Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why people are such jobsworths?

156 replies

Achildlessperson · 06/06/2023 20:24

For people that don’t have a genuine stake in the game (ie partners of an LLP, business owners), why do they care SO much about things to the point it doesn’t genuinely advantage them?

Partly fuelled by another thread I’ve seen about catching out someone with a doctor’s note, I have to ask - why do you care? I understand if it puts more workload on to you, then FINE. But again, that’s a top management problem. Workers are paid in exchange for their labour. I completely get high earning jobs where you know what you’re going into before. However, sometimes I really do wonder why people go out their way to be such jobsworths when the advantage to them is 0.

For example, there’s a pub where we live that also has its own takeaway style bar - fish and chips, ice cream etc. One day DH and I bought fish and chips (£14) and then sat in the outside bit (not the height of summer and not busy) and ordered two drinks from the bar. A waitress told us we couldn’t eat THEIR OWN FOOD in their beer garden. We had already paid for our drinks so got given two plastic cups to put them in and go 1 meter away, behind the wall to eat. What was the point? Why would you care? The young girl didn’t own the pub, is paid under 21 wage.

I feel employers, the ones making the 0.1%, really take advantage of this. They’re fine breaking moral and ethical conduct rules, avoiding tax to the highest, but expecting their employees on minimum wage to go above their pay / job role. If everyone just said no, compensate me fairly for this, then the labour market may actually improve.

Everyone refers to high earning tech jobs and how they’re overpaid etc but these companies just get it right. They pay highly, improve morale, in exchange workers are happy to go above and beyond. The company improves, profits increase, efficiency and productivity improves = win win.

so, why do people care SO much? Especially as by “caring” isn’t actually always the most ethical/moral action?

OP posts:
Smurfsareus · 07/06/2023 09:34

I once worked with a woman. She was about 15 years older than her boss. She would do ANYTHING to get praise from him. Famously didn't like dogs but agreed to dogsit for him as he was too stinge to pay for doggy daycare.

She was one of those women who'd go running to the boss at any slightest bit of gossip, tiniest and most fixable errors and she even enjoyed stirring the pot so the boss would look unfavourably on others. She was (is!) a nasty piece of work who clearly hated women.

I didn't get it. She was being paid a low salary and was horribly overworked. She could easily walk out the door into a better paying role. But she wouldn't- I think she liked the power she had.

E.g if she didn't like someone new - they wouldn't pass their probation because she would twist things and make up stories.

She's one of those people who was surrounded by staff who needed to focus on their work (intricate details) & she'd be there, on speaker phone with her annoying shrill daughter every single day on max volume. But at the same time declaring she's been in work since 7am because she's SO busy!

Maybe she wouldn't have to come in at 7am if she didn't spend the day waddling about and spreading lies. Like I say, her brown nosing hasn't really paid off, bless her.

QforCucumber · 07/06/2023 09:33

For example, there’s a pub where we live that also has its own takeaway style bar - fish and chips, ice cream etc. One day DH and I bought fish and chips (£14) and then sat in the outside bit (not the height of summer and not busy) and ordered two drinks from the bar. A waitress told us we couldn’t eat THEIR OWN FOOD in their beer garden.

She is absolutely right - if you have bought something to take away and then you start 'eating in' you haven't paid the correct tax on the meal and so she can't allow you to do that. VAT is applicable to eat in, and not on Takeaway.

funinthesun19 · 07/06/2023 09:32

She’s not a jobsworth. It’s not the waitress’ fault there are rules that you don’t agree with. She’s just doing her job and if she doesn’t enforce those rules then she will be the one who gets in to trouble.

Why should she put her job on the line for YOU? If she just lets people do as they please then she might end up getting sacked. Not really worth risking her livelihood for some randomers.

ThatWriterInTheCorner · 07/06/2023 09:32

For the fish and chips takeaway question, I think this has to do with VAT (it's due for eat-in food but not for takeaway). So business owners have to be pretty strict on enforcing where you sit.

In general, if I have a choice of who to annoy (the customer who I may never see again and whose worst sanction is being arsey with me, or the employer who told me what the rules are and can fire me if I don't enforce them) - I know what I'd choose to do.

IkeaMeatballGravy · 07/06/2023 09:27

There were 100+ applicants for my part time retail job, staff are disposable and we know it. It's cheeky of you to expect staff to bend the rules for you when it's putting food on thier table and a roof over thier heads. Simply put, the staff care more about themselves and thier families then some random customer.

LlynTegid · 07/06/2023 09:25

I offer two thoughts- fear of losing their job (many bosses are not nice), and given how entitled and unpleasant too many customers are, a sense of being able to have a kind of petty revenge.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 07/06/2023 09:24

Ardiaei · 07/06/2023 09:16

I usually find when people are complaining about ‘jobsworths’ it’s because they’re being asked to do something they don’t want to do, (or prevented from doing something) but don’t understand the reasons why.

Some people think traffic wardens are jobsworths because they’re not allowed to just park wherever they like.

Very often it’s entitled sorts of people; people who think rules should not apply to them, combined with a lack of self awareness and not being able to see the broader context.

Our local Facebook page is full of bitching about the traffic wardens. There is one in particular who gets a lot of hate and I really hope she doesn't live locally.

Posts are often "I parked on the main street on double yellows with my hazards on while I offloaded all my charity donations then took them into the shop, exchanged pleasantries with the volunteers and she appeared out of nowhere and gave me a ticket! What a jobsworth!" Then plenty of comments calling her awful names, accusing her of purposely making people's lives difficult etc.

It's literally her job...

StemStem · 07/06/2023 09:22

You won’t get a good reaction here. We are all curtain twitching jobsworths.

Ardiaei · 07/06/2023 09:18

The other point is no matter how low paid someone is, most people don’t want to lose their job, so they obey their employer and do what they’re paid to do.

Ardiaei · 07/06/2023 09:16

I usually find when people are complaining about ‘jobsworths’ it’s because they’re being asked to do something they don’t want to do, (or prevented from doing something) but don’t understand the reasons why.

Some people think traffic wardens are jobsworths because they’re not allowed to just park wherever they like.

Very often it’s entitled sorts of people; people who think rules should not apply to them, combined with a lack of self awareness and not being able to see the broader context.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 07/06/2023 09:13

ClemFandango1 · 07/06/2023 09:10

I agree OP.
I think with young employees it can be that they don't have enough life experience to apply sense over rigidity.

When I worked catering, I was amazed how people would defend the employer's unfair actions to their own detriment (in this case expecting hourly workers to stay unpaid until everything was done - so many hours of labour stolen).

At IKEA I asked them to sub one portion of carbs for another for my son who has a restrictive eating disorder - they point blank refused because computer said no.

But TBF to them, if the till won't let them do it and the management don't want them to do it, they just can't do it. It's not worth their job.
In my experience, it's the lower level managers trying to make a name for themselves who will make floor staff/cashiers lives a living hell if they don't tow the line. Upper management wouldn't see a problem.

OnMyWayToSenility · 07/06/2023 09:13

🤖

ClemFandango1 · 07/06/2023 09:10

I agree OP.
I think with young employees it can be that they don't have enough life experience to apply sense over rigidity.

When I worked catering, I was amazed how people would defend the employer's unfair actions to their own detriment (in this case expecting hourly workers to stay unpaid until everything was done - so many hours of labour stolen).

At IKEA I asked them to sub one portion of carbs for another for my son who has a restrictive eating disorder - they point blank refused because computer said no.

JudgeRudy · 07/06/2023 09:07

I care about things that don't affect me directly - because I have a very pronounced sense of right/wrong and Justice and I want to live in a fairer world.
Using your example of eating a takeaway in the beer garden - the employee is carrying out the duties assigned to her in exchange for a wage. Fair. The employer doesn't want anyone eating takeaways in the beer garden. They have their reasons, maybe it's too difficult to police, maybe there's a potential issue with waste (food/paper)....but ultimately in MN style No, is a complete answer.
I know people work cash in hand whilst claiming benefits. That's unfair. I don't want to pay tax either but I do. It's unfair that someone should have more income than me simply by conning the state. The state includes me. It's stealing. I care.

Of course, thete have bern timrs when ive been the opposite of a jobsworth. Ive made a decision against policies. This isnt through apathy though, lve made a conscious decision that i feel the 'rules' arent fair. You seem to either lack imagination or to be incredibly insular if you don't understand a 'jobsworths' mentality.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 07/06/2023 09:02

Doing the job you're being paid to do isn't being a jobsworth 🙄

Floralys2 · 07/06/2023 09:00

I think a lot of the time things that can be seen as petty are actually being mentioned because the person being called petty is looking at the bigger picture

For example, in my job I often get people who have came to pick up a car they've bought but instead of just doing that they try to walk around the private compound next door and look at other cars

I also have people that want to drive cars on-site that they haven't paid for yet

I just tell them that it's our policy and that I'm following instructions from my manager

Most people are okay with it and I don't overly like confrontation but the more I do it the easier it gets

Florissante · 07/06/2023 08:57

If I've understood you OP, it's a race to the bottom where everyone does the bare minimum and no one gives a shit about anyone but themselves.

That sums up a lot of threads I've seen on MN lately.

TheKobayashiMaru · 07/06/2023 08:56

You are paid to do a job and some of those jobs come with rules that you are told to enforce whether it makes sense or not.

Saw a woman complain bitterly that she wasn't given free plastic bags in a nice clothes shop as she 'had spent a lot of money'. The assistant tried to explain that it is the law and she cannot give a bag away, however the woman still grumbled.

Florissante · 07/06/2023 08:56

littleripper · 07/06/2023 08:53

The waitress will be sick of clearing up peoples wrappers, the wrappers attract vermin and it is her job! She is not a jobsworth. A jobsworth is someone like the ticket inspector who made my mum and a man who was very happy where he was move because they were in the 'wrong seats'.

That happens when you are in seats reserved for other people and / or you are in the wrong class (first versus standard) on the train. So, yeah. Deserved.

YukoandHiro · 07/06/2023 08:55

BarelyLiterate · 06/06/2023 20:40

Because the waitress is doing what her employer tells her to? Because she is worried that if she doesn’t try to enforce her employer’s policies she will be in trouble?
OP, if you really need to have this stuff explained to you, it’s pretty clear that you have never had to do minimum wage service industry work in which you have zero discretion, zero autonomy and you just have to do as you’re told. Or else.

Hear hear.

And just cast the net a bit wider for a moment. Sure, the waitress doesn't give a rats ass abut the business but she cares about saving enough money to be able to pay her rent and stay on at uni to finish her course. So she does what she's told because it does benefit her.

I hate this spectacularly Mumsnet phrase, but I'm afraid in this instance, OP, you really do sound like hard work.

Florissante · 07/06/2023 08:55

Kazzyhoward · 07/06/2023 08:34

Not when the customer know he's actually right, and it's the shop worker who's wrong, when it's faulty goods, or the manager not knowing their store's own return policy!

Your post has just proved my point.

littleripper · 07/06/2023 08:53

The waitress will be sick of clearing up peoples wrappers, the wrappers attract vermin and it is her job! She is not a jobsworth. A jobsworth is someone like the ticket inspector who made my mum and a man who was very happy where he was move because they were in the 'wrong seats'.

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 07/06/2023 08:52

There are jobsworths, there are people doing the job they're contracted to do and respecting the guidelines of that contract/workplace and there are CF clients who don't understand the law.

The example of the fish and chips has 2 of the above 3 things meeting in the Venn diagram. The missing one isn't the jobsworth.

JandalsAlways · 07/06/2023 08:52

SchoolShenanigans · 07/06/2023 08:04

Fairness as a concept is something most people value.

👏👏👏
If I've understood you OP, it's a race to the bottom where everyone does the bare minimum and no one gives a shit about anyone but themselves.
Also, some people actually take pride in doing a good job. I know I really value if I've helped someone resolve an issue

JandalsAlways · 07/06/2023 08:50

Well I work hard and do my best and I resent having colleagues who are paid the same (or more than me) doing f all. That's why it bothers me, even though yes it's technically managements problem. But actually it's not, that work just gets given to someone else. Also I like to have good service, not the bare minimum so people doing as you suggest ruin it for everyone. Trying to sort out an error on a phone bill at the money and it's a nightmare because I just get passed on to different people and no one can be bothered actually resolving the issue. Noticing this more and more, probably because of shitty attitudes like yours.

Swipe left for the next trending thread