Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To put 5 year old through operation solely so they don't have to wear glasses?

58 replies

blueby7 · 06/06/2023 19:09

5 year old wears glasses, she has an issue with her eyes where she needs them for correction but not for eyesight.
Specialist has said will need an op on both eyes but not sure when.
She hates wearing glasses.
I'm wondering if it is wrong to get the operation solely for the purpose of not having to wear glasses anymore?
The operation isn't major but it is on both eyes and eye health scares me as they are so important and delicate.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MumYourBabyGrewUpToBeACowboy · 07/06/2023 20:19

I always worry about children’s bodily autonomy but, as the drs recommend the surgery & your child has expressed the desire to get her eyes fixed I see no ethical issues here.

MedievalMadness · 07/06/2023 00:54

Will they need a general anaesthetic? I only ask because I know a 17 year old who had an operation to pin back his ears as they really stuck out. His Mum gave him the choice and he wanted it done. He had a bad reaction to the anaesthetic and died.

The odds of that happening are so low they wouldn’t not present a reason not to have a GA. My DM was so anxious about my health as a child she wouldn’t let me get my tonsils removed and my childhood and education were totally blighted and miserable as a result.

OP i would rather pre-empt what sound to be very unpleasant symptoms (headaches are pretty awful) and get your DDs name on the waiting list especially as she is going to need this surgery sooner or later. The advantages sound to outweigh the disadvantages- sparing her future symptoms, she hates wearing glasses and helping her vision issues in the short term too. No one likes the thought of surgery for their DC but this sounds necessary and very beneficial.

notawittyname1954 · 07/06/2023 00:13

My daughter had a lazy eye and it was picked up when she was 4. She went through patching and wearing glasses to improve the sight and just before she started infants school she had the operation. Although it looked sore and bloodshot she was fine even the day after. Her sight is not perfect at 36 and she wears glasses for reading. She always says that she is so glad that we had the operation done. I think it would have really affected her confidence if we hadnt had it done.

vipersnest1 · 07/06/2023 00:01

My perspective comes from personal experience.
My Dad had a 'lazy eye' and was only operated on as an adult. His eye still wandered when he was tired, upset or ill. The operation didn't help his vision at all and he was classed as having useful vision in only one eye.
My DC2 was born with a genetic condition that affected their vision (to the point that they were registered blind at two months old). They have a squint when tired, etc, and an operation would only be for cosmetic reasons, despite them having useful vision.
My honest advice is to grab the opportunity with both hands. Yes, your child might still need glasses, but do anything you can to make the impact on them as little as possible, and the sooner the better. The longer you leave it, the more likely it is that it won't make a difference to their vision, or if left long enough, an operation would ultimately mean they end up with double vision.

Thriwit · 06/06/2023 23:47

DS had squint surgery when he was 6. It was very quick, he just had a very red eye for a few weeks. From what I remember they just snipped a tiny muscle.
He still needs his glasses though, and he has a compensating prescription to help keep his eyes in line. If he goes a day without his glasses, his squint starts to come back. (He has long-sightedness & severe astigmatism too though).

My understanding is that 5-7 is the perfect age to have the operation.
I would check about the not needing glasses any more though.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/06/2023 23:40

OP, why would you want to wait? I see no upside to putting it off.

Whatevergetsyouthroughthenight · 06/06/2023 23:24

caringcarer · 06/06/2023 20:47

Will they need a general anaesthetic? I only ask because I know a 17 year old who had an operation to pin back his ears as they really stuck out. His Mum gave him the choice and he wanted it done. He had a bad reaction to the anaesthetic and died.

That’s not helpful. This is not an operation for vanity, it will save the child from potentially losing her sight in one eye or having double vision and no depth perception, meaning a lifelong disability. The consultant has said that glasses will only help for a while. She’ll be in more danger of getting run over by a car due to having no depth perception if she doesn’t have the operation than the tiny risk from a general anaesthetic. The younger you are when this procedure is done, the better the success rate.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 06/06/2023 22:42

Also if you aren't squeamish about eyes you can watch the surgery here

Just so you get an idea of what it might be like

Strabismus Eye Surgery | Inside the OR

Go #InsideTheOR with Nicholas Volpe, MD as he treats a patient suffering from strabismus and double vision.

https://youtu.be/Gm6-dlbSuHk

Catchasingmewithspiders · 06/06/2023 22:36

blueby7 · 06/06/2023 20:33

Cannot thank people enough for replies. I haven't really had anyone to talk to with any experience of these kinds of things.

What I mean is that at the moment she is managing it by wearing glasses. The glasses on the most part alleviate the squint.
So at present if we went ahead with the operation I would feel like it was so she didn't have to wear glasses which I was questioning whether that was a good enough reason for a surgery on both eyes.

Having read the responses I am thinking that maybe it is. Especially the PP who mentioned it being better now than to wait until the middle of headaches or prolonged double vision.

I didn't have surgery as a child for squint because my mother thought that glasses were sufficient especially as I needed them to also correct my vision

I literally have a headache every single day of my life. I'm visually impaired as well, but the Drs gave explained the vast majority of the headaches are due to the squint and they now can't operate due to other eye conditions.

I have been able to observe eye surgery (long story) and I've seen squint correction surgery. Its fairly quick, not particularly invasive and has a quick recovery time.

Ignore anyone who tells you their uncle had it done and they took the whole eyeball out. People love to tell me this when they realise I have a squint but there are a whole miriad of nerves and muscles that mean this really isn't what happens (not to mention the optic nerve which is not the elastic band some people think it is!)

Therira · 06/06/2023 22:30

My son had an op on both his eye at 6 years old to correct a double squint. I was the same as you, and felt bad doing it for 'cosmetic' reasons, but its the best thing we ever did for him. He's nearly 10 now and I look back at pictures of his eyes almost constantly crossed, and realise that it was 100% the correct choice. Confidence wise, everything. He now only requires glasses for reading.
The op wasn't long and surgeon said its very common. Only thing that shocked me was he cried blood when he woke which I wish I knew as it panicked me but apparently very normal and stopped the next day. Recovery wasn't long at all.
Good luck I hope it goes well if you go through with it. x

WilbursWinnie · 06/06/2023 22:24

Good eyesight damnit

BaroldBalonz · 06/06/2023 22:23

caringcarer · 06/06/2023 20:47

Will they need a general anaesthetic? I only ask because I know a 17 year old who had an operation to pin back his ears as they really stuck out. His Mum gave him the choice and he wanted it done. He had a bad reaction to the anaesthetic and died.

And I know someone who was killed driving a car, but hey, guess what, I still drive.

And this post has been as helpful and relevent as yours ...

WilbursWinnie · 06/06/2023 22:23

I'm another example of successful op. I had the op age 5. I don't remember much about going into hospital, other than not wanting to let the doctor listen to my chest with a stethoscope Blush

I don't remember any pain. I had to wear eye patches on my good eye to "exercise" the bad eye for a while afterwards.

40 years later and I still have food eyesight and haven't needed glasses since.

I say do it!.

Cc1998 · 06/06/2023 22:21

This surgery isn't so your child won't need glasses in the future. I think you need to discuss this again with the doctor as you've misunderstood the need for treatment.

buzz91 · 06/06/2023 22:07

I also had this surgery at 7, I barely remember it or the recovery other than staring at my eye in the mirror not long after to look at the stitches. My ‘squint’ is returning though 25 years later, so it’s not a fixed for life thing but lasted a long while!

AppleDumplingWithCustard · 06/06/2023 21:55

caringcarer · 06/06/2023 20:47

Will they need a general anaesthetic? I only ask because I know a 17 year old who had an operation to pin back his ears as they really stuck out. His Mum gave him the choice and he wanted it done. He had a bad reaction to the anaesthetic and died.

Oh for goodness sake! Thousands of people have relatively minor surgery every day without having any adverse reaction. What you’re describing is an incredibly rare outcome and of no help whatsoever for the OP.

bellac11 · 06/06/2023 21:53

As a glasses wearer I say get the Op. Mine are for eyesight but I deeply regret not going for laser treatment when I was a lot younger before I started to go short sighted on top of my long sight

Glasses are a ball ache, marking your nose, not showing your make up properly, steaming up at the wrong minutes, rubbing your ears in the summer, constant wiping of them because the lenses get grubby, mascara wiping off on the inside from eye lashes. Then the cost of the bloody things.

Cloudyz7 · 06/06/2023 21:49

I'd really recommend reading 'Fixing My Gaze' by Sue Barry. There's an old Ted Talk here but you should read the book as goes into so much more detail.

I've had squint surgery on each eye as a child and then as adult (purely for cosmetic reasons). It's only after reading Sue Barry's book did I have a lightbulb moment and everything made sense - I now know why I find the things I find difficult difficult. It's because I don't have binocular vision (ie see in 3d or have much depth perception). Sue Barry manages to fix her eyes through vision therapy despite the fact that all the literature saying that you can't after the age of 6.

I would explore vision therapy for your daughter.

TEDxPioneerValley - Sue Barry - Fixing My Gaze

Susan R. Barry, Professor of Biological Sciences at Mount Holyoke College, South Hadley, Massachusetts talks about "Fixing My Gaze.""For most of my life, the...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XCCtphdXhq8

YesSirMam · 06/06/2023 21:42

get it done. I have a squint. It massively knocks my confidence. I had it corrected as a child & adult but unfortunately hasn’t been successful & I will never develop 3D vision. I’ve had 4 ops. No complications. Quick recovery. Complications are soo rare. It’s almost unheard of.

AnnaMagnani · 06/06/2023 21:37

Squint - this isn't just about wearing glasses or not.

My DM has a poorly managed squint and has barely any vision in one eye due to lazy eye. It's been disabling for her throughout her life.

She'd have loved it if this could have been avoided with an op.

Bluetrews25 · 06/06/2023 21:35

I had this done as a child (a million years ago) the worst part was that my Mum was not allowed to stay with me back then. Recovery was fine and had no more double vision.

Yea · 06/06/2023 21:30

My 9 year old had the surgery in March for quite a severe squint in one eye and it has been amazing. He does need glasses, but it’s amazing he can now not wear them and his eyes are completely straight, he’s not getting double vision any more and he’s using both eyes at the same time or ‘binocular vision’ most of the time. It’s not just cosmetic, plus it has had an amazing effect on his confidence too.

Starlightstarbright1 · 06/06/2023 21:29

I had the op when I was 7 . Now in my 50’s my eyes don’t work wonderfully together but far better than if it wasn’t corrected

oobladay · 06/06/2023 21:28

No worries @blueby7 I hope that my double vision experience didn't come across as something that might cause worry. It really is hugely rare, even in adults. I ended up googling studies because there weren't many real life experiences online and found one where something like 0.8 of adult patients in the study had some post operative double vision after 6 weeks and only 1 patient had this at the year mark. Trust my luck to be in that boat 😂 I mention it only because even with that side effect the benefits have been huge.

It was easy to choose for myself as an adult but understand very different when choosing for our dc.

IncognitoPanda · 06/06/2023 21:23

Lots of misinformation on here, some of it quite shocking. Please have a read of this https://abuhb.nhs.wales/files/patient-information-leaflets1/eyes/squint-surgery-information-for-patients-pdf/ then discuss your questions with your eye specialist

https://abuhb.nhs.wales/files/patient-information-leaflets1/eyes/squint-surgery-information-for-patients-pdf/