Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not taking my children to see their grandparents?

342 replies

Herringbone1 · 06/06/2023 23:57

For context my children are primary school age. We have a busy life (like most parents with young children) activities, full time jobs then throw in housework, trying to shoehorn in some family days together etc. leaves very little time for much else. Grandparents are retired and do very little aside from casual hobbies. Don’t drive. Live around an hour away but make very little effort to have a relationship with their grandsons. No significant health issues that would prevent them from visiting.

AIBU I’m not taking my children on a 2 hour round trip to see them when they make such little effort? I feel guilty thinking well maybe I should try more but I then I think well why can’t they get public transport to come see us? Why is it my responsibility to encourage their relationship? They made the choice not to drive, not me.

OP posts:
Lizziespring · 10/06/2023 12:21

If public transport is quicker, cheaper and easier than driving, why not visit them that way yourself? Then when you leave, simply suggest a date for them to return visit to you next time. If you actually want them to visit, which sounds unlikely as you don't seem to like them.

5555L · 10/06/2023 12:11

I agree with you and I’m in the same boat. 1 set of grandparents make 0 effort, to the point it’s my little ones birthday and they asked what to get. I said what we got and they just bought a cheaper version of what we already bought. They don’t call unless we call and they’re semi retired and have plenty of money (which annoys me because they buy cheap plastic toys or just give hand me downs that are already on their way out - 1st Christmas they bought a cheap hand me down that was scuffed and scratched and had material coming off of it). We have a toddler, cats and work full time so I don’t feel we should make effort to drag everything 3.5 hours away when they don’t even make an effort to call and check on our toddler. YANBU.

zingally · 10/06/2023 11:43

I'm a big fan of the saying "roads go both ways" when it comes to one-sided family visits. But I do also feel that some allowances should be made for the elderly.

But perhaps the GPs are happy with the current level of contact, and see no reason to change? Have they said they want to see more of the boys? What were their own experiences of having/being kids and seeing grandparents?
Personally, I didn't see my grandparents much growing up. They weren't much more than the nice old people I saw a couple of times a year. 2 of them had passed just before I made double digits in age. The other 2 made it into my late teens.

Catza · 10/06/2023 11:38

When I was little we lived in another country and required a visa and a 15h train journey to visit my grandparents. They came maybe once in 9 years but my mum used to take me to theirs for Christmas and summer holidays without a fail. I had a wonderful time with them and hate to think what would happen if my mum thought it was unreasonable for her to make an effort. I entertained myself fine on the train too with a couple of books and home baked goodies grandma packed for the journey back.

Herringbone1 · 10/06/2023 11:20

Donetrying1 · 10/06/2023 11:18

Your post makes me feel very sad.
l am a grandparent who hardly sees my grandchildren.
Their parents are both very busy and both work so l only see them once in a while. I can’t drive (couldn’t afford lessons and l was a carer for my mum)and live an hours and a half’s drive away
l think you have to think of the children, surely it’s better for them to see their grandparents no matter who is making the effort?
So many children don’t have grandparents so if it were me l would make the effort.

Do you travel to see them?

OP posts:
Donetrying1 · 10/06/2023 11:18

Your post makes me feel very sad.
l am a grandparent who hardly sees my grandchildren.
Their parents are both very busy and both work so l only see them once in a while. I can’t drive (couldn’t afford lessons and l was a carer for my mum)and live an hours and a half’s drive away
l think you have to think of the children, surely it’s better for them to see their grandparents no matter who is making the effort?
So many children don’t have grandparents so if it were me l would make the effort.

Mumto2littleloonies · 10/06/2023 10:06

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable at all!

My MIL works and still pops over at least once a fortnight to see my DD (FIL has some health issues so prefers to stay at home) and we visit them once a month or so at their house.

My own mum rarely even bothers to check in on us to see how we are, let alone comes to visit us. To add context, we have not had a falling out, she just isn’t bothered about anyone who isn’t my younger sister or her kids (I’m one of 5 kids). She doesn’t work but does drive.

My mum speaks to YS daily and visits her every week on a Sunday. Is ALWAYS babysitting for her etc. I’ve asked her to watch my son (7) 4 times in his life and she has cancelled on me all 4 times (once was for a funeral, luckily I was prepped and double booked babysitter).
I used to take my son to visit her (40 minutes away) fairly regularly too, but got fed up of being the only one making the effort for their relationship (I don’t care that she isn’t bothered about me, but he’s a child!).

so no, I don’t think you’re being unreasonable at all. The effort should be reciprocated, not just expected of you all of the time.

Herringbone1 · 10/06/2023 10:03

pineapple360 · 10/06/2023 09:37

How well do you your parents get on with your children? Do they have a strong relationship?

I come from a very dysfunctional family so I can relate to your posts. I don't think you're being unreasonable.

My parents kept me away from my grandparents, I only saw them about once a year at best. When I was a teenager/young adult I felt they were alienating me from them. However now as an older adult and parent myself, I can understand why they did what they did! My grandparents were definitely worse than my parents and also of the couldn't be bothered persuasion!

My parents were not great parents to me but they are good grandparents to my daughter. The difference in my case is they are actively involved and and arrangements work both ways.

If I were in your situation I think I would address it directly with my parents and say that they are welcome to see my children and have a relationship with them, but we need to take it in turns for visits as you are under a lot of pressure from various demands. Ask if there's anything that is preventing them visiting or they are worried about. Perhaps it can be solved. Or perhaps they just can't be bothered! Either way the proof will be in the pudding. If you speak to them directly and nothing happens then you know the problem is with them.

Ultimately you know your parents best and you know what's best for your children. Whatever decision you make, you need to make sure you're happy with it and can justify it to your children should they ask later (not written in an accusatory way, but if they are like me they will probably ask!). I hope this can be resolved and solidarity for managing with parents who aren't great!

Thank you for your understanding. This is good advice to move things forward. Since starting this thread I have invited them over but they declined as they’ve got plans which is fair enough. I’ll try and do it a bit more in advance next time. They did say they will sort something out soon so we shall see. I have heard this a lot. If it doesn’t happen I’ll go visit them and speak to them about coming over to us next time. I do want my children to have a relationship with them it’s just lack of effort on their part / the practicalities of visiting them that make it difficult for me.

I know people think I’m unreasonable and everyone on here seems to have the time but I can’t express how little time we actually have to make that journey on a regular basis.

OP posts:
pineapple360 · 10/06/2023 09:37

How well do you your parents get on with your children? Do they have a strong relationship?

I come from a very dysfunctional family so I can relate to your posts. I don't think you're being unreasonable.

My parents kept me away from my grandparents, I only saw them about once a year at best. When I was a teenager/young adult I felt they were alienating me from them. However now as an older adult and parent myself, I can understand why they did what they did! My grandparents were definitely worse than my parents and also of the couldn't be bothered persuasion!

My parents were not great parents to me but they are good grandparents to my daughter. The difference in my case is they are actively involved and and arrangements work both ways.

If I were in your situation I think I would address it directly with my parents and say that they are welcome to see my children and have a relationship with them, but we need to take it in turns for visits as you are under a lot of pressure from various demands. Ask if there's anything that is preventing them visiting or they are worried about. Perhaps it can be solved. Or perhaps they just can't be bothered! Either way the proof will be in the pudding. If you speak to them directly and nothing happens then you know the problem is with them.

Ultimately you know your parents best and you know what's best for your children. Whatever decision you make, you need to make sure you're happy with it and can justify it to your children should they ask later (not written in an accusatory way, but if they are like me they will probably ask!). I hope this can be resolved and solidarity for managing with parents who aren't great!

Herringbone1 · 10/06/2023 09:19

NoThanksymm · 10/06/2023 04:22

You are being an ass. They are your parents.

Also it’s ONLY AN HOUR!! We drive 7 twice a month to see mine (yes one way).

i don’t know why it is, but kids go to parents. We went to my grandparents house, now I go to parents. It’s going home, where as parents may feel like they are intruding, or they just get fussy in their old age and comfortable at home - that is fine and respectable.

your comments around public transport. Then you should take it! People watching will entertain the kids.

costs - come on! Here again you are being unreasonable. The cost of two hours round trip is minimal - or you have chosen a gas guzzler and can afford it. Plus you are probably being fed while there, offset cost right there.

your parents driving- this is where you are being crazy, self centred and unreasonable. If your parents are at the age where they are choosing not to drive they are doing a service to everyone!! My grandfather couldn’t feel his feet, had Parkinson’s, and didn’t give up his truck till a mysterious dent appeared in it. My old land lady couldn’t turn her head, covered the vehicle with reflective tape, 100% should not have been driving. So thank you to your parents for giving up their licence. Parents often won’t keep their kids abreast of health issues, so please give them some grace on this.

if you want them to be coming over more, invite them more. ‘Hey I’m making a roast on Tuesday, can you come? Stay the night?’ Or kids have extracurriculars then have them meet you at a middle location.

Read my replies - they haven’t given up their licence. They’re more than capable of getting public transport. It’s not a health issue. They’ve had numerous invitations. It’s not practical for them to meet in the middle/there isn’t much to do.

OP posts:
NoThanksymm · 10/06/2023 04:22

You are being an ass. They are your parents.

Also it’s ONLY AN HOUR!! We drive 7 twice a month to see mine (yes one way).

i don’t know why it is, but kids go to parents. We went to my grandparents house, now I go to parents. It’s going home, where as parents may feel like they are intruding, or they just get fussy in their old age and comfortable at home - that is fine and respectable.

your comments around public transport. Then you should take it! People watching will entertain the kids.

costs - come on! Here again you are being unreasonable. The cost of two hours round trip is minimal - or you have chosen a gas guzzler and can afford it. Plus you are probably being fed while there, offset cost right there.

your parents driving- this is where you are being crazy, self centred and unreasonable. If your parents are at the age where they are choosing not to drive they are doing a service to everyone!! My grandfather couldn’t feel his feet, had Parkinson’s, and didn’t give up his truck till a mysterious dent appeared in it. My old land lady couldn’t turn her head, covered the vehicle with reflective tape, 100% should not have been driving. So thank you to your parents for giving up their licence. Parents often won’t keep their kids abreast of health issues, so please give them some grace on this.

if you want them to be coming over more, invite them more. ‘Hey I’m making a roast on Tuesday, can you come? Stay the night?’ Or kids have extracurriculars then have them meet you at a middle location.

Titusgroan · 10/06/2023 03:15

Nanny0gg · 09/06/2023 19:00

You can fuck right off with 'entitled boomers'

Being entitled has nothing to do with age

Agree@Nanny0gg MN is full of discriminatory comments about boomers.
I cant stand any form of discrimination.

Bambi7 · 09/06/2023 22:31

It is frustrating.

I make the effort to see the in laws and even my husband doesn’t bother as he’s so fed up with them. I do it for my DC (and a little bit because I just thing it’s the right thing to do) as they want to see them and now they don’t even respond.

My grandmother told me once “I know what it’s like to be your age but you don’t know what it’s like to be my age”. That gave me some reflective thinking.

Its hard and I don’t have any answers. Maybe delve a little deeper as to why they don’t for your children’s sake.

ilovemyspace · 09/06/2023 21:30

Doesn't it all depend on how much YOU, as a parent, want them to be involved in your childrens' life?

My parents were reluctant to travel to visit ( 2.5 hrs away) because of personal reasons (I didn't delve too deeply and took at face value that they had difficult in travelling to visit). I made the effort to travel to them because I wanted my children to know they had family / grandparents.

Both my children and my parents loved this time together and built a strong bond. So, I guess my advice would be - do what you think is important for your family x

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 09/06/2023 21:05

Herringbone1 · 09/06/2023 20:59

Yeah they’ve been invited numerous times and to things I know they’ll love as they’re interested in. They’ve spoken about coming and said they will but it never materialises. We’ve not spoken about the half way meet-up as there’s not much half way between us really. Not without them having to get 2x forms of public transport.

@Herringbone1 I think the fact you've invited them to things you know they'll love and be interested in is really lovely of you. But I think the fact they say they'll cone but it 'never materialises' suggests there might be a serious, underlying mental illness with one of your parents as I suggested in a previous post. Maybe?

Herringbone1 · 09/06/2023 20:59

LT1982 · 09/06/2023 20:28

or even meet halfway?

Yeah they’ve been invited numerous times and to things I know they’ll love as they’re interested in. They’ve spoken about coming and said they will but it never materialises. We’ve not spoken about the half way meet-up as there’s not much half way between us really. Not without them having to get 2x forms of public transport.

OP posts:
Sierra26 · 09/06/2023 20:42

Sounds exhausting if it’s all on you. It seems to me it’s mostly about the lack of reciprocation. You’d be happy to keep making the effort if it was matched by equal (or close to equal) effort on their part. Doesn’t have to be all or nothing.

On principle it’s ridiculous but in reality you have to decide if you can tolerate and if the relationship is worth the disproportionate effort

LT1982 · 09/06/2023 20:28

or even meet halfway?

LT1982 · 09/06/2023 20:26

Have you actually invited them to come and visit you? Maybe they don't want to intrude

NorthernGnashers · 09/06/2023 20:19

OP, have these grandparents complained that they don't see their grandchildren? I remember my lovely grandad travelling to see me on the bus.

Nanny0gg · 09/06/2023 20:08

Segway16 · 09/06/2023 19:09

Fuck off boomer. Visit your grandkids.

I do. All the time (invited)

Lookaways · 09/06/2023 19:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Jem123456789 · 09/06/2023 19:44

I’m sure they don’t expect a visit every weekend but surely once a month isn’t a big deal? I can’t fathom not making that effort for them or your children.

johnd2 · 09/06/2023 19:28

There are too many replies (that I haven't read) for mine to make a difference but if it does - my advice is - stop worrying about what they should or shouldn't do and what's fair and what are the obligations, and start thinking about what you want and what suits you.
You might find there's a middle ground that doesn't require validation from outside. Also try to be flexible over time - maybe now you don't feel able to take on this extra load, that's fine, but maybe in 3 months time you'll fancy a visit despite the hassle -if so make it happen at that point.
Also consider discussing with your parents about your concerns, they may not surprise you, but if neither side is communicating then nothing will change.

Tiredmama53 · 09/06/2023 19:27

Not OP but the train is often faster than driving.

Swipe left for the next trending thread