023 06:31

I live in a town where many surrounding towns are quicker by train. Our nearest city is 45 minutes by car but 40 by train. The nearest town is 25 minutes by car but 18 minutes by train.

Sorry, that was supposed to be a reply to someone saying they didn’t believe public transport could be quicker than driving.

GrinAndVomit · 09/06/2023 06:31

I live in a town where many surrounding towns are quicker by train. Our nearest city is 45 minutes by car but 40 by train. The nearest town is 25 minutes by car but 18 minutes by train.

realitytransurfing · 09/06/2023 06:28

My dad was the same OP. I did make an effort but I certainly didnt kill myself to visit if I was exhausted at the end of the week. I think if I was you, I'd make a compromise and visit on a time schedule that felt doable. It certainly wouldnt be weekly but maybe once a month or so?

The thing is, relationships take effort on both sides otherwise one person always ends up feeling resentful. Do they show other interest by phoning and asking about their GC? I think context is important here. If they didnt make any other efforts then honestly, I wouldnt worry about it too much. If people really care about something, they'll make the effort to show it. I grew up with one nan who was very involved in my life and the other who showed little interest. It didnt scar me for life as some seem to be suggesting, all that happened was that I ended up not being very close to her at all. Looking back, I think it was sad more for her that she didnt want to spend time with me because she ended up quite lonely but I certainly didnt grow up feeling I was missing out because I had plenty of other people in my life who did care.

Channellingsophistication · 09/06/2023 06:12

Yabu. Surely you want to see your parents? I would take my children to see them. I don’t think an hours drive is that much. Do you get on with your parents?

Or if public transport is so easy why don’t you use that route instead of driving or why not invite them down for a long weekend.

stayathomer · 09/06/2023 05:50

Another saying you should drive to see them! I understand why you think this but I think you need to look at the fact that you think they’ve nothing better to do. I’ll be honest a big guilt thing with me is my sis and on the other side bil are very good at getting their kids to phone and send homemade cards to gps, we never pushed for it. Relationships are two ways. Give them a call today and open the lines of communication x

Tooearlytothink · 09/06/2023 05:13

YANBU and I hate seeing this narrative that just because they’re your parents you have to be the one to make all the effort. It’s a parent’s responsibility to make sure they have a relationship with their kids, grown or otherwise, not the other way round. Can you help with this, yes, if you feel they’re interested & care, but it can’t all be on you. You wouldn’t go out of your way to maintain a friendship or any other relationship that was this one sided so why should you here.

myfaceismyown · 09/06/2023 00:08

I would have a chat with them. Ask them what they think of the grandkids and if they like seeing them. It seems to me you feel obliged because its the "right" thing to do, not because it is making anyone happy. My now adult DCs tell me all sorts of things I would never have allowed when they spent time with my deceased parents - but have really happy memories. Life is short. Truly. Try to make this work for all of you.

Mamanyt · 08/06/2023 23:33

Do remember that, at some point, refusing to take them might come back and bite you on the tender bits. I'd make the effort, at least occasionally, so that the "why wouldn't you take us?" question never comes up. And things like that tend to come up.

JediNinja · 08/06/2023 23:01

I'm on a similar situation. Grandparents live 1h away but drive. We have hectic lives with work spilling onto weekends, we both work full time and there's always lots of housecleaning to do at the weekend, sports things the kids do during the week and at the weekend... I just don't have the energy and the time to drive up. They are retired, travel all the time, and have no other grandchildren. They don't look too interested and have declined invitations to their birthday parties ("it's for the other kids") and school shows. It always feels that we are ticking box of "we saw each other this quarter". We get along and when they come, it's ok but doesn't feel either like they were looking forward to seeing the kids. More of a tick box thing. We are kind of accepting it now but it was hurtful for a while.

CountessWindyBottom · 08/06/2023 23:00

JandalsAlways · 07/06/2023 04:25

To me, it's your kids missing out so I'd do it

Exactly this.

Finallyfree41 · 08/06/2023 22:55

Normally I’d have completely agreed with you. My mum had never made a particular effort with my children (she was a great mum but not exactly touchy-feely) but after finding out last week that she has terminal cancer I now feel so guilty for not making more of an effort and am left trying to make up for it, life is very short. If they want to see your children, take them

mandlerparr · 08/06/2023 22:25

I have not read all the back and forth here, but if they already have a good relationship with one set of grandparents, then don't sweat it. Especially if your parents are still smoking and if they may drink while watching the kid.
If they are not disabled or feeble in any way, there is not one good reason they cannot use public transportation. When I first read this, I was going to say to let them spend a weekend over there every month or two. My grandmother lived about an hour from us and came and took us once a month or so. It was great. But, your parents don't seem to have a kid friendly home. Stop stressing about it.

Honestwife · 08/06/2023 21:52

You need to spend time with your parents, if it wasn’t for them you wouldn’t be here breathing and living a life. Take you children with you, they won’t be around for long and you will only regret it. With age some ppl don’t have the confidence to travel on public transport and with Covid having a big impact this maybe the case.

Middleagedspreadisreal · 08/06/2023 21:39

Time with Grandparents is invaluable. You need to MAKE time, especially as you've got transport. No matter what you think of them, your children deserve a relationship with them.

MistyMountainTop · 08/06/2023 21:10

MistyMountainTop · 08/06/2023 21:01

Both my parents are dead, one very recently. I have no guilt! Maybe you do...

And if you do, then I'm very sorry for you.

azlazee1 · 08/06/2023 21:10

Are grandparents asking to see the children more? If not, why create a problem where none exists. There are plenty of families who get to see relatives on holidays, but not much at other times. If, in fact, it is you who wants a closer relationship, then you should make the effort.

MistyMountainTop · 08/06/2023 21:01

momtoboys · 08/06/2023 18:59

Perhaps those "guilt mongering" responses were from people who know of what they speak.

Both my parents are dead, one very recently. I have no guilt! Maybe you do...

CoffeeCakeAndALattePlease · 08/06/2023 21:01

Like most topics on mn, I think it should be a middle ground.

Go to visit them sometimes, invite then to visit you sometimes and maybe once or twice a year meet somewhere in the middle.

We do a real mix in our family. GP on dhs side are an hour away and usually results in DC2 getting carsick so is a pain but we manage it best we can. But they also come here regularly although do drive which is easier.

My df is much older, very unwell and has terrible mobility so I almost always go there but sometimes he says he'll come to us instead.

Everyone needs to compromise and make some effort.

celticprincess · 08/06/2023 20:49

When I was a child we only ever saw my grandparents when my parents took us to see them. And later in life when we took public transport or drove over to see them. They didn’t drive. For Xmas my DM would go and collect my grandparents on my dads side and bring them back to ours and then take them home again. We usually visited them every other weekend for a few hours.

Now as a single parent my kids usually see my parents when I take them. Neither live that far. One drives and one uses public transport. We usually drop in several times a week on my DM. My DD was more a meeting him at the pub type thing for lunch. The main reason though is my mum can’t use my stairs to access my only loo. My DM is my main childcare though and all childcare is done at her house.

The other set of grandparents live a few hours drive. That’s a mutual arrangement if them visiting for a weekend or their dad taking them for a weekend. When we were together we would all go for the weekend. But usually mutual.

Flippingnora100 · 08/06/2023 20:41

OP, it sounds like you are disappointed with your parents’ lack of effort. I know how that feels. My mum was a wonderful grandmother, but died in 2015. The remaining 3 pretty much suck. My dad will make an effort if we go to him, but has only come to see us once in 3 years. My father in law is similar. My mother in law has never once visited her grandchildren, who are 12 and 8 now. They met her at a wedding last summer and didn’t know who she was! I find it kind of sad for my kids, as I had amazing grandparents who I was really close with.

We now go and see the GPs if we want to, but we feel no obligation any more. I mainly see it as their loss if they aren’t that bothered.

I don’t think anyone else can judge. I think it’s entirely your call and you’ve got to do what’s right for you. It sounds like you make all the effort doesn’t work for you so maybe you should talk to them and let them know and say you’d like to start taking turns and you’ll wait for them to visit next.

Ultimately, if your kids and their GPs only have a relationship because you made 100% of the effort, then how deep a connection is it really going to be? Obviously if a GP is unable, that’s a completely different story.

Yourcatisnotsorry · 08/06/2023 20:31

Are they supportive and involved the time you are together? Do they call and show interest in your and your children’s lives? If so it’s either they know you are busy and don’t want to intrude or they don’t like the public transport/being far from home (my mum is like this, she can’t be out for more than a couple of hours). If they are just not bothered about you and your kids then I think yanbu to leave them to it. Can’t imagine how people get this way but sadly they do :-/

phoenixrosehere · 08/06/2023 19:52

Angelil · 08/06/2023 17:50

LOL YABU. We drive 12 hours each way at least twice a year to enable our children to see my PIL. I think they have visited us a grand total of 4 times in 15 years. Count yourself lucky it’s only an hour! As for it being difficult to entertain your kids in the car…have you tried audiobooks? Our Audible subscription is the only thing saving everyone’s sanity on the 12+ hour car rides that I just mentioned.

Why should OP count herself lucky when you have chosen to make that twice a year long journey?

To my parents, it is a 8 hr flight and a 5 hour drive one way not including getting to the airport which we’re an hour away from and have to leave the house at least 3 hours early. They know it is harder for us to visit them than it is for them to visit us so they try and visit us once a year and we them when we can. They can stay longer with us (usually stay for two weeks) than we can with them (five full days), we have more space at our home to accommodate them and take them to different places within the UK and to Europe when they visit. They get more time with our children visiting us than they do with us visiting them.

In-laws are a 5 hour drive (rarely is that with traffic and loo breaks) and they come twice a year by train while we were going up 6-8 a year but have cut down to 4-6 due to the boys being in school, and planning to cut it down to 4 since it’s getting expensive.