Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why people are such jobsworths?

156 replies

Achildlessperson · 06/06/2023 20:24

For people that don’t have a genuine stake in the game (ie partners of an LLP, business owners), why do they care SO much about things to the point it doesn’t genuinely advantage them?

Partly fuelled by another thread I’ve seen about catching out someone with a doctor’s note, I have to ask - why do you care? I understand if it puts more workload on to you, then FINE. But again, that’s a top management problem. Workers are paid in exchange for their labour. I completely get high earning jobs where you know what you’re going into before. However, sometimes I really do wonder why people go out their way to be such jobsworths when the advantage to them is 0.

For example, there’s a pub where we live that also has its own takeaway style bar - fish and chips, ice cream etc. One day DH and I bought fish and chips (£14) and then sat in the outside bit (not the height of summer and not busy) and ordered two drinks from the bar. A waitress told us we couldn’t eat THEIR OWN FOOD in their beer garden. We had already paid for our drinks so got given two plastic cups to put them in and go 1 meter away, behind the wall to eat. What was the point? Why would you care? The young girl didn’t own the pub, is paid under 21 wage.

I feel employers, the ones making the 0.1%, really take advantage of this. They’re fine breaking moral and ethical conduct rules, avoiding tax to the highest, but expecting their employees on minimum wage to go above their pay / job role. If everyone just said no, compensate me fairly for this, then the labour market may actually improve.

Everyone refers to high earning tech jobs and how they’re overpaid etc but these companies just get it right. They pay highly, improve morale, in exchange workers are happy to go above and beyond. The company improves, profits increase, efficiency and productivity improves = win win.

so, why do people care SO much? Especially as by “caring” isn’t actually always the most ethical/moral action?

OP posts:
taxguru · 07/06/2023 13:47

But then if there's a dine-in section, why not just sit there? because it is more expensive

Yes, but the dine-in usually comes with waitress service, proper crockery, knives & forks, etc., hence the higher price, whereas takeaway is just the food, a container and maybe some plastic cutlery. So they weren't getting the "dining in" experience by eating a takeaway to try to save money!

lieselotte · 07/06/2023 13:31

Now I'm in a professional career, I have the ability and voice to question rules, work with my managers, develop my own ways of working but back then I had no option. I either did what my boss told me or I'd be without a job

Indeed. But that actually shows that there is a different, and wider, problem here - one that has been mentioned in other contexts too - that poorly paid staff are not allowed to have opinions. For example, how many times do retailers come up with stupid policies that their staff have to follow, without asking staff what they think, given that they are actually doing the job day in day our and not sitting in an ivory tower office somewhere.

I also blame head offices for the lack of staff and the lack of properly trained staff.

lieselotte · 07/06/2023 13:26

Did you miss the bit where they bought drinks from the pub? If they hadn't bought fish & chips from the takeaway, they'd have been allowed to sit and drink the drinks they'd bought, so they'd have occupied those tables anyway, even if just for a drink. It was a beer garden after all

I had not read it properly and do agree that it was a stupid rule in that particular scenario, especially if the beer garden wasn't busy and if they had bought drinks. They would be there anyway. But then if there's a dine-in section, why not just sit there? because it is more expensive

I also think it's a bit silly when you buy a drink for you and your child in a coffee shop and they complain that you give your child a cereal bar because you didn't buy it there. Yes but I bought the drinks, so I would be sitting here anyway. But staff are constantly asked to make allowances for people and I guess it gets a bit wearing.

Neighbours87 · 07/06/2023 12:28

I hate the term jobsworth. It’s always used by people who want special treatment and who think your job isn’t important

OopsAnotherOne · 07/06/2023 12:26

When I was a waitress I had a few similar rules I had to ask people to stick to, I wasn't a "jobsworth" as you claim, I was doing my job. If I didn't, I'd get it in the neck from my manager who owned the restaurant and made the rules. It was a minimum wage job and I was a 17 year old who personally couldn't have given less of a shit about the rules but as an employee, I didn't ask people to follow them and my boss saw that I was constantly slacking in this area, I was disposable and I'd soon be out of a job.

Now I'm in a professional career, I have the ability and voice to question rules, work with my managers, develop my own ways of working but back then I had no option. I either did what my boss told me or I'd be without a job, I didn't like it anymore than you clearly don't but if you have an issue in future, take it up with the manager or owner of the establishment as they're the ones making the rules, not the waiting staff - gone are the days where waitresses can be asked to do something by their boss and reply "no, I don't want customers to think I'm a jobsworth so I'm not going to do that", that's a very quick way to be dismissed.

Florissante · 07/06/2023 12:22

Maverickess · 07/06/2023 12:21

@Florissante

I have read it that the pub has a takeaway section, so part of the pub. But, as it's takeaway there shouldn't be an expectation that you then dine in because well, you've bought take away and they do offer dine in too, so there's a choice to be had.
OP chose, ordered and paid for takeaway and then is pissed off that she couldn't dine in, and wants to blame someone else for that.

Yes. I agree with you.

Maverickess · 07/06/2023 12:21

@Florissante

I have read it that the pub has a takeaway section, so part of the pub. But, as it's takeaway there shouldn't be an expectation that you then dine in because well, you've bought take away and they do offer dine in too, so there's a choice to be had.
OP chose, ordered and paid for takeaway and then is pissed off that she couldn't dine in, and wants to blame someone else for that.

Maverickess · 07/06/2023 12:16

taxguru · 07/06/2023 11:41

Did you miss the bit where they bought drinks from the pub? If they hadn't bought fish & chips from the takeaway, they'd have been allowed to sit and drink the drinks they'd bought, so they'd have occupied those tables anyway, even if just for a drink. It was a beer garden after all.

Then why, if they bought drinks from the bar, couldn't they buy the fish and chips from there too and thus sit at the tables as a dining customer?
The tables aren't for takeaway customers, clearly whether they buy a drink or not - if the fish and chips had been wrapped and stayed that way while OP had her drink, then I'd say absolutely, but it's clear the OP ordered from the takeaway part (clue is in the name, it's to take away) and then demanded the facilities of the seated part to eat them. That's not what she bought, she bought takeaway, to well, take away.
I'm inclined to think that she did it that way to try and strong arm the person serving into allowing her to use dine in facilities for the takeaway she bought, probably because the takeaway prices are cheaper than the dine in and she didn't want to pay the higher price but benefit from the facilities of it.
And then call the person who said no a jobsworth because it didn't work and she didn't get her own way, and further say that it shouldn't matter to that person because OP doesn't think it affects them.
Not doing what your employer tells you to affects you when they notice and then reprimand you for it, it can ultimately cost you your job, but then seemingly that's what people are increasingly expecting of people in customer facing jobs, for them to put themselves in the firing line with the employer and sometimes the law too, so that they can have something they want, and then personally insult when it doesn't happen.

Florissante · 07/06/2023 11:58

I'm not clear what point you are trying to make, taxguru.

It is standard policy not to allow food or drink that is bought elsewhere to be consumed on a second premises. For example, a cafe would take a pretty dim view of a customer ordering a cup of tea to accompany a packed lunch. A restaurant with a licence would not allow customers to bring in a bottle of wine to drink with their meal (unless there was such an arrangement in place in advance).

taxguru · 07/06/2023 11:41

Maverickess · 07/06/2023 11:28

Not busy at that moment in time, absolutely no guarantee it will stay that way while takeaway customers use the tables, that more takeaway customers won't see OP using the tables and demand the same (because it's not fair if they're not allowed as well, even if the tables are filling up) that eat in customers won't walk in and want to use the tables too.

Of course it may not happen, but then hospitality is unpredictable because people like to be spontaneous, and that's what things like this are based on, the fact you can (and where I work frequently do!) Go from 5 customers to 50 in a short space of time.

But hey, let's not think like that because it doesn't give the opportunity to bash service workers and have a little bit of superiority over someone else by calling them a jobsworth does it?

Did you miss the bit where they bought drinks from the pub? If they hadn't bought fish & chips from the takeaway, they'd have been allowed to sit and drink the drinks they'd bought, so they'd have occupied those tables anyway, even if just for a drink. It was a beer garden after all.

MrsMikeDrop · 07/06/2023 11:38

Ardiaei · 07/06/2023 09:16

I usually find when people are complaining about ‘jobsworths’ it’s because they’re being asked to do something they don’t want to do, (or prevented from doing something) but don’t understand the reasons why.

Some people think traffic wardens are jobsworths because they’re not allowed to just park wherever they like.

Very often it’s entitled sorts of people; people who think rules should not apply to them, combined with a lack of self awareness and not being able to see the broader context.

Agree with this

Maverickess · 07/06/2023 11:28

taxguru · 07/06/2023 11:07

@Maverickess

The tables are there for people who have bought food from the eat in section of the menu, not the takeaway section. If takeaway customers use the tables and there's no where for eat in customers to sit, then they are going to complain that there's no where to sit and that staff aren't enforcing the rules......

Context is everything. If the place is busy, yes, obviously priority should be given to the "eat in" customers, but if it's otherwise pretty empty, then it really doesn't matter whether someone sits there having bought from the takeaway. That's where the "jobsworth" comes into it! I.e. the inability to apply discretion at times when it really doesn't matter!

Not busy at that moment in time, absolutely no guarantee it will stay that way while takeaway customers use the tables, that more takeaway customers won't see OP using the tables and demand the same (because it's not fair if they're not allowed as well, even if the tables are filling up) that eat in customers won't walk in and want to use the tables too.

Of course it may not happen, but then hospitality is unpredictable because people like to be spontaneous, and that's what things like this are based on, the fact you can (and where I work frequently do!) Go from 5 customers to 50 in a short space of time.

But hey, let's not think like that because it doesn't give the opportunity to bash service workers and have a little bit of superiority over someone else by calling them a jobsworth does it?

Seasonofthewitch83 · 07/06/2023 11:25

It will be those folks who react the most when they get made redundant etc - they do not realise that ultimately the company does not care about them.

taxguru · 07/06/2023 11:07

@Maverickess

The tables are there for people who have bought food from the eat in section of the menu, not the takeaway section. If takeaway customers use the tables and there's no where for eat in customers to sit, then they are going to complain that there's no where to sit and that staff aren't enforcing the rules......

Context is everything. If the place is busy, yes, obviously priority should be given to the "eat in" customers, but if it's otherwise pretty empty, then it really doesn't matter whether someone sits there having bought from the takeaway. That's where the "jobsworth" comes into it! I.e. the inability to apply discretion at times when it really doesn't matter!

Maverickess · 07/06/2023 10:55

The tables are there for people who have bought food from the eat in section of the menu, not the takeaway section. If takeaway customers use the tables and there's no where for eat in customers to sit, then they are going to complain that there's no where to sit and that staff aren't enforcing the rules...... Yet people like you are determined to slate those doing the enforcement because it doesn't suit you.

I would bet if you wanted to order from the eat in section and there was no where to sit for you because of takeaway customers then you'd be moaning that she's not doing her job properly by enforcing the rules.

Either way the staff end up in the wrong and either called useless or jobsworths.

If you wanted to sit there, why buy from the takeaway and not the eat in? Was it cheaper from the takeaway bit because they don't provide somewhere to sit and charge more when they do and you've decided that you're going to try and force the service you want by complaining but not actually pay for or ask for it?
You got what you ordered and paid for, yet you still feel like you have grounds to complain, because you........ Got what you ordered and paid for?

Gtsr443 · 07/06/2023 10:16

Inclined to agree OP - a farm shop I've used for over a decade has a huge stack of fruit and veg cardboard boxes for customers to use. I popped in and bought some seeds and compost (came to about £20) and grabbed a couple of boxes. A young lad on the tills stopped me and told me I hadn't bought the "right things" to entitle me to a free box and made me put them back. (ffs)

And that was me lost as a loyal customer.

OriginalUsername2 · 07/06/2023 10:10

If the waitress let you eat there she’d not be able to argue against other customers wanting to do the same. You have to nip it in the bud quickly.

taxguru · 07/06/2023 10:09

We came across a jobsworth at Newcastle university offer holders' day. There were two lectures/sessions happening in adjacent lecture theatres for different subjects. Outside in the corridor, there were two "refreshment" tables, one outside each lecture theatre door. They were offering tea/coffee, cakes, biscuits, etc., but each was different, run by students wearing different coloured T shirts with the names of their departments on them, i.e. one said "Maths", the other said "Physics). When we were waiting to go in at the Maths lecture theatre, we had cake and coffee from the Maths table. When we came out, and we were virtually the last out because we'd stayed behind to talk to some of the staff, both tables were packing up, putting the uneaten food in bin bags. There were still some paper cups of cold orange juice on the Physics stand, so we went over and asked if we could have a couple - girl behind the counter said, no, only for Physics offer holders, not Maths offer holders, and then promptly poured the remaining ones into the sink! The other couple of guys stood at the stand looked at her in amazement at what she'd just done! There's classic jobsworth behaviour, doing something and imposing a rule that really, really, doesn't matter!

taxguru · 07/06/2023 10:03

@QforCucumber

She is absolutely right - if you have bought something to take away and then you start 'eating in' you haven't paid the correct tax on the meal and so she can't allow you to do that. VAT is applicable to eat in, and not on Takeaway.

Nope, that's wrong. There's VAT on takeaway hot foot such as fish & chips.

taxguru · 07/06/2023 10:01

@ThatWriterInTheCorner

For the fish and chips takeaway question, I think this has to do with VAT (it's due for eat-in food but not for takeaway). So business owners have to be pretty strict on enforcing where you sit.

Nope, hot food/drink is VATable whether it's eaten in or taken away. Fish & chips will be VATable at standard rate wherever it's eaten.

It's cold food that can be zero rated if eaten off the premises, but VATable if eaten on the premises. Hence why if you buy a cold sandwich at a counter, they'll ask if you're eating in (vatable) or takeaway (zero rated).

IglesiasPiggl · 07/06/2023 10:01

Often workers, especially junior ones, are not allowed to exercise judgement because they risk making a wrong or unfair decision.

Hankunamatata · 07/06/2023 09:55

Society would crumble without rules 🤷‍♀️

dreadingitt · 07/06/2023 09:49

This reply has been deleted

This user is a previously banned troll so we have removed their threads and posts.

JauntyJinty · 07/06/2023 09:43

I always think "Jobsworth" is an odd term dripping with entitlement

It's a shortened version of "It's more than my jobs worth" which is short for- "If I do that it could result in me being fired"

So OPs example is quite apt "I wanted to eat my fish and chips there. It's against the rules, which the staff enforced so they won’t be reprimanded, BUT I WANTED TO!"

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 07/06/2023 09:37

QforCucumber · 07/06/2023 09:33

For example, there’s a pub where we live that also has its own takeaway style bar - fish and chips, ice cream etc. One day DH and I bought fish and chips (£14) and then sat in the outside bit (not the height of summer and not busy) and ordered two drinks from the bar. A waitress told us we couldn’t eat THEIR OWN FOOD in their beer garden.

She is absolutely right - if you have bought something to take away and then you start 'eating in' you haven't paid the correct tax on the meal and so she can't allow you to do that. VAT is applicable to eat in, and not on Takeaway.

I'm really surprised that the OP, so apparently up on "rules" and "jobsworths" doesn't know the actual law. It's been the law for years.